The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Archive for the ‘analysis’


The illiterate solicitor 123

Posted on August 19, 2025 by

Before becoming a politician Nicola Sturgeon had a brief and somewhat unsuccessful career in the world of law. Which means she has no excuse whatsoever for this:

Because in law, yes it does. That’s EXACTLY what it means.

Read the rest of this entry →

The World Inside Her Head 131

Posted on August 15, 2025 by

The media coverage of the gender-ideology revelations in Nicola Sturgeon’s memoir has been based on a couple of short sentences from it, but since the main section of the book devotes 14 pages to the subject it’s worth checking out in depth, at least until something more interesting happens.

Highly intelligent people only, obviously.

Read the rest of this entry →

The Envious Heart 134

Posted on August 14, 2025 by

There was one revealing moment in what was an otherwise nauseatingly sycophantic interview with Nicola Sturgeon by Adam Fleming on BBC2 last night.

And the thing it revealed is what Sturgeon’s book is really about. Because as more and more extracts have found their way into the public domain this week, the overarching theme of “Frankly” has become impossible to miss.

Read the rest of this entry →

The Endless Evil Of Everyone Else 199

Posted on August 12, 2025 by

As more and more of Nicola Sturgeon’s memoirs ooze out into the public sphere like pus leaking from a burns-victim’s blisters, it’s easy to get overwhelmed by the sheer volume of rank, festering untruth spreading out in all directions.

First she audaciously attempted to blame Alex Salmond for supposedly leaking the news of his own arrest on false sexual-assault charges to the press, a laughably mad allegation totally derided by everyone involved including the journalist the story was leaked to (by Sturgeon’s own chief of staff, Liz Lloyd).

For good measure she then accused the MSPs investigating her conspiracy against him of being mere puppets controlled and directed by Salmond, an obvious nonsense immediately refuted by them directly, in case the idea of Murdo Fraser taking orders from Alex Salmond wasn’t already too idiotic to contemplate.

And her spewing sewage cannon still wasn’t done, managing to dredge up another smear that Salmond had been secretly opposed to equal marriage in 2012, an assertion so laughably obviously disproved by entire truckloads of evidence that making it can only have been a result of the gravest desperation.

(Or perhaps pure jealousy that Pink News never made HER their “Ally Of The Year”, as they did with both Salmond and David Cameron.)

But even so, this might be the boldest Hail Mary attempt of all.

Because even for Nicola Sturgeon, trying to rewrite time itself is an ambitious move.

Read the rest of this entry →

Rapist’s Rights 98

Posted on August 11, 2025 by

Say what you like about Nicola Sturgeon, but she’s not stupid. Releasing her memoirs when the Scottish Parliament is in recess has ensured acres of media coverage for what so far have been extremely anodyne “revelations” bundled up with barefaced and obvious lies of such startling audacity that it’s almost impossible to discuss them rationally. (Which is of course the point.)

But this extract from an interview to be aired on ITV tonight is actually interesting.

In it, Sturgeon doggedly continues to refuse to use male pronouns for multiple rapist Adam “Isla Bryson” Graham, despite admitting that he IS male, instead calling him “they”. But it was the bit before that that raised our eyebrows.

Read the rest of this entry →

Snowflake Patrol 91

Posted on August 08, 2025 by

We’ve written a couple of articles about the media coverage of this already, but as the slow summer season continues it’s worth taking a little time to have a proper look at the source material, because it’s your cash that’s being spent on it, and used to shape public policy in Scotland.

And it’s very hard to overstate both what a waste of money, and what a colossal insult to every woman in Scotland, it represents.

Read the rest of this entry →

The Churn 96

Posted on August 07, 2025 by

A little over two years ago, three SNP MSPs contested the leadership of the party in the wake of the sudden resignation of Nicola Sturgeon. All were full of grand plans and dreams for the future of the party, the nation and the independence movement.

None of the three is leader now, and in nine months’ time none of them will be SNP MSPs. Indeed, it’s overwhelmingly likely that none will be an MSP at all.

And that, readers, is not a sign of a party – or indeed a Parliament – in good health.

Read the rest of this entry →

Trying To Understand 29

Posted on August 06, 2025 by

It can be very hard to follow the arguments of people trying to convince you to vote for the SNP on the regional list at next year’s election. Here’s one just a month ago:

So that’s clear – indy supporters MUST IGNORE the “siren voices” telling them to vote for smaller indy parties, because they can’t win any seats and therefore to vote for them is to “throw away” your list vote.

And this was them just two weeks ago, strenuously insisting that the small parties were a busted flush and there was no chance of a “non-SNP route to independence”:

So it was a bit confusing to read this yesterday:

Because all of a sudden, it seems that you CAN vote for the smaller indy parties, regardless of whether they win seats or not, because the list vote will actually be a de-facto referendum and the votes will still count. And indeed, apparently you SHOULD do so, because an SNP-only route – the thing which was the only hope a fortnight ago – is now “totally unachievable” and ONLY working in concert with the smaller indy parties can succeed.

Heavens, what huge transformative event did we miss?

Read the rest of this entry →

The Deafening Echo Of Nothing 137

Posted on August 03, 2025 by

These two Sunday front pages three weeks apart sounded awfully similar.

But it turned out to be a lot worse than we thought.

Read the rest of this entry →

The Changemakers 35

Posted on August 03, 2025 by

When we get bored in the summer silly season, we often start poking around in stats. This week we’d been pondering the complete waste of everyone’s time Anas Sarwar’s four and a half years in charge of Scottish Labour have been, and the open goal he’s missed in failing to capitalise on a period of constant chaos and turmoil for the SNP.

That got us to thinking about which leaders in the Scottish Parliament era have made a significant difference (in either direction) to the fortunes of their parties, and from there it was pretty short work to illustrate it in the form of a graph.

It rather leaps out at you, doesn’t it?

Read the rest of this entry →

The Empty Hearse 207

Posted on July 30, 2025 by

There’s been a very unfortunate typo here.

“Scotland’s independence” should read “SNP’s gravy bus”.

Read the rest of this entry →

Scotland’s Saviour 72

Posted on July 28, 2025 by

No, wait, hear us out.

It’s not what you think.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,904 Posts, 1,241,301 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Tommo on And Nothing Happened Forever: “‘So we really may as well not have bothered’ The same could be said of both the mainland devolved assemblies;…May 9, 17:26
    • paul on And Nothing Happened Forever: “From Sri Lanka’s electoral commision: 03. What are the qualifications and disqualifications to be a candidate at a Parliamentary election…May 9, 17:23
    • Breastplate on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Aidan, pu tin is used as a bogeyman to scare the bejeesus out of us western plebs. The horrific idea…May 9, 17:08
    • Lorncal on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Och me, it was a joke, Geri. Yes, I agree that this is a very evident sign of decay on…May 9, 17:07
    • Geri on And Nothing Happened Forever: “It has done a lot of good, TBF. Once SNP completed Alex Salmonds projects the decline & rot started. Sturgeon…May 9, 17:07
    • Sven on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Turabdin @ 11.30. Somehow as I survey the Cowards’ Castle of self serving careerists at Holyrood the portion of W…May 9, 16:55
    • What Rot on And Nothing Happened Forever: “We DID start somewhere. We’ll never get closer than to where Alex took us. The generation that fought with Alex…May 9, 16:50
    • Bilbo on And Nothing Happened Forever: “The media focus on all these boats coming across the English channel but nothing is mentioned about the many, many…May 9, 16:28
    • Lorncal on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Thank you for that, Sven. I was going to do a bit of research myself because I wasn’t sure. That…May 9, 16:25
    • Rob on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Is the closure of the Scottish parliament really such a bad thing? I would vote for its removal these days…May 9, 16:17
    • Bilbo on And Nothing Happened Forever: “I had caught a bit of Swinney on Sky news and it was vomit inducing. It’s hard not to get…May 9, 16:14
    • Mark Beggan on And Nothing Happened Forever: ““Whatever happened to Leon Trotsky? He got an Ice pick that made his ears burn.”May 9, 16:13
    • Bilbo on And Nothing Happened Forever: “With respect, you come into this forum with such nonsensical stuff about the SNP. It’s coming across as you are…May 9, 16:07
    • Bilbo on And Nothing Happened Forever: “What Rot If you had actually read it, the AI response I had quoted was a summary of the specific…May 9, 15:54
    • TURABDIN on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Life is not an easy matter… You cannot live through it without falling into frustration and cynicism unless you have…May 9, 15:53
    • Geri on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Okeydoke, I see what you mean. You’re referring to the UK being a signatory. Interesting can of worms that. Could…May 9, 15:52
    • Geri on And Nothing Happened Forever: “He isn’t a signatory. He withdrew over Crimea. Crimea was never a part of an independent U. U failed to…May 9, 15:25
    • Mark Beggan on And Nothing Happened Forever: “‘And what costume shall the poor girl wear To all tomorrow’s parties? A hand-me-down dress from who knows where To…May 9, 15:19
    • Jim Thomson on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Why would the unionist media want to do that?May 9, 15:16
    • 100%Yes on And Nothing Happened Forever: “I was just wondering if Mr Broon was in downing street to address Scotland and the constitutional question?May 9, 15:10
    • Geri on And Nothing Happened Forever: “AI Dan doesn’t realise it’s all pantomime. Reform is just another distraction for another five years cause the British State…May 9, 15:05
    • Aidan on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Obviously as a signatory to the ICC he’d be arrested upon arrival but sure . .May 9, 14:51
    • Geri on And Nothing Happened Forever: “I think we need some Lego vids lol.. Bite size & factual.May 9, 14:47
    • Geri on And Nothing Happened Forever: “What Rot Aye, but it can be a quick digest/brief summary if you only pay attention to the official sources…May 9, 14:39
    • What Rot on And Nothing Happened Forever: “We DID start somewhere. We’ll never get closer than to where Alex took us. The generation that fought with Alex…May 9, 14:37
    • Minceheid on And Nothing Happened Forever: “robertkknight says: 9 May, 2026 at 1:38 pm Best toddle off back to Wee Ginger Fud. To be honest I’d…May 9, 14:30
    • TURABDIN on And Nothing Happened Forever: “What’s happening in QUÉBEC… https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20251030-30-years-after-cliffhanger-vote-quebec-separatists-voice-hope-for-independence Mon dieu, a 17 year old rapper…… SNP looking a bit carehome?May 9, 14:25
    • Izzie on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Sorry dont know what you mean? After the troubles the Party has experienced and the dite predictions of a yesr…May 9, 14:18
    • What Rot on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Why do people keep quoting AI responses as any kind of evidence of anything. AI is not facts; it’s simply…May 9, 14:06
    • Cynicus on And Nothing Happened Forever: “”[…the SNP] are the corpse blocking our path. The less popular they get, the more our chances recede, and they’re…May 9, 14:01
  • A tall tale



↑ Top