The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Quoted for truth #42

Posted on January 13, 2014 by

“Herald View”, the Sunday Herald, 12 Jan 2014:

“The Deputy First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, is to be commended for refusing to participate in the victimisation of the ‘undeserving poor’. She promises to scrap the bedroom tax, keep housing benefits and reject the forthcoming Universal Credit, which amalgamates a whole range of benefits into one payment. The Nationalists say they will increase social security benefits and the minimum wage annually by the rate of inflation.

However, they cannot secure these protections under the current constitutional arrangements.”

“We share the Deputy First Minister’s belief that Scottish voters want no part of this war on benefits.

Welfare is likely to become a central issue in the referendum campaign, if only because it highlights the difference in political culture between Scotland and the south-east of England. The SNP say that only with independence can Scotland be protected from Tory policies.

Can Better Together persuade Scots that if we stick with the UK we will not be subject to the benefit reforms that are being driven through Westminster, and that there can still be what the former Labour Prime Minister, Gordon Brown, yesterday called ‘a union for social justice’ in Britain?

Of course, Gordon Brown has no power to deliver the new powers he believes Scotland should have.

Nor are his proposals sufficient to ensure social justice in Scotland. The Unionists must come up with something more substantial if they want to prevent many Scots who aren’t nationalists voting yes to independence to ensure that Tory policies stop at the Border.”

Does Labour being even tougher on welfare than the Tories count, we wonder?

49 to “Quoted for truth #42”

  1. Alex Grant says:

    All we need now is an editorial on the economics situation incl today’s announcement re debt and a serious view on market reaction if WM dared to reject Scotland’s CONTINUED participation in a currency Union

    Reply
  2. Brian Powell says:

    “The Unionists mus come up with something more substantial”, but they can’t.
     
    Whatever they come up with it would need to survive the Two Party system in Westminster, and the House of Lords, and future Westminster Governments.
     
    No matter how ‘enshrined’ the existence fo Holyrood becomes, without full control of resources it will be forever at the mercy of Westminster policies, and the need to pay for them, no matter if the requirement for the policies does not originate in Scotland.
     
    I hope this eventually penetrates and voters really, really begin to understand this.

    Reply
  3. gordoz says:

    Well if thats the Sunday Herald view they are to be commended.

    Reply
  4. Gray says:

    Interesting to note that the article is by an un-named journo .. is this the view of Ian Stewart, the editor?

    Reply
  5. dinnatouch says:

    That should be the final nail in Better Together’s coffin if the rest of the Scottish press didn’t act as the propaganda division of UK PLC.

    Reply
  6. Taranaich says:

    Of course, Gordon Brown has no power to deliver the new powers he believes Scotland should have.
     
    I know, right? If only we could’ve seen him as Prime Minister, even for only three years or so, then we could’ve seen what he would’ve done in power to grant Scotland the powers he says they should have.
     
    *Paddington stare*

    Reply
  7. heraldnomore says:

    Ian Stewart’s at The Hootsmon, and these are not words I’d expect him tto allow into print.

    Reply
  8. Bugger (the Panda) says:

    O/T
     
    If it is not Duck Houses and flat screen TVs, it is portaits of one and other.
    The Court of Louis XIV had nothing on this lot.
    link to telegraph.co.uk
     
     

    Reply
  9. PRJ says:

    The term “unionist” is usually linked to the Tory party. Should we not be replacing this term with “Labour party and partners.”
    The continuing use of “unionist” disconnects the voter from the labour party.  

    Reply
  10. Tony Little says:

    @gordoz
     
    There are only two comments on the article.  Usually hundreds from anti-independence supports on other article which are less fact-based.  It really says something about the position of many Herald readers.  
     
    I am still of the belief that nearer the time the Herald will come out as YES.  (However, I am not prepared to bet my house on it!)

    Reply
  11. SquareHaggis says:

    @BtP
     
    Oh my Gawd, what an obscene waste of taxpayers hard earned cash.
     
    Can’t understand what Blair is doing among that lot, he’s not even an MP!

    Reply
  12. Bugger (the Panda) says:

    Tony Little
    As i viewed it, there are no comments on the article, although two on the casptured version.

    Reply
  13. SquareHaggis says:

    Oh, wait a minute though, he’s a “Peace Envoy” to the Middle East – hahaha, so funny it’s sad 🙁

    Reply
  14. Smith says:

    Congratulations … I see you’ve now popped up on Newsnow.
     
    link to newsnow.co.uk

    Reply
  15. Ian Brotherhood says:

    Here’s a portrait of Alistair Carmichael, painted just ten minutes after Nicola had finished with him:
     
    link to galeri3.uludagsozluk.com

    Reply
  16. gordoz says:

    @Taranaich
    Dont take offence but that was as sarcastic and cutting as a ‘Noel Gallagher’ retort. Clinical man – seriously made me laugh
     
    @Tony Little
    ‘Who are you going to believe me or your own eyes ?’ (Boom, Boom)
    We live in hope –

    Reply
  17. ronnie anderson says:

    SquuareHaggis, Tony Blair is the EU peace Embassidor to the Middle east, if you had notice on that TV piece his left lapel , torn garment pinned , you,s are no tearing ma Armanni suit  fur nae cunt, its a Jewish custom to tear clothing at a death.

    Reply
  18. alexicon says:

    Today while visiting my local, I had someone say to me that he is voting YES because of the Tories attack on welfare.
    Before he was a fifty/fifty yes or no, but I assume that he’s had a shock in the post regarding his benefits.
    Another YES in the bag.

    Reply
  19. SquareHaggis says:

    Uk debt and the Scottish Independence referendum – from the Uk Treasury
     
    link to gov.uk

    Reply
  20. ronnie anderson says:

    ah forgot on my last post re T Blair he negotiated away £350mil to the EU , UK taxpayer,s money to help Spain, they built road,s with the money, ambassidor,s job secured.

    Reply
  21. Horacesaysyes says:

    Now what we need are similar sentiments to be expressed in a paper with a slightly higher circulation, but it’s a start.

    Reply
  22. Macart says:

    Here we go.
     
    link to theguardian.com
     
    That’ll leave a mark. 🙂

    Reply
  23. SquareHaggis says:

    Alex Salmond on Good Morning Scotland 02:37
     
    link to bbc.co.uk

    Reply
  24. Gin says:

    For the fist time in many years I bought a sunday paper YESterday –  the sundayherald .  Happy to give business and support to the one Scottish paper that seems to making an effort at balance.
     
    Also hoping that the Putin #indyrefski Front Cover will be a great historical artefact and rise in value from £1.30 in years to come 🙂

    Reply
  25. FraserP says:

    Exactly, Horace. The circulation of the Scottish Daily Mail is more than twice the Herald’s. The Record and Scottish Sun have more than ten times as many readers. More people read the Dundee Courier than read the Herald. Quality is all very well, but when it comes to voting only quantity counts.

    Reply
  26. Macart says:

    O/T
     
    For sheer short sighted idiocy this one by Chris Deerin takes the biscuit.
     
    link to theguardian.com
     
    Two tablets and a lie down in the darkened room required.

    Reply
  27. Alex Grant says:

    Deerin’s article is amazing. More amazing that the Guardian reprints shite originally published in the Daily Mail! Shows you how much they ‘get it’!

    Reply
  28. Kalmar says:

    “Flat screen TV” klaxon, Bugger the panda 🙂

    Reply
  29. Macart says:

    @Alex Grant
     
    BTL is entertaining. Even some of the unionist support are somewhat agog.
     
    No bloody wonder. The Grauniad and a blatantly right wing article?

    Reply
  30. Jingly Jangly says:

    RE Icm poll Gruard, SNP at 4% as we only have 8.3% of UK Population does that mean that the SNP have nearly 50% in Scotland?

    Reply
  31. setondene says:

    The Herald hasn’t ceased being a unionist paper.  This is part of a managed retreat.  Sort of – ‘OK then, we might concede you some powers on welfare but we know you’re not really interested in defence or oil revenues’.

    Reply
  32. MochaChoca says:

    OT – Gordon McIntyre-Kemp on STV Scotland Tonight this evening in response to the latest developments…. Should be good! 

    Reply
  33. ronnie anderson says:

    Macart, ma heart,s bledin on the piece , the world,s fawin apart,FFs a load of valium, fur that pish lol.

    Reply
  34. Tamson says:

    @Macart:
     
    that’s not the only very interesting piece in the Guardian just now. How’s about this CiF piece?
     
    link to theguardian.com

    Reply
  35. ronald alexander mcdonald says:

    Brown came up with next to bugger all when he was Prime Minister never mind now.

    Reply
  36. HandandShrimp says:

    The Chris Deerin piece in the Guardian is a shocker. It is a lift from a Daily Hell piece. I feel dirty having just read it. I may have been slightly intemperate.

    Reply
  37. Macart says:

    @ronnie
     
    Know whit ye mean fella. Know whit ye mean.

    Reply
  38. Macart says:

    @Tamson
     
    Oh jeez after the weekend the opposition have just had, that’s the capper. 😀

    Reply
  39. Macart says:

    @HandandShrimp
     
    I thought you were perfectly well behaved. 🙂

    Reply
  40. HandandShrimp says:

    Macart
     
    I confess to be mildly shocked at being told in the Groaniard that staying British is a “moral” imperative. I’m not entirely pleased if truth be told.

    Reply
  41. Horacesaysyes says:

    o/t – My wife is currently filling in a YouGov survey which is asking about the referendum and in particular media outlets and how much you trust them to cover Scottish issues including the referendum. It’ll be interesting to watch out for the results.

    Reply
  42. Macart says:

    @HandandShrimp
     
    Definitely a click baiting exercise, but I never thought to see a beaut like that in the Groan. Darling was right y’know. it did get worse. 😉

    Reply
  43. HandandShrimp says:

    Macart
     
    True but I didn’t think he meant the next day. The gloves are off.

    Reply
  44. joe kane says:

    Robin McAlpine explains how the Labour method of attacking and destroying the welfare state differs from their Better Together Tory mates’ preferred method –

    The campaign against the welfare state is now in full-flow in Scotland: Your guide to unmasking and destroying it ~ Jimmy Reid Foundation 
    link to blacktrianglecampaign.org

    Reply
  45. Morag says:

    I am still of the belief that nearer the time the Herald will come out as YES.  (However, I am not prepared to bet my house on it!)
     
    If they do, I will joyfully renew my regular order.  As well as paying Stu.

    Reply
  46. Patrician says:

    Rachel Reeves, the true face of the Labour party.  When anyone tells you that labour are the party of the working class, the downtrodden, the poor, just point them at Ms Reeves and what she says out loud.  I hadn’t realised until I read the attached article she is marked as future leadership material, and that is so scary.  She appears to be to the right of Tony Blair and she doesn’t even feel the need to hide it.

    Reply
  47. Morag says:

    More people read the Dundee Courier than read the Herald. Quality is all very well, but when it comes to voting only quantity counts.
     
    I don’t care.  It will bring joy to me personally to have my Herald back, and that ain’t gonna happen without a big, brash, indy-colours-to-the-mast coming-out.

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “I don’t care. It will bring joy to me personally to have my Herald back”

      Newspapers are good things. I enjoy reading them, in most ways more than I like using websites for news. I wish there was one I felt I could bear to give money to in good conscience at the moment (other than the Sunday Herald, which I buy most weeks).

      Reply
  48. Beastie says:

    Ah, that’s a refreshing piece of writing to find in a newspaper. But it’s the Sunday Herald, so it’s not a total surprise.

    You can argue that the Sunday Herald doesn’t have a big readership, but when was the last time a Dundee Courier front page got shared thousands of times on Facebook and Twitter? How many times has a previous day’s release of an image boosted their hardcopy sales?

    I’m betting never.

    The days have long gone when the copy you get from the newsagent is the only way you’d see the paper. The Sunday Herald is doubtless well aware of this and the release of that particular front page was not just for breaking a big story that no other paper seemed to have decided to pay any attention to (because seriously, they couldn’t have missed it) it was also a very cheap, very effective advertising campaign. I wonder how many extra sales they got because of it?

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,787 Posts, 1,221,993 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • 100%Yes on According As We Need Them: “For those interested in Scotland, the message about the union is making its mark. https://menafn.com/1109571674/Scotlands-Constitutional-Status-Revealed-As-Legal-Fiction-Experts-Confirm-Basis-For-UN-DecolonisationJul 15, 08:06
    • DaveL on According As We Need Them: “‘…on the route to liberation, I reckon mime and interpretative dance are the only way to go.’ Can you explain…Jul 15, 02:20
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “Poetry is all very well if you’re into that sort of thing. But when it comes to illustrating the oppressed…Jul 15, 00:17
    • Confused on According As We Need Them: “guy charged was an “aussie”, in a kilt; maybe done an ancestry.com and got told he was “connor macleod of…Jul 14, 23:32
    • Confused on According As We Need Them: “I was never an inmate unlike yourself. Did we meet? – if they had held onto the asylums we could…Jul 14, 23:20
    • Confused on According As We Need Them: “there was a young poster on wings cheap snarky disruption his thing agent x was his name the union his…Jul 14, 23:18
    • Alf Baird on According As We Need Them: “Development of poetry in the native tongue forms a key part of the liberation process and in understanding the colonial…Jul 14, 23:01
    • agent x on According As We Need Them: “@ James What in particular did you find Excellent?Jul 14, 22:00
    • James on According As We Need Them: “Excellent, Northcode. Keep ’em coming.Jul 14, 21:50
    • James on According As We Need Them: “Funny how the unionist rag describes the removal of the stone from a thief as ‘notorious’….Jul 14, 21:48
    • Gribble on According As We Need Them: “On the subject of intimidation on the stump, the impression as often given that this is a worsening problem. But…Jul 14, 21:39
    • Northcode on According As We Need Them: “Excellent article about a young Martinican psychiatrist’s time studying with the great Francesc Tosquelles at the Saint-Alban psychiatric asylum. Thanks…Jul 14, 21:30
    • Breastplate on According As We Need Them: “John Main, You Unionists seem to routinely register your disapproval on the reliance of 300 year old documentation, but accept…Jul 14, 20:43
    • agent x on According As We Need Them: “@ Northcode I notice there has been minimal, or maybe make that no support or encouragement for your poems on…Jul 14, 20:15
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Just Good Friends: “In case you are unaware (and for comparison): WAR O THE WARLDS By H. G. Wells – Owerset intae NOR-EAST…Jul 14, 20:11
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “Enjoying your use of iambic quadrameter, NC. And your random departures from it too. If you’re taking requests, highlights from…Jul 14, 19:49
    • Northcode on According As We Need Them: “I posted one of ma braw poems recently about the demon Nuckelavee being cawd up fae the depths o’ the…Jul 14, 19:38
    • Hatey McHateface on Just Good Friends: ““trying as usual to undermine anything about Scotland” You should read Rev Stu’s articles and not just jump straight to…Jul 14, 18:06
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “In this heat you need to be eating salads.Jul 14, 17:55
    • twathater on Just Good Friends: “Wow the yoonies are out in force trying as usual to undermine anything about Scotland ,they’re like wee yapping dugs…Jul 14, 17:35
    • Dan on According As We Need Them: “In a bid to disrupt mental Main’s posting stream… Related to this article, there’s a fair few quid being spaffed…Jul 14, 17:14
    • Mark Beggan on According As We Need Them: “The Gravy boat is just a woke away. Just a woke away Just a woke away Just a woke away.Jul 14, 16:55
    • Mark Beggan on According As We Need Them: “I’m getting out of here. They’re all mad!Jul 14, 16:54
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: ““can a thief be robbed?” Now I’m confused, Confused. You have stated on here many times that when it comes…Jul 14, 16:48
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: ““nothing of the colonizer’s is appropriate for the colonized” Stand out post from Professor Baird. Anybody with him on calling…Jul 14, 16:20
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “Nice try, NC, but easily discounted, as you have failed to provide any evidence for your assertion that Scotland’s high…Jul 14, 16:01
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: ““Scotland as a Lunatic Asylum” When Confused writes on a subject so aligned with his own, lived experience, it behoves…Jul 14, 15:51
    • Hatey McHateface on Just Good Friends: “Another post from Confused enthusing over the idea of a bankrupt and socially fractured England just south of our unprotected…Jul 14, 15:47
    • Confused on According As We Need Them: “mythology – when Edward 1 stole the stone of destiny it was to make himself legitimate, for a “true king”…Jul 14, 15:21
    • James Cheyne on According As We Need Them: “Northcode. The trouble with ignorance is that it can, if left unfettered become an indoctrination of the mind. Even if…Jul 14, 15:01
  • A tall tale



↑ Top