The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



A swing and a miss 143

Posted on October 05, 2015 by

From today’s Herald:

foxpos

Mmm, that’s positive.

Kicking the dog until it bites 326

Posted on September 06, 2014 by

Today’s Daily Mail carries a dismal article under a hysterical essay of a headline reading “Homes vandalised, accused of stealing jobs and an atmosphere of discriminatory intimidation: The savage racism turning Scotland into a no-go zone for the English”. (It actually describes a couple of minor incidents, spread over several years, affecting a single elderly couple in Stirling, without a shred of evidence that they were in fact motivated by their Englishness.)

There are undoubtedly small pockets of anti-English racism to be found in parts of Scotland, like there are small pockets of every kind of racism and prejudice found in every country in the world. But why would any Scottish person ever be driven to feel animosity towards the English – our friends, our family and our neighbours?

englishpassport

Not just because of a few isolated nutters on Facebook, surely?

Read the rest of this entry →

More empty threats at your expense 159

Posted on August 02, 2014 by

The UK government is about to put another taxpayer-funded leaflet through every door in Scotland, laden with dire warnings about the consequences of independence.

Boiled down to just five bullet points – one of which is the meaningless “best of both worlds” – it presents the case for the UK as amounting to keeping the pound (which Scotland can do either way), higher public spending (omitting the fact that Scots pay over the odds for said spending), jobs with UK companies (which would be unaffected because EU law demands freedom of employment) and lower energy bills.

onshorewind

The latter is based on the oft-repeated claim that fuel bills would rise in Scotland because the rUK would no longer pay to import subsidised Scottish renewable energy. But an article in The Ecologist this week, by two respected academics from Robert Gordon University in Aberdeen, blows that argument out of the water.

Read the rest of this entry →

When you’re happy and you know it 173

Posted on July 29, 2014 by

Alert readers will of course remember a few short weeks ago in April, when “Better Together” attracted much great hoopla in the press for its relaunched, “more positive” campaign strategy which would dazzle Scots with the feelgood benefits of the Union.

fearwatch

We thought it’d be worth checking in and seeing how that was going.

Read the rest of this entry →

Voting for Christmas 137

Posted on July 05, 2014 by

There’s a curious piece in today’s Guardian about the Scotstoun area of Glasgow, home to the shipbuilding yard of BAE Systems. It typifies what’s perhaps the most successful and consistent strategy that the No campaign has managed to deploy in the entire independence debate. Let’s listen in.

Read the rest of this entry →

Positive case finally unveiled 160

Posted on June 24, 2014 by

And this time we’re not being sarcastic. We were bemused yesterday when a number of people on Twitter started swapping referendum-based jokes about Stanley Baxter, who for younger readers used to be some sort of pantomime star and vaudeville performer. The jokes were explained today when it was revealed, to our considerable surprise, that Mr Baxter was in fact still alive and urging a No vote in the referendum.

baxter

Baxter, who left Scotland 55 years ago and told the Times that he now returns only for “the odd funeral”, nevertheless felt able to assert from these occasional visits that support for a Yes vote was founded in hatred for the English from simple-witted Scots who “don’t know any better” caused by “Braveheart” and hey, stay awake at the back there because we’re coming to the important bit.

And that’s that the comedian, who made a career out of telling TV viewers that the people of Glasgow had hilarious incomprehensible accents in need of translating into proper English, also went on to (no doubt impeccably) articulate the real reason, never previously spoken aloud, that the No campaign wants Scotland to stay part of the UK.

Read the rest of this entry →

None more positive 116

Posted on May 12, 2014 by

Alert readers will have noticed that we’ve been studying the UK government’s latest independence paper today. The 24-page booklet comes with a foreword from the Secretary of State for Portsmouth promising that it contains “the positive case for Scotland remaining in the United Kingdom”, so we thought it’d be fun to share some of our favourite snippets of positivity.

betterdogether

We could do with some cheering up.

Read the rest of this entry →

Bring me sunshine 112

Posted on April 24, 2014 by

Remember how the No campaign was definitely going to be much more positive from now on, pushing a feelgood “sunshine strategy” to persuade Scots that the UK was the best of both worlds?

gethurt

Let’s see how that’s going, shall we?

Read the rest of this entry →

Votes of No confidence 119

Posted on April 16, 2014 by

“Sod it”, we thought, “let’s compile a list after all.

taxiformrmcdougall

Clearly we’re not impartial judges of how the No campaign is being conducted. To assess its performance with any degree of fairness, we must instead take the widest possible sample of opinion from those on its own side. Here goes, then.

Read the rest of this entry →

Another sunny day in La-La Land 118

Posted on March 21, 2014 by

An extraordinary front-page headline in today’s Herald blares “Miliband pledges positive case for Union as No inject love into debate”. (We apologise to any readers we may have just inadvertently upset with the thought of Ed Miliband “injecting love” into them while they’re still digesting their breakfast.)

positiveed

The article’s rather shy on details of Ed’s positive case, but luckily the Guardian has it.

Read the rest of this entry →

We less, we happy less 189

Posted on March 13, 2014 by

We’re given to believe that this is real, not a spoof.

lessjobs

Just when we thought our opinion of them couldn’t possibly sink any lower.

Read the rest of this entry →

Stories of the week, 16/2/2014 121

Posted on February 16, 2014 by

The top five most-read stories on Wings Over Scotland in the last seven days. (Which have already broken last week’s all-time record for one-week pageviews, incidentally.)

1. Comical Ali’s perfect game
The “Better Together” mailshot where literally every sentence is a lie.

2. The killer inside
The Madness Of Prince George (Osborne).

3. What you won’t read today
Actual financially-literate people assess Scotland’s currency options.

4. Turn and river
The real meaning behind the currency threat.

5. They don’t care about you
Scottish Labour admit they’ll hurt Scotland to win Westminster.

This week’s theme: the positive case for the Union.

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,691 Posts, 1,208,833 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • gregor on A crisis of democracy: “The Fraud (2025): Exclusive: Humza Yousaf challenges Elon Musk to debate: ‘Name the day, name the hour’: https://www.thenational.scot/news/24857305.humza-yousaf-challenges-worlds-richest-man-elon-musk/ https://archive.ph/4hHzm #TheHumzaChallengeJan 14, 17:48
    • gregor on A crisis of democracy: “Worry: “To think about problems or unpleasant things that might happen in a way that makes you feel unhappy and…Jan 14, 17:21
    • Confused on A crisis of democracy: “will wragg “video exists of 3 males urinating on him” I reckon such little spreadsheets exist for holyrood, and given…Jan 14, 17:20
    • Confused on A crisis of democracy: “for wingers who don’t know the name https://archive.ph/bcjay that’s all I read on herJan 14, 17:12
    • Derek Thomson on A crisis of democracy: “I think they were all caricatures. Did you not think that?Jan 14, 17:06
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on A crisis of democracy: “And he just might, since in the long term it would likely ensure lots more Reform MPs.Jan 14, 16:57
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on A crisis of democracy: “Oh ffs. A while back I pulled in a bunch of posts from my personal website, thinking to make them…Jan 14, 16:56
    • Mark Beggan on A crisis of democracy: “Look further.Jan 14, 16:49
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on A crisis of democracy: “Mm. The current polling makes voting SNP 1&2, remarkably, even more cretinous than it was last time. With the Unionist…Jan 14, 16:48
    • Mark Beggan on A crisis of democracy: “George Marshall Secretary of StateJan 14, 16:47
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on A crisis of democracy: “What was on offer in 2011 was just an even worse form of FPTP.Jan 14, 16:45
    • Daisy Walker on A crisis of democracy: “The left cheek of the British Establishment’s Government is making the right cheek look like the adult in the room,…Jan 14, 16:39
    • Heaver on A crisis of democracy: “If Farage pledged to introduce PR and dissolve parliament for a new election within one year of becoming PM, I’d…Jan 14, 16:39
    • gregor on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Considered: “Considered opinion/view/decision.” “An opinion or decision that someone has reached after a lot of thought: It is my considered…Jan 14, 16:30
    • Dave Hansell on A crisis of democracy: ““On the full figures, just 18% of the electorate supports the governing party…” It seems reasonable to assume that figure…Jan 14, 16:29
    • gregor on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Clever dick: “Someone who shows that they are clever, in a way that annoys other people: If you’re such a…Jan 14, 16:21
    • John K on A crisis of democracy: “Give me a break. Same tired “argument” trotted out by the Dems over the last year. e.g. If Trumpy-boy is…Jan 14, 16:20
    • duncanio on A crisis of democracy: “Marshal Plan?Jan 14, 16:15
    • Mrd on A crisis of democracy: “‘videogames’? What game is this?Jan 14, 16:14
    • Michael on A crisis of democracy: “They are definitely different in terms of the policies and the attitudes that they have, their ‘clients’ who they want…Jan 14, 16:14
    • Paul on A crisis of democracy: “Thanks Rev, pulled all the facts together which the MSM doesn’t understand or (more likely) do not want to admit.Jan 14, 16:12
    • Insider on A crisis of democracy: ““Reform want to invade Poland.” Eh ? Says who ?Jan 14, 16:12
    • gregor on A crisis of democracy: “re. Corbyn “Keir Starmer became leader, at the request of I***el lobby group the Board of Deputies of British Jews.The…Jan 14, 16:12
    • Dave Hansell on A crisis of democracy: “Can’t find a reference to that on a search engine. Is this actually a reference to the Marshal Plan? -…Jan 14, 16:10
    • Blackhack on A crisis of democracy: “I think that the major reason for the “non Voters” is just the fact that there’s really little choice between…Jan 14, 16:02
    • John.H on A crisis of democracy: “Considering Keir Starmer’s obvious contempt for democracy, I think he’s looking for a way to avoid a general election. No…Jan 14, 15:56
    • Andy on A crisis of democracy: “The worry over here about the USA (among the saner commentators) is not that there wasn’t a free and fair…Jan 14, 15:56
    • gregor on Safeguarding Is Not Right-Wing: “BBC (2025): Prison officer jailed for 13 years for child rape: “A “depraved” former prison officer who admitted raping a…Jan 14, 15:55
    • Confused on A crisis of democracy: “The US waged relentless financial warfare against the UK in WW2 – the objective to bury the british empire, to…Jan 14, 15:31
    • Lorna Campbell on A crisis of democracy: “Indeed, Mark, but I suspect that was deliberate because they wanted Britain’s status as a global leader. It became very…Jan 14, 15:22
  • A tall tale



↑ Top