The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



Your friends and neighbours 104

Posted on May 02, 2015 by

We know that politicians are allowed to lie in election literature, but we’re struggling to see how this isn’t fraud, which is something different altogether.

neighbours

Click the image to see both letters full-size.

Read the rest of this entry →

Business as usual 105

Posted on January 10, 2015 by

An unsurprising result.

legaldecent

Read the rest of this entry →

Under false pretences 441

Posted on December 27, 2014 by

We’re still supposed to be on a skeleton service for the festive period, but we couldn’t just let this one slide. The cashflow problems at the Labour Party must be more severe than previously thought, because the entire organisation seems to be sharing a single email account. We got yet another begging letter today, from the same address previously named as “Iain McNicol” and “Ed Miliband”, but today’s one was credited to shadow women’s minister Gloria De Piero.

gloria

Alert readers will recognise the appeal as one we’ve been watching for 11 days now. It’s an attempt by the UK party to raise some cash to employ 10 campaign assistants specifically for Scottish Labour. The jobs are still openly listed as such on the Labour website’s situations-vacant page. Yet the party seems oddly reluctant to say so.

Read the rest of this entry →

A serious allegation 140

Posted on September 20, 2013 by

We’ve been meaning to mention this curious extract from a “Please send us cash!” mailshot that “Better Together” sent out this week:

btcobblers

It’s the middle sentence that caught our eye. We’re reasonably sure that the Scottish Government isn’t allowed under either Electoral Commission or Scottish Parliament rules to “spend millions of pounds of public money on propaganda campaigns”.

And while we also know that there are very few rules about political organisations telling lies to voters, one of the few that DOES exist is a prohibition against falsehoods where “the specific statement in question is part of a direct solicitation for money”, which this quite clearly is.

We might just have to drop the ASA a wee line.

How politicians are licenced to lie 24

Posted on August 03, 2012 by

After we wrote this morning’s piece on party membership figures, we thought it might be interesting to look into what we’d initially intended as a throwaway last-line joke. Disturbingly, what we found out was that even in a society so tightly regulated that you can be fined thousands of pounds for using the word “summer” in the wrong place or threatened with imprisonment for making rude comments on Twitter, it’s apparently completely legal for our politicians to tell us outright lies.

We’re not talking about matters of opinion or interpretation or spin here. We mean that as far as we can establish, our politicians can openly lie to us about empirical, measurable facts, and there isn’t a thing we can do about it.

The thing that sparked our inquiry was Scottish Labour’s assertion on its Twitter page that it’s “Scotland’s largest political party”.

Now, as far as we can make out, that statement isn’t true in any meaningful sense whatsoever. In so far as it’s possible to establish, Scottish Labour has thousands fewer members than the SNP, collected 300,000 fewer votes in the last Scottish election, has fewer MSPs and fewer councillors than the SNP, and generates much less money. But that’s not really the point.

One reader suggested to us that the basis for the party’s claim is that it has more elected representatives than any other if you include Westminster MPs as well as Holyrood ones. While it’s stretching grammar to its breaking point to suggest that that constitutes being the “largest political party” in any sense that an average person would interpret the term, we can see how there’s just about a semantic defence.

But the point is that even if there wasn’t, there isn’t anything we could do about it.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,995 Posts, 1,254,122 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Only when the people of England, Wales and Ireland recognise there is no actual parliament of Scotland in the Westminster…” Nov 22, 12:18
    • sarah on Mind Your Business: “Rev, I hope that your network of supporters is gathering a body of donors to provide statements of authority for…” Nov 22, 12:13
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Police Scotland are actually police England under the Crown of Englands Westminster laws, legislation and Statues ” Scotland Act “…” Nov 22, 12:01
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “AI- Dan “Yes – if in doubt blame the “Anglo” Boo boo! Perfidious Albion wasn’t coined for nuffink. You really…” Nov 22, 11:58
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “The way out for all of the nations of these Isles is some genuine fact finding to the original hoax,…” Nov 22, 11:42
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “What happens when England, Wales and Ireland realise that there is No treaty of Union with Scotland other than a…” Nov 22, 11:23
    • James Barr Gardner on Mind Your Business: “Police Scotland refused to issue an incident number for the report of crime of reset, their answer it was covered…” Nov 22, 11:04
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “@Geri 9:08 Biolabs. You forgot the biolabs. Also the Nazis. And the baby eating. Take your time, Geri, as otherwise…” Nov 22, 08:57
    • Minceheid on Mind Your Business: “Hatey McHateface says: 21 November, 2026 at 4:47 pm It’s not something you can do all by yourself, MH. You’ll…” Nov 22, 08:22
    • twathater on Mind Your Business: “Andee has stated that 3/4 of uk citizens either want back into the EU or want to work closer with…” Nov 22, 03:09
    • twathater on Mind Your Business: “THAT is a great idea ,as one who has repeatedly proposed and promoted that DONORS get together and instigate a…” Nov 22, 02:43
    • Aidan on Mind Your Business: “Yes – if in doubt blame the “Anglo”” Nov 22, 01:40
    • Anthem on Mind Your Business: “Because their fat controller is a member of the cabinet.” Nov 22, 00:25
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “Confused is correct. The EU was colonised by the yanks & the wankers in Blighty, the kiss ass errand boy,…” Nov 21, 21:08
    • Hamish M on Mind Your Business: “Breaking news: SNP cancels £60,000 loan repayment owed to Peter Murrell https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c9p83kyryp7zo” Nov 21, 18:20
    • Captain Caveman on Mind Your Business: “To be fair, Spartan, I’m surprised you give Confused’s inane arse-drippings the time of day. Funny how the “english” [sic]…” Nov 21, 17:29
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “It’s not something you can do all by yourself, MH. You’ll need somebody to shovel your shite on a daily…” Nov 21, 16:47
    • Hatey McHateface on The Shots You Don’t Take: “You don’t really want to know the answer, Confused. Very probably far more than you.” Nov 21, 16:34
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Seriously? So you’re another antisemite blaming the Jews for everything? Or is what Confused’s angling at going over the top…” Nov 21, 16:31
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Always helps to hear the view from The Kremlin. Cheers, Geri.” Nov 21, 16:27
    • Spartan 117 on Mind Your Business: “For once, a sensible post from Confused that sums up the state of the European Disunion and the “thinking”, if…” Nov 21, 16:02
    • A2 on How To Change People’s Minds: “That Moawri link takes you off this page (which I was trying to read)on to your x link for the…” Nov 21, 14:57
    • Andy Wiltshire on Mind Your Business: “Was it anonymous again?” Nov 21, 14:46
    • James on Mind Your Business: “Excellent. Keep ’em coming. The squealers will appear ony meenit.” Nov 21, 13:32
    • Confused on The Shots You Don’t Take: “questions that need answered (a selection) “So, Nikki – how much fanny have you had?” SNP gov is full of…” Nov 21, 13:25
    • Confused on Mind Your Business: “the EU was a good idea to begin with – a west european trading bloc and a counterbalance to overweening…” Nov 21, 13:17
    • Minceheid on Mind Your Business: “Hatey McHateface says: 21 November, 2026 at 9:42 am I don’t understand it myself, but it seems there is no…” Nov 21, 11:49
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: ““They’re not gonna be wanting to hear any of your puerile shite.” You better STFU then. The EU won’t exist.…” Nov 21, 10:53
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “I don’t understand it myself, but it seems there is no doubt about it – the people are speaking -…” Nov 21, 09:42
    • Chas on Mind Your Business: “It would not surprise me to learn that the Scottish Government are channeling funds to an entity called ‘Scottish Nature…” Nov 21, 09:35
  • A tall tale



↑ Top