It’s Wings’ 14th birthday today, and to be entirely honest with you, readers, like a lot of teenagers we’re having a bit of an existential crisis. It’s quite difficult to see any point in being a Scottish political journalist for the next five years, because it’s just going to be one depressing Groundhog Day after another.
So rather than moan on as usual, today we’re handing over to a precocious new talent whose enthusiasm can’t be dimmed. It’s one that garnered a lot of attention this week by delivering a comprehensive and very entertaining spanking to SNP MP and devoted friend of the site Pete “Cosy Feet” Wishart.
With skills like that already placing it well beyond the abilities of most of the Scottish political commentariat, we thought we’d give it a tryout and ask it to take a look into the country’s future.
The following article is completely unedited other than a bit of formatting, though we did ask it (with only partial success) to tone down the haggis-and-bagpipes stuff slightly from its first draft. Ladies and gentlemen, we give you Grok. Unlike most journos, it provided links and it did write its own headline.
Perhaps the key graphic from last night’s by-election in Caerphilly is this one (green means Plaid Cymru in the context of Wales):
In the end, Plaid won pretty comfortably in what had been predicted to be a very tight contest between them and Reform, with a majority of almost 4,000. But Plaid aren’t going to be the next government of the UK, so what’s the real story?
Last month, when half a football team of armed police ambushed and arrested comedy writer Graham Linehan at Heathrow Airport for a couple of tweets, we said this:
Today, even more swiftly than we thought, this happened:
We should point out right at the start that a reader donated £12 back in the summer specifically to send us to Nicola Sturgeon’s book event in Bath last night.
So on the surface level this is just flat-out hilarious.
Firstly because, as we showed you yesterday, the “significant proportion of Scotland’s population” which appears to have been won back to the SNP since John Swinney became its leader is… 1%.
All of the words you’re about to read below were written by the same person in the last few days. It’s completely verbatim and none of it is taken in any way out of context. It means what it sounds like it means.
But even if you’ve got a forehead the size of the “eggheads” from the famous Tefal ads of the 1980s, you’ll never guess the big reveal at the end.
Kevin McKenna has a piece in today’s Herald asking the question that is now the core issue for the Scottish independence movement.
The short version of the answer is usually attributed to Mark Twain: “It is far easier to fool someone than to convince them that they’ve been fooled”. But that does nothing to explain the fool’s mindset to us, or help devise a way to get them to accept it.
To some degree that’s because – as we saw so starkly in the “NO DEBATE!” tactics of the gender ideologly cult – part of the problem is that the built-in defence mechanism of the fooled is something George Orwell described in “1984”:
“CRIMESTOP means the faculty of stopping short, as though by instinct, at the threshold of any dangerous thought. It includes the power of not grasping analogies, of failing to perceive logical errors, of misunderstanding the simplest arguments if they are inimical to Ingsoc, and of being bored or repelled by any train of thought which is capable of leading in a heretical direction.
CRIMESTOP, in short, means protective stupidity. But stupidity is not enough. On the contrary, orthodoxy in the full sense demands a control over one’s own mental processes as complete as that of a contortionist over his body.”
What that means in practice is that the fooled never reflect on their own behaviour, far less enter into a meaningful discussion of it. In Orwell’s dystopian Oceania, that was to save them from torture and death at the hands of the Thought Police. More often nowadays, it’s simply to avoid humiliation on social media.
Either way, it’s vanishingly rare to hear someone elaborate on why they’re choosing to remain fooled. Which is why we’re so lucky today.
We were going to write something today for the anniversary of Alex Salmond’s tragic death, but then we read Kevin McKenna’s piece in today’s Herald On Sunday and we can’t improve on it, so go and have a read of that before you do anything else.
Alex always believed in looking forward, not back, so we doubt he’d be overly fussed at the pathetic “tribute” paid to him at the SNP conference this morning. What would undoubtedly have exercised him a lot more would have been the wretched current state of the party he loved and built from almost nothing into the dominant force in Scottish politics.
And nothing typifies that wretched state better than the craven and gutless capitulation of a speech given by Tommy Sheppard yesterday, opposing the rebel amendments to John Swinney’s non-strategy on independence.
It said a lot more than he thought it did, but none of it good.
It’s really very hard to overstate what mendacious, duplicitous shite this is.
It did its job, though. As expected, the SNP conference comprehensively voted down the rebel amendments to Swinney’s motion on independence “strategy” and backed his grand plan of winning a majority, begging Keir Starmer for a second referendum – just like Nicola Sturgeon and Humza Yousaf had done before him with Theresa May, Boris Johnson, Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak – and then scuttling obediently away with his tail between his legs when Starmer told him to get lost.
The SNP conference opened today with Stephen Flynn (primary interest: the career of Stephen Flynn), Karen Adam (primary interest: any shiny or jangly object) and Susan Aitken (primary interest: MOAR PIES), which ought to be more than enough by itself to convincingly illustrate that these are not serious people.
But if you somehow still weren’t certain, there’s this:
That, readers – from Flynn, supposedly the party’s sharpest talent – is political strategising on the level of a football manager wearing his lucky underpants for a cup tie. David Cameron didn’t grant the 2014 referendum because he HAD to, he did it because he saw a political opportunity to kill off independence for decades by delivering a strong victory for the Union.
In the end he got away with the gamble, much more narrowly than he expected to, and no UK Prime Minister will make that mistake again. (Especially as Cameron foolishly DID follow it up with a repeat performance, over Brexit, and this time lost the vote and ended his political career.)
What’s embarrassing is not that Swinney and Flynn are publicly endorsing such an absolute joke of a “strategy”, but that they know it’ll be enough to see the SNP returned to government, where the strategy will fail (whether by not securing the majority or by doing so and having Keir Starmer briskly tell them to sod off), and they can safely trouser fat Holyrood salaries for another half-decade with all the pressure off.
But what if conference delivers a surprise defeat for the leadership during this afternoon’s debate? We don’t expect it to – conference is stuffed with the payroll vote these days, and holding it in Aberdeen yet again has made it as hard as possible for rebels to turn up en masse, short of booking a leaky bothy near Dounreay – but let’s allow it as a possibility just for the sake of argument.
sarah on Mind Your Business: “It looks that way, I agree. So many backstabbers who owed everything they had to Alex. Also there’s only so…” Nov 22, 16:16
100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “Salmond wasn’t a saint and he certainly wasn’t a hardline nationalist, all he was was the best of a rotten…” Nov 22, 15:39
James Che on Mind Your Business: “Sarah, I do not know why Alex took he route he did, or why he never spoke about the information…” Nov 22, 15:17
James Che on Mind Your Business: “For a long time now it has not been about who votes in the elections, but who ounts the elections,” Nov 22, 14:57
100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “The SNP has agreed three years before any election to give there support to Labour and Andy Burnham as the…” Nov 22, 14:51
sarah on Mind Your Business: “It is indeed a great pity that this topic wasn’t part of Alex’s public speaking. Although imagining an SNP government…” Nov 22, 14:19
Geri on Mind Your Business: “Cappy, There you go again with that exceptionalist shite. The UK wasn’t a lone voice consistently trying to sway policy.…” Nov 22, 14:09
James Che on Mind Your Business: “Early discussions with Alex Salmond, after he had been in Westminsters library regarding the Treaty of union caused a change…” Nov 22, 12:56
Captain Caveman on Mind Your Business: ““Confused is correct” Ha. Really? Apart from the laughable inconsistencies that I’ve pointed out between the very things even he…” Nov 22, 12:41
James Che on Mind Your Business: “Only when the people of England, Wales and Ireland recognise there is no actual parliament of Scotland in the Westminster…” Nov 22, 12:18
sarah on Mind Your Business: “Rev, I hope that your network of supporters is gathering a body of donors to provide statements of authority for…” Nov 22, 12:13
James Che on Mind Your Business: “Police Scotland are actually police England under the Crown of Englands Westminster laws, legislation and Statues ” Scotland Act “…” Nov 22, 12:01
Geri on Mind Your Business: “AI- Dan “Yes – if in doubt blame the “Anglo” Boo boo! Perfidious Albion wasn’t coined for nuffink. You really…” Nov 22, 11:58
James Che on Mind Your Business: “The way out for all of the nations of these Isles is some genuine fact finding to the original hoax,…” Nov 22, 11:42
James Che on Mind Your Business: “What happens when England, Wales and Ireland realise that there is No treaty of Union with Scotland other than a…” Nov 22, 11:23
James Barr Gardner on Mind Your Business: “Police Scotland refused to issue an incident number for the report of crime of reset, their answer it was covered…” Nov 22, 11:04
Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “@Geri 9:08 Biolabs. You forgot the biolabs. Also the Nazis. And the baby eating. Take your time, Geri, as otherwise…” Nov 22, 08:57
Minceheid on Mind Your Business: “Hatey McHateface says: 21 November, 2026 at 4:47 pm It’s not something you can do all by yourself, MH. You’ll…” Nov 22, 08:22
twathater on Mind Your Business: “Andee has stated that 3/4 of uk citizens either want back into the EU or want to work closer with…” Nov 22, 03:09
twathater on Mind Your Business: “THAT is a great idea ,as one who has repeatedly proposed and promoted that DONORS get together and instigate a…” Nov 22, 02:43
Aidan on Mind Your Business: “Yes – if in doubt blame the “Anglo”” Nov 22, 01:40
Anthem on Mind Your Business: “Because their fat controller is a member of the cabinet.” Nov 22, 00:25
Geri on Mind Your Business: “Confused is correct. The EU was colonised by the yanks & the wankers in Blighty, the kiss ass errand boy,…” Nov 21, 21:08
Hamish M on Mind Your Business: “Breaking news: SNP cancels £60,000 loan repayment owed to Peter Murrell https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c9p83kyryp7zo” Nov 21, 18:20
Captain Caveman on Mind Your Business: “To be fair, Spartan, I’m surprised you give Confused’s inane arse-drippings the time of day. Funny how the “english” [sic]…” Nov 21, 17:29
Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “It’s not something you can do all by yourself, MH. You’ll need somebody to shovel your shite on a daily…” Nov 21, 16:47
Hatey McHateface on The Shots You Don’t Take: “You don’t really want to know the answer, Confused. Very probably far more than you.” Nov 21, 16:34
Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Seriously? So you’re another antisemite blaming the Jews for everything? Or is what Confused’s angling at going over the top…” Nov 21, 16:31
Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Always helps to hear the view from The Kremlin. Cheers, Geri.” Nov 21, 16:27
Spartan 117 on Mind Your Business: “For once, a sensible post from Confused that sums up the state of the European Disunion and the “thinking”, if…” Nov 21, 16:02