The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


A kind of freedom

Posted on April 15, 2025 by

Alert readers will have noticed our so-far-fruitless attempts to extract information from the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator regarding the disturbing activities of the controversy-plagued LGBT Youth Scotland.

We are far from the only people raising concerns about the charity – we know of at least 17 separate formal complaints against LGBTYS in the past year alone, yet the OSCR has declined to open any sort of formal inquiry into them. (It carried out three such inquiries in 2024.)

But despite the OSCR’s assertion that “we strive to be transparent and accountable”, when we went to find those complaints (including, of course, the one from ourselves) to link you to them, we hit a brick wall that rapidly turned into a whole new concern.

The OSCR has a Freedom Of Information page, but it contains no links to either the FOI requests it has received or its responses.

It does however state that the OSCR has adopted the Model Publication Scheme produced by the Scottish Information Commissioner, which it helpfully links to.

The first clause of the Model Publication Scheme is this:

And a few lines later it makes very clear what it means by “publish”.

In other words, that you should be able to find FOI responses on the OSCR’s website without having to email them and ask.

So we went back to the OSCR’s FOI page and clicked the link on “our FOISA policy”. It links to a document which includes a paragraph on “Our Publication Scheme”.

That points to the OSCR’s “Guide To Information”, which is a dead link. (Something of a speciality of the OSCR website, as we know.)

However, if you go back to the main Freedom Of Information page, there’s a working link to the information guide.

The guide states again that the OSCR is signed up to the Model Publication Scheme, and notes that the published information is available “on our website”, without stipulating where.

The document contains a total of 51 links, including to the OSCR’s Equalities Strategy and guidance on how charities can safely support Ukraine (which redirects to a page saying “We’re sorry, this page no longer exists”), but nothing about anywhere you can read FOI requests and responses.

The closest it appears to get is the section headed “Communications”, which simply links back to the main Freedom Of Information page.

And round and round you go in circles, without ever getting the information you want. Which just isn’t good enough, folks. So we’ve asked for an explanation, but since we already know how that goes with the OSCR, we’ve also gone straight to the Information Commissioner to alert them to the OSCR’s clear non-compliance with the Model Publication Scheme.

To: enquiries@foi.scot

I note with some concern that it appears to be impossible to locate responses to FOI requests anywhere on the website of the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator (OSCR). Their “Guide To Information”, located here, makes no reference to where responses are published.

The “Publication” section of their FOISA Policy, located here, merely directs readers to the aforementioned Guide To Information, which is of no assistance, and their Freedom Of Information page, located here, does not include any link to where responses are published.

It does however claim that they adopt the Scottish Information Commissioner’s “Model Publication Scheme” with regard to FOIs. That scheme, which as you know is published here, stipulates in its first clause that:

“1. The Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (FOISA) requires Scottish public authorities to adopt and maintain a publication scheme. Authorities are under a legal obligation to:

(i) publish the classes of information that they make routinely available

(ii) tell the public how to access the information they publish and whether information is available free of charge or on payment.”

(It notes that the definition of “publish” is that the information must be “available to anyone to access easily without having to make a request for it”.)

The OSCR therefore appears to fall at the first hurdle, since as far as I can establish it does not tell the public how to access the information it publishes with regard to FOI requests at all, let alone “easily”. I consider myself a reasonably diligent and competent professional journalist and I’ve been trying to locate said information for an entire morning without success, merely being sent round and round in circles to pages which do not contain or link to it.

I am keen to hear the Information Commissioner’s view on this matter.

Hopefully the SIC will be more helpful and competent than the OSCR is.

0 to “A kind of freedom”

  1. Gav says:

    Excellent sleuthing Stu

    Reply
  2. MaryB says:

    Who is responsible for OSCR? Who do they answer to? Who has oversight?
    Surely there is a minister in the Scottish Parliament who is responsible for it?
    The answer(s) to these questions could be quite revealing.

    Reply
  3. Anton Decadent says:

    A cliche, I know, but keep up the good work.

    Reply
  4. MaryB says:

    The current non-executive director is a former yoga teacher who’s been on the public sector board merry-go-round. Part of the quangocracy.

    Reply
  5. Frank Gillougley says:

    Really, Stu, you are a star.

    But what on earth did you think that the civil service do all day long, other than construe labyrinthine legalese concerning how to protect, obscure and cover up their tracks and those of other government organisations on the same payroll?

    Government sinecures are a major growth industry now especially since the rise of IT which equates to a whole new generation of toilet monitors, but there’s nothing here to really bother your silly little head with. They know best. Now be a good boy and eat up your cereal. There’s a good lad.

    All bureaucracies are self-serving. End of.

    Reply
  6. David Hannah says:

    Lock these beasts up. Get them to fuck out of Scottish public life.

    Reply
  7. gregor says:

    I did a FOI request to the Care Inspectorateand got a similar response today.

    Reply
  8. Hatey McHateface says:

    “the Scottish Information Commissioner” (SIC).

    Very droll 🙂

    No doubt no pun was intended, but seriously, was there nobody in the room capable of thinking that one through?

    Reply
  9. twathater says:

    There appears to be numerous statements that the information MUST adhere to legal parameters BY LAW, the question has to be who is overseeing and REGULATING the various nonentity government departments to ensure they are complying with the law (surely that would be the Scottish Information Commissioner) which then begs the question are they deliberately ignoring these flagrant breaches of the law or has no one reported the various government departments engaging in these duplicitous illegal actions

    Reply
  10. Mark Beggan says:

    Fantasy or Reality?

    Scottish children are in Danger from LGBTQ.

    The LGBT brigade are after Scottish children because there is no chance of a future LGBT generation coming up behind to take their place. The big plan being lets brainwash boys and girls into “it’s” to Secure the Queer future. The lesbian adoption experiment in Scotland is up to it’s neck in blood. So they changed tactics.

    If this is the reason behind the criminal activity of the LGBTQ gang then the whole Scottish government,legal system is facing charges of conspiracy and collusion.

    Reply
  11. McDuff says:

    This madness is prospering at the expense of our children and you have to wonder at the silence of the MSM and that of parents.
    Thank God for the rev.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,741 Posts, 1,216,169 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • crazycat on Tough Calls: “Yes, you are wrong. Labour was in power from 1997 till 2010. Both the GRA (2004) and Equality Act (2010)…Apr 19, 21:28
    • Hatey McHateface on Tough Calls: “As a SOVEREIGN Scot I demand more money, a bigger house and some wheels powered by a V8. I guess…Apr 19, 21:19
    • Hatey McHateface on Tough Calls: “Aye, Alf, “they had it coming” continues to be a staple of a certain cadre of the Indy supporters. The…Apr 19, 21:10
    • agent x on Tough Calls: “But the Scottish government love the GRA 2004 so much that they would reduce the age to 16 and remove…Apr 19, 20:49
    • agent x on Tough Calls: ““(23) Invalidity of the Scottish Government’s Guidance 266. For all these reasons, we conclude that the Guidance issued by the…Apr 19, 19:40
    • agent x on Tough Calls: ““While this ruling was caused by a policy of the Scottish government, it was actually caused by Westminster by allowing…Apr 19, 19:10
    • PacMan on Tough Calls: “This is what Ruby who used to post here said all along. It was brought in under Labour but the…Apr 19, 19:04
    • Marie on Tough Calls: “Why? It’s only very recently that most people have come to realise that gender identity theory is based on what…Apr 19, 18:26
    • Nae Need! on Tough Calls: “Pacman, AFAIK, that’s why we now really need the GRA 2004 to be repealed. The GRA 2004 was installed under…Apr 19, 18:10
    • Mark Beggan on Tough Calls: “And James McBull, don’t forget the McBullsApr 19, 17:50
    • Mark Beggan on Tough Calls: “Who?Apr 19, 17:47
    • Nae Need! on Tough Calls: “It IS truly sad. The damage that has been done. The mess that has been created, for no ‘need’, only…Apr 19, 17:46
    • Young Lochinvar on Tough Calls: “Oh dear PacMan That’s not going to go down too well with the John Bull constants on here 🙂Apr 19, 17:43
    • Nae Need! on Tough Calls: “He does, doesn’t he.Apr 19, 17:41
    • Nae Need! on Tough Calls: “Oh, VERY good, Chris. Clever. Thank you. 🙂Apr 19, 17:40
    • Nae Need! on The Moral Vacuum: “Indeed. This is in response to your last paragraph. And of course there is one prominent individual that fits the…Apr 19, 17:37
    • PacMan on Tough Calls: “It doesn’t look good for those in support of Trans https://archive.is/eL93D A former civil servant who played a key role…Apr 19, 17:10
    • Pat Blake on The Moral Vacuum: “Alf, wonder for a moment that this is not all an English plot but a fundamental flaw in the heart…Apr 19, 16:44
    • James on Tough Calls: “Outstanding. Laughed so hard.Apr 19, 16:38
    • GeoffC on Tough Calls: “They followed Nicola’s lead……Apr 19, 16:34
    • Mark Beggan on Tough Calls: “Female Toilets. The Tranny’s favourite place until Wednesday. Have no fear Man in Skirt Swinney The Ass licker is crawling…Apr 19, 16:32
    • Mark Beggan on Tough Calls: “They can clear out the disabled toilets that were being used as storage.Apr 19, 16:27
    • twathater on Tough Calls: “Brilliant depiction of the imbecility of the politicians that this needed to be shown to them, well done Chris As…Apr 19, 15:44
    • Alf Baird on Tough Calls: “The conflict you refer to occurred because, among other reasons, U imposed the U language on the R speaking community…Apr 19, 15:40
    • agent x on Tough Calls: “Correction – “failed Ex SNP MP”.Apr 19, 15:38
    • twathater on Tough Calls: “Same shite as usual Chasie dick , still nothing constructive to contribute just like yir fellow yoonies fuckwitApr 19, 15:26
    • agent x on Tough Calls: ““Mhairi Black: Misogyny underpins this ‘protecting of women and girls” https://www.thenational.scot/politics/25101877.mhairi-black-misogyny-underpins-protecting-women-girls/ ——————————————– Oh dear – failed SNP MP is not…Apr 19, 15:10
    • Hatey McHateface on Tough Calls: “Colonialism “is based on psychology”. And there was me thinking it was based on nasty people with more or better…Apr 19, 14:44
    • Hatey McHateface on Tough Calls: “A garden shears probably covers most variations.Apr 19, 14:35
    • Hatey McHateface on Tough Calls: “An we’re a’ doomed.Apr 19, 14:28
  • A tall tale



↑ Top