The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Missing the point of a referendum

Posted on November 15, 2011 by

Scottish Labour embarrassed themselves horribly today when they jumped on comments from SNP MSP Stewart Maxwell in which he noted that the Scottish Government was only legally empowered to hold an advisory referendum on independence rather than a binding one. Not withstanding the fact that ALL referenda in the UK are only advisory, whether conducted by Holyrood or Westminster or anyone else, Labour’s humiliating blunder was in triumphantly asserting there was something new about this position, when in fact the very first sentence of the SNP’s National Conversation website – dating back over two years – says the exact same thing:

“The First Minister has outlined plans for a public consultation on a draft Referendum Bill which sets out proposals for an advisory referendum on extending the powers of the Scottish Parliament.”

But there’s another aspect to the nature of referenda that everyone seems to be inexplicably overlooking of late. The Unionist parties have recently ramped up a campaign in which they demand the SNP “clarify” every last item of policy in an independent Scotland, from currency and EU membership to renewable energy transmission costs, pension provision, and all the way down to what colour the First Minister’s going to paint Bute House’s front door. What nobody seems to have grasped is the fairly crucial point that that’s not what a referendum is for.

Referenda are not for deciding multiple policies. Nobody campaigned in the AV referendum on a platform of cutting the 50p tax rate or investing in public transport, they campaigned on whether they wanted AV or not. An independence referendum resolves one issue and one issue alone: who elects the next government.

In Scotland’s case, the referendum will determine whether from that point on it’s the people of Scotland who get to choose Scotland’s government, or (as at present) the people of England, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales. The policies of that government – and every one that follows it – will be decided by regular elections.

The Conservative Party, for example, is against UK membership of the Euro. If Scotland votes for independence in the referendum, Scotland will not then move to join the Euro, because the referendum is not about Euro membership. What will happen is that we’ll have a general election in May 2016, parties will stand in that election on a comprehensive policy platform which will include how they feel about joining the Euro, and the people of Scotland will vote for them.

The government and Parliament that comes into being as a result of the election is what gets to decide whether we join the Euro or not – and indeed, everything else down to the FM’s door hue.

If Scotland became independent the Scottish Conservatives could, if they wanted, campaign for election on a platform that they’d immediately apply to rejoin the Union. If they won a majority, they would be perfectly entitled to pursue that policy. It would of course be highly controversial, because the opposition would claim that people had voted for them on the balance of a whole raft of reasons, and might not necessarily approve of that specific one. The Tories might retort that those were cancelled out by some voters having voted for other parties even though they supported reunification, because on balance they preferred the manifesto of those parties.

It’s a tricky dilemma, because you can’t reasonably infer someone’s position on an individual policy when what they’ve actually done is choose their overall favourite out of several 50-policy packages. Which is precisely why we occasionally have specific, single-issue referenda that determine one thing and one thing alone, and why we keep them separate from elections. Am I the only one who gets that?

3 to “Missing the point of a referendum”

  1. Allen Aitken says:

    well worded,

    Reply
  2. I pleased Labour won control of Glasgow city council.
    Labour Must win back seats Like Glasgow Kelvin
    and also Glasgow Anniesland. I am strong Labour
    voter.

    Reply
  3. Appleby says:

    That’s nice dear. Do you have a point to make or are you just pleased you and yours are not in the dole queue and have to get a proper job?

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,791 Posts, 1,222,770 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Peter McAvoy on Safety First: “When Trump meets Von Der Leyen,I hope he calls her irrelevant and an a power grabbing dictator and tells her…Jul 26, 13:29
    • Confused on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “the union, some helpful analogies : – a badly stitched up pantomime horse, with Scotland in the back, getting farted…Jul 26, 13:29
    • Northcode on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “I like how Billy Kay ends his book, The Mither Tongue. Scots is as essential to Scotland as her folk,…Jul 26, 13:22
    • Confused on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “Trump: Horrible migrant invasion is killing Scotland US president told Scotland ‘get your act together’ on arrival for four-day visit…Jul 26, 13:19
    • Confused on Safety First: “Trump says ANGLO IMMIGRATION IS KILLING SCOTLANDJul 26, 13:12
    • Confused on Safety First: “Scottish independence is there for the taking, lads : the cost will be – – Turnberry is back on the…Jul 26, 13:09
    • Confused on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “England has been booted out of 65 countries worldwide. – no one has ever asked them back. Some of these…Jul 26, 13:05
    • James on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: ““Re-join the UK”…Oh, ma sides. Stop it! All around the world they’re queuing up to re-join right enough! ROTFLMFAO.Jul 26, 13:02
    • David Wardrope on Safety First: “It’s beyond laughable now really. Did I read the other day that Dr Upton was offended that Nurse Peggie was…Jul 26, 13:02
    • James on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “Day off, annual leave was it?Jul 26, 12:56
    • willie on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “Interesting points Northcode but when do you recognises Gaidhlig to have come to Scotland. Gaidhlig or the Goidelic version of…Jul 26, 12:44
    • Mark Beggan on Safety First: “Foghorn Leghorn has left the building. Bye bye ( again) Mhairi.Jul 26, 12:44
    • Stuart on Safety First: “It’s funny how people who tell us to accept “climate science”, refuse to accept biological science, which is far more…Jul 26, 12:41
    • Andy Wiltshire on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “If Scotland became independent and ran its own affairs, could it then decide to re-join the UK? Would that decision…Jul 26, 12:41
    • Northcode on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: ““A pertinent hypothesis here may therefore be that the Brittonic Pictish language, coupled with other influences (travel, migration, trade etc)…Jul 26, 12:35
    • willie on Safety First: “Of course there is a huge police presence around the Donald Trum visit. He is of course the president of…Jul 26, 12:24
    • Aidan on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “@Xaracen – I have repeatedly explained and provided evidence to support the fact that the petition has been thrown out.…Jul 26, 11:54
    • Mark Beggan on Safety First: “It’s very kind of the President to spend a little time with Sticky the Stick Insect. No one else gives…Jul 26, 11:47
    • Alf Baird on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “Fearghas, in ‘The Mither Tongue’ Billy Kay informs us of the origins and natural development of what we term as…Jul 26, 11:31
    • agent x on Safety First: “Yes but once Swinney has a chat with Trump all of the World’s problems will be solved immediately.Jul 26, 11:17
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “‘DECLARATION OF ARBROATH: John Duns Scotus and the Idea of Independence’ by Professor Alexander Broadie FRSE Professor Alexander Broadie is…Jul 26, 11:17
    • Chris Downie on Safety First: “Look on the bright side, it’ll be amusing to see Swinney about turn and kiss Trump’s orange arse during his…Jul 26, 11:11
    • Stuart MacKay on Safety First: “Why are police forces, and the prison service, so easily manipulated for political purposes? Is it simply that politicians have…Jul 26, 10:52
    • Xaracen on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “You first, Aidan! You made the original claim that Scotland’s Petition had been; ‘sent packing’, ‘rebuffed’, ‘all over’, ‘an automatic…Jul 26, 10:28
    • Marie on Safety First: “The UK has turned into a police state – not just Scotland. Sturgeon is despicable – I agree.Jul 26, 10:20
    • Astonished on Safety First: “Brilliant, because it’s true. Thanks to Sturgeon and anyone who is still a member of the SNP.Jul 26, 09:36
    • Mark Beggan on Safety First: “Police Scotland learning how to walk on the streets. The vans there just in case someone gets dizzy.Jul 26, 09:22
    • Northcode on Everybody’s Normal Nowadays: “The Venerable Bede tells me that my people, the Picts, were not true natives of Britain but came originally from…Jul 26, 08:59
    • sarah on Safety First: “Hooray! Welcome back, Chris. Will the public finally get the message as to who is responsible for spreading this faux…Jul 26, 07:58
    • Effijy on Safety First: “Well Done Chris! The police have become something of a farce in recent years. Homes with professionally monitored intruder alarm…Jul 26, 07:36
  • A tall tale



↑ Top