The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



Weekend: The state of our union 9

Posted on May 19, 2012 by

As part of our continuing look at the people who haven’t yet their minds up about independence, we’re delighted to present this piece by Sue Lyons. If you’re a “Don’t know” too, we’d love to hear from you – why not drop us a line?

I am a mum and a wife. In point of fact, I’m an English wife married to a Scottish husband, with three English children from my first marriage and two Scottish children from my current marriage. Why would I even bother to mention that at all, you might wonder – surely it doesn’t matter where my children were born, surely I love them just the same? And you would be right.

What makes it worth mentioning is that my husband is a Scottish nationalist. In fact, he’s such a Scottish nationalist that were the UK government to say tomorrow “You can have independence for Scotland but you have to pay for it yourself”, he would say, “Where do I sign?”

He describes himself as “rabid” and he’s absolutely right – if you cut off his leg he would have a saltire running through it like a stick of rock (but not Blackpool rock, because that’s in England). Not for him the sitting on the fence that others might do, not for him the idea that you can vote for the SNP and yet still be undecided on independence. John is for an independent Scotland completely and absolutely. That sometimes causes fun and games in our own personal Union – our home.

Read the rest of this entry →

Weekend guest: View from the fence 57

Posted on May 06, 2012 by

Ray McRobbie has his own blog, but dropped us a line to ask whether we’d be interested in hearing from someone who used to be anti-independence but now resides in the “undecided” camp. We said we’d be delighted. Take it away, Ray.

I’ve written a wee bit on the issue of Scottish independence in the past, without explicitly outlining my own view. A couple of years ago I was quick to criticise the Scottish National Party, and I’m not exactly a fan of Alex Salmond. Since then I’ve seen a lot, heard a lot and read a lot. I’ve studied the issue in some depth for my dissertation at university, and I figure I’ll be reading and writing a bit more in the lead up to the 2014 referendum. So I decided at some point I should actually outline where I stand. At least for the moment.

As it happens, I’m not really a decisive person. I usually like to have all the facts on something before I make a choice. A yes/no question is not often easy for me as I might pick the “wrong” option. This is a strategy I cannot depend on when it comes to Scottish independence. The referendum will most likely boil down to a yes or a no, but in reality it’s much more than that.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,928 Posts, 1,244,333 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Xaracen on In pursuit of clarity: “You made the claim of rejection, your job to back it up, not mine to refute it.Jun 7, 15:05
    • DavidT on The Massive Face Of Truth: “Mind, some used to copy-and-paste from the blog.Jun 7, 14:43
    • Aidan on In pursuit of clarity: “lol – Xaracen: if you are involved in this eccentric escapade why don’t YOU publish all the correspondence with various…Jun 7, 14:43
    • Hatey McHateface on In pursuit of clarity: “Fascinating stuff, Confused. As if by magic you manage to blame all the world’s ills on the English and the…Jun 7, 14:36
    • Aidan on In pursuit of clarity: “That is what is known in the legal profession as a “bare denial”, I.e. a simply statement of “no I…Jun 7, 14:34
    • Xaracen on In pursuit of clarity: “@Aidan; “the approach to the UN had already been rejected.” Oh, FFS, not this tripe again! Prove it! Show us…Jun 7, 14:29
    • Effijy on The Massive Face Of Truth: “It’s a pity that it’s the Sun doing the interview. Over to the Editor now to twist and turn every…Jun 7, 14:24
    • Hatey McHateface on The Massive Face Of Truth: “Fourth comment from the top, Alf. Is that a new personal best?Jun 7, 14:23
    • Hatey McHateface on In pursuit of clarity: “When you write about big mouths, Northy, we must all defer to your lived experience.Jun 7, 14:21
    • Hatey McHateface on The Massive Face Of Truth: “Now that fame is chapping your door, Stu, promise us you won’t let it go to your head and turn…Jun 7, 14:14
    • Confused on In pursuit of clarity: “the tendency towards disorder in macro social systems, the existence of a “social entropy” is a constant and tragic problem…Jun 7, 14:05
    • Skip_NC on The Massive Face Of Truth: “(a) It’s the weekend so they’re at their dachas. (b) Now that they know the only advocate in Scotland ever…Jun 7, 13:48
    • McDuff on The Massive Face Of Truth: “You fully deserve this vindication rev, it was about time.Jun 7, 13:29
    • Northcode on In pursuit of clarity: “I disagree, Jay I think you should increase the number of comments you post in this place.Jun 7, 13:17
    • Alf Baird on The Massive Face Of Truth: ““Scotland has traditionally prided itself on the strength of its institutions” Fortunately now we know that our institutions are colonial.…Jun 7, 13:15
    • barelybare on The Massive Face Of Truth: “I agree an honest fundraiser to repay the Weirs would likely have succeeded. The actual fundraisers for referendum and for…Jun 7, 13:04
    • Jay on In pursuit of clarity: “Spade, Northcode, your knowledgeability far exceeds mine. I will reduce comments but keep reading. Best regards.Jun 7, 12:52
    • Northcode on In pursuit of clarity: “An intelligent response, Spade. You make several good points. I think we are yet to witness the SNP’s final, cataclysmic,…Jun 7, 12:30
    • Frank Roberts on The Massive Face Of Truth: “I got a four figure sum returned on behalf of my wife and I for donations made in 2017 and…Jun 7, 12:29
    • David Blake on The Massive Face Of Truth: “Pieces like this one in The Sun are very important. It is disgraceful that most papers seem to have taken…Jun 7, 12:02
    • Northcode on In pursuit of clarity: “Aye, Jay, I’ve read Childe’s “What Happened in History”, a couple of decades ago at least. My take on it,…Jun 7, 11:54
    • Northcode on In pursuit of clarity: ““Salvo/Liberate fundraiser which also has a case to answer for embezzlement…” Ah, the old Tu Quoque logical fallacy of “you…Jun 7, 11:50
    • Martin on The Massive Face Of Truth: “Very good interview from Connor and credit to The Sun for it too. You’ve got a great way with words,…Jun 7, 11:50
    • Nicky T Naquetti on The Massive Face Of Truth: “KICK ‘EM IN THE PRONOUNS, STUJun 7, 11:48
    • Ronald Bennett on The Massive Face Of Truth: “Hi Stuart, how did you gain access to the Murrell’s house to conduct your interview with ‘The Sun’?Jun 7, 11:36
    • Francis on The Massive Face Of Truth: “Well done. Keep the pressure on. Keep asking the questions – this could not be more important. Where are the…Jun 7, 11:35
    • Andy Wiltshire on The Massive Face Of Truth: “Anything back from the policing and prosecutorial branches of the SNP yet?Jun 7, 11:20
    • sam on In pursuit of clarity: “What evidence have you that the UN has rejected Scotland’s case?Jun 7, 11:19
    • Spade on In pursuit of clarity: “Colonialism takes many forms. The first colony of the colonising country is always its own people. What we are essentially…Jun 7, 11:15
    • Jay on In pursuit of clarity: “Northcode: your comment somehow reminds me of a book (read in part) by V. Gordon Childe, ‘What Happened in History’,…Jun 7, 11:00
  • A tall tale



↑ Top