The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


The doomsayers and the damage done 85

Posted on December 07, 2012 by

Earlier today we reported on the latest misery-laden assessment from business leaders about how Scottish independence would damage the economy, cause milk to curdle in the bottle, spread plague in the rat-infested slums and see Craig Levein return as national team manager. Just for fun, we thought we’d dig out some of the other things that business leaders have told us would bring untold gloom and catastrophe crashing down on our heads over the last couple of decades.

Read the rest of this entry →

A curious transformation 46

Posted on December 07, 2012 by

These are the leaders of the nation’s business community, as they present themselves to us when explaining that they’re the mighty “masters of the universe” and require to be paid ever-soaring salaries in order to generate wealth and jobs and growth, because without them society itself will crumble to dust and we’ll all be reduced to foraging for berries in the shattered ruins of our once-proud civilisation.

Read the rest of this entry →

Sometimes it’s all just too much 67

Posted on December 05, 2012 by

We’re over the worst of the flu now, readers. You can blow out those prayer candles. Sadly, though, we’re still not quite at 100% fighting fitness, so it might be a wee bit too dangerous to wade recklessly into the pool of shrieking, panicked insanity that poor Brian Wilson is thrashing around in at the Scotsman today.

If you perhaps weren’t yet certain of the power of Nicola Sturgeon’s tremendous and widely-lauded keynote speech at Strathclyde University on Monday, Wilson’s furiously incoherent and plainly terrified response is the proof of the pudding. The No camp is losing the argument, and they don’t know what to do about it.

We’re not about to help them out with strategy tips as to the right way to make their case, but out of basic human decency we’ll give them one clue: this isn’t it.

When push comes to shove 142

Posted on December 04, 2012 by

We had a brief but enjoyable Twitter debate (Twebate? Twiscussion? Twargument?) with the Spectator’s excellent Alex Massie earlier today, on the question of whether it’s possible for a person to genuinely belong to two countries at once. Our view has long been that it isn’t, but Massie seemed incredulous, querying whether Sir Walter Scott and Donald Dewar really didn’t see Scotland as a “proper” country.

We’ve long pondered over the simplest analogy to explain our view, and for want of a better alternative (plus we still have the flu) reluctantly went down the war route.

Read the rest of this entry →

The bananas splits 48

Posted on December 03, 2012 by

[FOOTBALL KLAXON.]

Okay, this has gone on long enough. We’ve been trying for quite a few months now to get anyone to explain something to us, and nobody ever has an answer. We’ve sat and watched with our heads in our hands as the SPL and SFL have competed to come up with the most bonkers, convoluted proposals for the reconstruction of Scottish football.

The SPL want two leagues of 12 splitting into three leagues of eight then merging back into two leagues of 12 again at the end, plus a league of 18 that just bumbles along feeling a bit left out of all the splitting fun. The SFL counters with a bizarre 16-10-16 (or possibly 16-10-18) system that has nowhere near enough fixtures in it, but proposes to fill the gaps with playoffs and by padding out the least popular competition in the Scottish game – the League Cup.

And all the while everyone pointedly ignores the most successful league system ever created in Scotland, which by coincidence was also the least embarrassingly stupid one, and which never ended with the team in 8th place in the final table having more points than the team in 5th place while all the other leagues laughed at us.

Please, for the love of God, someone tell us why.

Read the rest of this entry →

Scotsman proofreader vacancy still open 7

Posted on December 03, 2012 by

Perhaps the paper was confused after watching yesterday’s Andrew Marr Show, on which the host asked the question (at 37m) “Are you in favour of a squeeze on welfare?”, to which the allegedly-Labour politician Mr Balls replied “Of course!”

(Balls subsequently tried to waffle his way out of the response by claiming that he’d reduce the welfare bill by creating jobs, but Marr had expressly asked whether he backed the specific cuts to in-work benefits in the current welfare reform bill, and despite his repeating the question several times Balls refused to give an answer.)

Read the rest of this entry →

Onwards and upwards 7

Posted on December 01, 2012 by

Despite slightly fewer posts last month than the preceding one, Wings Over Scotland still entered its second year by hitting another new all-time pageviews record in November, with an increase of nearly 25,000 to 429,114. The more telling statistic, though, was the number of unique users, which rocketed by a whopping 24% as almost 5000 new people came to visit, bringing total readership past 23,000.

(We were going to stop doing these every month, but with December’s figures likely to take a fall due to the Christmas break, we hope you’ll forgive us one more moment of self-congratulatory horn-tooting while we’re still on the upslope.)

It also seems a good time to remind you that we’re always on the lookout for features to draw even more readers in. In 2013 we’d like to broaden our contributor pool a bit and add some more names to the excellent talent we’ve already been proud to showcase. 2012 has seen a dozen people other than myself notching at least one WingsLand byline, and we want lots more voices next year. If you’ve got something to say and you want tens of thousands of people to hear it, you know where to reach us.

Baffling mystery solved 22

Posted on November 30, 2012 by

A few months ago, lots of people in the Glasgow area were wondering how the city’s Labour party was going to be able to fund some of the lavish promises in its council-election manifesto, such as free wi-fi covering the entire city. Thanks to the intrepid journalism of local freesheet The Glaswegian, the answers are beginning to emerge.

“Thousands of elderly people could be forced to give up safety alarms after the introduction of charges. Glasgow City Council will next month introduce a £3-a-week charge for the community alarm telecare service.

The council’s arms-length service provider Cordia say that around seven per cent of the 13,500 users – 945 – have indicated they no longer want the service due to cost. But opposition councillors say they have been told up to 3000 will give up the alarm.”

Here at Wings Over Scotland, we say good riddance to the despicable something-for-nothing scroungers demanding that ordinary taxpayers fund the emergency service that could be the difference between their life and death. We only hope that Labour will increase the charges as time goes on, because otherwise snatching £3 a week from 10,000 vulnerable old folk will still take over three years to produce the £5m that the council is contributing towards a “regeneration” project intended to restore the “lost grandeur” of the street directly outside its imposing city chambers.

Right-wing party does well in elections 56

Posted on November 30, 2012 by

But enough about Labour. UKIP also put in some strong performances in the three Westminster polls last night, scoring two second-place finishes and one third place on a night when the Lib Dems sank to an astonishing EIGHTH and the BNP outpolled the Tories in the same Rotherham seat. The truly disturbing thing, though – speaking as a current resident of England – was the total absence of a single viable party of the left.

The turnout in all three elections was dismal, with two of them barely scraping past the 25% mark and the most popular just managing to get a third of voters out. And it’s hard to avoid the conclusion that at least a significant part of the reason for that may be the near-total lack of meaningful choice available.

Read the rest of this entry →

Leveson on Salmond 74

Posted on November 29, 2012 by

Analysis later. If you simply want to read the two passages of the Leveson Inquiry’s report which concern the actions of the First Minister without wading through 2000 or so pages, you’ll find them below. Bored readers may wish to compare the contents with our own assessment/predictions from five months ago. (NOTE: Where it says “emphasis added”, the emphasis in question was added by Lord Leveson, not by us.)

Read the rest of this entry →

The partial truth 29

Posted on November 29, 2012 by

The Scottish media is winding itself up for another sustained assault on the Scottish Government. Kerry Gill of the Scottish Daily Express has been pushing the story hard since last night along with some journalists from other English papers, and the BBC’s Scotland correspondent James Cook set the scene in a tweet this morning:

Sure enough, the Scotsman carried it as a front-page lead below only the Leveson Inquiry report – while inflating the figure by over £31,000 for effect – and the Herald also carries a prominent piece, although at least only rounding the amount up by £1,420.

The reports reveal that 36 people spent around a week in the US, taking part in various business events in addition to attending the golf tournament, which the Scottish Government was contractually obliged to send a delegation to as part of the agreement to host it at Gleneagles in 2014, and which is predicted to be worth £100 million to the Scottish economy. But as the papers line up to hand the Holyrood opposition a club to hit the First Minister with over the spending, there’s a very significant part of the equation missing from the coverage.

Read the rest of this entry →

Some product 9

Posted on November 29, 2012 by

Keen-witted viewers may have spotted a couple of additions to the central links column, which will help to support the site without costing you anything. If you want to buy anything through Amazon, visiting their site via the button on the right will divert a few pennies from your purchase to Wings Over Scotland, which isn’t quite as good as them paying proper amounts of tax but at least it’s something.

GiffGaff, meanwhile, is a top-notch pay-as-you-go mobile-phone network we’ve been using for a couple of years now and highly recommend for its excellent-value packages (especially if you use the internet on your phone) and terrific customer service.

Commercial message ends. As you were.

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,971 Posts, 1,249,592 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Che on Spot The Problem: “The referral to the Supreme court is under the Crown of England under the The UK parliament which Scotland holds…Aug 27, 15:20
    • Alf Baird on Spot The Problem: ““The crown applies only to England under the Westminsters parliament acts” This should seem obvious, James, but is taking time…Aug 27, 15:17
    • Northcode on Spot The Problem: ““In the structure you have described “Westminster” plays no role at all.” Apart from the fact that the structure was…Aug 27, 15:11
    • James Che on Spot The Problem: “Tommo, Well done for checking out Scots laws, seeing as the money spoke of is mainly Scots finances that were…Aug 27, 15:10
    • Alf Baird on Spot The Problem: ““There a name for that” Prof Elkins refers to Anglo-imperial rule over annexed territories as ‘legalized lawlessness’. Westminster and its…Aug 27, 15:06
    • James Che on Spot The Problem: “Aidan, Scotland has never throughout history made a treaty of union with the Great Britain parliament or with the parliament…Aug 27, 14:59
    • James Che on Spot The Problem: “North code. Scotland has never entered into a treaty of union with the Great Britain parliament at any time in…Aug 27, 14:35
    • Tommo on Spot The Problem: “The offences of ‘misfeasance/misconduct in public office’ do not, as I understand it, exist under Scots law; however ‘Scots law…Aug 27, 14:32
    • James Che on Spot The Problem: “Stu, This is the complicated position you are having to deal with when it crown to the crown offices and…Aug 27, 14:19
    • willie on Spot The Problem: “So let me get this right. The COPFS commits murder but the system is if it decides to do nothing…Aug 27, 14:19
    • Spartan 117 on Spot The Problem: “If you believe any of that, you must be incredibly naive. Fabians have infiltrated every strata of the state apparatus…Aug 27, 14:18
    • agentx on Spot The Problem: “additional information: ” The appeal announced today by the information commissioner relates to a judgment made by the Court of…Aug 27, 14:15
    • Aidan on Spot The Problem: “In the structure you have described “Westminster” plays no role at all. It is the Scottish FM and the Scottish…Aug 27, 14:13
    • Northcode on Spot The Problem: “Aye, Alf. The Lord Advocate’s authority is enshrined in the Scotland Act 1998, and the Lord Advocate exercises these responsibilities…Aug 27, 14:05
    • agentx on Spot The Problem: ““Watchdog goes to Supreme Court over secret Whatsapps in Sturgeon row Scotland’s transparency watchdog is to take the Scottish Government…Aug 27, 14:05
    • agentx on Spot The Problem: “The Fabian Society does not advise all the governance of Great Britain or Crown officials, as it is not an…Aug 27, 13:52
    • James Che on Spot The Problem: “It is not surprising that most people outside of Scotland think the Scottish government is actually a Scottish government. But…Aug 27, 13:42
    • Aidan on Spot The Problem: “It’s nothing to do with the way Westminster runs Scotland. Scottish law has never provided for private prosecution (unlike English…Aug 27, 13:42
    • Michael Bruce on This Other Earth: “To be fair, crimes that come with a public and unambiguous admission of guilt are notoriously difficult to prosecute.Aug 27, 13:41
    • John Cleary on This Other Earth: “Hi Robert. Would that be the first ring fenced fundraiser in 2017 or the second ring fenced fundraiser in 2019?Aug 27, 13:33
    • Alf Baird on Spot The Problem: ““the Crown Office IS at least theoretically accountable to Parliament” Aye, an in Ashis Nandy’s ‘subtradition’ colony that has ‘digested’…Aug 27, 13:29
    • James Che on Spot The Problem: “Aidan, What you say is true, This is the way Scotland is run by the Westminster parliament legislation and Statues…Aug 27, 13:24
    • James Che on Spot The Problem: “The Fabian Society are not in only one governance of Westminster due to being under the Westminster parliament of Englands…Aug 27, 13:15
    • Alastair on Spot The Problem: “So the Crown as in the English Crown and its structures – the Scottish Crown has not been passed -…Aug 27, 13:15
    • James Che on Spot The Problem: “This Fabian Society think tanks for the governance of Great Britain is where the ideas are formed on more than…Aug 27, 13:08
    • James Che on Spot The Problem: “The Fabian Society are the think tanks advising all the governance of Great Britain and Crown officials under employment ,…Aug 27, 13:03
    • cirsium on Spot The Problem: “Thanks Rev – that provoked a laugh. Thanks also for your continued coverage of what is actually going on in…Aug 27, 12:58
    • Hatey McHateface on Spot The Problem: ““resolution would more likely come through … sustained external pressure” Maybe 100,000 Sovereign Scots on the streets every Saturday, demanding…Aug 27, 12:57
    • Effijy on Spot The Problem: “Dear God, It’s like a corrupt process Donald Trump has cobbled together. Did you hear that Trump has sacked everyone…Aug 27, 12:53
    • James Che on This Other Earth: “The left leaning think tank founded in Great Britain has many members in the Labour party and probably in in…Aug 27, 12:48
  • A tall tale



↑ Top