The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


What if the referendum ISN’T legal?

Posted on January 16, 2012 by

There's an aspect of the recent constitutional brouhaha that we're a little surprised nobody's looked into (so far as we've noticed). Let's assume for a moment that the Scottish Parliament, as claimed last week by the UK Government's Scottish Secretary Michael Moore, does NOT have the legal power to conduct any kind of referendum into Scotland's constitutional future (far less a legally binding one). And let's assume, for the sake of argument, that for one reason or another – perhaps the refusal of the SNP to play ball in negotiations – Westminster declined to give it that power.

How, then, could the people of Scotland ever legally choose to leave the Union against England's wishes?

It is an inviolable democratic principle, in this country and many others, that no administration can bind the hands of its successors. So despite the wording of the Treaty Of Union which stated that its effects were to endure "forever after", the Treaty cannot be imposed for eternity by those who signed it in 1707. But if the Westminster Parliament is the only arbiter permitted to allow the Scottish people a plebiscite on revoking it, and it chooses not to do so, how might the Scots legitimately extract themselves from the UK without armed revolt?

Electing MPs to Westminster is no good – making up less than 10% of the Parliament they can't force any legislation through, even were every one of them to represent a nationalist party. And in the Scottish Parliament, where it IS possible to elect a majority government dedicated to withdrawing from the Union, we've just been expressly told that there is no authority to even ask the question, far less act on it.

A mass petition? Millions demonstrating on the streets? The people of Britain tried that with the Poll Tax and the Iraq war, and a fat lot of notice the government took.

The UK government currently IS offering to empower the Scottish Parliament to hold a referendum, but while hinting at all manner of terms and conditions and limitations. It could, of course, also withdraw that offer at any moment. So can anyone tell us the democratic means by which the people of Scotland could assert and enact their desire to leave the Union, without asking for England's permission first?

Should such a means not exist – and it would seem that it doesn't – then the idea of Westminster imposing any rules whatsoever on the referendum mandated to the SNP by the Scottish electorate is a plainly indefensible outrage against the most basic rights of civilised peoples. We are not England's prisoners, and for that reason if no other, we are confident that any legal "obstacles" will be overcome. Roll on 2014.

5 to “What if the referendum ISN’T legal?”

  1. An Duine Gruamach says:

    Mass petitions and demonstrations were also of little avail in the devolution campaigns of the twentieth century.

    Reply
  2. Grant Thoms says:

    The same questions were posed in the Baltic states and in the break-up of Yugoslavia, especially the case in Montenegro; who cares what the imperialist state thinks, it's what the international community recognises that counts!

    Reply
  3. Colin Dunn says:

    Interesting. This seems to imply that by claiming to have the power to block a referendum that Westminster would be committing an illegal act under international law. Or am I reading too much into this due to complete and utter lack of any legal knowledge 😉 ?
    Colin

    Reply
  4. MartinB says:

    I'm minded of Canon Kenyan Wright's statement at the opening of the Scottish Constitutional Convention:

    'What if that other voice we all know so well responds by saying, 'We say no, and we are the state',? Well we say yes – and we are the people.'

    (source)

    Reply
  5. farrochie says:

    The treaty of union did not give the new parliament any legal right to alter or repeal the treaty. If the referendum concerns the ultimate existence of the union, one could argue that Westminster has no legal authority of such a referendum.
    See Prof David Walker, The Union and the Law, The Journal Online, June 2007.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,789 Posts, 1,222,287 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Alf Baird on The Pillars Of Sanity: “A widna haud ma breith on any UK state quango protecting the rights of Scots, though she may learn something…Jul 19, 17:06
    • Peter McAvoy on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Well done to everybody who refused to accept and challenged this woke fascism and to the deserved victories you have…Jul 19, 16:22
    • sarah on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Somewhere, over the rainbow… there is a happy land of sanity where children and women, and their supporters, can live…Jul 19, 15:53
    • Marie Clark on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Well done Stuart, you’ve been in this fight for a long time and it’s nice to see the outcome now.…Jul 19, 15:49
    • panda paws on The Pillars Of Sanity: “However deranged this week has been, I have every faith that next week will be the gift that keeps on…Jul 19, 15:47
    • agent x on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Meanwhile I am really enjoying watching the beautiful talented women playing in the EURO’s 25 without seeing big bollocked men…Jul 19, 15:45
    • SilentMajority on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Great article (and many thanks to the author!). Each and every victory an occasion to cheer. I am especially pleased…Jul 19, 15:28
    • duncanio on The Pillars Of Sanity: “And the hits keep coming.Jul 19, 15:24
    • Robert Mellish on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Meanwhile, at Pride Glasgow this morning, we could see on open and ‘proud’ display the extent of capture of corporate…Jul 19, 15:22
    • Mark Beggan on The Pillars Of Sanity: “It looks to me that the whole of Civic Scotland licks the gravy one way or another.Jul 19, 15:06
    • agent x on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Sturgeon: “There are people who have opposed this Bill that cloak themselves in women’s rights to make it acceptable, but…Jul 19, 15:03
    • agent x on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Well done Stu. I note that various press are stating that Swinney and NHS should put an end to the…Jul 19, 14:55
    • dramfineday on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Hear, hear, Jon.Jul 19, 14:47
    • Astonished on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Great work from all concerned. Any idea when we will start jailing all the transallies for all the harm they’ve…Jul 19, 14:35
    • Mark Beggan on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Monday to-do list; Visit Charity shops and complain about Trans flags. Demand to speak to the manager. It’s going to…Jul 19, 14:32
    • Mark Beggan on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Well done Rev. So it’s Operation Citadel. We know how well that worked out for the Wermacht.Jul 19, 14:27
    • sarah on Points Into Prongs: “O/T “Support Legal Fees For A Scottish TV Channel” crowdfunder. David Henry has worked for 10 years to try to…Jul 19, 14:26
    • Pete on The Pillars Of Sanity: “One line that sums up the entire debacle is “We haven’t even covered the latest developments in the Sandie Peggie…Jul 19, 14:22
    • Robert on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Good to see the late, great David Graeber quoted. I have often wondered where Graeber, as a prominent left libertarian,…Jul 19, 14:18
    • Andy Ellis on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Huge debts of thanks are owed to the few brave individuals (including your good self!) who whether willingly or by…Jul 19, 14:17
    • Gav on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Most satisfying article you’ve ever written Stu?Jul 19, 14:13
    • Jon Drummond on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Absolutely excellent article Rev Campbell. I salute you for your dogged determination in bringing this perversion to light and continuing…Jul 19, 14:13
    • GM on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Fine writing and a fine effort more generally. You should come back up to Scotland and put yourself forward for…Jul 19, 14:12
    • David on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Stu, congratulations to you. You fought these people all the way and can now rejoice.Jul 19, 14:03
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Points Into Prongs: “REST AND BE THANKFUL (Some online history) « The making of the road, in any sense that we would now…Jul 19, 13:44
    • Anthem on Points Into Prongs: “Yup, Noises need to be made.Jul 19, 13:26
    • Anthem on Points Into Prongs: “Yet britanica used to be the go to encyclopedia for historical facts. It just goes to show that the britnat…Jul 19, 13:24
    • Mark Beggan on Points Into Prongs: “And Brian Cox sucker.Jul 19, 13:02
    • Mark Beggan on Points Into Prongs: “The American trip is at the core of Crankys philosophy. Her dyke chums and the arse bandit Cummings.Jul 19, 13:00
    • GeoffC on Points Into Prongs: “This Route, is it along the “Rest and be Thankful”?Jul 19, 12:36
  • A tall tale



↑ Top