The closure of the UK Parliament for the summer holidays this week marked the end of my first political “year” with the SNP Group at Westminster, albeit a truncated one under unusual circumstances. Having served in Holyrood much is similar and familiar, even if anachronistic in style and reeking of snobbery. Staff are remarkably helpful and individual members can be exceedingly pleasant.
But this isn’t our Parliament and we’re most certainly not amongst friends.
Last month the Tory government published its white paper on EU migration post-Brexit. As a result, I spent my day arguing positively for immigration on social media, sharing fact-based articles showing that EU migration has had a very positive impact on the UK’s economy in the last decade.
However, one of my tweets was particularly popular, in which I specifically mentioned my personal experience with Scottish attitudes towards immigration.
Twitter is meant to be short and fleeting, leaving little room for telling long, nuanced stories. But the story behind this tweet is one I find worth telling, and I think it reflects incredibly well on the fact that there’s a bright, open future ahead of Scotland. I hope you find what follows to be worthwhile.
This article originally appeared on Allan’s blog. Reproduced with permission.
Dear Richard Leonard,
You can accept this letter as my formal resignation from membership of the Labour Party. And you may not like to hear that you are the straw that broke the camel’s back.
Last month saw the first meeting between the UK Brexit delegation and the EU’s, and by many accounts it fell far short of the UK’s expectations. David Davis spent months drumming up the “strong and stable” approach which would see both the divorce deal and the subsequent post-Brexit trade deal negotiated simultaneously. He was told by everyone that this wouldn’t happen, but simply brushed off the warnings. When push came to shove, he finally accepted that he’d have to negotiate the divorce deal first.
This is just the latest in a long string of failures and ineptitudes over the course of the UK’s handling of the whole farcical process and it got me thinking. If Scotland had voted Yes in 2014, what would it have looked like if the Scottish Government had handled that vote the way the UK has managed Brexit?
The complete series so far. If you’ve got a story like this to tell, or you know anyone who does, Phantom Power want to hear from you – drop them a line.
Chas on Step One: “Andy-Project Fear has nothing to do with my reasoning. I have set to see any meaningful, realistic projections, financial or…” Jul 13, 11:34
Captain Caveman on Step One: ““Sadly Chas you’re falling in to lazy Project Fear catastrophism which will be instantly recognisable to many pro independence campaigners…” Jul 13, 11:27
James on Step One: ““…. A dismal routine. Invariably anti-independence headlines stood out on all front pages. The BBC of course duly recycled these…” Jul 13, 11:05
Northcode on Step One: “We cannot know how many eligible indigenous Scots voted SNP in the parliamentary elections – those data are not captured.…” Jul 13, 11:03
Andy Ellis on Step One: “Sadly Chas you’re falling in to lazy Project Fear catastrophism which will be instantly recognisable to many pro independence campaigners…” Jul 13, 10:52
Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Step One: “LIBERATION SCOTLAND UPDATE July 2026 www.youtube.com/watch?v=QoyyPd_7E18” Jul 13, 10:16
Chas on Step One: “Scotland will never achieve Independence until there are some honest Politicians who will tell the populace what Independence will actually…” Jul 13, 10:14
MaryB on Step One: “Meanwhile, Liberation Scotland’s update on the ongoing work at the UN, is on utube. Well worth a listen.” Jul 13, 09:05
Andy Wiltshire on Step One: “It’s infuriating that pretty much every UK newspaper and broadcaster has some kind of Scotland correspondent, and yet they have…” Jul 13, 09:03
Hatey McHateface on Step One: “Would it be fair to say that even if the SNP have “comprehensively failed the Scottish people”, the Scottish people…” Jul 13, 08:35
Hatey McHateface on Step One: “Let’s not get carried away before we’ve checked his religion.” Jul 13, 08:11
Hatey McHateface on Step One: “Personalised attacks on everybody is the norm. You only really notice it when it’s somebody you personally support. Looking at…” Jul 13, 08:04
Hatey McHateface on It just takes a beat: “In no particular order: Naw. My particular hatred is reserved for the people who saddled Scotland with the Hate Crimes…” Jul 13, 07:51
Saffron Robe on Step One: “Very well said, Stuart. The SNP’s existence now depends on failing to deliver independence; for them, failure is success -…” Jul 13, 00:42
Mark Beggan on Step One: “Did you see those two goals by Bellingham. If only Scotland had players of this calibre.” Jul 13, 00:22
Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Step One: “Dan Vevers writes: « [Ian] Dommett said: “Between 2004 and 2012. Murrell was my best client. […] Dommett added he…” Jul 12, 23:10
Northcode on Step One: “‘Oh, did it, aye?’ Northcode 22:58” Jul 12, 22:59
Northcode on It just takes a beat: ““It’s not as if you’ve got anything else to offer…” Do you even hear yourself… you, the most verbose bore…” Jul 12, 22:57
Mark Beggan on Step One: “‘The law came along to multiply the trespass. But where sin multiplied, grace multiplied even more.’ Romans 5:20.” Jul 12, 22:14
Hatey McHateface on It just takes a beat: “Good one, Northy, you get back into your comfort zone. Cursing and swearing for Scotland hasn’t got us Indy yet,…” Jul 12, 22:09
agentx on Step One: ““An insider has now claimed that Murrell “called the shots” at Yes Scotland. It comes amid a police probe into…” Jul 12, 21:34
Northcode on It just takes a beat: ““…But I’m being unkind…” This is what happens when a Scot tries being fair to the English… the cunts (although…” Jul 12, 21:32
Hatey McHateface on Step One: ““He and his party will not mourn the loss of Scotland when the chips are down” That’s odd, Lorncal. He…” Jul 12, 21:24
Lorncal on Step One: “Yes, Turabdin, and now Yes Scotland is under scrutiny, just in case we were to rally behind it and Liberation…” Jul 12, 21:08
Steve A on It just takes a beat: “Hopefully the new Hillsborough Law will (in future) force the polish to take a more honest role in this affair.…” Jul 12, 21:05
Hatey McHateface on It just takes a beat: ““my beef is with the English state, not ordinary English folk” How odd. So the England team doesn’t represent the…” Jul 12, 20:06
Alastair on Step One: “Still no sign of their 2025 Accounts that were due to be submitted to the Electoral Commission by 7th July” Jul 12, 19:59
sam on Step One: “Polis still investigating the missing cash.” Jul 12, 19:26
sam on It just takes a beat: “Mike Danson https://pureportal.strath.ac.uk/en/publications/towards-and-industrial-policy-for-scotland-a-discussion-of-princi/ Gerry McCartney https://vhscotland.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Gerry-McCartney-University-of-Glasgow.pdf Mariana Mazzucato, economist Andrea Bradley, education” Jul 12, 19:22
TURABDIN on Step One: “it was sustained civil disobedience and non cooperation that hastened the end of british rule in india not the hot…” Jul 12, 19:19