The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Archive for the ‘comment’


Mightier than the sword 87

Posted on March 06, 2014 by

As we noted last week, Eton- and Sandhurst-educated Sir Norman Arthur, figurehead of the No campaign’s latest high-powered grassroots fundraising drive, has a very impressive military record – Commanding Officer of the Royal Scots Dragoon Guards, Commander of the 7th Armoured Brigade, General Officer Commanding of the 3rd Armoured Division, General Officer Commanding of Scotland and mentioned in despatches during the Troubles in Northern Ireland in the 1970s.

nopopery

It’s just lucky the IRA didn’t have Twitter, or things might have been different.

Read the rest of this entry →

They said, he said 125

Posted on March 05, 2014 by

Here’s a “Better Together” spokesman on Alex Salmond’s New Statesman lecture:

“Alex Salmond seems to have ditched his plan to be best pals with the rest of the UK and has instead decided to tell the English, Welsh and Northern Irish people how rubbish they are.”

We were there. Want to know what he actually said about England?

Read the rest of this entry →

The declaration of aspiration 210

Posted on March 05, 2014 by

So we’re just letting this one slide, are we?

“[David Mundell], who next year will mark 10 years as the only Tory MP in Scotland, says, if there is a Yes vote, the First Minister’s declaration of Independence Day will have no legal status and be merely an aspiration.”

The Edinburgh Agreement seems increasingly not worth the paper it’s written on.

Still some places available 154

Posted on March 04, 2014 by

Sounds like Hands Across The Border might be struggling for recruits.

handsacross

So how long before participation becomes a mandatory part of the Work Programme?

A tried and trusted strategy 96

Posted on March 04, 2014 by

Does any of this sound familiar, readers?

“Federalists [the opponents of Quebec independence] argued that the Yes campaign’s undertakings, such as those on using the Canadian dollar and joining international organisations, were, to a greater or lesser extent, dependent on the agreement of the rest of Canada, on other countries or on international organisations.

The assertion that Canada would immediately assume the obligations and rights of all Canada’s treaties and conventions was particularly controversial. The US, Canada and Mexico all stated that Quebec should not assume that entry into NAFTA would be automatic.”

Read the rest of this entry →

Why we shouldn’t do walking away 107

Posted on March 04, 2014 by

When former chancellor Alistair Darling said the following during the currency row, he should have known better (and no doubt did):

“The nationalist threat to default on debt if they don’t get their way on currency is reckless. The impact of Alex Salmond’s default would be to say to the world that we cannot be trusted to honour our debts.”

The empirical fact is that an independent Scotland would not be defaulting, reneging on, or walking away from anything. That’s because the UK government has already taken full responsibility for all debt accrued up to the date of Scottish independence.

wienerkongress

So we can just forget about it, right?

Read the rest of this entry →

Remember what they think of you 114

Posted on March 04, 2014 by

Prominent New Labour writer Dan Hodges has a piece in the Telegraph today (because where else would a New Labour commentator have a column?) about UKIP now being an openly racist party. It contains the following passage:

“Last May Farage visited Edinburgh, where he was met by a small but aggressive mob of protesters. Eventually he had to be escorted from the scene by police for his own safety.

Directly accusing the SNP of being behind the protest, Farage described the protesters as ‘racist Nazi scum’. The incident was, he said, ‘deeply racist and displayed a total hatred of the English’.

And he’s right. He wasn’t targeted on the basis of his race, but on the basis of his nationality. And as he said, that was racist.”

We’ll leave aside that the protest was nothing to do with the SNP or Scottish nationalists, that it was organised by a radical left-wing group and that one of the two men arrested in connection with the incident was in fact English himself. None of those factual inconveniences are allowed to get in the way of Hodges’ bigotry.

Read the rest of this entry →

The case as it is 72

Posted on March 02, 2014 by

If you missed it live, here’s the audio recording of the debate held at the Volunteer Rooms in Irvine on Friday. (The event wasn’t video-recorded, despite Clan Destiny Films having a high-quality camera team there, because the Labour MP for Central Ayrshire, Brian Donohoe, refused to give his permission.)

irvindebate

Click the image for the two-hour MP3 file.

Read the rest of this entry →

The meanings of life 81

Posted on March 02, 2014 by

This week’s edition of the Sunday Herald is a “referendum special” marking 200 days of the campaign to go (although actually it doesn’t have an awful lot more referendum coverage than a normal issue).

sh200

There are lots of things worth reading – as ever, we recommend spending a modest 69p for a digital copy via PressDisplay – but what really caught our eye were the two interviews with the heads of the Yes and No camps, Blairs Jenkins and McDougall.

Read the rest of this entry →

Pay your money, take your choice 83

Posted on March 02, 2014 by

This morning’s Scotland on Sunday:

devosos

Well, that seems clear.

Read the rest of this entry →

As other selves see us 56

Posted on March 01, 2014 by

Will Self in the New Statesman, 28 February 2014:

“As someone who for the past two decades has visited Scotland at least three or four times a year, and spent a great deal of those visits in and around the former steel town of Motherwell, I cherish few illusions about the country.

On the whole, I’ve considered independence to be something of a no-brainer: if ever there was a small, potentially socialistic state that could do with being detached from its deluded imperialist neighbour, it’s Scotland.”

Despite our misgivings about the shortbread, bagpipes, sporrans, whisky, Nessie and deep-fried Mars bar cover, the magazine’s special “Scotland” issue isn’t bad at all. Of course, as Scots we’re all far too mean to pay £3.95 – £3.95! – for a copy, but do go and browse it on your local newsagent’s shelves.

Read the rest of this entry →

A quirk of fate 58

Posted on March 01, 2014 by

The diagram below comes from an interesting feature in The Chemical Engineer Today, pointed out to us by an alert reader and which has a few flaws but is still well worth a browse if you have (quite a lot of) time.

seamap1

But the thing giving us a wee wry smile this morning is the realisation that if Tony Blair’s 1999  grab of 6000 square miles of Scottish sea is allowed to stand in post-Yes negotiations, we’ll find ourselves in a situation where the “Clyde”, “Argyll” and “Fife” oilfields belong to the rUK, while “Britannia” belongs to Scotland.

Blair’s theft, aided and abetted by Donald Dewar and largely hushed-up by the media, is no laughing matter. But sometimes you just have to appreciate a nice bit of irony.

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,975 Posts, 1,250,476 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on Anything But That: “Can’t you read, sam? It’s Mr Beggan to you. Seriously, though. Do you honestly believe you rate being hated? Get…Sep 6, 21:25
    • Hatey McHateface on Anything But That: “What is it now, Sooty? Auld Lochnagar always quick to get the shirt lifting accusations in early? Well, he did…Sep 6, 21:18
    • sam on Anything But That: “No friends, no wife, no job. Just hatred and Beggan.Sep 6, 21:01
    • Young Lochinvar on Anything But That: “MB Wrong (yet) again.. You probably never heard those insults on yer air cadet “Lionheart deployment” in ‘84 (to make…Sep 6, 21:01
    • Young Lochinvar on Anything But That: “To the Cow (Chas) from the Confused dot com tv add: “Who’s That Whistling!!! Lighten up FFS..Sep 6, 20:50
    • Young Lochinvar on Anything But That: “HMcH Corrie and Emmerdale.. Sigh! Such is life Sweep (or is it Parsley the Lion) to keep a happy marriage.…Sep 6, 20:42
    • Mark Beggan on Anything But That: “No they never. You just made that up. It was a Jerry helmet and a Japs eye. That’s why all…Sep 6, 20:41
    • Chas on Anything But That: “It is refreshing to see a bout of common sense and realism breaking out on Wings and…….. from an unlikely…Sep 6, 20:25
    • Hatey McHateface on Anything But That: “What’s that you say, Sooty? What would Auld Lochnagar ken aboot a TV soap that only his missus watches? You’re…Sep 6, 20:24
    • agentx on Anything But That: ““Jenny Gilruth is being groomed as a potential successor to John Swinney” https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/stephen-flynn-infuriates-civil-servants-37632876 —————————————— Could there be a more inappropriate…Sep 6, 20:15
    • Mark Beggan on Anything But That: “If anyone turns up declaring that they are chicken farmer then we should really begin to panic.Sep 6, 20:05
    • Young Lochinvar on Anything But That: “Call Quality Polis!! Hatey has Northcode locked up in his basement and has stolen his log-in details!!! It’s like a…Sep 6, 20:03
    • Mark Beggan on Anything But That: “I would like to read more of what you wrote today. You are on it. Ideological europhiles are yesterday. The…Sep 6, 20:01
    • Young Lochinvar on Anything But That: “MB We used to call the Germans “box heads”, they called us “island monkeys” Whits yer hat size Beggars? 12×12…Sep 6, 20:00
    • Hatey McHateface on Anything But That: “There’s a precedent. Ribbentrop was a champagne salesman.Sep 6, 19:53
    • Hatey McHateface on Anything But That: “Wow, Northy! The bridges are in sheets of flame today. I hope you’ve found the courage and decency to tell…Sep 6, 19:48
    • Hatey McHateface on Anything But That: “Man up, Northy! Don’t let sam intimidate and cow you into agreement and obedience. Stand tall! Besides, even if he…Sep 6, 19:40
    • Northcode on Anything But That: “Interesting… TURABDIN is chasing symbols: UN intervention external validation geopolitical rescue fatalistic narratives AgentX is describing strategy: democratic legitimacy internal…Sep 6, 19:16
    • Northcode on Anything But That: ““Northcode, I have always enjoyed your posts.” As do I yours.Sep 6, 19:13
    • Hatey McHateface on Anything But That: “Well, well. I predicted there would be a few things you wouldn’t want to talk about, sam. And my prediction…Sep 6, 19:12
    • Mark Beggan on Anything But That: “It is Mr Beggan to you. You dont decide anything about this page. Threats of violence Sam is the squeak…Sep 6, 19:04
    • Mark Beggan on Anything But That: “Auf Wiedersehen, Pet Who would have thought a perfume salesman would change German history. It is the end of the…Sep 6, 18:51
    • sam on Anything But That: “Usually I scroll past much of what is btl comment regarding it as shite. A good deal of that shite…Sep 6, 18:49
    • Young Lochinvar on Anything But That: “Missing person appeal! Will the real Northcode come forward please, his account here has clearly been hacked and it appears…Sep 6, 18:36
    • Mark Beggan on Anything But That: “Salmond new how difficult the task to unite Scotland internally would be. Everybody was on board on the anti English…Sep 6, 18:23
    • Mark Beggan on Anything But That: “Well said Northy. Better late than never, about Ten years late, but none the less. Seriously! That is something that…Sep 6, 18:12
    • Young Lochinvar on Anything But That: “NC Stopped reading at “the UK constitution is recognised by the UK Supreme Court”. Kind of says it all really..Sep 6, 18:02
    • TURABDIN on Anything But That: “Strategy and a preternatural understanding of the opponent. WOW….if only.Sep 6, 17:59
    • factchecker on Anything But That: “Just repeating this because it’s the best summary I’ve seen in years. Well done, Northy. “Independence requires maturity, realism, and…Sep 6, 17:09
    • Hatey McHateface on Anything But That: “sam likes to present ideas as evidence and conjecture as fact. He never quotes any source until he’s satisfied its…Sep 6, 16:52
  • A tall tale



↑ Top