The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Archive for the ‘analysis’


Echoes from history 62

Posted on August 05, 2013 by

We’d never heard of this until a reader mentioned it this morning in the comments, and it seems worth bringing to wider attention. The article we’re about to (re)print below is a transcript originally created by the now-defunct www.alba.org, along with a couple of extracts from the Scottish press of the time.

The original version is still visible on www.archive.org, but we’ve tidied it up a bit and added a few notes and comments of our own in red.

Read the rest of this entry →

Won’t somebody think of the children? 53

Posted on August 04, 2013 by

One of the benefits, if that’s the right word, of the Daily Record’s shambolic new iPad app is that the 30-day trial period means we got to see a print copy of the Sunday Mail today for the first time in years. It was largely like a parochial edition of Heat magazine (“FAT LASS DATES THIN BLOKE” got a spread), but buried 40-odd pages in was a “special report” that doesn’t seem to have made it onto the paper’s website.

mailthumb

The Mail accompanies the report with an editorial entitled “We must not abandon our Geordie pals”, which is very carefully worded in order to give the impression that a Yes vote would be to do just that, without actually saying so. But the actual content of the report is curiously at odds with the headlines.

Read the rest of this entry →

Quieter little voices 33

Posted on August 03, 2013 by

It’s been an interesting week for the Scottish media. First the Sun’s website vanished behind the clouds of a paywall, and today the Daily Record unveiled a new version of its tablet app which no longer gives readers the weekday paper for free.

recordipad

(Both papers, naturally, presented these new restrictions as enhancements.)

Read the rest of this entry →

The squirrel parade 40

Posted on August 01, 2013 by

Some of the more cynical independence supporters among our readership may today be asking themselves “What is it that Labour are trying to bury today with all this ludicrously farcical ‘Labour For Independence’ business?” 

skwirl

Allow us to suggest a few possibilities.

Read the rest of this entry →

Two cousins 36

Posted on July 31, 2013 by

The internet’s been enjoying itself since last night knocking up satirical versions of The Sun’s wraparound cover today. For no immediately apparent reason (except perhaps that it’s a slow time for news) the paper has suddenly decided to give a “State Of The Union”-type address explicitly setting out its beliefs on a variety of subjects.

suncovers1

We thought that it might pass a few idle moments to compare the UK and Scottish editions, and see how closely those beliefs matched up on either side of the border.

Read the rest of this entry →

The big decision 77

Posted on July 30, 2013 by

You’ve bravely waded through a 3500-word book review already this morning, so let’s give you something a little more bite-sized to digest.

decision

This one could be a game-changer, folks. Brace yourselves.

Read the rest of this entry →

Another country 137

Posted on July 30, 2013 by

Wings Over Scotland went to London last weekend, for no particular reason other than a change of scenery. After a trip to the faux-bohemian Camden Market – in which about six different stalls are now repeated over and over in a sad, gentrified mockery of its previous more anarchic life, yet while still maintaining much of the vibrant feel – we set off in no particular direction and found ourselves in Trafalgar Square.

Despite having been to the capital dozens of times, I’d never visited the home of Nelson’s Column, which is far bigger in real life than it looks in pictures, managing to dominate what is a very large plaza with no shortage of other imposing monuments and decorations. (Including the vast National Gallery and, at the moment, an incongruous enormous bright blue cockerel.)

cockerel1

Suitably inspired, we elected to take a stroll to the Embankment, past the London Eye, and from there on a walking tour of the heart of the British establishment. Searching for exploitable weaknesses, obviously.

Read the rest of this entry →

The sting’s the thing 63

Posted on July 29, 2013 by

We talk often of the “swarm of wasps” approach to debate that’s the main strategy of the No campaign. The guiding principle of it is to throw out so many dubious assertions, straw men and red herrings, all at once, that it’s all but impossible for your opponent to effectively counter all the different thrusts of the attack, like trying to swat wasps with a broken tennis racquet.

wasps

To see how it works, let’s take a look at the Herald’s front page splash today.

Read the rest of this entry →

Behind open doors 78

Posted on July 26, 2013 by

As we noted earlier, the Wings Over Scotland spy at last night’s “Better Together” meeting in our home town of Bathgate last night wasn’t alone. Some intrepid readers also attended the event, and recorded the whole thing to find out what the No campaign are telling people away from the scrutiny of the media.

It’s a grim watch, but we’ve picked you out some highlights.

Read the rest of this entry →

The Bullshit Files 137

Posted on July 26, 2013 by

Tonight saw the launch of “Better Together Bathgate”, the No camp’s debut foray into our beloved hometown. The email advertising the event, sent out on the 15th of July, said “I hope to see you at the on 28th June” [sic], which might help to explain the rather sub-spectacular turnout of around 40 hardy souls from a town of 16,000.

bullshitfiles1

Of that 40 or so, several (perhaps as many as a quarter) were dastardly pro-Yes spies. And we know that for certain, because one of them was ours.

Read the rest of this entry →

Later than you think 364

Posted on July 24, 2013 by

In an extraordinary outburst on TV last night, “Better Together” campaign chairman Alistair Darling accused Alex Salmond of exaggerating the amount of extractable oil in the Scottish sector of the North Sea by 1,200%.

The former Chancellor (who we learned a few weeks ago thinks the population of Scotland is six million, creating an impressive 705,000 imaginary Scots) suggested that rather than the 24 billion barrels currently estimated by the oil industry – and commonly cited by the UK government – there were in fact just 2 billion barrels left.

darlingoil

As BT are a tad wobbly with numbers, let’s do a quick bit of arithmetic on that.

Read the rest of this entry →

The hopeless case 89

Posted on July 22, 2013 by

We linked you yesterday to a quite startling display of cognitive dissonance, as a dedicated Labour activist struggled to reconcile his party’s position on Trident with his own belief in disarmament, reaching some quite extraordinary contortions of logic in an attempt to convince himself that staying in the Union represented the best way of ridding the United Kingdom of weapons which are enthusiastically supported by every major UK political party and the Lib Dems.

torctrident

But it’s not just mad bloggers who are frantically trying to whip up a sandstorm of spin to obscure Labour’s final abject surrender to the nuclear weapons lobby.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,918 Posts, 1,243,507 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • 100%Yes on Pandora’s Campervan: “What ever surplus money the SNP got he or them just spent it on what ever they wanted, wither it…Jun 2, 14:53
    • Cynicus on Pandora’s Campervan: ““Begs the question, why did the Crown feel they had to agree to a deal? Could they not have proved…Jun 2, 14:44
    • 100%Yes on Pandora’s Campervan: “Sturgeon forced to answer for herself on national TV, with crocodile tears, only to turn round and say what have…Jun 2, 14:37
    • Rogueslr on Pandora’s Campervan: “With only 4 miles on the camper van it should make a good price at auction. But, I am left…Jun 2, 14:34
    • BigJay on Pandora’s Campervan: “There was an interesting article in the Sunday Times, part of which outlined the Swinney/Murrell connection from their schooldays, church…Jun 2, 14:23
    • Cynicus on Pandora’s Campervan: “absolutely!Jun 2, 14:22
    • agentx on Pandora’s Campervan: “PUBLIC FUNDS £8,143,658.37 in Short Money from the House of Commons £2,437,821.47 in policy development grants from the Electoral Commission…Jun 2, 14:21
    • Iain Ross on The View From Row Z: “The van should be shown in the Balance Sheet at cost price (ex VAT) less accumulated depreciation. Not sure what…Jun 2, 14:19
    • Andy Wiltshire on Pandora’s Campervan: “Exactly! Come on Wingers, there must be a lawyer here who can address this vital point.Jun 2, 14:13
    • RobertG on Pandora’s Campervan: “I also wonder if the deliberate own goal decision to go to the Supreme Court over indyref2 was part of…Jun 2, 14:12
    • Rocky on Pandora’s Campervan: “Who were the Sloggi knickers for?Jun 2, 14:09
    • Jim Anderson on Pandora’s Campervan: “Getting interesting as the extent and timing of the control failures by Beattie and Sturgeon that favoured Murrell’s criminality are…Jun 2, 14:05
    • barelybare on Pandora’s Campervan: ““I’ve been through the 107 pages of items bought by Peter Murrell” Keep in mind that BBC list excludes all…Jun 2, 13:59
    • Al-Stuart on Pandora’s Campervan: “. Hi Stuart. Thanks for your excellent Pandora’s Box article. I’ve been through the 107 pages of items bought by…Jun 2, 13:49
    • LES HALLES on Pandora’s Campervan: “Out of all this, one thing everyone should be thankful for are your unrelenting efforts to shine a light into…Jun 2, 13:48
    • TURABDIN on Pandora’s Campervan: “It is of course not beyond reason to suspect the entire SNP «staff» of being British intelligence spooks, both knowing…Jun 2, 13:36
    • 100%Yes on Pandora’s Campervan: “Its should be no public inquiry then return the money that was donated to the SNP. Is it possible to…Jun 2, 13:26
    • 100%Yes on Pandora’s Campervan: “Jester or just a complete and utter idiot Colin Beattie with 1mb of ram for brain power. Who says one…Jun 2, 13:20
    • Antoine Roquentin on Pandora’s Campervan: “Excellent, as always, Stuart!Jun 2, 13:09
    • Ian Smith on Pandora’s Campervan: “They couldn’t have known because Murrell covered his tracks with a sophisticated fraud. Like coding a robotic lawnmower from a…Jun 2, 13:00
    • Douglas on Pandora’s Campervan: “Surely a question for COPFS who, in my opinion, have been way too tight with government during Ms Sturgeon’s reign.Jun 2, 12:58
    • I. Despair on Pandora’s Campervan: “Exactly.Jun 2, 12:58
    • Frank Waring on Pandora’s Campervan: “Everyone now understands that the SNP solicited funds to be ‘ringfenced for a future Referendum campaign’, and then used this…Jun 2, 12:56
    • Achnababan on Pandora’s Campervan: “Probably true … but Sturgeon is naturally vindictive and ruthless … she disna need an excuse!Jun 2, 12:53
    • barelybare on Pandora’s Campervan: “Thanks for your fantastic work Stuart. Your August 2021 challenge about the supposed SNP expenses has often been on my…Jun 2, 12:52
    • robertkknight on Pandora’s Campervan: “The loan repayment to the Weirs allegedly using Indyref2 ring fenced funds is what I want to hear more about,…Jun 2, 12:41
    • holymacmoses on Pandora’s Campervan: “I just have a feeling that Mr Murrell dealt with the small beer. Sturgeon was in charge of the ‘national’…Jun 2, 12:41
    • Cynicus on Pandora’s Campervan: “McKenna is with you; “Only when John Swinney and his cronies are forced to resign can decency return to the…Jun 2, 12:36
    • Alistair on Pandora’s Campervan: “The true motive for the conspiracy against Salmond and the treatment of Joanna Cherry also becomes clearer. If either had…Jun 2, 12:35
    • Cynicus on Pandora’s Campervan: ““ .. if you view them through a lens of a chief executive with almost unlimited power to spend money…Jun 2, 12:17
  • A tall tale



↑ Top