The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Claimed in full

Posted on January 20, 2014 by

Much gratitude tonight to alert reader “Albamac”, who’s not only compiled the whole of “The Claim Of Scotland” into a single very small (1MB), easy-download PDF file but has converted it in the process into one with cut-and-pasteable text for quotability. We’ve uploaded it to the Repository, and you can also download it from this direct link.

claimed

Big love once again too to Wilma Watts who made our serialisation possible in the first place, and to the sadly-deceased Herbert James Paton for writing a book that for the most part could have been released yesterday. We highly recommend it as a starting point for any undecideds you know who might not want to jump straight into the debate with something as openly partisan as this site. Having read it, we suspect they’ll be hungry for more truth, and then you can send them our way.

54 to “Claimed in full”

  1. Dave McEwan Hill says:

    We must get this back into print and readily available. I’d contribute (not an awful lot out of my wee pension)and I’m sure many others would too.

    Reply
  2. Luigi says:

    Could you include the Foreword please?

    Reply
  3. Murray McCallum says:

    Thank you Wilma. What a find.

    Downloaded the full version in a few seconds (replacing my valve sets has improved my computing machine’s performance).

    Reply
  4. Andrew Parrott says:

    Scotland Resurgent by Andrew Dewar Gibb published by Eneas Mackay in Stirling in 1950 is also very interesting. The last sentence of the introduction reads “It is from now on with the case for and against the resumption of nationhood by Scotland that this book is concerned” I think it is a reflection of the middle of the last century that he speaks of nation and not state.

    Reply
  5. Would it be possible to get the whole book as a single .mobi file for Kindle?

    Reply
  6. Thepnr says:

    Well done Albamac, I’ve emailed this to family members already. Cheers.

    Reply
  7. Creag an Tuirc says:

    Dave McEwan Hill and Rev, you may find this site interesting. You can print books on demand. link to lulu.com

    Reply
  8. Albamac says:

    @Luigi

    That’s the only ‘F’ word that’s been neglected during the process. 🙂

    I’ll add it as soon as I can, Luigi. I think that’s about as far as it needs to go, unless anyone has a bright idea.

    Having some trouble with mobi conversions. Single chapters were okay but later attempts not quite up to scratch.

    Reply
  9. Albamac says:

    @Rev. Stu

    Glad it’s in the repository. That’s where it belongs.

    Reply
  10. Albamac says:

    @Scots Renewables

    Working on it but, after numerous attempts, still not quite right.

    Reply
  11. Martyman says:

    I’ve managed to convert it into a semi-readable Mobi format (for kindle) using Calibre. Just give me a heads-up on how to send it on …..

    Reply
  12. Luigi says:

    You’ve done a great job, Albamac.

    It is very much appreciated.

    Cheers L.

    Reply
  13. Archie [not Erchie] says:

    @ Albamac – Thankyou and to Rev Stu for teasing us with a chapter a day. I have had comments from expats in NZ who want it all. I would say its had a global impact.

    Reply
  14. Albamac says:

    @Martyman

    How well is the formatting preserved? Does it look right and read well or is it messy?

    The latest conversion I have has unexpected line feeds and some of the rest (headings and quotes) is pretty untidy.

    Reply
  15. Morag says:

    That’s great, muchos grazias. Am I the only one seeing a lot of random bold letters? Is it my Acrobat reader?

    Reply
  16. Martyman says:

    Managed to upload a copy to my skydrive in mobi format – seems ok.

    link to ppl.ug

    Reply
  17. Albamac says:

    @Martyman

    Forgot to say that you can fling it over on albamac at scotspot.net

    Reply
  18. Martyman says:

    @Albamac

    I played around with the settings in Calibre. Something to do with the ‘Heuristic processing’ option.

    Don’t get me wrong – it’s pretty basic formatting, but there doesn’t appear to be any formatting errors or bad line breaks etc

    Reply
  19. Martyman says:

    @Albamac

    Don’t know if you caught the link above, but I have emailed you a copy.

    As I said, no fancy formatting, but no errors either. For Kindle, it should be fine.

    Reply
  20. Albamac says:

    @Martyman

    Hey, that looks fine! I think I ran into problems when I used an MS Word file as source – neither surprised nor deeply disappointed. 🙂

    Reply
  21. Cindie aka CR says:

    Thanks so much Albaman, Martyman, Rev Stu and Wilma. Have downloaded my copy to Kindle and am off to read

    Reply
  22. msean says:

    I now have it on my kindle,it’s came out very well,better than some other attempts at conversion I’d done.Thanks to all.

    Reply
  23. SquareHaggis says:

    Many thanks to everyone involved in bringing this very important works up into the public domain.

    Interesting images from Ukraine

    link to tinyurl.com

    Slide show – image 7

    Could be useful in an article.

    Reply
  24. SquareHaggis says:

    @Albamac – try a basic font, one style, ariel would do it, should spread across the formats easily that away.

    Reply
  25. SquareHaggis says:

    link to bellacaledonia.org.uk

    Tickets to hear Alan Bissett plus others @ Celebrate Burns Night – Royal Mile, Edinburgh 24th

    Reply
  26. Patrician says:

    Converted quite nicely to epub. Thanks Wilma Watts and albamac and for the original conversion. I agree with DMH, this needs a hard copy version printed for distribution.

    Reply
  27. Truth says:

    Thanks for all the conversion efforts. I now have it downloaded to my kindle app.

    Of course, I’ve now had to find out as much as I can about Herbert James Paton. Remarkable that he wrote this book in his 80s.

    There’s a short biography of him here:

    link to giffordlectures.org

    and another on the Glasgow Uni website including a picture. A fine figure of a man he was:

    link to universitystory.gla.ac.uk

    Reply
  28. Norrie says:

    Works brilliant in iBooks on the iPad, thanks for everyone’s efforts.

    Reply
  29. X_Sticks says:

    Many. many thanks Albamac. What a brilliant read. It should never have been allowed to go out of print.

    I doff my hat to Herbert James Paton. A true Scot in every sense of the word. Huge thanks also to Wilma Watts for allowing its reproduction.

    Reply
  30. DonUnder says:

    I’ve been waiting for the completion of this serialisation before diving into it. And now we have it in Kindle i’ve no excuse 🙂

    Many thanks to everybody involved in this! Great effort.

    Reply
  31. Wilma says:

    Thanks to Albamac and Reverend Stuart for finding a way of making this wonderful book accessible. Happy reading.

    Reply
  32. Dave says:

    Just loaded the Mobi version on my new Kobo Touch eReader (£30 from WH Smiths). Many thanks for all concerned in the conversion. I also have the white paper ePub version on my Kobo.

    Reply
  33. Taranaich says:

    Just wanted to give another big thank you to Wilma for making it possible, the Reverend for putting it up for all to read and gain inspiration, Albamac for transcribing it however you magical image-to-text wizards do it (little goblins typing on tiny computers? Is that it?), and of course to the late Herbert James Paton for writing such an amazing, remarkable book. Paton may have been an advocate for home rule rather than independence, but it’s clear he loves Scotland, and wants nothing more than to see her people thrive. Let’s make that happen.

    Reply
  34. Kate says:

    Thanks so much @ Albamac, now got it in my kindle for reading again. converted easily with calibre.

    Reply
  35. Hardin says:

    Just as a FYI it would cost around £2000 to print & bind 1000 of these as paperback books. Fun fundraiser to drop off around Scotland?

    Reply
  36. Ken says:

    This is a great read. Many thanks.

    On a similar line, I’ve been trying to find an article written by a gentleman who worked at Westminster around the time this book was published. He gave an insight into how separate Scottish figures have been available, even though denied by Whitehall. The article outlined how well Scotland performed, even before the North Sea discoveries. Also his amazement that the truth has been successfully kept from us for decades.

    I gave my last print-out away and have forgotten his name. Can anyone help please. Thanks.

    Reply
  37. Adrian B says:

    @ Ken,

    Would it be John Jappy that you were thinking of?

    link to wingsoverscotland.com
    link to google.co.uk..0l4.496.5877.0.11162.10.8.0.2.2.1.5916.7826.0j3j2j5-2j9-1.8.0….0…1ac.1.34.heirloom-hp..1.9.1963.hAwaHtf8leg

    Reply
  38. Albamac says:

    Just got much closer to what I wanted with the mobi file. I’m like a dog with a bone but that’s the final edition.

    You can download it here, if you like, and give it a spin.

    It may be better than what you have. Worth a try.

    Reply
  39. Ken says:

    Thank you Adrian. That’s the one. I was very close with my search, but not close enough. I’ll be able to sleep tonight without all the permutations I had running through my head. 🙂

    Reply
  40. Dave says:

    How about submitting this to Project Gutenberg? It has a crowd-sourced proofreading feature which would let us all give a final polish to a few pages each. The ebook would then be available for free to all the world in a variety of formats.

    Reply
  41. Wilma says:

    Truth
    Thank you for the links, very informative.

    Hardin and Dave. Tell me how we can go about this. I was worried about copyright issues but I followed a link that Truth gave (above) and found that H J Paton’s” Gifford Lectures” are already available free online. I think that he would be delighted that his book is being appreciated.

    Reply
  42. Wilma says:

    Albamac
    I have downloaded from the link the Reverend has given at the top of the page -which is fine- but when I took up your offer in your post it said it could not be opened, what am I doing wrong?
    I have sent the link to all my email contacts whether they want it or not. We must keep spreading the word and what you have done is fantastic, many thanks.

    Reply
  43. Albamac says:

    Hi Wilma,

    I’ve just downloaded and opened it again without any trouble. I’m using Amazon’s free Kindle reader on my desktop.

    Reply
  44. Albamac says:

    Wilma,

    I think I see where the problem is. The previous link was for the pdf version. The link in my post is for the mobi version.

    Reply
  45. memaw says:

    Albamac

    Many thanks.

    Reply
  46. Wilma says:

    I have the kindle app on my PC so should it not have worked?

    Reply
  47. Albamac says:

    Wilma,

    Yes, it should. I can’t think why it wouldn’t. I only know that it’s working fine at my end.

    Has anyone else had problems after downloading it using the link in my earlier post? Wilma and I need your feedback, folks.

    Reply
  48. Kenny says:

    @Albamac

    Works fine for me, and looks rather splendid. Many thanks.

    Reply
  49. Dave says:

    @Wilma

    Check out this link for how to start the Gutenberg process.

    link to gutenberg.org

    It does need to be copyright free but I think I read above that the copyright owner had consented.

    Reply
  50. Albamac says:

    Dave & Wilma,

    Done so far for print:

    Cover, foreword, table of contents and chapters.

    Haven’t started on the index – saved the worst for last.

    Reply
  51. Wilma says:

    Albamac

    How can I contact you privately?

    Reply
  52. Albamac says:

    Wilma

    Email albamac at scotspot.net

    Reply
  53. Albamac says:

    @Kenny

    You’re welcome!

    Reply
  54. Albamac says:

    Thanks to everyone who expressed their appreciation.

    It’s…em…much appreciated! 🙂

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,967 Posts, 1,248,813 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Che on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “The realisation of what you know and what is legal in Scotland. The devolved parliament and those who claim they…Aug 17, 18:08
    • Alf Baird on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: ““this has the British state all over it” Indeed, and Frantz Fanon explained the inner workings of a colonial justice…Aug 17, 18:03
    • James Che on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “And in Scotland the devolved parliament is not a Sovereign entity nor those that sail under that banner, The people…Aug 17, 17:54
    • James Che on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “Where do you go once discovered that there is no official crown office in Scotland due to the treaty of…Aug 17, 17:49
    • Frank Gillougley on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “The sooner they put the Scottish parliament building up for sale the better. It’d make quite an impressive second-hand furniture…Aug 17, 17:14
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: ““GORGON HEAD OF POWER” Extracts from ‘The Crisis in Humanist Political Theory’ (1931) by Herman Dooyeweerd: « In his work…Aug 17, 17:14
    • Aidan on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “I’m going to say that this is very unlikely to be true Northcode, Roddy Dunlop only has the information that…Aug 17, 17:08
    • Northcode on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “You’ve put forward a reasonable question. Here’s an answer that might help clarify things. Signing off accounts does not meet…Aug 17, 15:55
    • sarah on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “Without restoring Scotland’s independence, we will never have a chance to rectify the corruption of our various institutions. We needn’t…Aug 17, 15:42
    • ALANM on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “This case provides further evidence of a phenomenon which has been growing rapidly since the start of the century. I…Aug 17, 15:36
    • cirsium on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “Rev – I thought that the fact that Scotland is not currently fit to be an independent nation again was…Aug 17, 15:30
    • 100%Yes on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “The noose around Scotland neck is Holyrood and thinko’s who work their.Aug 17, 15:29
    • Graf Midgehunter on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: ““It makes no sense to me that here is the golden opportunity to rid the UK of the Scottish national…Aug 17, 15:18
    • Heather McLean on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “Unfortunately Scotland is a banana republic without the actual bonus of bananas. The contempt for the people of Scotland is…Aug 17, 15:11
    • Ian Smith on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “It was a big achievement to push the Murrell court date past the election, and hardly likely to be a…Aug 17, 15:07
    • Skip_NC on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “Because with Holyrood there is the pretence that we have some control over our own affairs. Without it, the truth…Aug 17, 15:06
    • Williams on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “Surely it’s the folk who signed off on the accounts?Aug 17, 15:02
    • Williams on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “Surely it’s the folk who signed off on the accounts?Aug 17, 15:01
    • Heaver on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “Corrupt media.Aug 17, 14:58
    • 100%Yes on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “McDuff, I quite agree, the British state knows and is involved. Sturgeon is being protected. Independence isn’t going to die…Aug 17, 14:50
    • Hatey McHateface on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: ““you have nothing worth fighting for” What tripe. It’s worth fighting for the establishment of a system of justice that…Aug 17, 14:46
    • robertkknight on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “… let’s face it. If the SNP were prosecuted on what is clearly an open and shut case and were…Aug 17, 14:32
    • TURABDIN on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “THE WORLD of do as you Please. https://nypost.com/2026/08/17/us-news/trump-warns-us-will-bomb-the-s-t-out-of-oman-if-they-interfere-in-strait-of-hormuz-conflict/ Greenland is safe….for the moment. «If you don’t have justice as a…Aug 17, 14:23
    • Northcode on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “The Dean of Faculty tells us that he believes the crime of embezzlement has been committed in the case of…Aug 17, 14:19
    • McDuff on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “Quite agree. I find it just a tad strange that when questions were being asked about the missing Indy Ref…Aug 17, 14:17
    • robertkknight on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “The only conclusion to draw is that Swinney’s weasel worded 100-second confession had previously been given in private to Police…Aug 17, 14:15
    • desimond on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: “Apropos of nothing… How much has Scottish Police budget increased in last 12 years: In cash terms, the policing budget…Aug 17, 14:04
    • Hatey McHateface on Believers In The Ruins: “As always, sam, lack of demographic analysis of the respondents answers renders these statistics meaningless. As always, sam, you know…Aug 17, 14:02
    • macdonut69 on The Land Of Do-As-You-Please: ““It [Wings previous letter] does not identify any significant new information that was not available to investigators at the time”…Aug 17, 13:51
    • Hatey McHateface on Believers In The Ruins: “So Trump did the medievalist women haters a big favour by topping the stale, male beardies? I’ll monitor events with…Aug 17, 13:47
  • A tall tale



↑ Top