The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


The Rorschach Test 87

Posted on January 10, 2023 by

The release of some early 2021 census statistics relating to gender was greeted with glee and elation by Nancy Kelley, CEO of Stonewall in the UK. Vindication at last!

(Kelley declined to mention that her figure of 262,000 was substantially less than half the number of trans and non-binary individuals – 600,000 – that her organisation has habitually claimed for years.)

The census suggested that England and Wales are home to 48,000 transwomen (and 48,000 transmen), from the total who’d answered No to the voluntary question asking if their gender identity aligned with their sex at birth.

(The largest number that said No, around 118,000, didn’t tick the boxes of transwoman, transman or non-binary, nor wrote in their own. An unknown number of these may have been rejecting “gender” altogether. 30,000 ticked “non-binary” and 18,000 wrote in a gender because they were REALLY special.)

But, as we’ve been told time out of number, we must accept what people say about themselves. So 48,000 transwomen it is. So few. So vulnerable. And that number got me thinking.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,759 Posts, 1,218,016 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Young Lochinvar on The Ace Attorney: ““One of the most”.. Well aye but what about potty mouth Mhairi ( the Labour Party left me) Black? One…May 20, 03:31
    • Young Lochinvar on The Ace Attorney: “I don’t think The Wallace sought a sinecure or pension from anyone. Therein lies the problem and why the English…May 20, 02:26
    • Peter McAvoy on The Ace Attorney: “Yet again people commenting are arguing against the SNPs inaction and abiding by The UK supreme court opposing the Scottish…May 20, 02:14
    • Young Lochinvar on The Ace Attorney: “Mia So very well said. Bravo!May 20, 01:54
    • Mia on The Ace Attorney: ““I would suggest that the number of pro-independence MPs or MSPs elected at any election is irrelevant” On this point,…May 19, 22:55
    • Oneliner on The Ace Attorney: “The art(ifice) of the infiltrator laid bare.May 19, 22:29
    • McDuff on The Ace Attorney: “Independence is the wrong word. We were already an independent country when we joined England to create the UK and…May 19, 22:09
    • sarah on The Ace Attorney: “Robert, just to confirm – your link is to the Saturday afternoon SSRG session where Sara Salyers and Prof Robert…May 19, 21:27
    • Hatey McHateface on The Ace Attorney: “The traditional right-wing media is certainly portraying it as a betrayal of Brexit. I don’t know if that is true,…May 19, 20:45
    • Hatey McHateface on The Ace Attorney: ““Oh. We’re going to do some more demanding” Now, now. Be fair tae the boy. He actually wrote: “That means…May 19, 20:31
    • Dunx on The Ace Attorney: “The CEO of Salmon Scotland has this to say about the deal “It eases the burden on our farmers, processors…May 19, 20:26
    • Dunx on The Ace Attorney: ““Confirming that the initial 1707 treaty of union was not ratified,” The treaty was ratified by the Scottish Parliament when…May 19, 20:20
    • robertkknight on The Ace Attorney: “I can’t recommend this enough as it spells out our current Westminster/Supreme Court impasse/road block, as outlined in the article,…May 19, 20:05
    • Andrew scott on The Ace Attorney: “Watch out Snp-rubbish Liebour awful Tories nowhere Reform will rush thru the gapMay 19, 20:03
    • Effijy on The Ace Attorney: “Some of Starmer’s minor concessions with the EU are built on yet again selling out Scottish Fishing Rights for yet…May 19, 19:51
    • Mike on The Ace Attorney: “It would be interesting to read what “clear strategy” Sheppard proposes? Maybe Kelly’s spurious SNP1&2 will form part of it.…May 19, 19:34
    • Breastplate on The Ace Attorney: “Then no doubt you voted for Scottish self determination in 2014 because of the good governance of Alex Salmond?May 19, 18:53
    • Joan Savage on The Ace Attorney: “ExcellentMay 19, 18:49
    • Joan Savage on The Ace Attorney: “Tommy doesn’t understand anything about our history. That the so-called union never happened. The terms of the Articles of Union…May 19, 18:48
    • Breastplate on The Ace Attorney: “You’re quite right Mia. I’ve yet to hear any politician explain that denying a referendum is denying democracy. It doesn’t…May 19, 18:45
    • factfinder on The Ace Attorney: “I would suggest that the number of pro-independence MPs or MSPs elected at any election is irrelevant. If the wishes…May 19, 18:31
    • twathater on The Ace Attorney: “Is anyone surprised that these tr@i torous scum are now starting to panic and shit themselves , they would have…May 19, 18:26
    • James Cheyne on The Ace Attorney: “Mia, I love reading your comments,.you have that fire inside, along with common sense that all Scottish people sorely need…May 19, 18:03
    • agent x on The Ace Attorney: “100% agreeMay 19, 18:01
    • Elizabeth Hagan on The Ace Attorney: “If the Scottish Government had concentrated on good & successfully policies and convinced people of their abilities more people might…May 19, 17:46
    • ScottieDog on The Ace Attorney: “It would be really refreshingly honest if the SNP campaigned as such – English sovereignty over Scots. So even with…May 19, 17:33
    • James Cheyne on The Ace Attorney: “Tommy Sheppard, Ace Attorney, another one of the begging bowl great pretenders, that will ask for a pension from Scottish…May 19, 17:30
    • Mia on The Ace Attorney: “For as long as any politician who claims to pursue independence continues to hide like a disgusting coward behind the…May 19, 17:24
    • Ian McCubbin on The Ace Attorney: “I have heard bullshit, grifter talk and then there is Tommy Shepherd. The UK aka English government has no say…May 19, 17:21
    • Shug on The Ace Attorney: “Poke of chips for ShepherdMay 19, 17:20
  • A tall tale



↑ Top