The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



The outstanding balance 591

Posted on February 10, 2019 by

We had an interesting exchange with Scottish Labour MP Paul Sweeney this week on the deathless lie that is the “fiscal transfer” – the £10bn or so that Unionists rather startlingly insist the rest of the UK generously donates to Scotland every year out of the goodness of its heart, just for the pleasure of our company.

As you can see, the debate was of a high intellectual standard.

Read the rest of this entry →

The useless Samaritans 76

Posted on September 15, 2013 by

We’ve been meaning to nag someone to present this data in a super-snappy visual form for ages, then what do you know except that the splendid Stewart Bremner just pops up out of nowhere and does it without even being asked.

samaritans

Independence will NOT “abandon England to the Tories”. If the people of the rest of the UK choose to vote Tory, we can’t save them from themselves, even were we to be so arrogant as to assume we had any business doing so. If they choose to vote Labour, they’re equally capable of electing them just fine without our help.

Scottish votes are almost totally irrelevant to UK elections. We have no impact on the government England gets. They, on the other hand, force governments that we voted against on us more than 60% of the time. That’s not a union of equals. That’s the political equivalent of domestic abuse. It’s never the wrong time to walk away.

Read the rest of this entry →

The invisible truth 4

Posted on February 12, 2012 by

There are some stories which persist long after they’ve been debunked, a recent example being Joan McAlpine’s supposed accusation that anyone opposing the SNP was “anti-Scottish”. However many times it was shown that she didn’t say any such thing, however often she explained what she HAD said, the lie kept being perpetuated (and will doubtless continue to be in the coming months and years) by people who knew full well it wasn’t true, because it suited their agenda to do so.

The notion that Scotland is massively subsidised by England is another such political legend, and we don’t imagine for a second that this story from today’s Sunday Times will stop the endless stream of idiots on the Telegraph, Mail and Express (both above and below the line) from continuing to assert it at every opportunity.


But at least now you can handily link them to the actual facts, even if they don’t want to hear them. The full article can be read below.

Read the rest of this entry →

Alex Salmond Dictator-Comparison Bingo! 59

Posted on February 03, 2012 by

It won’t have come as any surprise to SNP supporters that the media – the same one that devoted hundreds of column inches to misrepresenting Joan McAlpine’s “anti-Scottish” comments on Twitter – was today absolutely silent on Labour MP Denis McShane’s comparison of Alex Salmond to Serbian war criminal Slobodan Milosevic.


MacShane, who voted in favour of the Iraq War, hasn’t deleted the tweet, despite a storm of protest on Twitter. But he’s only the latest in a long line of Unionist politicians to compare Scotland’s democratically elected First Minister (who as far as we know isn’t implicated in a single death) to murderous genocidal dictators.

Labour in particular are fond of crying about the nasty cybernat “bullies” who occasionally call Labour politicians names online, but those are pseudonymous internet users with not a shred of evidence that any of them are members of – or even vote for – the SNP. We’re not aware of any elected Nat representative or even pro-independence journalist ever having likened Gordon Brown or Tony Blair or Ed Miliband to Hitler, but the brave defenders of the Union have no such scruples. MacShane is merely the latest in a long and ignoble line, so we thought it’d be a good idea to keep track and see if we can get a full house.

Read the rest of this entry →

Why Labour doesn’t need Scotland 111

Posted on January 10, 2012 by

One of Labour’s sneakier tricks in opposing Scottish independence is to appeal to Scottish voters’ sense of social responsibility. The former party of socialist internationalism begs the Scots to show Unionist solidarity with their poor comrades in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, who would – the story runs – be abandoned permanently to the mercies of the evil Tories if the Westminster Parliament was deprived of its traditional sizeable block of Labour MPs from Scotland.

This narrative is regularly propagated by Labour’s friends in the media (and sometimes by gleeful Tories too). Only today, for example, the Scotsman carries the line in a piece which asserts that an independent Scotland would leave David Cameron “with an inbuilt Tory majority for his party in the rest of the UK”.

There are, of course, innumerable things wrong with this argument – for one, the dubious morality of using Scottish MPs to impose a Labour government on English voters who may have rejected one, when Scotland has its own Parliament and England doesn’t. (An offshoot of the timeless West Lothian Question.) And for another, the highly questionable premise that the modern-day Labour Party is ideologically significantly different from the Tories anyway.

But the biggest problem with the notion is simply that it’s completely untrue.

Read the rest of this entry →

Missing the point of a referendum 3

Posted on November 15, 2011 by

Scottish Labour embarrassed themselves horribly today when they jumped on comments from SNP MSP Stewart Maxwell in which he noted that the Scottish Government was only legally empowered to hold an advisory referendum on independence rather than a binding one. Not withstanding the fact that ALL referenda in the UK are only advisory, whether conducted by Holyrood or Westminster or anyone else, Labour’s humiliating blunder was in triumphantly asserting there was something new about this position, when in fact the very first sentence of the SNP’s National Conversation website – dating back over two years – says the exact same thing:

“The First Minister has outlined plans for a public consultation on a draft Referendum Bill which sets out proposals for an advisory referendum on extending the powers of the Scottish Parliament.”

But there’s another aspect to the nature of referenda that everyone seems to be inexplicably overlooking of late. The Unionist parties have recently ramped up a campaign in which they demand the SNP “clarify” every last item of policy in an independent Scotland, from currency and EU membership to renewable energy transmission costs, pension provision, and all the way down to what colour the First Minister’s going to paint Bute House’s front door. What nobody seems to have grasped is the fairly crucial point that that’s not what a referendum is for.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,993 Posts, 1,253,931 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “You really have to laugh at English journalism & it’s fake hysteria. C isn’t occuuuuupied. It never belonged to U.…” Nov 17, 11:02
    • Aunty Flo on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Thank you for that, Fearghas. Beautiful and inspiring.” Nov 17, 09:51
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““I’ll tell you what being terrified is, Geri. When it’s 1 AM, you’re alone in the flat, and the illegal…” Nov 17, 09:30
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on How To Succeed In Scotland: “‘ST PATRICK’S BREASTPLATE’ « The prayer as recorded is dated on linguistic grounds to the early 8th century. » «…” Nov 17, 09:12
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Good news for bridge builders this morning. Looks like there’s gonna be more work than they can handle.” Nov 17, 08:28
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Awww! Dave’s spitting the dummy. Fresh nappy needed, richt noo! Dinna dae onything rash, Dave, such as hinging aroond the…” Nov 17, 08:20
    • DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I remember when the moron Hatey turned up here. All he did was act as the Andy Ellis sidekick. Comments…” Nov 16, 23:11
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “So now the Wings BTL soup correspondent and Scotland’s pre-eminent beaver phobe has been triggered. Posting about moon howling too…” Nov 16, 22:26
    • Dan on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Hatey says : “I’ll tell you what being terrified is, Geri. When it’s 1 AM, you’re alone in the flat,…” Nov 16, 21:50
    • 100%Yes on How To Succeed In Scotland: “He comes here and betrays himself as Hatey McHateface when we know his true identity A Force for good, priceless.…” Nov 16, 21:07
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “@ Hatey McHateface says: 16 November, 2026 at 5:10 pm “Scotland and the Scots were pre-eminent in many areas, and…” Nov 16, 19:27
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “We should all be terrified of this bullshit. Anyone doing any online banking or shopping will already be aware that…” Nov 16, 19:09
    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “DaveL; Good question. And all day every day too.” Nov 16, 19:00
    • James on How To Succeed In Scotland: “A whole 31 minutes, Alf, afore the SP left another pile of manure. Keep up the good work. You’re on…” Nov 16, 18:55
    • twathater on How To Succeed In Scotland: “You take great pleasure in tarring EVERYONE who votes for the Scum Nonce Party as tribalist brain dead fuckwits ,…” Nov 16, 18:24
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “@Alf Perhaps I’m aware of when Scotland and the Scots were pre-eminent in many areas, and people from third-world shitholes…” Nov 16, 17:10
    • Alf Baird on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““who could hate Scots and Scotland more” ‘Self-hatred’ is an essential part of the colonial condition (Fanon), and colonialism itself…” Nov 16, 16:49
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Well done, Dave, big word – “rhetorical”. Did you get help? Here’s a big phrase: “logical fallacy”. Naw, Dave, nowt…” Nov 16, 16:40
    • DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Rhetorical question, is there anyone alive who could hate Scots and Scotland more than wee Adolf McHateface?” Nov 16, 15:45
    • Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““It really is incumbent on all of us, CC, to continue to expose what clings to the Scottish Indy movement,…” Nov 16, 14:46
    • Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““They’ve lived under illegal sanctions for decades” “Illegal” sanctions you say – how precisely are they supposedly illegal? On the…” Nov 16, 14:41
    • Lorncal on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I know, 100%, that the SNP leadership and so many of those that fawn around it, are irredeemable and should…” Nov 16, 14:11
    • Lorncal on How To Succeed In Scotland: “The ‘gender’ thingy was never a distraction, Geri. It was the vanguard of a huge ‘woke’ – post modernist/cultural Marxist…” Nov 16, 13:57
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““I’m terrified and despairing” Naw, sarah, you’re not. Genuine question. If anybody knows of a more self-pitying, hysterically over exaggerating…” Nov 16, 13:39
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I guess, Alf, we have to learn to separate Memmi’s “objective of the coloniser” from the common sense “objective of…” Nov 16, 13:32
    • sarah on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Yes indeed. We are all completely at the mercy of international profit-makers who have no concern for our welfare. Does…” Nov 16, 13:08
    • Alf Baird on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““make it even harder for us to break away and become independent” Some here appear to be doing a good…” Nov 16, 13:01
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I’m certainly smart enough to understand that if it’s the will of the Scottish people (it’s certainly the will of…” Nov 16, 12:37
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““They’re considerably better off than you are” There you go, CC, that’s you been told. Told by somebody who would…” Nov 16, 12:22
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““she stuffed every seat in Holyrood with fuckwits” Inexplicable you don’t have one. Then again, maybe you do. Your inability…” Nov 16, 12:13
  • A tall tale



↑ Top