It’s a Bank Holiday and frankly there’s absolutely bugger-all of any interest in the news today, so I hope you’ll forgive me a personal indulgence, readers. I’ve only used the personal pronoun for a couple of Wings articles out of over 2,300 in the site’s two and a half years of existence, because the independence debate isn’t about me. But a curious piece in today’s Herald by David Torrance merits such a response.
If you don’t see what it’s got to do with that video*, bear with me.
We’ve quite frequently highlighted the ugly, irresponsible tone of the No campaign’s – and especially Labour’s – comments about “foreigners”in the independence debate. And the reason we do is because that sort of language feeds attitudes like these.
I had no idea what to expect from the UKIP public meeting in Bath tonight. The city is genteel, wealthy and has been solidly Lib Dem for over 20 years. While there are of course some sketchier areas and it hasn’t been immune to the UK’s recent economic troubles, generally speaking it has little to complain about.
So when UKIP booked the 730 downstairs capacity of the Forum (a rather beautiful old Art Deco former cinema from the 1930s) for a public meeting, I hung onto the hope that there was at least a reasonable chance it’d be half-empty.
We’re off to watch the Scottish Cup semi-final now, so to keep you all entertained for the next couple of hours here’s a little something we put together at the request of columnist and broadcaster Lesley Riddoch, and for anyone who was listening to Radio Scotland’s “Headlines” this morning.
Hopefully we won’t need it ourselves by 3.30pm. #COYR
If it’s Wednesday, Labour must have changed their position on their future-devolution proposals again. Following our latest highlighting of the glaring contradictions in the shambolic “Devo Nano” plans, responses have started arriving to your letters.
If you’ve been listening closely, you’ll have heard that the position on whether the Scottish Parliament would be able to reduce taxes below the UK level has see-sawed from “No you can’t” (Johann Lamont MSP, 18 March) to “Yes you can” (Richard Baker MSP, 28 March) and back to “No you can’t” again (Tom Clarke MP, 4 April).
Earlier today we highlighted two pieces of disgraceful, mendacious smearing by The Scotsman, in conjunction with an “anonymous” Labour MP. The articles coincided with a wider campaign of demonisation across most of the Scottish and UK media against supporters of independence, backed up by elected Labour representatives on social media in what might easily be seen as a co-ordinated attack.
The tweets above are from the account of semi-literate Labour councillor for East Kilbride, James Docherty. They follow a week in which the Edinburgh South MP Ian Murray described the placing of one or more small “Yes 2014” stickers on his constituency office windows as an “out of control” escalation of intimidation and Alistair Darling accused some people objecting to a businessman sending a document full of scaremongering lies to 500 employees of his company as “shaming Scotland”.
These hysterical smears would be laughable were it not for the consequences they may yet bring about. We highlight some of those consequences below.
While we wait for the full detail of what look like being even more watered-down and insipid “Devo Lite” proposals from Labour than we were expecting, we suppose we might as well spend a minute on last night’s big “Better Together” announcement that Eddie Izzard was going to hold a benefit gig for the No campaign, putting the Union on a par with starving Ethiopians and earthquake victims.
Einstein is claimed to have said that the definition of insanity was doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results (and readers hopefully already know our views on Quote Nazis), so we found a line attributed to Izzard in the press release particularly striking.
Northcode on The Modern Politician: “I say, old chap, Mogger’s unnatural and deeply condescending accent is straight out of the empire’s metropolitan centre, don’t ya…” Feb 15, 13:25
Xaracen on The Modern Politician: “@Andy Ellis; The way you stated “Scotland becomes de facto an independent state the moment a majority of votes is…” Feb 15, 13:20
Young Lochinvar on The Modern Politician: “Confused A great many national anthems are shitty and dirges, heck God save the King is defo top ten chart…” Feb 15, 12:59
Hatey McHateface on The Modern Politician: “BBC reporting that Upton has walked from NHS Fife. Perhaps a case of New Year – New Grifts.” Feb 15, 12:56
Andy Ellis on The Modern Politician: “@Xaracen & @Aiden There is no cast iron guarantee that the either the British nationalist state OR the international community…” Feb 15, 12:45
Hatey McHateface on The Modern Politician: “I think it’s the Covid Spreaders who like to say that a journey of one thousand miles starts with the…” Feb 15, 12:37
Cynicus on The Modern Politician: “Thanks TURABDIN for the excellent FT link on US Strategy for AI. “Its pillars focus on supercharging domestic AI development…” Feb 15, 12:23
Alf Baird on The Modern Politician: ““Englands Great Britain hoax” Aye, an Imperial hoax drawing in the ‘crazed’ colonized. According to the great Rees-Mogg himsel, where…” Feb 15, 12:08
Northcode on The Modern Politician: “Guid day tae aw ma fallae scribbledouners here in this place this fine Sunday day, aye. May Christ oor saviour…” Feb 15, 11:58
TURABDIN on The Modern Politician: “I DOUBT FEW WOULD NOW ARGUE against the case for calling the US politician Donald Trump a species of «fascist»and…” Feb 15, 11:18
James Cheyne on The Modern Politician: “All political parties in Scotland are registered in England,” Feb 15, 11:10
James Cheyne on The Modern Politician: “Colin Alexander, Both the SNP and the Greens party in Scotland are registered parties in England.” Feb 15, 11:08
James Cheyne on The Modern Politician: “All these problems in and for Scotland.while Colonised. And Scots sleep away the weeks, months and years in a daydream…” Feb 15, 11:05
Aidan on The Modern Politician: “@Xaracen – I don’t think the plebiscite election route is guaranteed to succeed by any stretch of the imagination. It…” Feb 15, 10:00
Xaracen on The Modern Politician: ““Scotland becomes de facto an independent state the moment a majority of votes is achieved.” And has any leader of…” Feb 15, 09:45
Hatey McHateface on The Modern Politician: “Not from me, YL. I will always support the right of every Scot to imagine whatever vividly phantasmagorical hallucinations his…” Feb 15, 09:12
Hatey McHateface on The Modern Politician: “@Aidan Any pits that do re-open, most of the dirty, dangerous work will be done by ROVs and robots. It’s…” Feb 15, 08:55
Aidan on The Modern Politician: “Dan’s back and he’s fucking complaining, to nobodies surprise. Of course Lorna is right, coal mining was both dangerous and…” Feb 15, 07:55
Sven on The Modern Politician: “Willie @ 05.07. Gosh Willie, if it left Turkey around the 19th January and is now scheduled to arrive Corunna…” Feb 15, 07:12
Willie on The Modern Politician: “Seems that the new MV Isle of Islay may have been sustaining problems. The ferry built in Turkey was originally…” Feb 15, 05:07
DaveL on The Modern Politician: “‘Captain Swinney is believed to have gone down with his ship.’ If only but I’m afraid he fucked off quick…” Feb 15, 03:14
Colin Alexander on The Modern Politician: “The SNP and Scottish Greens will be delighted that Ebay are procuring donations for the Mermaids charity. Are Mermaids brainwashing,…” Feb 14, 23:42
Dan on The Modern Politician: “Big Country – Steeltown Vid contains footage of dirty men doing hard dirty work so not safe for some. www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ssx1Davnkw” Feb 14, 22:50
Dan on The Modern Politician: ““No, I don’t think coal mining was ever anything but dire Says it all. Perma “worried” woman rather than celebrate…” Feb 14, 22:38
Geoff Anderson on The Modern Politician: “I didn’t know he was a Spurs fan……. https://x.com/ScotExpress/status/2022733679576113365?s=20” Feb 14, 22:08
Lorna Campbell on The Modern Politician: “William Campbell: yes, I absolutely agree with you, but it was not the norm until Thatcher introduced council house ownership.…” Feb 14, 21:49
Young Lochinvar on The Modern Politician: “Well I’d like to imagine this anniversary may just, just mibbes, mighta have helped put some fire in the belly…” Feb 14, 21:46
Lorna Campbell on The Modern Politician: “Often you simply cannot turn back the clock. No, I don’t think coal mining was ever anything but dire, but…” Feb 14, 21:20
Alf Baird on The Modern Politician: “Plenty of wee coasters and fishing boats even smaller than the new £50 million Isle of Islay sailing oot there…” Feb 14, 21:09