The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Terminological inexactitude

Posted on October 06, 2012 by

We’re confused again, readers. At its forthcoming conference the SNP will debate whether or not to change its policy on NATO membership, in full public view. After the debate, a vote of the party’s membership will determine what the policy will be. This wholly open and natural political process is of course variously described by the Scottish media as a “split”, a “U-turn”, an “internal battle” and a source of “rebel fury”.

Meanwhile, the Liberal Democrats refuse to allow the YesScotland campaign to take a stall at their conference, and when some members offer dissent, leader Willie Rennie angrily castigates them in a letter describing their actions as a “disrespectful stunt”, on the grounds that the media might have covered the stall’s presence.

(Great work keeping it out of the press, Willie. Just the three stories in a week, then.)

We feel we must have somehow misunderstood the meanings of the words “liberal” and “democratic”. Can anyone point us towards a more up-to-date dictionary?

10 to “Terminological inexactitude”

  1. DougtheDug says:

    Since the Lib-Dems are a hard line unionist party the fact that they don’t want a Yes Scotland stand at their Scottish regional conference is quite understandable.

    The odd bit is that many of their Scottish members, including these five in the Herald, don’t seem to recognise that they are in fact members of a hard line unionist party.

    The strangest thing I take from the incident is Willie Rennie’s statement, “It is the clear wish of members that we promote our vision of a federal UK.”, because I’ve looked and looked on the Lib-Dem website and I’ve not found a policy which refers to a federal UK yet.

    Reply
  2. Morag says:

    I wonder what would happen if Bitter Together applied for a stall at the SNP conference?  Talk about a cat in a dog suit!
     
    I suspect, let them come, then point and snigger.

    Reply
  3. tartanfever says:

    Good point Morag, there may well be a stall for them. Wonder if we can find out.

    Personally I’d like to set out a stall at the Lib Dem conference. It would be called the ‘Home rule stall’
    Looking rather battered and dilapidated, (picture an old wooden greenhouse with all the windows broken, peeling paint and weeds everywhere) it would be manned by a skeleton sitting in a rocking chair, cobwebs everywhere and every few minutes tumbleweed would roll across. Accompanying this scene would be the haunting soundtrack of bleak, windy landscape and the squeaking of a rusty hinge. 

    Reply
  4. James McLaren says:

    Tartanfever
     
     
    and a Rye Cooder track

    Reply
  5. Morag says:

    Oh, I don’t seriously think they’d show up.  But I’m not convinced the SNP would deny them entry if they did.

    Reply
  6. Davy says:

    “Tartanfever”
    That sounds more like the lib-dem conference it’s-self. 

    Reply
  7. tartanfever says:

    Sorry Morag, didn’t read your post properly, I was thinking that the Bitter Together campaign would have a stall at the Lib Dem conference, not the SNP conference.

    A ‘bitter together’ stall at the SNP conference would be great – I’d love for them to answer the   positive case for staying in the union ! What a hoot that would be.

    Reply
  8. Richie says:

    Hopefully they’ll try to get a stall at the tory and labour conferences too.

    Reply
  9. Steve Syme says:

    Us Labour for Indy folk are thinking about a stall/ stand at Labour conference.

    We’ll be as popular as a fart in a spacesuit. 

    Reply
  10. muttley79 says:

    @Steve Syme
     
    How is your campaign going?  What have you made of the events of the last month?  A lot seems to have happened since the march last month….

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,906 Posts, 1,241,801 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on The Broken Rainbow: “@ Geri says: 14 May, 2026 at 11:59 pm “Then we grow up” Aw, Geri, just two more minutes and…May 15, 07:44
    • Hatey McHateface on The Broken Rainbow: ““ATLS got little to no MSM exposure” Jeezo, that one again. It’s the 21st century, even in the parochial, overlooked…May 15, 07:37
    • Hatey McHateface on The Broken Rainbow: “There’s been a lot of water under the bridge since 2021, Fearghas. I used to be a fan too. His…May 15, 07:27
    • Hatey McHateface on The Broken Rainbow: ““32 entries so far on this page for that Hatey troll clown” Surely you mean FROM that Hatey troll clown?…May 15, 07:18
    • Sven on The Broken Rainbow: “Off Topic. I don’t want Anne killed with hammers, and I hope the milk monitors leave Y Lochinvar alone.May 15, 06:15
    • Willie on The Broken Rainbow: “No, some comments do not show. I’m not sure why. I recently posted some anodyne comments about whether reporting of…May 15, 05:46
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Broken Rainbow: “Without questioning the validity of above expressed anger, it may – for balance – be timely to proffer a glimpse…May 15, 01:41
    • Anne on The Broken Rainbow: “Thanks For The tip Geri!May 15, 01:14
    • Anne on The Broken Rainbow: “?May 15, 01:12
    • Geri on The Broken Rainbow: “Anne, Just a heads up. There is a delay on posts appearing on this site. You have to give it…May 15, 00:40
    • Del G on The Broken Rainbow: “Please could you analyse recent Westminster elections in the same fashion? % votes per party, no of seats, the no…May 15, 00:40
    • Geri on The Broken Rainbow: “Wow Anne, I didn’t know that.May 15, 00:30
    • Anne on The Broken Rainbow: “There was plenty of leafletting and campaigning however Craig did not communicate with anyone or offer to help in any…May 15, 00:16
    • Anne on The Broken Rainbow: “There was plenty of leafletting and campaigning however Craig did not communicate with anyone or offer to help in any…May 15, 00:15
    • Young Lochinvar on The Broken Rainbow: “Beggars Aye very good bumpkin. “Hatey” is stalking everyone on this site Adolf! Just not everyone appreciates it as you…May 15, 00:14
    • Anne on The Broken Rainbow: “Murray accusing other candidates of anti trans views when he did not know any of them is extremely offensive and…May 15, 00:07
    • Anne on The Broken Rainbow: “Addendum Murray accusing other candidates of anti trans views when he did not know any of them is extremely offensive…May 15, 00:06
    • Geri on The Broken Rainbow: “I remember when I was sweet sixteen. I’d have voted for someone from MTV if they were standing for election.…May 14, 23:59
    • Anne on The Broken Rainbow: “There was plenty of leafletting and campaigning however Craig did not communicate with anyone or offer to help in any…May 14, 23:58
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Broken Rainbow: “———— SNP Emma Roddick 11,162 (30.4%) ———— Liberal Democrat Neil Alexander 10,735 (29.2%) ———— Independent FERGUS EWING 7,840 (21.3%) ————…May 14, 23:57
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Broken Rainbow: “Craig Murray’s low vote was undoubtedly at least partly due to his being hospitalised with serious heart complications: « Now,…May 14, 23:35
    • Mark Beggan on The Broken Rainbow: “You are stalking Hatey. Isn’t this fun.May 14, 23:29
    • George Ferguson on The Broken Rainbow: “@Dan 11:01pm If Alba had stood then their polling of between 1 and 2 % would have held up. Far…May 14, 23:22
    • Dan on The Broken Rainbow: “https://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2026/05/dr-manivannan/ “The party I stood for, Alliance to Liberate Scotland, while having no formal position on the issue, featured mostly…May 14, 23:01
    • Onlooker on The Broken Rainbow: “You’re wrong, get over it. And if I am wrong, I would freely admit it. You’re the one who probably…May 14, 23:00
    • Geri on The Broken Rainbow: “& Palantir?May 14, 22:55
    • Geri on The Broken Rainbow: ““I’ll be cheering them on.” There’s a surprise, grand dad. From the safety of yer bedsit, no doubt. I’m glad…May 14, 22:49
    • George Ferguson on The Broken Rainbow: “@Onlooker So the UK Government partner for Digital ID has not officially been announced. Euan Blairs apprentice Company is not…May 14, 22:49
    • Onlooker on The Broken Rainbow: “Nope. https://fullfact.org/technology/digital-id-euan-blair/May 14, 22:18
    • Onlooker on The Broken Rainbow: “32 entries so far on this page for that Hatey troll clown. Carry on, spammy nutbag!May 14, 22:13
  • A tall tale



↑ Top