The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



Out of the quagmire 887

Posted on January 14, 2019 by

UK politics is stuck fast in the mud, going nowhere, and the casualties are mounting. Whether on Brexit, independence or anything else, we’ve all become so dug-in to our positions that some people – naming no names – have forgotten where the battle lines are or what their political war was even about in the first place.

For 30 months now, the Yes movement has been trying to answer the question of how to get a second indyref. The SNP has a triple-locked democratic mandate based on Scotland being dragged out of the EU against the will of its people, but as strong a moral argument as that is it unfortunately runs straight into a brick wall of reality: the constitution is reserved to Westminster.

Equally we’re consumed by the ongoing Brexit trainwreck, which has no apparent escape route from a poisonous stalemate paralysing the UK’s politicians and leaving nobody in control as the country heads for some very hard buffers.

As the self-imposed Brexit deadline looms, Theresa May is running out of options. Her deal is a dead duck. When it inevitably fails, there are two possible scenarios: a second EU referendum of some sort (nobody can agree what the options would be), or a general election.

Neither the Tories nor Labour want another referendum because both parties want Brexit to happen, so another election is the more likely. But all the polls suggest it would deliver much the same hung parliament as we have now, solving nothing.

Last week, SNP MP Joanna Cherry QC gave a speech to a diverse pro-Europe group that includes former Green leader Caroline Lucas, pro-indy commentator Lesley Riddoch and Tory MP Dominic Grieve. And as she waxed lyrical, with a twinkle in her eye Cherry slipped in reference to a hitherto-undiscussed plan that offers an escape route for everyone.

Read the rest of this entry →

Fighting in the War Room 228

Posted on November 09, 2015 by

Last Friday’s article on the limitations of GERS caused quite a stir among the stout defenders of the Union, as social-media users may have noticed over the weekend.

Amidst the wildly-flailing fury-storm of shouty, abusive responses which pathologically evaded addressing the article’s point, the one vaguely factual argument raised was the notion that an independent Scotland wouldn’t be able to make significant savings on its current (notional) £3bn defence budget because NATO supposedly requires all member states to spend 2% of their GDP on defence.

warroom

So we thought we’d see if it was true.

Read the rest of this entry →

The limitations of GERS 297

Posted on November 06, 2015 by

Last week the BBC treated viewers to a Question Time hosted in Edinburgh, where a right-wing economics journalist from MoneyWeek magazine called Merryn Somerset Webb explained to a somewhat disgruntled Scottish audience why the government were right to bail out the bankers, but not steel workers.

It capped off an interesting week but to see why we’ll have to rewind a few days and revisit the work of an amateur Unionist blogger of our unwelcome acquaintance.

petshopboys

The amateur blogger in question has been garnering a fair amount of attention lately from straw-clutching Unionist hacks for his “analysis” of the Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland (GERS) figures, in which he purports to show a sizeable deficit in the economy of an independent or “full fiscal autonomy” Scotland.

In essence, the analysis amounts to dumping all the GERS summary tables into a Microsoft Excel graph, adding the Office of Budget Responsibility (OBR) forecast for oil revenue, and pointing to a resulting £9.1bn gap between Scotland’s public spending and its total revenue.

This, he asserts, is in addition to Scotland’s share of the hefty deficit the UK currently runs. His conclusion, shouted loudly and often by every angry Unionist on Twitter, is that the government of an independent Scotland – which tellingly they always assume to be an SNP one – would either have to drastically cut public services or raise taxes to fill this “black hole”.

It’s an interesting piece of analysis. Or it would be, if it wasn’t total nonsense.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,707 Posts, 1,212,834 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • gregor on For Mridul And Sandy: “The liberal elite strongly disagree (as usual:)Feb 15, 15:48
    • yoon scum on The thickness of blood: “Okay lets go into your world of chick don’t have dicks What is the answer? Should we ban anyone who…Feb 15, 15:44
    • gregor on For Mridul And Sandy: “Anonymous disagree. Ignore them, lolFeb 15, 15:42
    • yoon scum on The thickness of blood: “There is many within the “independence” movement who are deeply uncomfortable with freedom of speech Just look at the rage…Feb 15, 15:34
    • TheParty1sOver on The thickness of blood: “Chicks don’t have dicks. Women’s changing rooms are called women’s changing rooms for a reason.Feb 15, 15:32
    • Jim Thomson on The thickness of blood: “Seems clear of any malware nonsense.Feb 15, 15:30
    • gregor on The thickness of blood: “Freedom of speech does not apply to you lot.Feb 15, 15:28
    • Jim Thomson on The thickness of blood: “I saw a quick flash of something that looked like that filename as I opened the “Wings” tab. Did a…Feb 15, 15:18
    • gregor on The thickness of blood: “UNISON has predetermined that you lot (social media participants) are bullies and bigots.Feb 15, 15:17
    • yoon scum on The thickness of blood: “The salary can’t be that good As the position is still open and Scotland is awash with EX-SNP MPs who…Feb 15, 15:16
    • yoon scum on The thickness of blood: “Lets look at this from another angle How would you feel if a male walked into your son’s changing room…Feb 15, 15:14
    • Ali on The thickness of blood: “I’ve also been affected, now seems to be clear. If you need reassurance download and run “Malwarebytes” free version available.…Feb 15, 15:09
    • Skip_NC on The thickness of blood: “How do I apply for the job as the Non Executive Whistleblowing Champion? I used to be an over-officious football…Feb 15, 15:06
    • gregor on For Mridul And Sandy: “re. “whatever happened to r**y?” she was always up for a fight, bashing people I mostly didn’t like – I…Feb 15, 15:05
    • yoon scum on The thickness of blood: “I just tried in a different browser to my normal one and it is trying to download stuff It is…Feb 15, 14:59
    • IndyJay on The thickness of blood: “Hi Stu Your link to Rev. Stuart Campbell still redirects to server.client.exe which is malware. Readers, if you accidentally download…Feb 15, 14:59
    • Andy Anderson on The thickness of blood: “I am not anti anyone who feels they wish to dress and behave as if they are another sex. The…Feb 15, 14:59
    • yoon scum on The thickness of blood: “I’d imagine that if this is truly someone born in the wrong body then I think quite far down the…Feb 15, 14:54
    • gregor on For Mridul And Sandy: “re. “What say you to that, gregor?” WTF.Feb 15, 14:54
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The thickness of blood: “This was a problem yesterday but it should be fixed. You may have a caching issue. Try clearing your browser’s…Feb 15, 14:53
    • Del G on The thickness of blood: “Twice when viewing this article, a program called support.client.exe has downloaded. I have no intention of letting it run. By…Feb 15, 14:51
    • John C on The thickness of blood: “It strikes me that NHS Fife and Upton are trying hard to waste time in the hope it put Peggie…Feb 15, 14:51
    • yoon scum on The thickness of blood: “Scottish politics and public bodies has a serious problem not with YOONs But with absolute LOONs You really need to…Feb 15, 14:42
    • gregor on For Mridul And Sandy: “The Communist (15/02/25): ‘Army of Europe’ needed to challenge R***ia says Zelensky: “Zelensky said: “I really believe the time has…Feb 15, 14:31
    • Joan Savage on The thickness of blood: “Thank you, Wings. From msm it’s been difficult to gauge how this was going. However I have been so enraged…Feb 15, 14:30
    • Andy Anderson on The thickness of blood: “Excellent Stu. My wife has been brainwashing me with details of this case every day. Women’s rights ignored again, It…Feb 15, 14:28
    • Jeannie McCrimmon on The thickness of blood: “Sandi Peggie has been put through hell by immoral imbeciles.Feb 15, 14:22
    • TURABDIN on For Mridul And Sandy: “CLASSIC STURGEON WISDOM.  I don’t feel we need to be independent for me to feel confident in my Scottish identity.…Feb 15, 12:34
    • gregor on For Mridul And Sandy: “I love vintage machinery – engineering marvels e.g. my German Anker FZ sewing machine (not mentioning my wee hand-cranked, battered…Feb 15, 12:30
    • sarah on For Mridul And Sandy: “That’s the one I got the other day. I deleted w/o opening,Feb 15, 12:22
  • A tall tale



↑ Top