The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



The tyranny of majorities 288

Posted on February 21, 2017 by

The reliably-wise Stephen Bush of The New Statesman said something perceptive yesterday on the subject of an EU referendum, although it applies much more widely.

bushref

It’s a view we’ve held for many years, most often in relation to UK governments ruling with huge majorities won on pretty tiddly pluralities of the vote (often in the mid-30%s), where the bulk of the electorate has no defence against a party it didn’t vote for.

Despite an electoral system that makes such events far rarer, the phenomenon crops up a lot in Scotland too, and both sides are guilty, often on the same subject. Scottish employment figures, for example, alternate with almost metronomic regularity between being higher/lower than those in the rest of the UK, and whichever it is in any given month one side or the other will trumpet it as conclusive and permanent proof that Scotland’s governance is better/worse than that of London.

(Even though Holyrood in fact has almost no power over the economy, so deserves little of either the blame or credit, whichever applies that month.)

The most common case, though, is Trident.

Read the rest of this entry →

In concrete boots 313

Posted on February 18, 2017 by

From today’s Herald:

heraldbae

It seems a good time to bring up another piece of our poll data.

Read the rest of this entry →

Doublethink of a number 124

Posted on February 17, 2017 by

The one great pillar of the argument against Scottish independence – greater than not being allowed into the EU, greater than being forced to barter with beads and potatoes because we wouldn’t have a currency, greater than losing Doctor Who or having the Chinese take their pandas back – is the economy.

Scotland is far too wee and too poor to be independent, they say – while indignantly denying that they’re saying it – because we only survive now thanks to a vast bailout every year from the rest of the UK, by which they in fact mean England. (Because it’s sure as heck not coming from Wales or Northern Ireland, which by any measure you care to choose are far poorer than Scotland.)

moncktonukip2

The name and size of this bailout vary wildly. Sometimes it’s a “deficit”, sometimes it’s a “black hole”, sometimes it’s a “fiscal transfer”, and it can be £8bn, £9bn, £10bn, £15bn, £28bn, £32bn or any other figure up to a hundred and eleventy thousand million bajillion squillion depending on who you’re talking to.

(The last one’s probably either David Coburn or Jackie Baillie.)

And while there are a dozen separate and compelling reasons why that argument is complete rubbish, none of them have any traction with diehard Unionists determined to believe that one of the richest and most blessed nations on Earth couldn’t possibly manage its own affairs like, say, Latvia or Ireland or Kuwait or Slovakia can.

But it turns out there IS a – surprisingly simple – way to get Unionists to categorically deny that England subsidises Scotland. You just have to ask them.

Read the rest of this entry →

Every revolution starts with a lone voice 256

Posted on February 16, 2017 by

From these small beginnings shall our ultimate victory come.

natanth

The votes for “God Save The Queen” being driven by Tories, English-born residents and supporters of a particular football club probably won’t come as the biggest shock in the world to anyone.

(Alert viewers will of course have noticed that due to MI5 INTERFERENCE in the poll, there were actually two votes for Hoots Mon, which have been suspiciously rounded down to one. We are conducting an investigation, by which we mean brutal purge.)

Dumbing it down for Ruth 71

Posted on February 16, 2017 by

Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson managed to make a bit of a balloon of herself earlier this month when she contrived to get THREE fairly key facts wrong in a single tweet about a poll on a second independence referendum.

ruthjim

(We’re not sure who the guy in the picture with her is. Probably a colleague.)

We suspected the reason she’d so badly misunderstood the data was that there were two options for “have another indyref in the next two years” and only one for “don’t have another indyref”, so when we were putting our latest poll together we thought we’d try to make it easier for her by having an equal number on both sides.

Read the rest of this entry →

A close shave 71

Posted on February 16, 2017 by

There’s a nice piece in today’s Scottish Sun about one of the findings of our newest Panelbase poll, on who was Scotland’s all-time best First Minister.

mountnicmore

We thought you’d want a more detailed look at the data behind it.

Read the rest of this entry →

Local colours 135

Posted on February 15, 2017 by

Just for fun.

ndyball

(The combined figure for all football fans, incidentally, is Yes 52% No 48%.)

All the damn vampires 306

Posted on February 15, 2017 by

There were no surprises in our latest Panelbase poll with regard to the independence question, at least not in terms of the headline figures – in line with a flurry of recent polls they came out at Yes 46% No 54%, with 2016’s Brexit vote seemingly having caused almost equal numbers of people to change sides since 2014.

indyfeb

But as readers will know, we usually like to probe a little bit deeper into the thoughts of our respondents than other media do, so we asked a few more questions on the subject. And the results of that were just plain weird.

Read the rest of this entry →

Kicking down the doors 323

Posted on February 14, 2017 by

When we commissioned our latest opinion poll from Panelbase, we were aware that there’d been a lot of polls recently about independence and Brexit/the EU and even Westminster voting intentions, but surprisingly few on the next thing that Scots will actually go to polling stations for – the council elections in May.

labdisaster

That’s odd because it’s a pretty significant vote, and could lead to some fairly seismic changes in how the country is governed. Despite losing the popular vote for the first time in 2012, Labour are still the dominant force in Scotland’s town/city halls, running almost twice as many of the country’s 32 local authorities (either in sole control or in coalition/minority administrations) as the SNP – 16 to nine.

Depending on the outcome in May, the Nats could either secure a grip on all levels of Scottish elected politics for the first time ever, or a Tory alliance with Labour as junior partners could keep most councils Unionist – something which could have all sorts of wider ramifications beyond local services. (That’s an article for another day.)

So the results below are pretty interesting.

Read the rest of this entry →

The cart and the horse 99

Posted on January 18, 2016 by

One of the most frustrating things about the independence campaign was when people tried to put policies before principles. The point of Scotland being independent, as we pointed out in the Wee Blue Book, isn’t so that it can install any particular political party in government or pursue any particular political direction. It’s simply for Scotland to be able to choose those for itself, not have them imposed on it against its will by the people of another country.

To that end, we’ve often published poll findings that show Scots holding views that are at odds with our own (eg on the death penalty or workfare), because it’s always worth remembering that you have to persuade the electorate you have, not shout angrily at it in the hope it’ll become the electorate you WISH existed.

mortonjudd

If you insist that independence must mean Policy X, you run the risk of needlessly and wrongly alienating people who support independence but might not back Policy X. It’s something that’s always worth keeping in mind.

Read the rest of this entry →

Crunching the numbers 151

Posted on January 15, 2016 by

For ages now it’s been nagging at us that there wasn’t a quick and easy reference point for all the opinion polls we’ve commissioned, listing all the subjects covered by each poll and linking to both our own analyses of the figures and the raw data tables for people who wanted to go delving in amongst the stats themselves.

pollsmaybe

So now there is – it’s here. (And in future you can easily locate it under “Polls” in the menu bar running across the top of the front page.) We’re off for a bit of a lie down.

Ten more years 115

Posted on November 16, 2015 by

Here’s a very quick one from our latest poll:

“From 0 (absolutely no chance) to 10 (a certainty), what do you currently think is the likelihood of Labour winning the 2020 UK general election?”

labwin

Above the midpoint (ie people who DON’T think Labour will win): 56%
Below the midpoint (people who DO think they’ll win): 28%

Get ready for Tories until 2025 at least, folks.

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,995 Posts, 1,254,152 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Alf, Sometimes when Hatey is using his thoughtful hat, he is pleasant to converse with, on other occasions his need…” Nov 22, 20:20
    • Southernbystander on Mind Your Business: “So you are saying UK elections are rigged. What is you evidence for this James? It is an easy thing…” Nov 22, 19:41
    • Aidan on Mind Your Business: “Alright Geri – so to sum up “the end is nigh” just like it was last week and the week…” Nov 22, 19:29
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “Imagine being on yer holidays & still shitting yersel you’ll miss something posted on a chat forum. I bet you’re…” Nov 22, 19:28
    • sarah on Mind Your Business: “It is so clear that what you say is correct, Alf Baird. After all, if there is a Treaty between…” Nov 22, 19:07
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “There’s that yoon hypocrisy again. Where the Union is all ancient guff from the dark ages – then when ppl…” Nov 22, 19:07
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “They’re winning the war. Funny that eh? There’s the West – always peddling the myth that everyone is skint &…” Nov 22, 18:47
    • Aidan on Mind Your Business: “Wonderful Geri – another two signature unhinged rants for me to read on this warm Sunday afternoon in Louisiana. Obviously…” Nov 22, 18:46
    • Aidan on Mind Your Business: “I don’t think it’s baffling at all that Alex Salmond focused on contemporary issues important and directly relevant to the…” Nov 22, 18:29
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “The next WM General Election is planned for the spring of 2027. All serious political observers agree on this. As…” Nov 22, 18:24
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Obviously a monumental injustice, then, for Andeh to take an annexed Scotland back into a closer relationship with, perhaps even…” Nov 22, 18:15
    • 100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “Sarah, You do know the referendum in 2014 was never a referendum to secure Independence but entirely designed to appease…” Nov 22, 18:03
    • Alf Baird on Mind Your Business: ““Well how wrong can one be? After all this was what our education in every school and university taught us.”…” Nov 22, 17:50
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “It must be very confusing when you and Lavrov get to chewing the fat, Alf. In his country, “liberation” means…” Nov 22, 17:48
    • 100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “I watched the video below and to be honest they where actually talking about with the SNP in power how…” Nov 22, 17:31
    • Alf Baird on Mind Your Business: “Correct James. International law confirms that whilst there remains colonial domination there can be no democracy for an oppressed people…” Nov 22, 17:23
    • 100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “The SNP is really the jewel in the British crown. https://www.itv.com/news/border/2026-11-21/snp-will-make-andy-burnham-prime-minister-in-hung-parliament” Nov 22, 17:16
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Drop Andeh a line before he goes too far down the road of conning Brussels with his PM of the…” Nov 22, 17:16
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Rial just a shade below 3.5 million to the pound, so still on the slide. Ruble looking a bit more…” Nov 22, 17:07
    • gm on Mind Your Business: “I agree, Sarah. he was and he did.” Nov 22, 16:55
    • sarah on Mind Your Business: “My comment was in response to yours, James Che! Alex an innocent amongst a pit of vipers.” Nov 22, 16:36
    • sarah on Mind Your Business: “It looks that way, I agree. So many backstabbers who owed everything they had to Alex. Also there’s only so…” Nov 22, 16:16
    • 100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “Salmond wasn’t a saint and he certainly wasn’t a hardline nationalist, all he was was the best of a rotten…” Nov 22, 15:39
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Sarah, I do not know why Alex took he route he did, or why he never spoke about the information…” Nov 22, 15:17
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “For a long time now it has not been about who votes in the elections, but who ounts the elections,” Nov 22, 14:57
    • 100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “The SNP has agreed three years before any election to give there support to Labour and Andy Burnham as the…” Nov 22, 14:51
    • sarah on Mind Your Business: “It is indeed a great pity that this topic wasn’t part of Alex’s public speaking. Although imagining an SNP government…” Nov 22, 14:19
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “Cappy, There you go again with that exceptionalist shite. The UK wasn’t a lone voice consistently trying to sway policy.…” Nov 22, 14:09
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Early discussions with Alex Salmond, after he had been in Westminsters library regarding the Treaty of union caused a change…” Nov 22, 12:56
    • Captain Caveman on Mind Your Business: ““Confused is correct” Ha. Really? Apart from the laughable inconsistencies that I’ve pointed out between the very things even he…” Nov 22, 12:41
  • A tall tale



↑ Top