Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service
25 Chambers Street
Edinburgh
EH1 1LA
4 June 2026
.
Dear Chief Constable and Crown Office,
RE: REQUEST FOR CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION — ALLEGED
MISAPPROPRIATION OF RING-FENCED POLITICAL DONATIONS
I write to request that Police Scotland/COPFS open a criminal investigation into the alleged misappropriation of funds donated to the Scottish National Party (SNP) on the basis that those funds would be held and applied for a specific, designated purpose.
If you subscribe to the theory that it’s better to fight 100 duck-sized horses than a single horse-sized duck, the SNP is knocking it out of the park today.
Because the papers just can’t make their minds up about the biggest story with which to attack John Swinney’s beleaguered party.
You’ve had a few pretty gruelling pieces to get through in the last week or so, readers, so here’s something a little more light-hearted.
It’s from an episode of Broadcasting Scotland on 27 November 2020, a month after we confirmed our big story about the SNP accounts and the missing fundraiser money. In it, snug-toed SNP MP Pete Wishart opines that there really is nothing to worry about, and we should all just put our trust in the party.
We’ll leave you to judge whose opinion stood the test of time.
On Sunday, Nicola Sturgeon told Laura Kuenssberg that the SNP’s accounts “went up and down” as her excuse for not noticing that hundreds of thousands of pounds had suddenly vanished from them overnight.
Several things leap out immediately from that clip.
One, there absolutely very much WAS “something glaringly suspicious in the accounts that I should have seen” – the party she led had raised almost £700,000 in two “ring-fenced” fundraisers that wasn’t there any more, which ought to have made its leader at least mildly curious.
And two, attempting to fob responsibility off onto the independent auditors simply won’t wash. It’s not their job to determine whether the SNP has kept its political promises or not, their job is simply to match up money coming in against money going out and produce a set of numbers to show what it all adds up to. It makes no odds to them if it was spent on a party conference, a fancy motorhome or a 50-foot golden statue of Danny La Rue. All they can see is numbers.
But even leaving those things aside, if we’re going to learn anything about how The Great Indyref Swindle got to this calamitous point unchecked we need to examine just how hard Nicola Sturgeon had to look the other way to fail to see what was going on literally under her nose and literally in her own back yard.
To tell you the truth, readers, we’re suffering from a little bit of option paralysis at the moment, although happily not in the same way Peter Murrell is.
The endless torrent of revelations following on from Murrell’s conviction a week ago isn’t just fascinating in its own right – it also forces numerous historical issues to be seen in a new light. At any given second there are half-a-dozen different articles we could be writing, but also so many to read that it’s hard to find the time.
We suspect this matter is going to run and run all through the summer silly season because there are simply so many angles and so many unanswered questions.
Sadly, this turned out to be prescient this morning.
Laura Kuenssberg did give Nicola Sturgeon an uncomfortable time in their interview on her Sunday programme on BBC News, but when confronted with the one gaping open goal that Sturgeon has no answer for – and even when Sturgeon TWICE set it up on a plate for her – Kuenssberg failed to knock the ball into the empty net.
That doesn’t – by some distance – mean there was nothing of interest to note, though, so let’s take a walk through (the first instalment of) what was said.
Now that Nicola Sturgeon is finally free of her gruelling MSP workload, which could give her anything up to two extra hours of spare time a week, she might like to start making a proper dent in the contents of her fully-loaded bookshelves.
The multi-statement meltdown that has been the unravelling of Nicola Sturgeon this week has been quite something to behold. Last night, for example, we swear our Twitter feed presented these two tweets one after the other.
We’ll be honest with you, readers, if we were in a situation where a lawyer was issuing statements for us, this isn’t what we’d want to hear.
“If my client had been charged, she’d be in prison right now” is a worrying distance short of a vote of confidence in your client’s innocence.
But the statement Aamer Anwar put out for Nicola Sturgeon last night – her FOURTH in 48 hours, despite saying on Monday morning that she’d be making no further comment on the Peter Murrell case – had rather more wrong with it than even that.
Hatey McHateface on The Lord Of The Rings: “Next HR election is 2031, so I’d give it until 2032. Putting my flippancy to one side for a moment,…” Jun 5, 17:07
Hatey McHateface on The Lord Of The Rings: “I was wanting it myself but I guess you beat me to it.” Jun 5, 16:59
Williams on The Lord Of The Rings: “If we want to be independent, a good start might be taking responsibility for our own behaviour. We need to…” Jun 5, 16:50
sarah on The Lord Of The Rings: “@ GM: I hope that you won’t be the only one! 🙂” Jun 5, 16:50
Andy Wiltshire on The Lord Of The Rings: “Keep the pressure up, Rev! Anything from the police yet?” Jun 5, 16:43
Hatey McHateface on The Lord Of The Rings: “You’re overlooking tribalism. It intersects to some extent with the sectarian divide, but it’s not an exact match. Our Scottish…” Jun 5, 16:33
David Brackenbury on The Lord Of The Rings: “Of course it is. The one positive about Sturgeon we can all agree on is that she is highly competent.…” Jun 5, 16:27
David Brackenbury on The Lord Of The Rings: “Of course it is. The one positive about Sturgeon we can all agree on is that she is highly competent.…” Jun 5, 16:21
Frank Gillougley on The Lord Of The Rings: “Did you ever see the film, ‘The Music of Chance?’ based on the story the late by Paul Auster (well…” Jun 5, 16:21
GM on The Lord Of The Rings: “I take your point Lewis E. and man do I hope you are right that the woke period is coming…” Jun 5, 16:10
Hatey McHateface on The Lord Of The Rings: ““We need to stop blaming MI5, the British state, etc” Crivens! Steep learning curve ahead!” Jun 5, 16:05
sarah on The Lord Of The Rings: “I repeat my suggestion of yesterday to all btl commenters: send an email to John.Swinney.msp@parliament.scot. Say as much or as…” Jun 5, 16:00
Hatey McHateface on The Lord Of The Rings: “Precisely. It’s illogical to subscribe to the “If their mouth is open, then they’re lying” school of thought yet still…” Jun 5, 15:58
gm on The Lord Of The Rings: “When she wants something she has to have it? Any obstructions to her getting what she wants will be removed?…” Jun 5, 15:54
Southernbystander on The Lord Of The Rings: “All countries are prone to corruption, God knows as an Englishman I am aware of this. Why would Scotland be…” Jun 5, 15:50
Casper on The Aims Of Justice: “Kicked the wasps nest. Something to look forward too.” Jun 5, 15:49
Lewis E. See on The Lord Of The Rings: “We need to stop blaming MI5, the British State etc. The SNP is full of people. People are fallible. People…” Jun 5, 15:44
John H. on The Lord Of The Rings: “I’m sure that MI5 will employ psychiatrists who check out any up and coming politicians. They must have been rubbing…” Jun 5, 15:28
Peter McAvoy on The Lord Of The Rings: “While reading the articles and comments this week that mentioned Peter Murrells spending. I was wondering who commissioned and paid…” Jun 5, 15:25
lothianlad on The Lord Of The Rings: “The SNP have become a very corrupt political party. This did not happen by accident!! MI5 will have played a…” Jun 5, 15:13
John H. on The Lord Of The Rings: “I left the SNP in 2019, having become sickened by what it had become under Sturgeon. It had become a…” Jun 5, 15:12
James Barr Gardner on Kings Of Crisis Management: “You can use “A lie begets a lie” to convey the idea that when someone tells a lie, they often…” Jun 5, 15:09
Morag on The Lord Of The Rings: “Interesting that you should cite the Lockerbie case. When I began to look at that I genuinely believed that if…” Jun 5, 15:03
Spade on The Lord Of The Rings: “The disgraceful argument that everything they do is aimed at achieving an independence referendum, and therefore they could/can legitimately spend…” Jun 5, 14:52
Jay on The Lord Of The Rings: “Mr. Beggan, what is your explanation for, firstly, the conduct of electors who support the SNP, secondly, conduct of Scottish…” Jun 5, 14:49
James on The Lord Of The Rings: “Indeed. How does that old song go….all together now, sing along with Peter; “…you don’t get me I’m a servant…” Jun 5, 14:33
Run the Border on The Lord Of The Rings: “If COPFS refuses to investigate, the question becomes whether the Lord Advocate can credibly claim the matter doesn’t meet the…” Jun 5, 14:33