We’ve only ourselves to blame, we’d be the first to admit. When we titled yesterday’s piece “AMS for lazy people” it was pretty much an invitation for people to get us to do their research for them, and so it proved.
Even as we slumped exhausted over a red-hot calculator, several readers wasted no time demanding a breakdown of how the mechanisms of the electoral system had affected last year’s European elections, in which UKIP defied some expectations (and delighted the Unionist parties and media) by taking a seat in Scotland.
The email we’ve had more than any other since the 8th of May is this one:
“Please can you explain how the Scottish election system works, and whether it’s a good idea for me as an SNP voter to give my list vote to someone else so as to ensure the maximum number of pro-Yes MSPs in Holyrood?”
We’d planned to leave that question until much nearer the relevant time, but to be honest we’re getting fed up of reading them, so let’s see if we can sort it out now.
Social media is alive today with tales of people being refused a vote in the Labour leadership election on the grounds that they don’t support Labour values (if anyone even knows what those are any more). We suspect you’ll be hearing quite a bit about it in the press over the coming days.
The prevailing reaction seems to be slack-jawed astonishment at the planetary-scale car-crash the party has allowed to develop around the issue, with another “coup” story thrown in for good measure in the Telegraph.
We can only think of one way the farce could become even worse.
There’s a comment piece by Scottish Tory leader Ruth Davidson in today’s Sunday Times, comprising 846 words which could be condensed into two: “SNP BAD”.
As such it could have been easily turned into a speech by any Scottish Labour leader of the last five years with nothing more than a quick search-and-replace of the words “Conservative” and “Labour”. It puts forward nothing remotely resembling a policy, just paragraphs of boilerplate waffle and a call for a debate.
Davidson professes to offer “a practical and pro-UK alternative to the SNP”, a programme which she boils down to two key components. It seems to have entirely escaped her notice that they contradict each other on the most fundamental level.
There’s much noisy chat at the moment about Jeremy Corbyn being 20 points ahead of his Labour leadership rivals on first-preference votes. His rivals seem to agree; they’ve turned their main efforts to competing amongst themselves for second and third preference “stop Corbyn” votes.
But could any of them really close such a huge gap? And what if they don’t?
Alert readers will recall that this site has expended some energy on debunking the lazy myth – which suits the media and Labour alike – that a significant factor in the unexpected Conservative majority in May’s general election was voters being scared back to the Tories by a fear campaign about the prospect of the SNP influencing a minority Labour government.
Having failed over the course of several years to label the SNP “Nazis” and “fascists” (or, depending on which sort of newspaper you were reading,“Tartan Stalinists”), the party’s political and media opponents have a new(ish) meme to punt: that the SNP is a religious cult made up of credulous, fanatical zealots impervious to logic or facts.
The leader of this new front is right-wing columnist Alex Massie, who by our count has managed to flog someone this diatribe at least four times already this year – the most recent being in yesterday’s Times:
With David Mundell and Ian Murray both having appeared on today’s “Good Morning Scotland” singing the praises of the wonderful Scotland Bill and how it would deliver all a nation could ever dream of, it seems a good time to publish the results of our recent Panelbase poll on the subject.
The nation, it seems, has rather more ambitious dreams.
Alert readers may recall a few weeks ago, when this was a thing:
The SNP standing for seats in England, of course, is an idea that’s been put forward before by some of the nation’s sharper and more insightful political commentators, but the party has for obvious and understandable reasons shown no inclination thus far to undertake the experiment.
But as we realised after chatting to a left-wing English chum this week (a successful creative and businessman), such a party actually already exists, and has dozens of MPs. It’s just that it’s currently trapped inside a corpse.
Alert readers may have noticed something of a glut of articles in the press recently by right-wing commentators angrily challenging the SNP to prove its left-wing credentials if and when the new Scotland Bill ever becomes law and grants Holyrood more powers over taxation, some minor aspects of welfare and – of course – road signs.
The zenith of the phenomenon must surely be today’s eye-rubbingly bizarre Scotsman story in which the Scottish Tories urge the SNP to increase tax in order to reverse, er, Tory cuts. But there’s method behind the seeming madness.
The battle-cry of right-wing Labour apologists all this week has been “realism”. It’s all very well people like Jeremy Corbyn having crazy old principles about what Labour is supposed to stand for, runs the argument, but you can’t argue with public opinion and public opinion is desperate for Labour to become Tories with a slightly softer edge.
Red on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Aye, I’m sure Nicola Sturgeon is desperately missing all that heterosexual sex she was definitely having with Peter Murrell. It…” Nov 18, 17:20
Geri on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Why are we surprised this would be Kuenssbergs burning question that keeps her awake at night? The UK doesn’t do…” Nov 18, 16:41
Andy Wiltshire on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Keep at them, Rev. Is there a (theoretical) date by which they have to respond to your application for judicial…” Nov 18, 16:37
lothianlad on The Shots You Don’t Take: “If its the bbc asking the questions, then they will soften any line of questioning that may not fit their…” Nov 18, 16:16
robertkknight on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Agent 003.5 still milking the British establishment for all it’s worth before being put out to grass and fading away…” Nov 18, 16:14
Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Shots You Don’t Take: “The police have been served with our application for judicial review. We await a response.” Nov 18, 15:58
duncanio on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Are Wings still considering prosecuting the SNP for alleged embezzlement from donors given that John Swinney admitted that monies had…” Nov 18, 15:44
MP on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Politicians used to subject themselves to Robin Day or Paxman, and if you look at old film they took part…” Nov 18, 15:27
Andrew Morton on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Face it, Sturgeon has some pretty serious protection from the UK establishment. She’ll never come to trial.” Nov 18, 15:20
dearieme on The Shots You Don’t Take: “The question should have been “Tell me, Mrs Murrell, is it true that mony a Murrell maks a muckle?”” Nov 18, 15:20
Hatey McHateface on The Shots You Don’t Take: “It’s possible that what President Trump was talking about recently regarding graft and sleaze is true in Scotland as well.…” Nov 18, 15:11
AlMac on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Excellent questions. Besides, I would have thought Laura would have had the question ‘do you still love Peter?’ already answered…” Nov 18, 15:04
Effijy on The Shots You Don’t Take: “I would like to know if the funds in Murrell’s personal accounts have been repatriated to the Party or more…” Nov 18, 14:50
Heather McLean on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Excellent investigative journalism -too bad actual newspaper and media “journalists” can’t show as much initiative as yourself! This is dragging…” Nov 18, 14:27
sarah on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Excellent piece of work, again, Rev. The MSM will be poring over it to get some tips, no doubt.” Nov 18, 14:11
Lorncal on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Of course you need proof to be convicted even if you turn out to be the wrong man. Mistakes are…” Nov 18, 13:34
Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “We can all guess who’s behind that idea eh? The one that has already changed everyone else’s laws & judiciaries…” Nov 18, 12:10
Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “We might’ve known that’d be a red rag tae the bull dug. Now they’ll set all Britnat phasers tae bait…” Nov 18, 12:05
Aidan on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““It’s difficult not to disprove their daily lies though” Care to name on single argument on any subject that you…” Nov 18, 11:35
Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: “@Bilbo Good grief, I mean I know my expectations of you were already at rock bottom, but this really is…” Nov 18, 09:41
Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Interesting article in the Guardian Online from Rafael Behr. Against the backdrop of the summit between the leaders of the…” Nov 18, 09:32
Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Excellent idea, James. Like everybody else, I would prefer you disappear for a week, rather than a day. We can…” Nov 18, 08:39
Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Anybody know when the UN is setting us free? I’m worried that some of the kiddies are playing with matches,…” Nov 18, 08:24
Bilbo on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Main is starting to act like a tart desperate for attention. He’s become pathetic and anyone who is entertaining him…” Nov 18, 07:23
Aidan on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Great point Dave – have you ever thought about publishing your memoirs? I am sure there’s a massive audience for…” Nov 18, 04:02
DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: “…he says, engaging with the ‘dim witted troll’ who isn’t worth engaging with… You truly are stupid.” Nov 18, 03:18
Aidan on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Yes James, please ignore, a dim witted troll like yourself isn’t worth engaging with.” Nov 18, 02:14
James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Bilbo; Can we have an ignore the Yoon Trolls day/week? Watch them go round in a love-in with each other?…” Nov 17, 22:07
James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Bilbo; Can we have an ignore the Yoon Trolls day/week? Watch them go round in a love-in with each other?…” Nov 17, 22:07
DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I see you took a lesson in the spelling of the word ‘cunt’. Comprehension of word combinations next eh? Who’d…” Nov 17, 20:50