The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



A funny kind of Unionism 274

Posted on June 20, 2018 by

In all the excitement of the torching of the devolution settlement, we forgot to mention a curious piece of data from our recent poll of English voters.

Of all the people south of the border who would gladly throw Scotland and Northern Ireland under the bus (and more to the point, out of the UK) in order to ensure England left the EU, by far the most willing were the voters of the only UK party which expressly identifies itself as standing FOR the Union – the Conservative And Unionist Party.

Read the rest of this entry →

Come friendly bombs and fall on Slough 74

Posted on June 05, 2018 by

We’ll shortly round up the last pieces of data from our Panelbase poll of English voters last month, but this one merits singling out, we think.

Wait, what?

Read the rest of this entry →

Being silenced is golden 80

Posted on May 31, 2018 by

The findings of Lord Bracadale’s report into hate-crime law in Scotland were published today (tl;dr version: OBFA’s coming back), and we couldn’t help observing them in the context of an interesting Guardian article on the alt/far right yesterday.

Because we’ve discovered something slightly odd about the subject.

Read the rest of this entry →

The Bank Of The Clyde 192

Posted on May 24, 2018 by

Of all the dishonest memes regularly put around by the Unionist side in the Scottish constitutional debate, the most bare-faced is the notion of the “fiscal transfer”. Part-time pretend economists harp on endlessly about how the UK “transfers” money (the current popular figure is £9bn) to Scotland to balance the books every year, as if it was a munificent gift out of the sheer kindness of Westminster’s heart.

The reality, of course, is that it’s a loan, which Scotland has to pay back with interest. If an independent Scotland ran a deficit – like almost every country on Earth – it could take that loan out from any number of possible lenders and carry on as normal.

It is in no sense whatsoever an argument for Scotland staying in the Union, because it’s completely irrelevant to the Union, except in so far as that the only reason Scotland needs to borrow money at all is because it’s been part of the UK for the last 40 years and has been left impoverished as a result while a very similar neighbouring country has become wealthy beyond imagination.

But still, let’s indulge them for a moment and assume there really is a £9bn hole in Scotland’s finances. Is there anything we could do to reduce the size of it significantly? Well, since you ask, we have some poll data on that.

Read the rest of this entry →

Girls And Boys 257

Posted on May 23, 2018 by

The phrase “the Labour Party has gotten itself into a catastrophic mess on [X]” is a sentence you can complete with almost any subject these days, whether it’s Brexit or anti-Semitism or anti-Asian racism or factionalism or Venezuela or just about anything else under the sun, so it should be no surprise that its gender policy is no different.

The party’s stance regarding all-women shortlists is now that men can be on them, so long as they say they’re women, with no questions asked, except when Labour decide arbitrarily that they aren’t really women at all because they’re obviously really men, except for all the other occasions when they’re obviously really men.

Which seemed like a timely moment for some more new poll data.

Read the rest of this entry →

Guess who’s coming to dinner? 250

Posted on May 22, 2018 by

Last week we revealed that English voters would happily see Scotland and Northern Ireland leave the UK if it was the price of securing Brexit. But one of the odder things was that those figures included a sizeable number of Remain voters, who don’t want Brexit to happen at all.

We were a little perplexed, so we did a follow-up question asking those people if they’d elaborate a bit and got some interesting replies. One person, for example, answered “The Scottish people are very arrogant and although they want to be separate from the rest of the UK they are happy to take money from England”. Charming.

But there was also another stream of opinion on the subject, and it was revealed in the responses to another question in the original poll.

Read the rest of this entry →

Tomorrow’s man today 108

Posted on May 21, 2018 by

Michael Gove has been saying some words today, to the general astonishment of all.

Which seems like a good time to bring up some more data from our latest poll.

Read the rest of this entry →

Dreaming the unpopular dream 69

Posted on May 20, 2018 by

A couple of weeks ago Scottish Labour announced, to the traditional merriment, its commitment to greater federalism for the UK, as it has done every year since 2011 or indeed since 1910. (Sometimes under the equally-meaningless term “Home Rule”.)

In today’s Sunday Times, the much-missed former SNP spin doctor Kevin Pringle also pondered the idea, concluding that he could get on board a federal Scotland in the UK under certain conditions:

So in our poll of English voters last week, we thought we’d ask their opinion.

Read the rest of this entry →

The island within an island 101

Posted on May 18, 2018 by

Our poll of English voters has already revealed that, on balance, the people of England would be happy to ditch Scotland, Northern Ireland and (very narrowly) Gibraltar as the price of Brexit. But what about if we approached the idea of England’s independence the other way round? We thought of that too.

If England was already independent, its electorate would (by almost 3 to 2) be happy to join up with fellow Leave voters in Wales, but only fractionally over half of English people would want to enter a union with Scotland if they weren’t already in one.

(To be fair, they’ve already had most of the oil, so we’re not quite as attractive a bride as we once were.)

Considerably fewer fancied taking on Northern Ireland, but fairly substantial minorities were keen on the idea of entering a sort of mini-EU with one or more of France, the Netherlands and Belgium. English people are weird. But it certainly appears that an awful lot of them think that the UK has had its day and they’d rather just go it alone.

(And only a bit over a third wanted to be joined with all three other UK nations.)

Super-alert readers may also recall that in our first ever Panelbase poll, way back in August 2013, just 18% of Scots said they’d vote for a union with England if Scotland was currently independent, with 55% saying no. Looking back on the past 300 years, it looks increasingly like hardly anyone thinks it was such a great move.

Nations overboard 178

Posted on May 17, 2018 by

As alert readers will recall, this week we commissioned Panelbase to poll the good people of England, and we got some answers that we think will blow your minds. But we’re going to start with one we suspect people will find sad, but all too predictable.

Many will remember bitterly the short-lived “lovebombing” campaign from the indyref, in which a list of semi-celebrities from the rest of the UK was assembled to assure Scots of how much they were valued and cherished by their UK partners.

Four years on, not so much.

Read the rest of this entry →

The most popular policy in the world 84

Posted on May 16, 2018 by

Just before we (thankfully) stop talking about this insanity entirely, one last thing.

This month, just for fun and a bit of a change, we’ve commissioned a Panelbase poll NOT of voters in Scotland, but our neighbours to the south. English folk are always complaining that in a world of UK devolution nobody speaks for them and them alone – Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have their own Parliaments, but not England.

So we polled 1020 English people (and we do mean English – we restricted responses to people who were both resident in England and were born there) about all kinds of things. Many were related to England’s relationship with Scotland and the rest of the UK, but while we were there we figured we might as well ask some other stuff too.

And as the UK parliament hotly debates Leveson 2 and press freedom in general, it seemed a pertinent time to re-ask a question which in polling invariably unites people of every colour, creed, class and persuasion across the entire UK, and which might be the only political policy anywhere in the UK which comes even close to matching the mass popularity of Scotland’s now-repealed Offensive Behaviour (Football) Act.

It’s this one:

English people love the Queen, but not as much as they love this idea. Men, women, young, old, rich, poor, Tory, Labour, homeowner, tenant, worker, student, it makes no difference. Overwhelming majorities of every single demographic support putting an end to the ridiculous situation that newspapers can get away with blaring an untrue story all over the front page (and pages 2, 3, 4 and 5) in gigantic screaming type, and then print the correction in a microscopic corner of page 23 two months later.

It’s just about the only thing that totally unites Remain and Leave voters – our poll found identical responses (79% for, 5% against) among those who want Brexit and those who want to stay in the EU.

It’s simple, practical and costs nothing. We can’t for the life of us work out why nobody is prepared to offer it to the nation. If any party wants to actually win the next election, we’d suggest sticking it on the front of the manifesto and preparing for a landslide.

While we’re talking about bigots 147

Posted on January 28, 2018 by

Which we were yesterday, we couldn’t help noticing this:

And that reminded us that we still had some more poll results to reveal.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,995 Posts, 1,254,151 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Southernbystander on Mind Your Business: “So you are saying UK elections are rigged. What is you evidence for this James? It is an easy thing…” Nov 22, 19:41
    • Aidan on Mind Your Business: “Alright Geri – so to sum up “the end is nigh” just like it was last week and the week…” Nov 22, 19:29
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “Imagine being on yer holidays & still shitting yersel you’ll miss something posted on a chat forum. I bet you’re…” Nov 22, 19:28
    • sarah on Mind Your Business: “It is so clear that what you say is correct, Alf Baird. After all, if there is a Treaty between…” Nov 22, 19:07
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “There’s that yoon hypocrisy again. Where the Union is all ancient guff from the dark ages – then when ppl…” Nov 22, 19:07
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “They’re winning the war. Funny that eh? There’s the West – always peddling the myth that everyone is skint &…” Nov 22, 18:47
    • Aidan on Mind Your Business: “Wonderful Geri – another two signature unhinged rants for me to read on this warm Sunday afternoon in Louisiana. Obviously…” Nov 22, 18:46
    • Aidan on Mind Your Business: “I don’t think it’s baffling at all that Alex Salmond focused on contemporary issues important and directly relevant to the…” Nov 22, 18:29
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “The next WM General Election is planned for the spring of 2027. All serious political observers agree on this. As…” Nov 22, 18:24
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Obviously a monumental injustice, then, for Andeh to take an annexed Scotland back into a closer relationship with, perhaps even…” Nov 22, 18:15
    • 100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “Sarah, You do know the referendum in 2014 was never a referendum to secure Independence but entirely designed to appease…” Nov 22, 18:03
    • Alf Baird on Mind Your Business: ““Well how wrong can one be? After all this was what our education in every school and university taught us.”…” Nov 22, 17:50
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “It must be very confusing when you and Lavrov get to chewing the fat, Alf. In his country, “liberation” means…” Nov 22, 17:48
    • 100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “I watched the video below and to be honest they where actually talking about with the SNP in power how…” Nov 22, 17:31
    • Alf Baird on Mind Your Business: “Correct James. International law confirms that whilst there remains colonial domination there can be no democracy for an oppressed people…” Nov 22, 17:23
    • 100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “The SNP is really the jewel in the British crown. https://www.itv.com/news/border/2026-11-21/snp-will-make-andy-burnham-prime-minister-in-hung-parliament” Nov 22, 17:16
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Drop Andeh a line before he goes too far down the road of conning Brussels with his PM of the…” Nov 22, 17:16
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Rial just a shade below 3.5 million to the pound, so still on the slide. Ruble looking a bit more…” Nov 22, 17:07
    • gm on Mind Your Business: “I agree, Sarah. he was and he did.” Nov 22, 16:55
    • sarah on Mind Your Business: “My comment was in response to yours, James Che! Alex an innocent amongst a pit of vipers.” Nov 22, 16:36
    • sarah on Mind Your Business: “It looks that way, I agree. So many backstabbers who owed everything they had to Alex. Also there’s only so…” Nov 22, 16:16
    • 100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “Salmond wasn’t a saint and he certainly wasn’t a hardline nationalist, all he was was the best of a rotten…” Nov 22, 15:39
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Sarah, I do not know why Alex took he route he did, or why he never spoke about the information…” Nov 22, 15:17
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “For a long time now it has not been about who votes in the elections, but who ounts the elections,” Nov 22, 14:57
    • 100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “The SNP has agreed three years before any election to give there support to Labour and Andy Burnham as the…” Nov 22, 14:51
    • sarah on Mind Your Business: “It is indeed a great pity that this topic wasn’t part of Alex’s public speaking. Although imagining an SNP government…” Nov 22, 14:19
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “Cappy, There you go again with that exceptionalist shite. The UK wasn’t a lone voice consistently trying to sway policy.…” Nov 22, 14:09
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Early discussions with Alex Salmond, after he had been in Westminsters library regarding the Treaty of union caused a change…” Nov 22, 12:56
    • Captain Caveman on Mind Your Business: ““Confused is correct” Ha. Really? Apart from the laughable inconsistencies that I’ve pointed out between the very things even he…” Nov 22, 12:41
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Only when the people of England, Wales and Ireland recognise there is no actual parliament of Scotland in the Westminster…” Nov 22, 12:18
  • A tall tale



↑ Top