The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



The politics of truthiness 105

Posted on February 16, 2015 by

One of the main strengths of the No campaign in the independence referendum was that it had an efficient production line for “truthiness”. Best known as a concept from the US satirical TV show The Colbert Report, the term means things that SOUND as if they’re true, and which people will therefore be inclined to believe, even though they fall apart under any factual scrutiny.

truthiness1

One good example is shown above. The facts on the graphic are individually true, and convey – without ever actually saying so explicitly – the message that Scotland is subsidised by the UK to the tune of £7.6bn a year.

But that message, despite being implied through exclusively true facts, ISN’T true, because the extra “spending” on Scotland is actually borrowing, which Scotland has to pay back. The real truth is that the figures on the left are accurate, and that Scotland heavily subsidises the rest of the UK.

But to walk someone through even the basic explanation of that is quite complicated and involved, whereas the original message is punchy and SOUNDS true. The simpler something is the more people want to believe it, so the implicit lie on the graphic is difficult to dislodge from their minds once it’s in there.

(It works especially well if the media is overwhelmingly on the side of those creating the misleading impression, because they can count on the fact that the mainstream press won’t run any analysis pointing out the flaws in the argument, and the only people who’ll ever encounter the explanation are those who actively seek it out.)

Truthiness, then, is a very powerful tool.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,993 Posts, 1,253,955 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Bilbo; Can we have an ignore the Yoon Trolls day/week? Watch them go round in a love-in with each other?…” Nov 17, 22:07
    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Bilbo; Can we have an ignore the Yoon Trolls day/week? Watch them go round in a love-in with each other?…” Nov 17, 22:07
    • DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I see you took a lesson in the spelling of the word ‘cunt’. Comprehension of word combinations next eh? Who’d…” Nov 17, 20:50
    • Bilbo on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Main is only on this site because he’s either banned from everywhere else or the ones where he’s not banned,…” Nov 17, 20:46
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Beaten to death” Naw, tenderised. You boys just don’t understand foreign cuisine. What’s that you say, Sooty? Is Dave wanting…” Nov 17, 20:30
    • DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Burning ppl alive” Check out the videos shot at the Odessa Trades Union building. Your ‘fighting friends’ aka Nazis did…” Nov 17, 20:01
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Burning ppl alive” Naw, Geri, cooking them. Babies and youngsters mostly. Try tae stick tae yer script. Showing initiative always…” Nov 17, 19:17
    • twathater on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Wee johnny Main should join his pals Cavey and Adey and go and look at Mark Col lets blogs it…” Nov 17, 18:15
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Main What exactly do you hope to achieve on this site? You’re not an independence supporter & you don’t like…” Nov 17, 16:20
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “AI-DAN No, it isn’t a war crime under international law. Shit was made perfectly clear during Minsk 1 & 2…” Nov 17, 15:38
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “With respect, CC, you’re not Scottish, so you’re not getting it. The primary motivator for James, Dave, Geri, Confused, etc…” Nov 17, 14:52
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Never mind all that, James. When’s Scotland gonna be independent? Couldn’t you maybe pick up the pace a bit? How…” Nov 17, 14:33
    • Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Hilarious that “James” and “DaveL” have to audacity to complain about others’ content when they themselves are – without the…” Nov 17, 14:23
    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “26 minutes.” Nov 17, 14:02
    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Adrian” aka Fox News excretes the usual bs right on cue. They obviously think if they repeat their shite ad…” Nov 17, 13:57
    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “DaveL; “….the cunts cunt….” ROTFLMFAO! 100% on the button.” Nov 17, 13:37
    • Aidan on How To Succeed In Scotland: “lol – so R invading U isn’t a war crime, but U defending itself from that invasion is a war…” Nov 17, 12:22
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “How’s it going as a “white n1gger” then, Confused? It’s a few days since you announced your new identity on…” Nov 17, 12:10
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Id put good money on that” Naw, Geri, you couldn’t. You’re penniless. It’s not possible for somebody like you, even…” Nov 17, 12:00
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Dan is correct. Scotland has absolutely zero control over immigration.” BS, Geri. As always. Take Glasgow, for example. The decision…” Nov 17, 11:49
    • Confused on How To Succeed In Scotland: “more interesting vids www.youtube.com/watch?v=YClIfiwBD_8&t=13s www.youtube.com/watch?v=jq9MHNEqOEI – can you imagine the shitstorm if some “white” person came out with anything 1/10…” Nov 17, 11:44
    • Confused on How To Succeed In Scotland: “https://archive.ph/NcAT2 “without you, we would do just -great-” more from “here’s what you could have won” https://archive.ph/kyu5W “women don’t lie…” Nov 17, 11:43
    • Confused on How To Succeed In Scotland: “we have just established a new world record for drinking your own piss https://archive.ph/9y7ZF – and for how long it…” Nov 17, 11:42
    • sarah on How To Succeed In Scotland: “A beautiful voice – thanks, Fearghas.” Nov 17, 11:22
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “You really have to laugh at English journalism & it’s fake hysteria. C isn’t occuuuuupied. It never belonged to U.…” Nov 17, 11:02
    • Aunty Flo on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Thank you for that, Fearghas. Beautiful and inspiring.” Nov 17, 09:51
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““I’ll tell you what being terrified is, Geri. When it’s 1 AM, you’re alone in the flat, and the illegal…” Nov 17, 09:30
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on How To Succeed In Scotland: “‘ST PATRICK’S BREASTPLATE’ « The prayer as recorded is dated on linguistic grounds to the early 8th century. » «…” Nov 17, 09:12
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Good news for bridge builders this morning. Looks like there’s gonna be more work than they can handle.” Nov 17, 08:28
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Awww! Dave’s spitting the dummy. Fresh nappy needed, richt noo! Dinna dae onything rash, Dave, such as hinging aroond the…” Nov 17, 08:20
  • A tall tale



↑ Top