The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



The Rorschach Test 85

Posted on January 10, 2023 by

The release of some early 2021 census statistics relating to gender was greeted with glee and elation by Nancy Kelley, CEO of Stonewall in the UK. Vindication at last!

(Kelley declined to mention that her figure of 262,000 was substantially less than half the number of trans and non-binary individuals – 600,000 – that her organisation has habitually claimed for years.)

The census suggested that England and Wales are home to 48,000 transwomen (and 48,000 transmen), from the total who’d answered No to the voluntary question asking if their gender identity aligned with their sex at birth.

(The largest number that said No, around 118,000, didn’t tick the boxes of transwoman, transman or non-binary, nor wrote in their own. An unknown number of these may have been rejecting “gender” altogether. 30,000 ticked “non-binary” and 18,000 wrote in a gender because they were REALLY special.)

But, as we’ve been told time out of number, we must accept what people say about themselves. So 48,000 transwomen it is. So few. So vulnerable. And that number got me thinking.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,696 Posts, 1,209,858 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Young Lochinvar on The Silent Revolution: “It’s well past that I think. The so called party of independence hiring the “pen for hire” Murray Foote as…Jan 24, 02:57
    • Young Lochinvar on The Silent Revolution: “I detest the term “progressive”, just as I hate the other hijacked phrases and words like “gay”, “pride”, “gender “…Jan 24, 01:23
    • gregor on A short treatise on stalking: “The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (Track 17): https://tinyurl.com/3akme8h2 #QJan 24, 00:29
    • Mark Beggan on The Silent Revolution: “Deviants the lot of them. Each and every one.Jan 24, 00:19
    • gregor on A short treatise on stalking: “Humza Yousaf: The Pursuit Of Purpose: What Motivates Musk? Spoiler Alert: The Nazi Salute Was a Hint: “The Party told…Jan 24, 00:13
    • gregor on The Silent Revolution: “‘It’ ? “Used as the subject of a verb, or the object of a verb or preposition, to refer to…Jan 23, 23:16
    • George Ferguson on The Silent Revolution: “O/T This post will probably not get through. First let’s deal with the substantive core of Stus article. Is anybody…Jan 23, 23:12
    • gregor on The Silent Revolution: “The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King: Éowyn’s Dream (Instrumental:) https://tinyurl.com/ytkj2dm5 #Storm #NoEscapeJan 23, 22:57
    • Zimba on The Great Hollowing: “That’s not my point and you know it. But hey.Jan 23, 22:36
    • robertkknight on The Silent Revolution: “Please… #gieitarestffsJan 23, 22:08
    • gregor on The Great Hollowing: “Trump Orders Release of JFK, RFK, MLK Assassination Files: https://x.com/i/trending/1882548212768071842 #TransparencyMattersJan 23, 22:06
    • Willie on The Silent Revolution: “Aye and other parts too Mark! A lot of boaby wallopers the SNP. Many of course are of course Jakess…Jan 23, 21:32
    • Willie on The Silent Revolution: “Anum Qaisar. Was she not the shooie in one time MP who was one of the dlevout Humxa Yousaf’s harem.of…Jan 23, 21:26
    • sarah on The Silent Revolution: “There were never any challenges. And it’s not easy to get 100 supporters from 20 branches when there is no…Jan 23, 21:25
    • gregor on The Silent Revolution: “BBC (2025): Abuse claims were ‘brushed under the carpet’: “The Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry has heard that allegations of physical,…Jan 23, 21:19
    • shug on The Silent Revolution: “The SNP needs its own security service to weed out the plants.Jan 23, 21:12
    • shug on The Silent Revolution: “I hear what they are saying about 100 members – seems a low number right enough. However 25% of a…Jan 23, 21:10
    • gregor on The Silent Revolution: “@TheSNPForum Plebs release: “NEW: Justice Secretary Angela Constance gave an emotional apology to the families of Katie Allan and William…Jan 23, 21:01
    • gregor on The Silent Revolution: “This is 2025…Jan 23, 20:23
    • Pipinghot on The Silent Revolution: “Got to keep the fear levels up.Jan 23, 20:02
    • gregor on The Silent Revolution: “The Fraud (2023): GCHQ drafted in to keep SNP leadership vote secure: “THE SNP is working with UK spy bosses…Jan 23, 19:44
    • PacMan on The Silent Revolution: “There is a distinct possibility that Trump’s term in office could have a detrimental effect on the woke politics in…Jan 23, 19:41
    • Willi on The Silent Revolution: “Less ordinary members on the NEC more special interest. That ells you that nothing has changed in this rank rotten…Jan 23, 19:17
    • gregor on The Silent Revolution: “@1984: “BREAKING: Millions of Scots will soon hear a ‘loud siren’ from their mobile phones to alert of danger from…Jan 23, 19:06
    • Hatey McHateface on The Silent Revolution: “I think you will be OK, TT. Back in the old days when we still had paper persons delivering the…Jan 23, 18:54
    • agent X on The Silent Revolution: “Millions of phones across Scotland to sound ‘Armageddon’ alert siren ahead of deadly Storm Eowyn Stay safe.Jan 23, 18:54
    • sarah on The Silent Revolution: “Rev tweeted today that the membership in June 2024 was 64,525, so you’re not far off, robertkknight.Jan 23, 18:40
    • gregor on The Silent Revolution: “OBN Dev: Fraud Files: King of Fraud: “And often the self-described, “Greatest Swiper of All Time” Stolen Bank ID numbers were…Jan 23, 18:37
    • robertkknight on The Silent Revolution: “If 100 constitute 0.15% of SNP members, by my reconning the total membership would be approx. 67,000. Therefore the 2.5%…Jan 23, 18:26
    • twathater on The Silent Revolution: “As I commented on the previous post Is this not another Angus Robertson’s version of democracy for the membership of…Jan 23, 18:14
  • A tall tale



↑ Top