The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



When Tories tell the truth 147

Posted on January 19, 2021 by

There’s a most revealing article by George Osborne in today’s Evening Standard. It’s well worth a read in full – it’s not very long – but this is the key passage:

The deathless defenders of Plan A will of course continue to shriek that “he’s a Tory so he must be lying”. And if any of them can ever actually manage to tell us what Scottish voters can possibly DO to Boris Johnson if he keeps refusing, we’ll be all ears.

But since they never seem to be able to do that, we’re going to thank Mr Osborne for that unusual outbreak of honesty, and for admitting that a simple point-blank refusal of democracy is the Tories’ best and only strategy to keep Scotland in the UK. Because for as long as the SNP don’t have a Plan B, it’s the only one they actually need.

Read the rest of this entry →

Quoted for truth #83 120

Posted on January 08, 2021 by

Agreeing with Tom Gordon from the Herald is a position that we really don’t like to find ourselves in, readers. But we can’t find fault with a single word of this column.

We could quote almost any of it, and we recommend digesting the whole thing, but this is as good a passage to pick out as any:

For most of this site’s existence it was the Unionists who were denying the obvious realities staring them in the face. It’s a source of great discomfort to us that many on the Yes side are now picking up the habit too. But we are where we are.

The irrefutable argument 140

Posted on July 05, 2019 by

We haven’t done a good old-fashioned Quoted For Truth in quite some time, but on occasion someone else makes a point in a way that just can’t be improved on.

We’ve always known/said that this is THE core case for independence, of course, but sometimes seeing it from another country’s perspective brings the message home.

One last thing to remember 74

Posted on March 09, 2016 by

The BBC’s Brian Taylor on GERS:

briantaylorgers

As we have, of course, noted before.

Presented without comment 166

Posted on February 28, 2016 by

A little snippet from a corner of today’s Scottish Mail On Sunday.

smosdavidson

The cost of everything 70

Posted on February 06, 2016 by

From an excellent letter in today’s Herald by Chris McLaughlin of Giffnock:

oftri

The only fault in Chris’ logic is that he’s a bit too generous to Labour.

Read the rest of this entry →

Quoted for truth #82 149

Posted on August 07, 2015 by

Frank Cottrell Boyce in the Independent, 7 August 2015:

“Only 25 per cent of the population earns more than £30,000 a year. Most media commentators (including me) do. For people like me, the country basically works. Politics doesn’t affect me. Politics, for me, is about how other people are treated. It’s easy inside my echo-chamber to believe that I am the norm, or the middle. Easy to forget that there are voices outside.

To people in my position, austerity can be read as regrettable but pragmatic. But to my friends and family, who live outside the bubble, it’s not regrettable, it’s terrifying. It’s also not pragmatic. The crackpot, gimcrack ideological nature of austerity becomes more apparent the closer you get to the point of delivery.”

Read the rest of this entry →

A revealing turn of phrase 79

Posted on March 25, 2015 by

From an editorial leader in this week’s London Evening Standard:

“The man likely to lead the SNP in Westminster, former party leader Alex Salmond, has made it clear that he is contemplating keeping a minority Labour government in power on a case by case basis. ‘If you hold the balance, then you hold the power,’ he said yesterday.

His price: an end to austerity and to Trident.

Labour leader Ed Miliband has come out fighting against the threat.

Seems to sum it up pretty well.

Something worth remembering 237

Posted on March 19, 2015 by

From politics.co.uk this morning:

“Those hoping that a Labour government would look very different from the current Conservative-led government are likely to be disappointed.

Asked by the Today programme what he would reverse from Osborne’s Budget yesterday, Ed Balls replied that there was nothing.

In through the out door 59

Posted on February 12, 2015 by

The Daily Mash, 12 February 2015:

dmash

Because a good satirist can sometimes make a point better in seven sentences than idiots like us can in a 1000-word article, and make it funny at the same time.

The Legacy 234

Posted on December 21, 2014 by

Iain Macwhirter in “Disunited Kingdom” (Cargo Publishing, 8 December 2014):

“It seems clear that the newspapers allowed their editorial agendas to get in the way of their communication with their readers. And this has had very serious consequences.

There is now a very large body of people in Scotland who are deeply disillusioned with the press, to such an extent that they simply no longer believe what is written there.

Look at any of the internet sites related to the Yes campaign and you will now find, not just criticism of mainstream media but a complete rejection of it, as if it were the propaganda arm of a foreign power.

This degree of alienation from the press, shared by hundreds of thousands of Scottish voters, is unprecedented and should be causing alarm, not just in editorial offices, but in the political parties which are also losing their ability to communicate. “

It’s a difficult assessment to dispute.

Read the rest of this entry →

The man who should know 117

Posted on December 15, 2014 by

The Times, 14 December 2014:

Scottish Labour has an ‘intellectual deficit’ because it is filled with ‘time-servers’ given seats to keep them quiet, according to Paul Sinclair, who served alongside Johann Lamont, the Scottish Labour leader, and at the heart of the ‘no’ campaign against Scottish independence.

In an excoriating attack on the moribund state of Labour north of the border, Mr Sinclair said that the party will pay the price in May.”

As someone who wrote Johann Lamont’s speeches for the last three years, on this occasion we’re going to defer to Mr Sinclair’s superior expertise.

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,723 Posts, 1,214,451 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Sven on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “It’s nice to know that following Mr Murrell’s arrest on 5th April 2023 Ms Sturgeon stated that she would “fully…Mar 21, 17:37
    • Marie on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “I just LOVE that Mia’s excellent posts get under your skin!!!Mar 21, 17:34
    • Hatey McHateface on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “If you add up all the numbers in your post, convert the sum to octal, then break it into digit…Mar 21, 17:30
    • Mia on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: ““folk who don’t vote, don’t count” When over 50% of the electorate approaches the polls and cast a vote validating…Mar 21, 17:11
    • Nae Need! on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Correct, she wasn’t. She has indeed. It is. The stench of decay and corruption is all too real. Like walking…Mar 21, 17:11
    • Andy Ellis on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Mia, folk who don’t vote, don’t count. Nor do they get to whinge about the outcome. It you want to…Mar 21, 16:34
    • Mia on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: ““Not content with voting slavishly for “Scottish” Labour for decades to no appreciable end, they have moved apparently seamlessly to…Mar 21, 16:23
    • Old John on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “There is little or no chance of there being a trial.Peter has agreed to take one for the team. He…Mar 21, 16:08
    • Harry Dunlop on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Rev, this line “she simply turned her chair to face the wall and didn’t say a single word for seven…Mar 21, 16:07
    • Andy Ellis on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Sheesh….remind me which plague was first again: was it rivers turning to blood or raining frogs? I mean, I know…Mar 21, 16:03
    • Young Lochinvar on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Another day, another cushy sinecure to push preferred social engineering on others; Maggie Chapman voted in as rector of Dundee…Mar 21, 15:48
    • Andy Ellis on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Why? Because they appear not to have learned from their own history. Not content with voting slavishly for “Scottish” Labour…Mar 21, 15:33
    • Ian Smith on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Sridhar is covering for her own advise that tortured and killed the elderly, and messed up kids, for nothing.Mar 21, 15:18
    • Ian Smith on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “She was largely given a soft time in interviews my a media sympathetic to her lefty statist woke agenda, and…Mar 21, 15:15
    • Ian Smith on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “To claim against the leader and treasurer you would have to demonstrate a loss. Didn’t the party pay back anyone…Mar 21, 15:11
    • MaryB on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “100%yes, Devi Sridhar, professor of Public Health at Edinburgh uni, has been on STV saying that the Coronavirus pandemic showed…Mar 21, 14:57
    • Ian Smith on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Even if she had called her up once in a blue moon you would have expected the conversation to turn…Mar 21, 14:55
    • Lorn on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “The Yes movement as a whole, then. Splitting hairs, Robert. The money was still raised to fight an independence referendum/campaign…Mar 21, 14:50
    • Ian Brotherhood on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “I’m reminded of Confused’s past comments, when he mentioned that so-and-so felt very sad and took a lot of pills.…Mar 21, 14:34
    • Mia on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: ““Maybe it was she who could clearly see that Indy would lose” That is irrelevant. If she decided not to…Mar 21, 14:05
    • Ian Brotherhood on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Well said. Sara Salyers discussed this with Roddy MacLeod on the recent TASP. Voter engagement is heading through the floor.…Mar 21, 13:57
    • Robert Hughes on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Quite so , Mia , though the difficulty at this point is envisaging a situation in which the ( ultimate…Mar 21, 13:53
    • ross on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “will we hear the intricacies of the embezzlement at court? This needs to be brought to court very soon. It’s…Mar 21, 13:46
    • Marie on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Your post from 9am is spot on Mia. Superb!!Mar 21, 13:23
    • Mia on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: ““It’s difficult not to conclude that the lumpen Scottish electorate is not just unutterably dense” Why? I actually think the…Mar 21, 13:17
    • Marie on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “Like you I have no belief in any of those compromised institutions. And I cannot take part in an electoral…Mar 21, 13:10
    • David Thomson on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “A local man, who admitted embezzling more than £134,000 from the post office where he was the manager to feed…Mar 21, 13:05
    • Ian Brotherhood on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “If the Holyrood parliament is nothing more than a sop then we have not had a democratic government in Scotland,…Mar 21, 13:04
    • diabloandco on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “That long????? Bargain basket , do not pass go , do not collect £200! It always puzzles me as to…Mar 21, 12:41
    • Andy Ellis on The Deep-Fried Banana Republic: “It’s difficult not to conclude that the lumpen Scottish electorate is not just unutterably dense. https://x.com/ScotNational/status/1903041556585889904 Given recent events both…Mar 21, 12:37
  • A tall tale



↑ Top