So this is interesting. Last week we were about to release some results from our latest Panelbase poll when events intervened. Naturally we’d asked a few questions about gender issues, and one of them concerned the Scottish Government’s potential legal challenge to the UK government’s use of a Section 35 order to block the Gender Recognition Reform bill.
There were three options in the question, and as luck would have it the three potential new leaders of the SNP each advocates a different one.
When assessing who might be the best choice for the next leader of the SNP, and by extension of the independence movement, it’s a pretty good rule of thumb to beware of anyone being bigged up by the Unionist media.
Can you spot the subtle change between these two National stories, readers?
Now, as they’re both in The National the standard of journalism is obviously completely dreadful, and so neither of them actually explains their headline. Nobody is named or quoted even anonymously, and there’s no elaboration other than that “[a member of] the NEC appeared to halt any proposal to use the next General Election as a proxy constitutional vote”, with no indication of HOW they “appeared” to do that.
But they DO raise the question of where on Earth – whoever becomes its new leader – the SNP goes from the smouldering bomb crater that Nicola Sturgeon has left it in.
The SNP constitution states that a leadership election should take place over a period of four and a half months. Having not had one in almost 20 years, the SNP are now to conduct one from start to finish in the space of four and a half weeks.
The voting period of two weeks (who needs two weeks to vote after three weeks of debate?) means that it’ll be over just a week too late for the party to be able to hold its “special democracy conference” to determine its independence strategy for the next couple of years, but also that the new leader will be in place just in time to file a legal challenge over the Gender Recognition Reform bill before the April deadline.
(Something the party president Mike Russell publicly called for today, in an apparent attempt to influence the outcome of the election. Indeed, he called for candidates not to go back on ANY of the outgoing leader’s policies, which rather invites the question of why they should bother electing a new leader at all.)
Nicola Sturgeon told Scotland’s press this morning that despite her weariness, she could have managed a few more months or even a year as First Minister, which would at least have got her halfway to keeping her promise to serve a full term if she was elected in 2021.
Which just makes her timing all the harder to explain.
We did so because we’d just been told – by a completely random source – that Nicola Sturgeon and John Swinney would both resign today, and Brown would be the interim leader while a replacement was elected. We’d never spoken to this person before, but the manner in which they said it made us take it more seriously than all the “someone told me” rumours we get told and ignore every other day.
As yet only the first part has been confirmed, but you have to admit that our source is looking pretty darn hot right now.
We’ve just had the results back from some very interesting new polling, and the first snippet is a particularly instructive one.
When challenged on questions of gender, the reflex response of politicians of most parties in the Scottish Parliament is to bang on about how overwhelmingly MSPs voted for the Gender Recognition Reform bill.
Curiously, so far no journalist has bothered to ask whether they care that according to every poll, they’re utterly failing to represent the views of their constituents on the subject – which is, after all, what they’re supposed to be there for.
So we just asked directly if people felt their MSPs were doing their jobs.
Ouch. By well over 2 to 1, respondents felt that they were being let down by the people who are supposed to speak for them. (Excluding DKs the margin is just shy of 70/30, very similar to the margin by which people in polls oppose self-ID generally.)
But it’s when you drill down into the detail that it gets a bit disturbing.
There are terms beloved of politics activists and commonly used on social media which are a baffling mystery to the general public. We’ve spoken several times of the word “gaslighting”, which is understandably used as shorthand for quite a complex thing that’s difficult to describe concisely, but nevertheless acts as a barrier to understanding for anyone not overly political.
Dan on Mind Your Business: “@ (NotSo)Southernbystander Well it is kind of hard for any mere punter on the street to provide definitive proof of…” Nov 22, 23:27
James Che on Mind Your Business: “Sarah, Alex was an innocent amongst vipers in many senses, perhaps mainly for his old fashioned beliefs that your word…” Nov 22, 23:10
James on Mind Your Business: “Seconded. Well said, Dan. Truth hurts and all that….” Nov 22, 22:03
Southernbystander on Mind Your Business: “Right Dan, so it isn’t a suggestion that actual votes cast are deliberately counted incorrectly, though James does seem to…” Nov 22, 21:52
Dan on Mind Your Business: ““So you are saying UK elections are rigged.” Well, the elehant in the room is there’s no English parliament elections…” Nov 22, 21:09
James Che on Mind Your Business: “Alf, Sometimes when Hatey is using his thoughtful hat, he is pleasant to converse with, on other occasions his need…” Nov 22, 20:20
Southernbystander on Mind Your Business: “So you are saying UK elections are rigged. What is you evidence for this James? It is an easy thing…” Nov 22, 19:41
Aidan on Mind Your Business: “Alright Geri – so to sum up “the end is nigh” just like it was last week and the week…” Nov 22, 19:29
Geri on Mind Your Business: “Imagine being on yer holidays & still shitting yersel you’ll miss something posted on a chat forum. I bet you’re…” Nov 22, 19:28
sarah on Mind Your Business: “It is so clear that what you say is correct, Alf Baird. After all, if there is a Treaty between…” Nov 22, 19:07
Geri on Mind Your Business: “There’s that yoon hypocrisy again. Where the Union is all ancient guff from the dark ages – then when ppl…” Nov 22, 19:07
Geri on Mind Your Business: “They’re winning the war. Funny that eh? There’s the West – always peddling the myth that everyone is skint &…” Nov 22, 18:47
Aidan on Mind Your Business: “Wonderful Geri – another two signature unhinged rants for me to read on this warm Sunday afternoon in Louisiana. Obviously…” Nov 22, 18:46
Aidan on Mind Your Business: “I don’t think it’s baffling at all that Alex Salmond focused on contemporary issues important and directly relevant to the…” Nov 22, 18:29
Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “The next WM General Election is planned for the spring of 2027. All serious political observers agree on this. As…” Nov 22, 18:24
Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Obviously a monumental injustice, then, for Andeh to take an annexed Scotland back into a closer relationship with, perhaps even…” Nov 22, 18:15
100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “Sarah, You do know the referendum in 2014 was never a referendum to secure Independence but entirely designed to appease…” Nov 22, 18:03
Alf Baird on Mind Your Business: ““Well how wrong can one be? After all this was what our education in every school and university taught us.”…” Nov 22, 17:50
Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “It must be very confusing when you and Lavrov get to chewing the fat, Alf. In his country, “liberation” means…” Nov 22, 17:48
100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “I watched the video below and to be honest they where actually talking about with the SNP in power how…” Nov 22, 17:31
Alf Baird on Mind Your Business: “Correct James. International law confirms that whilst there remains colonial domination there can be no democracy for an oppressed people…” Nov 22, 17:23
100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “The SNP is really the jewel in the British crown. https://www.itv.com/news/border/2026-11-21/snp-will-make-andy-burnham-prime-minister-in-hung-parliament” Nov 22, 17:16
Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Drop Andeh a line before he goes too far down the road of conning Brussels with his PM of the…” Nov 22, 17:16
Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Rial just a shade below 3.5 million to the pound, so still on the slide. Ruble looking a bit more…” Nov 22, 17:07
gm on Mind Your Business: “I agree, Sarah. he was and he did.” Nov 22, 16:55
sarah on Mind Your Business: “My comment was in response to yours, James Che! Alex an innocent amongst a pit of vipers.” Nov 22, 16:36
sarah on Mind Your Business: “It looks that way, I agree. So many backstabbers who owed everything they had to Alex. Also there’s only so…” Nov 22, 16:16
100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “Salmond wasn’t a saint and he certainly wasn’t a hardline nationalist, all he was was the best of a rotten…” Nov 22, 15:39
James Che on Mind Your Business: “Sarah, I do not know why Alex took he route he did, or why he never spoke about the information…” Nov 22, 15:17