At the weekend we all beheld the bizarre sight of two supposed investigative Scottish politics journalists sneering and trying to play down what appeared to be a genuinely major story about a live police inquiry into a possible £600,000 criminal fraud involving the party of government in Scotland.
Both of them work for the same rival outlet, so the most generous interpretation that could reasonably be put on their curious behaviour is that they were simply trying to focus attention instead on that outlet’s own big Sunday splash – also ostensibly a story of political fraud, albeit on a much smaller scale.
So let’s just clear that one up now to help them out.
Fresh from being embarrassed over a ridiculous smear story this week about someone complaining to the police about the use of a well-known political phrase by a Wings commenter, Tom Gordon of the Herald went on quite the attack yesterday.
The thread, which contains a number of basic factual errors about events*, continued for several more tweets all generally rubbishing our scoop from Friday afternoon and suggesting that no proper journalist (“the rest of us”) would have run the story.
So he must be feeling quite left out this morning.
Alert readers will know that for the past 15 months Wings has been investigating the apparent disappearance of almost £600,000 raised from supporters of independence (not just SNP voters) by the SNP in two fundraising campaigns in 2017 and 2019.
The money was supposedly to be “ring-fenced” for spending ONLY in a future indyref, and the party gave explicit and hotly-stated guarantees at the time of the first appeal that the money would definitely NOT be spent on party business.
But when the party’s 2019 accounts were published they showed that the SNP had less than £100,000 in the bank at the end of that year, and total net assets of less than £272,000. The £600,000 from the fundraisers was nowhere to be found, and the then-party treasurer’s feeble insistence that it was “woven through” the accounts in some unspecified way satisfied only the most gullible.
This week Wings Over Scotland has been told that the matter is now officially under investigation by the police.
Word reaches us from this afternoon’s meeting of the SNP NEC that three members of the Finance & Audit Committee (ie about half of it, we believe) have resigned on the basis that they’re responsible for the party’s finances but are unable to carry out their duties as chief executive Peter Murrell refuses to give them access to the books.
We don’t yet know if it’s specifically in relation to the missing £600,000 in “ringfenced” fundraiser money that was supposed to have been earmarked for use in a second independence referendum campaign but which cannot be identified in the records of a party whose last published accounts showed only £97,000 in the bank.
This isn’t quite yet a smoking gun, more of a starter’s pistol. But it’s already more than we’d expected from the Holyrood inquiry – an unambiguous statement that the First Minister misled it (and therefore Parliament) under oath.
What’s still missing at this stage is the word “knowingly”, which would turn it from a serious but non-fatal misdemeanour into a resignation offence. But nor, yet, is there any sight of the word “inadvertently”.
When Nicola Sturgeon is finally held to account for the charred, twisted and shattered ruins that she’s made of Scottish political and civic society in her desperate attempts to save her own neck, the complete discrediting of ostensible support organisations for victims of rape will be near the very top of the charge sheet.
But before we talk about that you really need to read this.
Because if you live in Scotland you can only rationally be one of two things at this moment in history: (a) terrified, or (b) an idiot.
We’ve received information this afternoon with regard to Nicola Sturgeon’s statements at today’s FMQs, which appear to have been wholly and disturbingly dishonest.
The quote below is from an email sent today by SNP communications chief Murray Foote, briefing ministers and MSPs on the official Scottish Government line, which is what the First Minister told the chamber in response to a question from Ruth Davidson.
Iain More on The Future Is Yesterday: “The latest Opinion Poll suggest that the SNP only has 33% support on the Constituency Vote. Yet we are living…” Feb 19, 06:07
Stuart MacKay on The Future Is Yesterday: “They’re more organised than you. Even if the SNP disappears, they’ll just hitch their wagon to the next horse that…” Feb 19, 05:56
Peter McAvoy on The Future Is Yesterday: “This list of candidates is only likely to increase despair. I wonder if they could keep Alexander Dennis open. No…” Feb 19, 02:13
Young Lochinvar on The Future Is Yesterday: “Aidan Sally Donald? I suspect you are barking up the wrong tree! Gaun yerself, go full-on-Tonto, ask Kelly Given out!!!…” Feb 19, 00:14
Young Lochinvar on The Future Is Yesterday: “Aidan Sally Donald? I suspect you are barking up the wrong tree! Gaun yerself, go full-on-Tonto, ask Kelly Given out!!!…” Feb 19, 00:13
James Barr Gardner on The Future Is Yesterday: “A Vote for the “Status Quo” is a Vote for Further Austerity at best, at worst a Third World War…” Feb 18, 22:21
Aidan on The Future Is Yesterday: “They’ll be advertising the vacancies for SNP MSP’s down at the job centre at this rate. I honestly think they’d…” Feb 18, 21:29
100%Yes on The Future Is Yesterday: “The SNP gave up on Scotland after the referendum. I just wished people would waken up before its to late…” Feb 18, 19:48
Effijy on The Future Is Yesterday: “It’s like 3 legged horses must have the right to enter the Scottish Grand National. If it can’t jump and…” Feb 18, 19:22
Hatey McHateface on The Future Is Yesterday: “Dunno why Stu has such a downer on Oor Fatima. I look at her and see future First Minister potential.…” Feb 18, 18:38
Hatey McHateface on Scotland In Numbers: ““For the arithmetically illiterate, professor Sullivan‘s percentages are not of mutually exclusive categories” Sez you! For the simply illiterate, perhaps…” Feb 18, 18:13
MaryB on The Future Is Yesterday: “Off topic but relevant. Inde car aka Gordon Ross reports that the UK government appears to have pulled the plug…” Feb 18, 18:10
100%Yes on The Future Is Yesterday: “So why not just vote Reform and be done with the SNP, sound good to me.” Feb 18, 17:37
Rob on The Future Is Yesterday: “I have always had a problem with the concept of “list” MSP’s. I don’t understand how a small group of…” Feb 18, 17:32
Cynicus on The Future Is Yesterday: ““Emma Roddick, currently a list MSP in Highland, is standing against Fergus Ewing for a constituency” ============ Vote Fergus Ewing…” Feb 18, 17:01
John on The Future Is Yesterday: “whatever is published by WoS, the short, stark truth remains simple: (i) despite a convincing and comprehensive track record of…” Feb 18, 16:16
Young Lochinvar on Scotland In Numbers: “Lorna HG Well’s “The Time Machine” appears to have accurately predicted the rise of the dissolute degenerate androgynous Eloi. Evolution;…” Feb 18, 16:12
Southernbystander on Scotland In Numbers: “This makes good sense, in theory. Did you ever see that programme where a Lincolnshire farmer was asked to employ…” Feb 18, 16:10
Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Scotland In Numbers: “Lorna, I invariably read and appreciate your contributions. The perennial question in this instance would seem twofold: “Are there any…” Feb 18, 16:05
sarah on The Future Is Yesterday: “Is there a glimmer of hope that at least one of these troughers won’t get back? Emma Roddick, currently a…” Feb 18, 15:58
Cynicus on Scotland In Numbers: “Lorna Campbell says: 18 February, 2026 at 1:48 pm “It is Stalinism/totalitarianism” ========= You perfect analogy. Under Stalin, the charlatan…” Feb 18, 15:57
Young Lochinvar on The Future Is Yesterday: “I don’t believe for a second that “the independent” courts alone decided sneaky Pete’s hearing would be held back to…” Feb 18, 15:51
Skip_NC on The Future Is Yesterday: “But all that one of the court cases may do is make people not want to vote for them. They…” Feb 18, 15:34
P C Foster on Scotland In Numbers: “@ Lorna– I think that we need to recognize that Westminster prevented the GRA. Also nurses in England seem to…” Feb 18, 15:23
Cynicus on Scotland In Numbers: ““….women who support the SNP and are members of the SNP not up in arms about the SNP attitude toward…” Feb 18, 15:00
sarah on The Future Is Yesterday: “I forgot Alba – if they joined the Alliance umbrella, that would be even better.” Feb 18, 14:59
Aidan on The Longest Road: “Scotland is one of the wealthiest countries in the world, as I pointed out GDP per capita in Edinburgh is…” Feb 18, 14:54
sarah on The Future Is Yesterday: “Horrifying, appalling, sickening, terrifying, outrageous. What a dreadful level the SNP has fallen to. Alliance to Liberate Scotland is the…” Feb 18, 14:46
Terry on The Future Is Yesterday: “You’ve been right for years. Agreed. They need to go. But how? Apart from us not voting for them. I’m…” Feb 18, 14:44
David on The Future Is Yesterday: “The thought of Campbell getting in makes me boke.” Feb 18, 14:30