The reaction of the Scottish media and political opposition to Audit Scotland’s annual report on the NHS today has been nothing if not predictable. But we thought you might like an instructive and enlightening look at the two very different types of approach they’ve taken to trying to mislead the Scottish people about it.
First up is the non-specific Scottish Labour apparatchik (as far as we’re aware he has no official role in the party since Jim Murphy quit – indeed we don’t know what he does for a living at all any more) Blair McDougall:
This is what we in the writing trade call a “flat-out lie”.
This month we’ve been noting a sudden avalanche of factually-questionable articles in the media attacking the SNP’s record in government. At the weekend and yesterday we also picked apart a highly misleading and disingenuous claim by Andrew Neil on the BBC’s Sunday Politics that there had been no cuts to the Scottish Government budget since the Conservatives came to power in 2010.
We weren’t going to take Professor Adam Tomkins’ hysterical “NATMAGEDDON!” article for this week’s Spectator seriously enough to pull it apart line by line.
But once we’d wiped the tears from our eyes we thought we’d better do our job.
As readers may have noticed, it’s been an extremely slow news week this week. The papers, having strung out the Michelle Thomson “crisis” beyond all endurance, have been reduced (in the case of today’s Daily Mail) to printing shock-horror pictures of her still sitting beside SNP MPs in the Commons, so little else is there to report.
(As far as we’re aware the Commons doesn’t have an official naughty step, so even if Thomson HAD been found guilty of doing anything wrong she’d have had to sit on the opposition benches just the same.)
But it seems the dastardly Nats have been getting up to something even worse than associating with a (currently) former colleague.
Much has been made this week of the Scottish Government’s decision to award a water services contract for council buildings, schools, prisons and some other public facilities to an English company (Anglian Water) over the bid by Business Stream, a wholly-owned subsidiary of publicly-owned Scottish Water.
Opponents of the SNP have claimed that the awarding of this contract means that the Scottish Government has somehow privatised the provision of water in Scotland.
Readers may not be completely astonished to learn it’s not true.
Most of Scotland’s news outlets, including the Times, Herald, Daily Record, Daily Mail, Express and the BBC, run today with the story that one in three Police Scotland officers intend to leave the force in the next three years, according to a recent survey for the Scottish Police Authority.
(The print edition of the Scotsman makes it the front-page splash, although the article has mysteriously vanished from its website.)
But a couple of pieces of important information are inexplicably missing.
All five of the opinion pollsters who regularly poll on Scottish politics (Panelbase, YouGov, TNS, Ipsos Mori and Survation) have now published surveys in the past two weeks asking the independence question. So it seems reasonable to expect there’ll be no more polls before the anniversary of the referendum on Friday.
Given the conventional wisdom that the economy, underpinned by that pesky volatile oil, was the main reason not enough Scots could be persuaded to take the leap into self-government, readers might expect that the dramatic collapse in the oil price since last year (when we checked today it was trading at just over $47 a barrel, less than half the $97 it was at the start of September 2014) would only have cemented voters’ feeling that they made the right decision.
A very brief post about football, because it was irritating to listen to the avalanche of gloom on social media on Friday night as Scotland lost to Georgia (again), and then have to watch this honking oaf go trolling.
Yesterday we noted an interesting apparent shift in the BBC’s political stance with regard to Scotland. Two serving senior political reporters have made open attacks on the SNP, backed up by other media and politicians, seemingly abandoning all notions of the impartiality to which the BBC is bound by charter.
(The Guardian’s hostile editorial was particularly bizarre, suggesting that devolving control of broadcasting in Scotland to Holyrood would turn the BBC into a mouthpiece of government, which inescapably suggests that the current Westminster-controlled BBC is a tool of either Labour or the Tories, depending which one is in power.)
This morning’s edition of The Times is the latest to join the offensive.
Stat-pummelled readers will be glad to know that this is the last article we plan to write about the vagaries of the AMS electoral system, and how it might apply to next year’s Scottish Parliament election, for some time. This one also shouldn’t be full of tables and figures, so strap yourself in and let’s get this job finished.
Red on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Aye, I’m sure Nicola Sturgeon is desperately missing all that heterosexual sex she was definitely having with Peter Murrell. It…” Nov 18, 17:20
Geri on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Why are we surprised this would be Kuenssbergs burning question that keeps her awake at night? The UK doesn’t do…” Nov 18, 16:41
Andy Wiltshire on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Keep at them, Rev. Is there a (theoretical) date by which they have to respond to your application for judicial…” Nov 18, 16:37
lothianlad on The Shots You Don’t Take: “If its the bbc asking the questions, then they will soften any line of questioning that may not fit their…” Nov 18, 16:16
robertkknight on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Agent 003.5 still milking the British establishment for all it’s worth before being put out to grass and fading away…” Nov 18, 16:14
Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Shots You Don’t Take: “The police have been served with our application for judicial review. We await a response.” Nov 18, 15:58
duncanio on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Are Wings still considering prosecuting the SNP for alleged embezzlement from donors given that John Swinney admitted that monies had…” Nov 18, 15:44
MP on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Politicians used to subject themselves to Robin Day or Paxman, and if you look at old film they took part…” Nov 18, 15:27
Andrew Morton on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Face it, Sturgeon has some pretty serious protection from the UK establishment. She’ll never come to trial.” Nov 18, 15:20
dearieme on The Shots You Don’t Take: “The question should have been “Tell me, Mrs Murrell, is it true that mony a Murrell maks a muckle?”” Nov 18, 15:20
Hatey McHateface on The Shots You Don’t Take: “It’s possible that what President Trump was talking about recently regarding graft and sleaze is true in Scotland as well.…” Nov 18, 15:11
AlMac on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Excellent questions. Besides, I would have thought Laura would have had the question ‘do you still love Peter?’ already answered…” Nov 18, 15:04
Effijy on The Shots You Don’t Take: “I would like to know if the funds in Murrell’s personal accounts have been repatriated to the Party or more…” Nov 18, 14:50
Heather McLean on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Excellent investigative journalism -too bad actual newspaper and media “journalists” can’t show as much initiative as yourself! This is dragging…” Nov 18, 14:27
sarah on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Excellent piece of work, again, Rev. The MSM will be poring over it to get some tips, no doubt.” Nov 18, 14:11
Lorncal on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Of course you need proof to be convicted even if you turn out to be the wrong man. Mistakes are…” Nov 18, 13:34
Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “We can all guess who’s behind that idea eh? The one that has already changed everyone else’s laws & judiciaries…” Nov 18, 12:10
Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “We might’ve known that’d be a red rag tae the bull dug. Now they’ll set all Britnat phasers tae bait…” Nov 18, 12:05
Aidan on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““It’s difficult not to disprove their daily lies though” Care to name on single argument on any subject that you…” Nov 18, 11:35
Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: “@Bilbo Good grief, I mean I know my expectations of you were already at rock bottom, but this really is…” Nov 18, 09:41
Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Interesting article in the Guardian Online from Rafael Behr. Against the backdrop of the summit between the leaders of the…” Nov 18, 09:32
Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Excellent idea, James. Like everybody else, I would prefer you disappear for a week, rather than a day. We can…” Nov 18, 08:39
Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Anybody know when the UN is setting us free? I’m worried that some of the kiddies are playing with matches,…” Nov 18, 08:24
Bilbo on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Main is starting to act like a tart desperate for attention. He’s become pathetic and anyone who is entertaining him…” Nov 18, 07:23
Aidan on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Great point Dave – have you ever thought about publishing your memoirs? I am sure there’s a massive audience for…” Nov 18, 04:02
DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: “…he says, engaging with the ‘dim witted troll’ who isn’t worth engaging with… You truly are stupid.” Nov 18, 03:18
Aidan on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Yes James, please ignore, a dim witted troll like yourself isn’t worth engaging with.” Nov 18, 02:14
James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Bilbo; Can we have an ignore the Yoon Trolls day/week? Watch them go round in a love-in with each other?…” Nov 17, 22:07
James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Bilbo; Can we have an ignore the Yoon Trolls day/week? Watch them go round in a love-in with each other?…” Nov 17, 22:07
DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I see you took a lesson in the spelling of the word ‘cunt’. Comprehension of word combinations next eh? Who’d…” Nov 17, 20:50