The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


The Path of God 60

Posted on February 17, 2013 by

We’re not quite sure what someone put in the tea at the Sunday Mail this morning, but the quoted-for-truth excerpt we’ve reproduced further down this post (emphasis ours) comes from what is a simply extraordinary editorial considering the source.

pathofgod2

We’ve been saying the same thing since 2011, of course, but seeing it in the Mail is a bit like the Telegraph saying “Y’know, communism isn’t all THAT bad”. The Indiana Jones analogy, and what it implies about independence, is particularly startling.

Read the rest of this entry →

Framing the debate 33

Posted on February 17, 2013 by

Headlines can be the bane of a writer’s life. Often – including on this site – an article will go out with a different title to the one the author originally envisaged, as part of the subbing process. Occasionally (if the sub-editor or editor isn’t very good at their job) the title can be one which the author feels misrepresents what they’ve written.

We have no idea whether or not that’s the case with a column in today’s Scotland On Sunday, penned by folk singer Karine Polwart, which goes under the eye-catching headline “Why I’ll vote Yes despite the SNP”. We’ll simply observe that there’s a fairly important word in that title which doesn’t appear at all in the actual article – and that indeed the thing the word describes is not referred to, or even obliquely implied, anywhere in the author’s words – and leave you to arrive at your own conclusions.

Don’t cut universal services for the old 63

Posted on February 16, 2013 by

Let me declare an interest. I am old enough to get the £200 tax-free winter fuel payment and free local bus travel anywhere in England. As I live in London my travel Freedom Pass extends to local bus and tube travel throughout London 24/7, and local trains from 0930. I guess the whole package is worth £700 a year to me, tax-free. Though in truth if I paid for London travel I would claim back much of it from clients and customers. So that’s that out of the way.

Well almost. I do not in the slightest need that money. If it disappeared tomorrow I would shrug and say “So be it”. It would not leave me freezing in the winter and cut off from family, friends or the local library. Or, come to that, work. So: I get it; I do not need it; and the amount is small enough in my personal financial affairs that whether I get it or not is neither here nor there.

So that leaves me uniquely able to say unequivocally that it would be complicated, counterproductive, and wrong to stop winter fuel payment and free bus travel for those over state pension age. Here’s why.

Read the rest of this entry →

Ask Wings Over Scotland 31

Posted on February 16, 2013 by

We note with interest a letter in the Scotsman today:

“This debate about the word “separation” is annoying and a distraction from the real issues. I am waiting for some answers from the SNP about the potential shape of an independent Scotland. This is a waste of time.

J ADAMS
Harrison Gardens
Edinburgh”

We’re not in the SNP, Mr Adams, but we’re happy to help you out anyway.

Read the rest of this entry →

The logic gap 79

Posted on February 16, 2013 by

As the son of a multi-millionaire, hereditary Labour MP Anas Sarwar has probably never had to think very much about money in his life. We’re not sure that’s an excuse for the mind-numbing arithmetical stupidity of what he says in the Daily Record today.

sarwarmisc

Proposing to “turn up the heat on the SNP by tearing apart some of their main policies”, and more specifically by continuing Labour’s enormously unpopular assault on universal services, Sarwar is reported by the paper as saying:

“there is no point funding free care for the elderly when half the people in the poorest parts of Scotland do not live long enough to take advantage.”

Bizarrely – and not for the first time it pains us to be obliged to spell out something so blindingly obvious – it seems to have escaped Mr Sarwar’s attention that dead people don’t require care. Therefore, the policy only requires to be funded for the people who DO live long enough to obtain its benefits, which means that the only financial savings to be made would be those made at the expense of old, sick, but still alive people.

Read the rest of this entry →

And finally… #20 21

Posted on February 15, 2013 by

We haven’t had anything from the Scottish Political Archive for a wee while, so in the light of today’s doom-mongering about the dangers of aggressive separatists, we thought we’d share a few other warnings from through the ages. Click to size up.

dangerseparatists

And just to bring us right up to date, there’s a bonus leaflet below.

Read the rest of this entry →

Peeking behind the curtain 92

Posted on February 15, 2013 by

In this site’s view, the single most important truth that YesScotland will need to convey to the Scottish electorate if it wants to win the 2014 independence referendum is the reality of what a No vote will mean for devolution. It’s a theme we’ve covered extensively, and will continue to highlight because it’s the core thing the Unionist campaign don’t want people to know.

enochpowell2

All three London-run parties are engaged in the pretence that if Scots reject full control of their own affairs they’ll be showered with new powers by Westminster, despite that premise collapsing under the slightest scrutiny. But today an alert reader pointed us towards something that reveals a much more convincing reality.

Read the rest of this entry →

Chancer calls bluffers 67

Posted on February 15, 2013 by

There’s a rather interesting story buried deep down in the dusty undergrowth of the Scotsman’s politics section today, featuring Jeremy Purvis of the cross-party “Devo Plus” (remember THEM?) group, which apparently marks its anniversary this month.

Purvis’s campaign (also featuring former Tory Presiding Officer Alex Fergusson and, um, we’re sure we’ll recall the others shortly) pretty much died at birth – its Twitter account last saw action on November 30 last year and we can’t even tell when the website was last updated because it has no timestamps, but it was a LONG time ago. He seems to have sensed an opportunity today, though, and has called on what the Scotsman rather startlingly refers to as “the anti-independence parties” to support Devo +’s proposals to devolve full tax powers to Holyrood in the event of a No vote.

Read the rest of this entry →

New things in cartons 39

Posted on February 15, 2013 by

We’re still mulling over the exclusive design/logo for “Heroes” in the fundraising campaign, but we were so pleased with this when we came up with it this morning that we thought it was too good to limit to people with lots of money.

betterourselves

It’s also the first Megastore sub-section with the new version of our masthead logo, designed to show progress from 2012 to 2013. (Last year we’d just found our old wings in the attic, now we’ve well and truly got them on. Not sure what we’re going to do for 2014 yet, maybe patch up all the holes.)

We might do a special version or exclusive colour run for Heroes or something, or come up with something different entirely. For now, click the image to see the product range, or just simply look at it and bask in our genius 😉

And finally… #19 42

Posted on February 14, 2013 by

We’re becoming increasingly concerned that perhaps Scotland SHOULD extinguish any remaining vestiges of independence and allow itself to be incorporated into a Greater England, if our education system is anything to go by.

We’ve highlighted on several occasions a catastrophically poor grasp of arithmetic in the Scottish populace, although for some reason it seems to be restricted to those intending to vote No in the referendum.

causesmall

“20 times 10 is 500” is bad even for Rangers fans, though.

8 Days Later 141

Posted on February 14, 2013 by

We were pretty stunned after the first 24 hours of our fundraising project, and we’re barely any less dumbfounded after another week.

Read the rest of this entry →

Good nationalism, bad nationalism 180

Posted on February 14, 2013 by

Unionists never miss a chance to sneer at “Braveheart”, a film which won five Oscars and tells a true story (very heavily embellished by Hollywood) about a people’s fight for self-determination. Only last night, Scotland Tonight retweeted one eager young No voter using it as an explanation for the increase in support for independence among the 18-24 demographic, even though the film came out almost 20 years ago.

This sort of thing, though, is fine:

skyfall1

That’s because nationalism is great, so long as it’s British.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,978 Posts, 1,251,135 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on Like Responsible Citizens Do: “So you’re enslaved now, Alf? There’s numbers you can call. They’ll get you out, or get you treatment. My money’s…Sep 15, 17:46
    • Hatey McHateface on Like Responsible Citizens Do: “I’m imagining, Alf, that you veer between the “no option” and the “co-operative venture” explanations, picking the appropriate one each…Sep 15, 17:42
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Fear And Favour: “A major theme of contemporary Italian philosopher Giorgio Agamben is that a ‘State of Exception’ is in force when the…Sep 15, 17:38
    • Colin Dawson on Fear And Favour: “I’ll be happy to donate.Sep 15, 17:34
    • Spartan 117 on Like Responsible Citizens Do: “Alf, you just proved my point. Stuff that happened in the 18th Century has no relevance whatsoever in 2026. Interesting,…Sep 15, 17:28
    • James Che on Fear And Favour: “The extra alphabet nonsense appears as soon as I press post,Sep 15, 17:24
    • Spartan 117 on Fear And Favour: ““McCafferty”, actually (bloody great play, that), but I suspect yes. “Come ahead, McQuillan”.Sep 15, 17:04
    • Iain Hamilton on Fear And Favour: “Card at the ready.Sep 15, 16:56
    • Alf Baird on Like Responsible Citizens Do: ““comparing present-day Scotland to some of the appalling historical examples which clearly do not match at all is not only…Sep 15, 16:51
    • M.E on Fear And Favour: “Rookie mistake. Judicial reviews are only available for gender related matters, as you know firsthand.Sep 15, 16:47
    • Alf Baird on Like Responsible Citizens Do: ““Who here cares about trinkets that were stolen. Our country was stolen.” Indeed so, Fearghas, as Burns wrote Scots and…Sep 15, 16:38
    • Frank Gillougley on Fear And Favour: “It’s that ‘McQuillan! Yer tea’s oot!’ moment.Sep 15, 16:38
    • Northcode on Like Responsible Citizens Do: “The UN process is actually much simpler than that, and it doesn’t involve sponsorships or evaluations for non-listed territories. Under…Sep 15, 16:22
    • Xaracen on Like Responsible Citizens Do: “Correction; I had said the UK can require Scotland NOT be added, but that isn’t correct. The UK has no…Sep 15, 16:21
    • Effijy on Fear And Favour: “They cannot get away with this!Sep 15, 16:13
    • Andy Ellis on Fear And Favour: “If the 12 years since #indyref1 have taught us anything it is that any mass movement will contain its leavening…Sep 15, 15:59
    • Xaracen on Like Responsible Citizens Do: “Northcode, my understanding from last year was that before Scotland’s petition can be evaluated, Scotland must be sponsored by a…Sep 15, 15:54
    • Captain Caveman on Fear And Favour: “I’ll be chipping in too, in the event of a fundraiser.Sep 15, 15:46
    • Captain Caveman on Like Responsible Citizens Do: “@BP “I’ve already conceded that Northcode is correct” Well in that case we’re agreed, and there isn’t really a discussion…Sep 15, 15:44
    • Robert McDonald on Fear And Favour: “Just shout up and I’ll be happy to assist with a donation.Sep 15, 15:42
    • Andy Ellis on Fear And Favour: “It’s now obvious to anyone with eyes to see that no progress will be possible towards the shared ultimate goal…Sep 15, 15:29
    • Hatey McHateface on Like Responsible Citizens Do: “I’ve never blamed migrants for all my ills. But I have a lot of sympathy for the people stabbed or…Sep 15, 15:29
    • Breastplate on Like Responsible Citizens Do: “HH, As long as Westminster calls the shots, Scotland can whinge and moan as much as they want, Scotland can…Sep 15, 15:22
    • Casper on Fear And Favour: “Its similar to BBC complaints – the process is to put you off. Keep it up.Sep 15, 15:10
    • Andrea on Fear And Favour: “I am ready to donate.Sep 15, 15:05
    • Hatey McHateface on Fear And Favour: “To be fair, CM’s preoccupations these days are only a little aligned with those of ordinary Scots, however much a…Sep 15, 15:05
    • Insider on Like Responsible Citizens Do: “James Che says: “Its always wise to look at what Westminster parliament is doing, has done in the past and…Sep 15, 14:55
    • MarkerPost on Fear And Favour: “Absolutely will contribute to any crowdfunding for this. Needs to be exposed to the sunlight.Sep 15, 14:53
    • Hatey McHateface on Like Responsible Citizens Do: “Can a colony be on the theoretical hook for billions of pounds worth of reparations for slavery, theft, genocide, etc.?…Sep 15, 14:44
    • Mark Beggan on Fear And Favour: “Stay Calm and Donate. Make Scotland Normal Again.Sep 15, 14:36
  • A tall tale



↑ Top