The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Archive for the ‘scottish politics’


Questions and sort-of answers 99

Posted on September 05, 2014 by

Last week we highlighted the dismissive, contemptuous attitude of many Scottish Labour MPs and MSPs to questions from their constituents, an approach perhaps borne of the safe seats occupied by most of those concerned. However, some politicians from the three Unionist parties in Scotland do still deign to correspond with the electorate, and it would be unfair of us not to acknowledge and credit them for that.

Below, then, are the other responses that Wings readers received to a number of questions relating to independence that we suggested they might like to pose to their elected representatives way back in July. (We’ve given it six weeks, and it seems safe to assume that any who haven’t replied by now aren’t going to.)

It’s a lengthy read, but we think you’ll find it enlightening.

Read the rest of this entry →

What didn’t really need saying 210

Posted on September 05, 2014 by

Here are two snippets from a couple of recent “Better Together” leaflets:

btshopping

Curiously, that 16% increase has fallen to 13% in their latest “briefing” full of made-up numbers Blair McDougall has pulled out of – well, let’s be polite and say “thin air”. But since they’ve been specifically named, let’s just check the claim with Tesco.

Read the rest of this entry →

If you can’t say something nice 502

Posted on September 04, 2014 by

…you probably write for the Express.

Yesterday we posted a couple of tweets observing the fact that the Scottish media had conspicuously ignored the phenomenon that is The Wee Blue Book. (We’d have made more of the total blanking had we been even a little bit surprised.)

benborland

Despite having extensively reported almost every other document published about the referendum debate (such as Sir Tom Hunter’s almost-impenetrable digital-only effort), the press saw nothing at all newsworthy about a 72-page book that’s been downloaded over 400,000 times online and which a small team of complete amateurs had managed to fund, print and distribute more than 250,000 physical copies of in a matter of days, with demand still far outstripping supply.

But it turned out we were being a little unfair.

Read the rest of this entry →

On moving to Yes 182

Posted on September 04, 2014 by

Bill Leckie in the Scottish Sun, 4 September 2014:

“I still have a list of nagging doubts, not least over who emerges to lead this new state. It’s just that… well, whereas not so long ago these doubts were what held me back, today they somehow seem exciting.

Will it turn out a Yes vote? Don’t ask me. I’m still too busy trying to work out exactly what it was about that conversation [with my son] that changed my mind on the most important collective decision we will ever make.

Today, I can still only offer this guess. That when all is said and done, maybe it just feels better to believe in something that could be amazing than to settle for what can never be better than OK.”

Love on the rocks 193

Posted on September 03, 2014 by

The neverending plague 247

Posted on September 03, 2014 by

From industry recruitment website oilandgaspeople.com today:

“Scotland could be sitting on more than double the amount of oil and gas reserves currently predicted, a new independent industry investigation has found. The investigation reveals that the scale of Scotland’s untapped frontier West Coast or Atlantic Margin has been underestimated.

The investigation was undertaken by oilandgaspeople.com, the world’s largest oil and gas industry jobs board, and independent North Sea oil and gas industry experts. The investigation included interviews with industry experts and collated seismic and expert evidence from a range of independent sources such as the British Geological Survey, DECC, oil and gas companies, the Institute of Petroleum Engineering and the  Energy Institute.

The findings show that the current predictions of extensive untapped reserves of oil and gas could be underestimated by 100%. The West Coast alone could provide oil and gas for at least 100 years with an estimated value of more than £1 trillion.”

Another 100 years? A trillion pounds? When will this curse be lifted from Scotland?

A thousand-word metaphor 237

Posted on September 02, 2014 by

landfillno

Assessing the earthquake 750

Posted on September 02, 2014 by

If anyone was still harbouring any doubts as to the significance of last night’s poll news, they would surely have been dispelled by this serious, thought-provoking and perceptive analysis on the BBC news channel’s “The Papers” roundup last night.

Of course, the poll might be a rogue. It might just be a temporary bounce from the second Salmond-Darling debate. And it still shows No in front. The Yes campaign will have to redouble its efforts in the last couple of weeks, not start congratulating itself.

But the one thing we can surely all agree on, right across the political divides, is that the most important aspect is whether someone might at some point have been slightly rude to Andrew Lloyd Webber on Twitter or not.

A surprising development 286

Posted on September 01, 2014 by

geyg

The rather sour Times leader linked in the tweet doesn’t actually specify the numbers, and the poll isn’t officially released yet as we write this, but we’d been hearing rumours of a Y47 N53 (excl. DKs) for a little while beforehand, so it looks like they were true.

Less than a month ago, YG stood at Y39 N61. If these numbers are confirmed, that’s a colossal 8% swing in three weeks, from the most No-friendly pollster around.

Game, as they say, on.

Read the rest of this entry →

Bringing the smackdown 123

Posted on September 01, 2014 by

We thought this deserved a wider audience after the Herald’s appalling front-page lead scare story today by Michael Settle and Kate Devlin, channelling Jim Murphy MP:

“SCOTTISH POLICE FEDERATION
5 Woodside Place, Glasgow, G3 7QF

MEDIA RELEASE

The Scottish Police Federation represents all police officers in the ranks of constable, sergeant, inspector and chief inspector, police cadets and special constables, over 18,500 people, 98% of all police officers in Scotland.

To: News Editor
Date: 1 September 2014
Subject: Independence Referendum

In response to the suggestion of absolute carnage in and around polling stations on the 18th Sept Brian Docherty, Chairman of the Scottish Police Federation said;

The independence debate has been robust but overwhelmingly good natured and it would prove a disservice to those who have participated in it thus far to suggest that with 17 days to go, Scotland is about to disintegrate into absolute carnage on the back of making the most important decision in the country’s history.

Politicians and supporters of whichever point of view need to be mindful of the potential impact of intemperate, inflammatory and exaggerated language, lest they be seen to seek to create a self fulfilling prophecy

ENDS”

Oooft. ‘Nuff said.

Brass neck polished again 130

Posted on September 01, 2014 by

The Daily Record, 27 Aug 2014:

“[Gordon] Brown said SNP proposals to cut corporation tax would benefit large companies, including energy firms.

‘The biggest beneficiaries of the SNP’s tax policy are the shareholders and directors of the privatised energy companies in Scotland,” he said. ‘”When you look at the Scottish National Party policies, inequality and poverty will survive until doomsday if Alex Salmond is all that confronts it.”

And Mr Brown again in the Observer, 31 August 2014:

“You’ve got to look at what the SNP is proposing. They’re dining out on Scottish traditions of equality to suggest that Scotland will always be more just in the policies we implement, but their only tax proposal is to cut corporation tax for the richest companies in the country.

They want to cut corporation tax by 3p in the pound. That’s less for health and pensions, not more.”

Veteran readers will know where we’re going next.

Read the rest of this entry →

A significant escalation 185

Posted on September 01, 2014 by

Last week, Yes voters only hated their families, not Scotland.

hatekids

This week it’s both. Can you feel the fear, readers?

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,871 Posts, 1,235,442 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on The Marshalling Plan: “If Reform do what they say, reform our politics, then they will have succeeded in working themselves out of a…Feb 4, 17:21
    • agentx on The Marshalling Plan: “John Swinney has ordered an investigation into his government’s dealings with Peter Mandelson to see if the “interests of Scotland…Feb 4, 17:21
    • Cynicus on The Marshalling Plan: “BigJay says: 4 February, 2026 at 3:32 pm . “…….lots of people are saying at the moment that they’ll vote…Feb 4, 17:02
    • Hatey McHateface on The Marshalling Plan: “Whooda thunk it, eh? The academic in his ivory tower, poring over his books, references and arcane theories reaches exactly…Feb 4, 17:00
    • Hatey McHateface on The Marshalling Plan: “A lot more shouty.Feb 4, 16:41
    • Chas on The Marshalling Plan: “Unbelievably you make more sense when you write about the 300 year old pish. How do individuals get appointed to…Feb 4, 16:35
    • James Cheyne on The Marshalling Plan: “Hatey, Never a truer word spoken, Perhaps they should all be fully transitioned, a new disguised terminology for ( medically…Feb 4, 16:07
    • Alf Baird on The Marshalling Plan: ““The only hope of getting rid of the SNP” and ensure you vote for independence is to vote for THE…Feb 4, 15:52
    • James Cheyne on The Marshalling Plan: “It is with valid reasoning of the above alone that Scotland should have a Sovereign peoples parliament in Scotland, run…Feb 4, 15:37
    • BigJay on The Marshalling Plan: “It’s 92 days (including today) to the Holyrood election on the 7th of May. Candidates have to be registered 23…Feb 4, 15:32
    • James Cheyne on The Marshalling Plan: “Willie, The present labour prime minister does not have a clean track record on past judgements or a present one…Feb 4, 15:18
    • Cynicus on The Marshalling Plan: “factchecker “ The only hope of getting rid of the SNP is to vote for a party that already has…Feb 4, 15:00
    • James Cheyne on The Marshalling Plan: “Willie, The case for Andrew is still as yet incomplete, I am sure there is more to come out, and…Feb 4, 14:56
    • DaveL on The Marshalling Plan: “Factchecker would be better served hanging pencils from his nostrils…Feb 4, 14:48
    • James Cheyne on The Marshalling Plan: “Factchecker, it has always been notable that no attention has been paid to – facts, but rather to learned opinion…Feb 4, 12:59
    • Cynicus on The Marshalling Plan: “Cherrybank says: 2 February, 2026 at 8:29 pm I think Craig Houston the You- tuber has a good chance of…Feb 4, 12:44
    • DaveL on The Marshalling Plan: “Labour makes sense? If it’s fact checking that’s led you to that conclusion you should give it up.Feb 4, 12:10
    • factchecker on The Marshalling Plan: “A sensible analysis, I think, Chas. It is almost unimaginable that any ‘new’ pro-independence party or group of parties can…Feb 4, 11:11
    • Alf Baird on The Marshalling Plan: ““I will never vote fascist” Civilization helps us “locate the origins of fascism within colonialism” (R.D.G. Kelley). And postcolonial theory…Feb 4, 10:27
    • Alf Baird on The Marshalling Plan: “Professor Black confirmed that in 1707 Scotland was annexed and England’s parliament was merely rebranded as ‘United Kingdom’ whenever it…Feb 4, 10:10
    • Chas on The Marshalling Plan: “Irrespective of the content, which Stu diligently and accurately provides in his articles, it never takes too long before the…Feb 4, 10:00
    • Marie on The Marshalling Plan: “Good post Willie. Who (ultimately) financed JE’s activities and why?Feb 4, 09:47
    • sam on The Marshalling Plan: “An insight into the political organisation of the Reform Party According to Beth Rigby. Beth Rigby Tweet 3 Feb 2026…Feb 4, 08:57
    • Hatey McHateface on The Marshalling Plan: “Receiving loud and clear, Skip_NC. You’ll be happy with your 7 pro-Indy seats at HR for the next 5 years.…Feb 4, 08:52
    • Hatey McHateface on The Marshalling Plan: “Perhaps ordinary Scots fowk see no need to vote to dismantle something they are being told doesn’t exist. That would…Feb 4, 08:37
    • Hatey McHateface on The Marshalling Plan: “I asked Grok to summarise your post, Confused: “Anyone who disagrees with Confused takes it up the shitter” Personally, I…Feb 4, 08:25
    • Hatey McHateface on The Marshalling Plan: “You’ve put your finger on the crux of the matter, Willie. How can we ever have a functioning democracy if…Feb 4, 08:12
    • Aidan on The Marshalling Plan: “It’s also a complete myth that oil = unimaginable wealth. Look at the top 30 oil producing countries, Scotland has…Feb 4, 06:12
    • Aidan on The Marshalling Plan: “Or is it really because as virtually no Scottish voter has ever heard of Liberate they don’t register on any…Feb 4, 06:07
    • Duncan Strachan on The Marshalling Plan: “Aye Frank he wouldnt look out out place amongst the rest of the stiffs.Feb 4, 01:11
  • A tall tale



↑ Top