The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Archive for the ‘comment’


So blind that you cannot see 56

Posted on December 06, 2013 by

That was always a pretty silly lyric. But anyway.

We had to switch the telly off after about 10 minutes of the news this morning. The piety was too much to take. So intead we’re just going to quote two things from the avalanche of comment that’s appeared this morning on the death of Nelson Mandela.

Read the rest of this entry →

Quoted for comedy 83

Posted on December 05, 2013 by

The Herald, 5 December 2013:

“A group of academics whose views on green energy underpinned a central plank of the Better Together campaign has published a shock U-turn report arguing that independence now offers the best way to meet Scotland’s renewables targets.

Small lunatic fringe forms splinter group 99

Posted on December 04, 2013 by

labfacebook

About 1,000 more and LFI will be bigger than Scottish Labour’s actual membership.

Partial freedom 147

Posted on December 03, 2013 by

We had to give the BBC a nudge before it replied to the last of our three Freedom Of Information requests, but at least this time we didn’t just get the standard fob-off.

Read the rest of this entry →

The talent pool 64

Posted on December 03, 2013 by

Well done to everyone who correctly guessed that our Mystery Guest last night was indeed Ruth Davidson. If you’d like to listen to Ruth’s 2009 demo reel for voiceover work which accompanied the letter, click the image below.

soundwave2

From that to the leader of a major Scottish political party in just two years. Hats off.

Quoted for truth #37 93

Posted on December 02, 2013 by

Professor James Mitchell of Edinburgh University, 2 December 2013:

“Under what circumstances would a UK Government (or Scottish for that matter) incline towards cooperation or conflict in its relations with its neighbour? The key is motivations.

Nobody should expect either Government to be motivated by good will. London will owe Scotland nothing and Edinburgh will owe London nothing.  Self-interest will dictate behaviour. Neither Government will act against its own self-interest but neither will act spitefully unless it wants to inflict harm on itself long-term.”

Read the rest of this entry →

The Captain’s Abyss 190

Posted on November 30, 2013 by

The realisation that the No camp’s reaction to the independence White Paper has been based on a massive, scarcely-believable misunderstanding/misrepresentation of reality has thrown a new light on all sorts of things from the past week.

bhole12

The most recent “BLACK HOLE!” story is a case in point.

Read the rest of this entry →

A tonic for the troops 125

Posted on November 29, 2013 by

As a living embodiment of the posh, braying public-school Tory-boy stereotype, Fraser Nelson of the Spectator used to reside in our “Zany Comedy Relief” links bar until we kicked him out for rarely lowering himself to write about Scotland.

fnelson

But his guest appearance in today’s Telegraph we enjoyed at least parts of.

Read the rest of this entry →

What Mariano Rajoy didn’t say 234

Posted on November 28, 2013 by

In “breaking news” during a dull ding-dong of a debate on Wednesday’s Newsnight Scotland, we were breathlessly told that Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy had made an important intervention in the debate about whether Scotland should keep paying for railway lines between London and Birmingham, weapons of mass destruction and Ian Davidson’s expenses. (We paraphrase.)

rajoy

Stopping just short of a drum-roll or mariachi band (yes, those are Mexican, but are you telling us BBC Scotland would know the difference?), viewers were dramatically informed that in a major new development Mariano Rajoy had said… exactly what he’s been saying for most of the last two years. 

Read the rest of this entry →

White line fever 87

Posted on November 26, 2013 by

We’re still dutifully ploughing through “Scotland’s Future”, but in truth we’re not really its target audience. We’re already convinced, and much of it is just like reading our own articles back except in rather blander language. What we can definitely say for certain is that it doesn’t lack detail – the composition of an independent Scotland’s armed forces, for example, is laid out almost down to the rifle.

speedread

Naturally, that didn’t stop the No camp from rushing onto the nation’s TV screens within minutes of the press launch ending with their considered, serious and thoughtful assessments of a document none of them had read.

Read the rest of this entry →

The Loch Ness Monster’s underwear 119

Posted on November 26, 2013 by

There’s an atrocious piece of journalism in this morning’s Guardian, and on this particular occasion we’re referring to its technical standards rather than any bias or spin. Here are the opening paragraphs:

“The Treasury has claimed Scotland’s voters will face tax rises of £1,000 per head after independence unless the next Scottish government immediately cuts billions of pounds in spending.

In a calculated effort to undermine the release on Tuesday of the landmark white paper outlining the case for Scottish independence, the Treasury said those increases would hit 2.4m people now paying the basic rate of income tax.

It said the alternative, according to the most optimistic scenario for Scotland’s economy and debt levels sketched out last week by the Institute for Fiscal Studies, would be to cut public spending by £3bn more than the UK government plans by 2021.”

We’re confused already.

Read the rest of this entry →

Pay up and shut up 148

Posted on November 25, 2013 by

So today we got a response from the BBC to our Freedom Of Information request concerning this story. Those of you who’ve ever sent an FOI request to the state broadcaster before probably won’t need to read any further.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,919 Posts, 1,243,594 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Ian on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Hopefully the broad ranging supporting cast over the past decade will also have some serious light shone on them. Maybe…Jun 3, 11:27
    • diabloandco on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “I have an awful idea that the fraudster is going to be found to have a ‘mental health problem’ -…Jun 3, 11:24
    • Ronnie on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “We can live in hope.Jun 3, 11:24
    • TURABDIN on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “The end of the coitus interruptus phase of Scottish nationalism? Might we now expect the real thing?Jun 3, 11:11
    • Alastair Gibb on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “I met Nicola once, in 2012 when I was coming back down Calton Hill following the first march and rally…Jun 3, 11:08
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Yes, I believe at one point it was designated as office equipment in the accounts.Jun 3, 10:59
    • Callum on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “There are reports Sturgeon is planning to leave Scotland to live in London. Not far enough if you ask me.Jun 3, 10:58
    • Confused on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “nice One wider issue – given that it has now been established Murrell is a fraudster, i.e. a dishonest person,…Jun 3, 10:57
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “A bawhair above nil. (There was a 30-second clip of me on STV News last night, though.)Jun 3, 10:57
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “I HAVE NO IDEA WHAT YOU MEANJun 3, 10:56
    • Dave on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Good work, as ever. What is clear from Murrell’s plea is that the accounts for this whole period are unreliable…Jun 3, 10:55
    • Ryan M on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Forensic journalism at its finest, Stu.Jun 3, 10:54
    • Ryan M on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Forenstic journalism at its finest, Stu.Jun 3, 10:54
    • desimond on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “There duly sits a big MASSIVE door almost off its hinges just waiting for a certain Stephen Flynn to boot…Jun 3, 10:48
    • Aidan on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Great article – cracking read! As you say, the irony being that quite possibly in an attempt to cover his…Jun 3, 10:42
    • agentx on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: ““In any event the party’s longstanding auditors resigned in 2023 rather than risk being caught up in any more dodginess.”…Jun 3, 10:42
    • TURABDIN on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “This is not Nicola STURGEON. https://www.shinylife.co.uk/shiny/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/PXL_20251009_1801229142.jpg We would not wish to bring sex into Scottish politics….would we?Jun 3, 10:41
    • Bobo bunny on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “https://www.facebook.com/share/v/19w7oZWbXw/Jun 3, 10:41
    • Jack Thomson on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Superb summary. Can you give me your thoughts on the following: All payments for the motor home were made in…Jun 3, 10:35
    • Cuphook on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “I look forward to other journalists ‘discovering’ these facts in the next day or two. A trenchant explanation that will…Jun 3, 10:30
    • Kenneth Coutts on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Superb reporting, do not let up , do not let them away with Any of it. Alex and his family…Jun 3, 10:25
    • Al-Stuart on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “. Y’know Stuart, in my former career as a plod, there were many miscreants for whom I and my colleagues…Jun 3, 10:25
    • Willie on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Absolutely informative detailed piece Rev Stu. This is journalism as it should be. No one should be in any doubt…Jun 3, 10:22
    • Joan Savage on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “I’m in no doubt that Sturgeon was an Accessory After The Fact. She was complicit in concealing Murrell’s crimes and…Jun 3, 10:22
    • Dubh on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Excellent work. No notes.Jun 3, 10:13
    • Michael P on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “It’s all there, and has been on this site for more than 5 years – the arrogance and short-sightedness of…Jun 3, 10:13
    • SilentMajority on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “If I wore a hat I would definitely take if off as a salute to you for this work..just brilliant!…Jun 3, 10:12
    • agentx on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: ““Nicola Sturgeon resigned as party leader in February 2021 and Peter Murrell followed suit as chief executive a month later”…Jun 3, 10:09
    • Ronnie on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Filleted.Jun 3, 10:09
    • peter on Up The Hill And Down The Slope: “Well done, a brilliant account. What chance of your expertise in this matter being aired on TV and radio?Jun 3, 10:01
  • A tall tale



↑ Top