The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Ask Wings Over Scotland 31

Posted on February 16, 2013 by

We note with interest a letter in the Scotsman today:

“This debate about the word “separation” is annoying and a distraction from the real issues. I am waiting for some answers from the SNP about the potential shape of an independent Scotland. This is a waste of time.

J ADAMS
Harrison Gardens
Edinburgh”

We’re not in the SNP, Mr Adams, but we’re happy to help you out anyway.

Read the rest of this entry →

The logic gap 79

Posted on February 16, 2013 by

As the son of a multi-millionaire, hereditary Labour MP Anas Sarwar has probably never had to think very much about money in his life. We’re not sure that’s an excuse for the mind-numbing arithmetical stupidity of what he says in the Daily Record today.

sarwarmisc

Proposing to “turn up the heat on the SNP by tearing apart some of their main policies”, and more specifically by continuing Labour’s enormously unpopular assault on universal services, Sarwar is reported by the paper as saying:

“there is no point funding free care for the elderly when half the people in the poorest parts of Scotland do not live long enough to take advantage.”

Bizarrely – and not for the first time it pains us to be obliged to spell out something so blindingly obvious – it seems to have escaped Mr Sarwar’s attention that dead people don’t require care. Therefore, the policy only requires to be funded for the people who DO live long enough to obtain its benefits, which means that the only financial savings to be made would be those made at the expense of old, sick, but still alive people.

Read the rest of this entry →

And finally… #20 21

Posted on February 15, 2013 by

We haven’t had anything from the Scottish Political Archive for a wee while, so in the light of today’s doom-mongering about the dangers of aggressive separatists, we thought we’d share a few other warnings from through the ages. Click to size up.

dangerseparatists

And just to bring us right up to date, there’s a bonus leaflet below.

Read the rest of this entry →

Peeking behind the curtain 92

Posted on February 15, 2013 by

In this site’s view, the single most important truth that YesScotland will need to convey to the Scottish electorate if it wants to win the 2014 independence referendum is the reality of what a No vote will mean for devolution. It’s a theme we’ve covered extensively, and will continue to highlight because it’s the core thing the Unionist campaign don’t want people to know.

enochpowell2

All three London-run parties are engaged in the pretence that if Scots reject full control of their own affairs they’ll be showered with new powers by Westminster, despite that premise collapsing under the slightest scrutiny. But today an alert reader pointed us towards something that reveals a much more convincing reality.

Read the rest of this entry →

Chancer calls bluffers 67

Posted on February 15, 2013 by

There’s a rather interesting story buried deep down in the dusty undergrowth of the Scotsman’s politics section today, featuring Jeremy Purvis of the cross-party “Devo Plus” (remember THEM?) group, which apparently marks its anniversary this month.

Purvis’s campaign (also featuring former Tory Presiding Officer Alex Fergusson and, um, we’re sure we’ll recall the others shortly) pretty much died at birth – its Twitter account last saw action on November 30 last year and we can’t even tell when the website was last updated because it has no timestamps, but it was a LONG time ago. He seems to have sensed an opportunity today, though, and has called on what the Scotsman rather startlingly refers to as “the anti-independence parties” to support Devo +’s proposals to devolve full tax powers to Holyrood in the event of a No vote.

Read the rest of this entry →

New things in cartons 39

Posted on February 15, 2013 by

We’re still mulling over the exclusive design/logo for “Heroes” in the fundraising campaign, but we were so pleased with this when we came up with it this morning that we thought it was too good to limit to people with lots of money.

betterourselves

It’s also the first Megastore sub-section with the new version of our masthead logo, designed to show progress from 2012 to 2013. (Last year we’d just found our old wings in the attic, now we’ve well and truly got them on. Not sure what we’re going to do for 2014 yet, maybe patch up all the holes.)

We might do a special version or exclusive colour run for Heroes or something, or come up with something different entirely. For now, click the image to see the product range, or just simply look at it and bask in our genius 😉

And finally… #19 42

Posted on February 14, 2013 by

We’re becoming increasingly concerned that perhaps Scotland SHOULD extinguish any remaining vestiges of independence and allow itself to be incorporated into a Greater England, if our education system is anything to go by.

We’ve highlighted on several occasions a catastrophically poor grasp of arithmetic in the Scottish populace, although for some reason it seems to be restricted to those intending to vote No in the referendum.

causesmall

“20 times 10 is 500” is bad even for Rangers fans, though.

8 Days Later 141

Posted on February 14, 2013 by

We were pretty stunned after the first 24 hours of our fundraising project, and we’re barely any less dumbfounded after another week.

Read the rest of this entry →

Good nationalism, bad nationalism 180

Posted on February 14, 2013 by

Unionists never miss a chance to sneer at “Braveheart”, a film which won five Oscars and tells a true story (very heavily embellished by Hollywood) about a people’s fight for self-determination. Only last night, Scotland Tonight retweeted one eager young No voter using it as an explanation for the increase in support for independence among the 18-24 demographic, even though the film came out almost 20 years ago.

This sort of thing, though, is fine:

skyfall1

That’s because nationalism is great, so long as it’s British.

Read the rest of this entry →

Putting out fire with gasoline 25

Posted on February 14, 2013 by

There’s a faintly astonishing story in today’s Scotsman. As if belatedly realising the damage that they’d done to the No campaign by detailing Labour’s toys-out-of-pram tantrum in the House Of Commons this week, the paper runs a firefighting exercise of a follow-up piece which reveals no new information, but gives the party a helpful platform from which to try to winch itself out of the hole.

iainmckenzie

(A “senior party source” duly obliged with the comically-absurd assertion that “the party’s main concern was that without a reference to independence, an MP could be stopped from speaking for going off the subject.”)

That’s not the astonishing part, of course – giving Unionist parties a platform is what the Scotsman exists for. The amazing thing is the size of the gulf between what the story reports as the reason for the debate’s cancellation and what the person whose debate it was had already said in public a full day earlier.

Read the rest of this entry →

Between the whines 44

Posted on February 13, 2013 by

Fans of TV panel shows will probably be aware of a regular strand on the BBC’s Mock The Week called “Between The Lines”, in which one comedian delivers lines from a speech in the persona of a public figure, while the other translates what they really mean. There’s a chucklesome example here.

blairmcdougall9

For a bit of fun we’ve decided to have our own attempt, with a letter sent out this week to the No campaign’s mailing list by the independence debate’s own Hugh Dennis: “Better Together” campaign director and creative truth interpreter Blair McDougall.

Read the rest of this entry →

Minor blogroll update 22

Posted on February 13, 2013 by

As veteran readers will know, we like to keep our blogroll fresh so that it offers only the leanest and juiciest collection of unmissable sites for when you’ve devoured every last page of Wings Over Scotland. This month we’ve had a small prune to make room for some new blood, if you’ll forgive the mixed metaphor.

Out go the Herald and Scotsman because, hey, you know fine where the Herald and Scotsman are. That freed a couple of slots which we’ve given to the all-encompassing “Dundee wifey” Subrosa and Liberal Democrat Voters For Independence, both very welcome additions which broaden our outlook considerably.

We’ve also hoofed the Spectator’s braying Fraser Nelson out of the Zany Comedy Relief section for not gracing us with any Scottish-themed doltishness in weeks, and his replacement is a grassroots Labour blog that we think you’re going to love to bits. Ladies and gents, please revel in the positive case for the Union that is Niko’s Bar.

Otherwise, as you were. Suggestions always welcomed.

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,987 Posts, 1,252,553 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Ex President Xiden on Still Time To Save Her: “Exactly. As I said elsewhere, the decision to charge never mind prosecute in cases like this, lies solely with the…” Oct 14, 07:39
    • Ex President Xiden on Still Time To Save Her: “The decision to prosecute in cases like this lies solely with the Crown Office. The police only follow their instructions.” Oct 14, 07:36
    • Willie on Still Time To Save Her: “Destroy the language,the culture, the history and you destroy the people. The UK needs Scotland’s resources and so that is…” Oct 14, 02:27
    • Bilbo on Still Time To Save Her: “Funny how there are sections of our society that has called on the Supreme court ruling about women to be…” Oct 13, 21:29
    • Bilbo on Still Time To Save Her: “These constant constitutional conversations are interesting when they are done on a civil basis but the reality is that they…” Oct 13, 21:11
    • Aidan on Still Time To Save Her: “As you know Alf – the Supreme Court is a superior court to the inner house (before we get into…” Oct 13, 20:09
    • Alf Baird on Still Time To Save Her: ““on ending the sovereignty of the Parliament of the United Kingdom over Scotland” Ignorance and wishful thinking on the part…” Oct 13, 19:56
    • Aidan on Still Time To Save Her: “Agreed Northcode – happy to let others decide, we’ve put our respective cases forward” Oct 13, 19:08
    • Northcode on Still Time To Save Her: “Thanks for the exchange. I think we’re reading the judgment differently, and that’s fine — the Supreme Court’s reasoning is…” Oct 13, 16:21
    • Aidan on Still Time To Save Her: “Sorry Northcode – you need to go back and read the case again in detail. What you are saying there…” Oct 13, 15:49
    • Northcode on Still Time To Save Her: “I think there’s a misunderstanding here about what the Supreme Court actually decided. The Court did describe a referendum as…” Oct 13, 15:15
    • Hatey McHateface on Still Time To Save Her: “sarah, have you tried using the “Contact” button at top of page?” Oct 13, 14:58
    • Hatey McHateface on Still Time To Save Her: “Frightening that people still have belief in the criminal justice system, isn’t it. Commit a serious sexual assault on a…” Oct 13, 14:52
    • sarah on Still Time To Save Her: “Rev, please re-post on here your article of 13th October 2024, “The Giant”. It will be a comfort to true…” Oct 13, 14:42
    • Anthem on Still Time To Save Her: “I hope you’re including Reform in that H.” Oct 13, 14:39
    • Aidan on Still Time To Save Her: “@Northcode – again that is objectively untrue, the Supreme Court did not say that the proposed referendum could not be…” Oct 13, 13:54
    • Hatey McHateface on Still Time To Save Her: ““curtailing them as the foreigners in their own Countries” There’s only one political party in with a shout of being…” Oct 13, 13:40
    • Hatey McHateface on Still Time To Save Her: “Always amusing to see Confused praising the Norwegians whilst simultaneously lambasting those who believe defense is a key government priority.…” Oct 13, 13:22
    • Northcode on Still Time To Save Her: “For clarity. Holyrood cannot legislate a binding referendum. But Holyrood can hold a consultative referendum — the Supreme Court did…” Oct 13, 13:17
    • Hatey McHateface on Still Time To Save Her: ““most people don’t … think the boat crossings bear any meaningful comparison to the actual Norman invasion; because it is…” Oct 13, 13:05
    • Captain Caveman on Still Time To Save Her: “Oh do shut up Alf. Your wishful thinking isn’t reality (again). Yeah, must’ve imagined all those crowds in London and…” Oct 13, 13:04
    • Alf Baird on Still Time To Save Her: “Turabdin makes a valid point, that “The Union is not «celebrated» in any way”. An wha but yersels wad want…” Oct 13, 12:49
    • Confused on Still Time To Save Her: “THE TELEGRAPH RUNS THE SAME STORY about 3 times a week – a budget “black hole” which means we should…” Oct 13, 12:39
    • Captain Caveman on Still Time To Save Her: “”because it is fucking stupid. Nicely summed up. TURABDIN gives Sixth Formers a bad name, and is attempting to write…” Oct 13, 12:28
    • Southernbystander on Still Time To Save Her: “It is with posts like this that you reveal your profound ignorance of the people of these islands Turabdin, how…” Oct 13, 12:15
    • Captain Caveman on Still Time To Save Her: “@Dan As I have said to you before, disagreeing with someone or pointing at the paucity of their outlandish/inaccurate claims…” Oct 13, 12:02
    • Captain Caveman on Still Time To Save Her: ““You said you’ve paid millions in taxes yet you spend a lot of your time posting on a blog about…” Oct 13, 11:51
    • willie on Still Time To Save Her: “I see Neale Hanvey ex SNP and Alba MP has made a tweet about a period of up to seven…” Oct 13, 11:32
    • James Che on Still Time To Save Her: “Hatey, It needs all the peoples to not recognise the legality of the SNP and the devolved parliament from Westminster.…” Oct 13, 10:52
    • James Che on Still Time To Save Her: “It is not Scotland protecting Nicola Sturgeon or John Swinney, Englands Westminster parliament [ Scotland Act ] is under the…” Oct 13, 10:17
  • A tall tale



↑ Top