The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Search Results

Karine Polwart statement 24

Posted on February 17, 2013 by

Karine Polwart is a Scottish folk singer and Green Party supporter. Earlier today we highlighted a curious editorial choice by Scotland On Sunday, which framed a column she’d written on independence as an attack on the SNP, despite Ms Polwart not mentioning the SNP anywhere in the text, either directly or indirectly.

Below is the text of a post on her Facebook page this morning, after SoS deputy editor Kenny Farquharson tried unsuccessfully to defend the use of the anti-SNP headline:

“Full text of my wee rant in favour of Yes Scotland in today’s Scotland on Sunday. For clarity, the title is not mine. If I’d wanted to frame my piece as an explicit go at the SNP then I would’ve done so.

YES Scotland is not a covert SNP operation. I believe the independents, Greens, socialists, and growing number of pro-Indy Labour and Liberal activists bless if there are any of the latter left) must shape that agenda too. Anyway, here’s to more voices being heard, and more proper heartfelt and visionary exchange between us about what’s WRONG, and why, and what might fix it (whether you think Independence is a possible answer or not).”

(Two small typos fixed for readability, otherwise unchanged. Original here.)

Read the rest of this entry →

Fine-tuning the news 94

Posted on April 07, 2014 by

The image below depicts three of what have been at least four different versions of the Scotsman’s story about our latest Panelbase poll. (So far, that is – who knows what might happen in an hour’s time?)

scotsheads

They show a fascinating evolution of editorial line, wouldn’t you say?

Read the rest of this entry →

A different outlook 46

Posted on March 17, 2013 by

Only the special ineptitude of the Scotsman could make the task of downloading a simple PDF into a near-impossible trial suitable for the Krypton Factor. We don’t advise you bother trying to get yourself a copy of “Scotland Decides” (the paper’s compilation of its eight-week series of pro- and anti-independence essays) from its own website unless you have a fetish for frustration, but thanks to the sterling efforts of Peter Bell we have a local copy here for you without all the dicking around.

positive

The contents of the document, when all taken together, are revealing.

Read the rest of this entry →

Better late than never 72

Posted on February 20, 2013 by

It might have taken three days, but we got there in the end. After:

karinepolwart2

And before:

Read the rest of this entry →

Framing the debate 33

Posted on February 17, 2013 by

Headlines can be the bane of a writer’s life. Often – including on this site – an article will go out with a different title to the one the author originally envisaged, as part of the subbing process. Occasionally (if the sub-editor or editor isn’t very good at their job) the title can be one which the author feels misrepresents what they’ve written.

We have no idea whether or not that’s the case with a column in today’s Scotland On Sunday, penned by folk singer Karine Polwart, which goes under the eye-catching headline “Why I’ll vote Yes despite the SNP”. We’ll simply observe that there’s a fairly important word in that title which doesn’t appear at all in the actual article – and that indeed the thing the word describes is not referred to, or even obliquely implied, anywhere in the author’s words – and leave you to arrive at your own conclusions.

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,700 Posts, 1,211,478 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • gregor on Seeding the briar patch: “KanekoaTheGreat @KanekoaTheGreat: “Why did USAID give $68+ million to the World Economic Forum?”: https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1887263131124310375Feb 6, 19:49
    • gregor on Seeding the briar patch: “Cheers Twathater – This is our Scotland…Feb 6, 19:29
    • Fiona MacDonald on Seeding the briar patch: “Apparently he was scared of Sandie. The truth is that he could kill a woman with one punch.Feb 6, 19:21
    • gregor on Seeding the briar patch: “BBC (06/02/25): Alba chief suspended over gross misconduct claim: “Alba’s general secretary has been suspended after being accused of gross…Feb 6, 19:20
    • Mark Beggan on Seeding the briar patch: “You’re gonna need a bigger Carstairs.Feb 6, 18:59
    • gregor on Seeding the briar patch: “STV News (06/02/25): ‘You will have to wait’: Sturgeon won’t rule out return to Holyrood: “Nicola Sturgeon has said Scots…Feb 6, 18:56
    • Hatey McHateface on Seeding the briar patch: “Well done you. Several hundred words of mince and you never mentioned “Rootless Cosmopolitans” once. “r4ped with sand, … with…Feb 6, 18:53
    • Hatey McHateface on Seeding the briar patch: ““I fluff for no one” Oh yes you do. “Sovereign Scots. Find out what it means.” It means that my…Feb 6, 18:46
    • Hatey McHateface on Seeding the briar patch: ““responsible for countless billions of deaths” One can only hope that gregor will be along in a minute to provide…Feb 6, 18:39
    • Hatey McHateface on Seeding the briar patch: ““With Musk’s daily outrages, his butchery of respectful public discourse and his association with the fascist right, I could drive…Feb 6, 18:31
    • Hatey McHateface on Seeding the briar patch: “Plenty in the SNHS is shite, twathater. We’re just about at peak tax, and some economists are predicting that Rachel…Feb 6, 18:26
    • Geri on Seeding the briar patch: “I fluff for no one. The population votes for a leader. That population should have the control to remove it,…Feb 6, 18:26
    • twathater on Seeding the briar patch: “BRAVO that deserves a post all to itself on ALL Scottish blogsFeb 6, 18:25
    • Confused on Seeding the briar patch: “mcternan is a well known fool, but sometimes he blurts out “truths that must not be said”Feb 6, 18:22
    • Captain Caveman on Seeding the briar patch: “What? You’re using “filter busting” (bastardised/hyphenated) words to deliberately circumvent word filters, and you’re discussing subjects that the host has…Feb 6, 18:17
    • Hatey McHateface on Seeding the briar patch: ““could find Scotland on a map” Just imagine how they would fare trying to find “scotland” 🙂Feb 6, 18:16
    • gregor on Seeding the briar patch: “Sorry, not my Lego McHatey. Speak to: #LEGOBTScotGovFeb 6, 18:14
    • Geri on Seeding the briar patch: “Ah, The Anglo Empire! Directly responsible for countless billions of deaths worldwide. It’s no contest is it? The West can…Feb 6, 18:13
    • Hatey McHateface on Seeding the briar patch: “Sorry, Mark, but the relevance of your reply eludes me. Talking of animals though, here’s something I discovered just recently:…Feb 6, 18:12
    • twathater on Seeding the briar patch: “You have just given BASTARD TAX moan an aneurysm talking about all this FREE stuff Geri , can you not…Feb 6, 18:11
    • Geri on Seeding the briar patch: “I never said I was off. The site owner has, as far as I’m aware, forbidden the topic of what’s…Feb 6, 18:09
    • Confused on Seeding the briar patch: “Farage is like some snot that sticks to your finger that you can’t get rid of no matter how often…Feb 6, 18:08
    • twathater on Seeding the briar patch: “Bastard tax moan loves to run to his wee fannys rescue whenever the fanny is disrespected or even disagreed with…Feb 6, 18:05
    • Young Lochinvar on Seeding the briar patch: “Ignored as spamFeb 6, 17:50
    • twathater on Seeding the briar patch: “Your minus votes shows there are those who just want the other greedy bastard party to emulate the other greedy…Feb 6, 17:33
    • Stuart MacKay on Seeding the briar patch: “Geri, he’s alive and kicking – well posting – on at least one other site I visit.Feb 6, 17:33
    • gregor on Seeding the briar patch: “No joke. Science Museum’s public guide claims heteronormative Lego is discriminatory against LGBT people/community – It’s concerned because normative Lego…Feb 6, 17:24
    • twathater on Seeding the briar patch: “That is worth an uptick Gregor , the franchise fanny doesn’t like anyone contradicting him or disagreeing with his excretionsFeb 6, 17:18
    • Hatey McHateface on Seeding the briar patch: “That’s a disgusting and inappropriate pic, gregor. Everybody can clearly see those Lego blocks’ naughty bits. How many times, gregor!…Feb 6, 17:16
    • Hatey McHateface on Seeding the briar patch: “I read a semi-technical review of the DeepSeek application. The reviewer reckoned it was about 20% less accurate than current…Feb 6, 17:12
  • A tall tale



↑ Top