The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


The referee’s a Mason

Posted on November 16, 2011 by

Professor John Curtice, a psephologist at Strathclyde University and the Scottish media's go-to guy for all political analysis, is often attacked by "cybernats" for alleged partiality in favour of Labour. This blog sighs in despair whenever online nationalists automatically scream "Biased!" at anyone who doesn't come onscreen in a kilt and Jimmy hat singing "Flower Of Scotland", but it has to be said that Prof. Curtice has done himself no favours at all this week.

As co-author of a report published yesterday by the Electoral Reform Society Scotland, the good professor has launched what the Scotsman today calls a "strongly worded attack" on Holyrood's proportional electoral system, under which the SNP won a majority of seats (53%) on 45% of the vote. As we noted yesterday, it's odd that the ERSS has chosen now to demand changes to the system, given that when Labour/Lib Dem coalitions had Holyrood majorities in 1999 and 2003, they also commanded less than 50% of the vote (45.5% between them in 2003, 49.5% in 1999), and nobody seemed to have a problem with that.

Now, to be fair to Prof. Curtice, the Scotsman does put words in his mouth, in their characteristic manner. The headline of the piece claims that the report brands the Holyrood system "a failure" (a description which we can't find anywhere in it) and also asserts that the report demands the system "should be changed to prevent one party winning an overall majority", which is something of an exaggeration – Curtice only actually says that the objective of the proposed changes is to make a majority "more difficult", not impossible.

But by fronting such a suspiciously-timed report, the Professor and the ERSS have allowed their credibility to be undermined by exactly the sort of distortion the Unionist media specialises in, and in doing so have left themselves dreadfully open to allegations of political colour. The society claims their motivation is honourable, and aimed only at promoting a fuller range of political views:

"We are convinced our democracy would work better with more parties in the system, so that more voices are represented and heard and that power is shared, checked and balanced."

…but the current method of electing the Scottish Parliament is perfectly capable of delivering that – in 2003, for example, the Greens got 7 seats, the Scottish Socialists won 6 seats and two independents also secured seats, those three groups between them providing almost 12% of the Parliament's MSPs. (For comparison, imagine the UK Parliament having 78 MPs from outwith the three main parties – the actual number is 28, with only one of those representing an English constituency.)

The simple fact is, the electorate could have elected a wider range of MSPs if they'd wanted to, as they have done in the past. Instead, they overwhelmingly chose the SNP. That's democracy, because in practice almost no democracy on Earth is perfectly proportional. This blog has no objections to bringing the Scottish Parliament closer to that ideal, but it's decidedly odd that supposedly neutral organisations like the ERSS didn't feel the need to suddenly press for it until the SNP won a majority.

We're absolutely confident, however, that the author of the above quote – the society's director Willie Sullivan – also being a Labour councillor in his day job (a fact the Scotsman inexplicably neglects to mention) is entirely coincidental.

 

PS The replacement PR method proposed by the ERSS report is one devised by the French mathematician André Sainte-Laguë. His most famous work is the calculation that it was scientifically impossible for bumblebees to be able to fly.

1 to “The referee’s a Mason”

  1. An Duine Gruamach says:

    Cannae whack that for neutrality, eh?  I guess this is what Gerry Hassan means when he talks about the Labour State.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,993 Posts, 1,253,708 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • shiregirl on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Not been on for a a few years so good to be back. Been reading, though. And lurking. Kez. Blessed…” Nov 11, 18:50
    • Aidan on Stand By Your Posts: “It is a state however, and only states can be the administering power of colonial territories for obvious reasons.” Nov 11, 18:46
    • Aunty Flo on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Well said, Professor. So, we can no longer realistically characterise our political ‘system’ either as democracy, or indeed as a…” Nov 11, 18:38
    • James on Stand By Your Posts: “The “UK” isn’t a country.” Nov 11, 18:31
    • Dan on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Almost every public office is filled by a proven failure, because failures are all we make any more.” Interesting use…” Nov 11, 18:12
    • Alf Baird on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Politicians are only a minor part of the establishment elites running a country. The Elitist Scotland report a few years…” Nov 11, 17:51
    • sarah on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Emma Roddick was selected on the basis of qualifying as disabled. The members gave her 2% of the vote but…” Nov 11, 17:31
    • Aidan on Stand By Your Posts: “The United Kingdom of course. But obviously London is not a colony, just as Scotland is also not a colony.…” Nov 11, 17:30
    • Forbes Johnstone on How To Succeed In Scotland: “It would be well received if any of these over paid abject failures who have mastered incompetence could respond and…” Nov 11, 17:13
    • gordon on How To Succeed In Scotland: “It’s more insidious than that, since 2015 selection has been determined by whether the candidates would just be happy with…” Nov 11, 16:48
    • James on Stand By Your Posts: “What country is London a colony of, Adrian? Tell us, tell us.” Nov 11, 16:34
    • panda paws on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Almost every public office is filled by a proven failure, because failures are all we make any more.” Plenty of…” Nov 11, 16:31
    • Lynn Fraser on How To Succeed In Scotland: “The company who sponsor the Ponsanby & Maisie podcast are advertising to recruit the new Chief Exec for the Scottish…” Nov 11, 15:39
    • duncanio on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Scotland: Failure Factory” Nov 11, 15:11
    • Holymacmoses on How To Succeed In Scotland: “The only way is down when you’re on the up” Nov 11, 15:10
    • I. Despair on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Leitch by name, leech by nature.” Nov 11, 15:05
    • Spartan 117 on How To Succeed In Scotland: “To say I’m triggered is an understatement. On a day when I was messaged to say I had to pick…” Nov 11, 15:04
    • Aidan on Stand By Your Posts: “Actually – a walled Roman settlement existed in London until around 450AD until it was likely sacked by the Anglo…” Nov 11, 14:49
    • Aidan on Stand By Your Posts: “Care to provide some analysis or evidence to back that up James, or is it just: “Dey gambling with all…” Nov 11, 14:44
    • 100%Yes on How To Succeed In Scotland: “There is hope if we all band together at the next Westminster election and vote not for the SNP but…” Nov 11, 14:40
    • James on Stand By Your Posts: “London and the south-east of England are the most heavily subsidised parts of the “UK” as you well know, Charlatan…” Nov 11, 14:07
    • Alison on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Scotland: where failing upwards is an art form.” Nov 11, 14:05
    • Xaracen on Stand By Your Posts: “London was never a sovereign nation, and that puts it well outside the colony envelope. It does not put it…” Nov 11, 13:26
    • Aidan on Stand By Your Posts: “Lol James – you can have a look at the funding and financing arrangements for those projects, London pays. I…” Nov 11, 13:22
    • Hatey McHateface on Vibecoding A Better World: “Always thought provoking to read an Indy Intellectual like James justifying the imperialist annexation of a former colony that had…” Nov 11, 12:11
    • Hatey McHateface on Stand By Your Posts: “Who’s teasing? I haven’t been more than an hour off the cludgie in the past week. Would cost me a…” Nov 11, 11:56
    • Aidan on Stand By Your Posts: “Once upon a time there was a huge centre of tech and finance, it produced unrivalled wealth which should have…” Nov 11, 11:55
    • Hatey McHateface on Stand By Your Posts: “Sun barely above the horizon and Confused is off, repeating his points to create a coherent world view in much…” Nov 11, 11:51
    • James on Stand By Your Posts: ““there’s new electric trains everywhere” central belt you mean? “new motorways (M8, M74)” central belt. “new railways opening (Alloa, Tweedbank)”…” Nov 11, 11:48
    • James on Stand By Your Posts: ““Colonised Londoners are forced to pay for all of those projects themselves.” Adrian, stop it! Oh, ma sides! One day…” Nov 11, 11:42
  • A tall tale



↑ Top