The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Archive for the ‘debunks’


Kezia Dugdale Fact Check, part 675 166

Posted on January 27, 2016 by

Here’s Kezia in the Independent yesterday:

powerful1

powerful

The most powerful? Did it just get promoted?

Read the rest of this entry →

The headline is always a lie 133

Posted on January 27, 2016 by

In a cunning meta-twist which simultaneously proves and disproves its own claim, the headline above is itself a lie. It’s of course not true that every single headline you read in a newspaper is absolutely false.

It is, however, a pretty good rule of thumb.

beafraid

Read the rest of this entry →

The sewer press 261

Posted on January 05, 2016 by

So, this appeared in the Herald today:

beggherald1

And that’s a problem, because it’s a complete and utter lie.

Read the rest of this entry →

Meet the new year, same as the old year 94

Posted on January 05, 2016 by

As politics wakes up from the holidays, any readers still bothering to gaze at the pages of the Scottish media could be forgiven for a crushing sense of deja vu.

2016papers

In more senses than one.

Read the rest of this entry →

BREAKING NEWS 126

Posted on December 28, 2015 by

Sometimes stuff breaks. Apparently this is news.

nhscrisisx

Read the rest of this entry →

An end to the matter 207

Posted on December 17, 2015 by

Remarkably, it seems some angry Unionists are still trying to dispute the known facts surrounding the Forth Road Bridge closure. We’d like to think this quote from today’s Central Fife Times – from Tony Martin, the man who was convenor of the authority managing the bridge until a few months ago – was unambiguous enough to settle it once and for all.

cllrmartin

That’s from the man who ought to know more about it than any human alive, and who as a Lib Dem councillor has no reason to make excuses for the Scottish Government.

cllrmartin2

It’s over, angry Unionists. Deal with it.

The Pish Gallop 133

Posted on December 15, 2015 by

We’ve spoken a number of times before on this site about the “gish gallop” or “swarm of wasps” debating technique, in which a person attempts to bury their opponent under such an overwhelming tsunami of false, misleading or nonsensical claims in a short space of time that they can’t possibly debunk it all.

The Urban Dictionary gives an example of the form:

gishgallop

Faced with such a rushing torrent of drivel, it’s almost impossible for an opponent to know where to start in order to begin to even scratch the surface (if you can scratch a torrent). And that brings us directly to Severin Carrell’s article in today’s Guardian.

Read the rest of this entry →

The Forth Road Bridge FAQ 268

Posted on December 14, 2015 by

Over the last few days, as most of Scotland’s media has focused on hysterical smear stories and outright lies, we’ve been digging around trying to uncover the truth about events around and leading to the closure of the Forth Road Bridge.

frb

Here’s what we’ve got so far.

Read the rest of this entry →

Lie by lie 195

Posted on December 13, 2015 by

The Scottish Mail on Sunday’s shock-horror Forth Road Bridge story today is also accompanied by an editorial leader. And if the main article was a piece of bare-faced deception, it’s got nothing on the opinion piece.

Read the rest of this entry →

Chiels that ding 251

Posted on November 19, 2015 by

The Unionist media has leapt on former SNP adviser Alex Bell’s blog post about the economic case for independence this week like a starving dog thrown a sausage.

It’s been wringing articles out of it for days, the latest being Torcuil Crichton’s column in today’s Daily Record, in which the unembarrassable hack (last seen trumpeting an entirely imaginary £20bn increase in Holyrood’s budget from the Smith Commission proposals) rather audaciously takes someone else to task over an economic “lie”.

tcbs

Bell’s article is such self-evidently weak sauce that we haven’t bothered with it until now. But as it seems clear that the papers are going to talk about nothing else for the forseeable future, we may as well point out the obvious.

Read the rest of this entry →

The wishful believers 417

Posted on October 28, 2015 by

As we observed last night, the BBC’s Andrew Neil has reacted with rather poor grace to his chiding at the hands of respected statisticians Jim and Margaret Cuthbert. Neil embarked on a Twitter blocking spree and tried to rewrite history, claiming that he’d “simply offered” the blunt claim that there had been no cuts to the Scottish budget in the last five years “as one measure” of the money available to Holyrood.

The problem for Neil is that we recorded video of his Sunday interview with the SNP’s Angus Robertson, and anyone can see for themselves that Neil made an unequivocal assertion with no suggestion whatsoever that there were any alternative measures.

wishitwantit

“In real terms there’s been – no – cut”, said Neil, spitting out the last three words with dramatic pauses between them for emphasis, in a statement whose stark absence of ambiguity unfortunately left him no wiggle room when the Cuthberts politely but firmly pointed out that it was “ridiculous” to argue that there hadn’t been any cuts, and that the budget “clearly has gone down”.

But Neil’s embarrassment is illustrative of a much wider delusion.

Read the rest of this entry →

A poverty of imagination 185

Posted on October 24, 2015 by

We don’t follow many Unionists on social media, because you end up wasting your day arguing pointlessly with a lot of people who are never going to change their minds and getting in a bad mood. But we’re told they were all very excited about an article in yesterday’s Daily Record.

recordeconomy

Penned by the paper’s political editor Davie Clegg, it’s a long diatribe about how the fall in oil revenues has created a black hole which now means Scotland is – stand by for a surprise! – too wee and too poor to be independent.

So far so meh – it’s not like it’s the first time we’ve heard that record played, after all. But as you can see from the image above, there’s also quite an interesting challenge printed in giant capitals at the foot of the page. We’re not in the Scottish Government, but it’s a rainy Saturday so we thought we might have a go.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,993 Posts, 1,253,963 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: “@Bilbo Good grief, I mean I know my expectations of you were already at rock bottom, but this really is…” Nov 18, 09:41
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Interesting article in the Guardian Online from Rafael Behr. Against the backdrop of the summit between the leaders of the…” Nov 18, 09:32
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Excellent idea, James. Like everybody else, I would prefer you disappear for a week, rather than a day. We can…” Nov 18, 08:39
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Anybody know when the UN is setting us free? I’m worried that some of the kiddies are playing with matches,…” Nov 18, 08:24
    • Bilbo on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Main is starting to act like a tart desperate for attention. He’s become pathetic and anyone who is entertaining him…” Nov 18, 07:23
    • Aidan on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Great point Dave – have you ever thought about publishing your memoirs? I am sure there’s a massive audience for…” Nov 18, 04:02
    • DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: “…he says, engaging with the ‘dim witted troll’ who isn’t worth engaging with… You truly are stupid.” Nov 18, 03:18
    • Aidan on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Yes James, please ignore, a dim witted troll like yourself isn’t worth engaging with.” Nov 18, 02:14
    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Bilbo; Can we have an ignore the Yoon Trolls day/week? Watch them go round in a love-in with each other?…” Nov 17, 22:07
    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Bilbo; Can we have an ignore the Yoon Trolls day/week? Watch them go round in a love-in with each other?…” Nov 17, 22:07
    • DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I see you took a lesson in the spelling of the word ‘cunt’. Comprehension of word combinations next eh? Who’d…” Nov 17, 20:50
    • Bilbo on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Main is only on this site because he’s either banned from everywhere else or the ones where he’s not banned,…” Nov 17, 20:46
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Beaten to death” Naw, tenderised. You boys just don’t understand foreign cuisine. What’s that you say, Sooty? Is Dave wanting…” Nov 17, 20:30
    • DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Burning ppl alive” Check out the videos shot at the Odessa Trades Union building. Your ‘fighting friends’ aka Nazis did…” Nov 17, 20:01
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Burning ppl alive” Naw, Geri, cooking them. Babies and youngsters mostly. Try tae stick tae yer script. Showing initiative always…” Nov 17, 19:17
    • twathater on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Wee johnny Main should join his pals Cavey and Adey and go and look at Mark Col lets blogs it…” Nov 17, 18:15
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Main What exactly do you hope to achieve on this site? You’re not an independence supporter & you don’t like…” Nov 17, 16:20
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “AI-DAN No, it isn’t a war crime under international law. Shit was made perfectly clear during Minsk 1 & 2…” Nov 17, 15:38
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “With respect, CC, you’re not Scottish, so you’re not getting it. The primary motivator for James, Dave, Geri, Confused, etc…” Nov 17, 14:52
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Never mind all that, James. When’s Scotland gonna be independent? Couldn’t you maybe pick up the pace a bit? How…” Nov 17, 14:33
    • Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Hilarious that “James” and “DaveL” have to audacity to complain about others’ content when they themselves are – without the…” Nov 17, 14:23
    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “26 minutes.” Nov 17, 14:02
    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Adrian” aka Fox News excretes the usual bs right on cue. They obviously think if they repeat their shite ad…” Nov 17, 13:57
    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “DaveL; “….the cunts cunt….” ROTFLMFAO! 100% on the button.” Nov 17, 13:37
    • Aidan on How To Succeed In Scotland: “lol – so R invading U isn’t a war crime, but U defending itself from that invasion is a war…” Nov 17, 12:22
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “How’s it going as a “white n1gger” then, Confused? It’s a few days since you announced your new identity on…” Nov 17, 12:10
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Id put good money on that” Naw, Geri, you couldn’t. You’re penniless. It’s not possible for somebody like you, even…” Nov 17, 12:00
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Dan is correct. Scotland has absolutely zero control over immigration.” BS, Geri. As always. Take Glasgow, for example. The decision…” Nov 17, 11:49
    • Confused on How To Succeed In Scotland: “more interesting vids www.youtube.com/watch?v=YClIfiwBD_8&t=13s www.youtube.com/watch?v=jq9MHNEqOEI – can you imagine the shitstorm if some “white” person came out with anything 1/10…” Nov 17, 11:44
    • Confused on How To Succeed In Scotland: “https://archive.ph/NcAT2 “without you, we would do just -great-” more from “here’s what you could have won” https://archive.ph/kyu5W “women don’t lie…” Nov 17, 11:43
  • A tall tale



↑ Top