The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


The (same) old scoreboard

Posted on July 10, 2013 by

We’ve spoken before of the difficulty of empirically demonstrating anti-independence bias in the Scottish and UK media, because of the relative rarity of directly comparable situations. So today we’re pleased to see one of them present itself.

denmarkeu

Michael Gray of National Collective recently visited Scandinavia and did a nice bit of journalism, securing quotes from a number of senior Danish politicians to the effect that an independent Scotland’s membership of the EU would be “a mere formality” and that the subject was “a non-issue”.

Good news. But how does it help us illustrate media bias?

To its credit, the Herald picks up the story this morning with a prominent piece by Robbie Dinwoodie entitled “Danish interviews contradict Better Together’s EU claims”. As yet, we haven’t seen the quotes reported anywhere else.

But what happened earlier this year when a very similarly-ranked politician from another small European nation – Latvia – put forward the opposing view, that EU membership for Scotland would be less straightforward to achieve?

“Independent Scotland ‘would have to apply from scratch to join EU'”
(Telegraph)

“A third European foreign minister has told the BBC an independent Scotland would have to apply for EU membership.”
(BBC, one of several articles and broadcasts)

“Yes vote means reapplying to EU, says Latvia’s foreign minister”
(Daily Record)

“Independent Scotland would have to apply to EU”
(Scotsman)

“An independent Scotland would have to do a lot of negotiating”
(The Independent)

“Yes vote for Scotland ‘means reapplying to EU'”
(Herald)

“Latvian minister says independent Scotland would have to apply to join EU”
(The Courier)

So, that’s a pretty straightforward impartiality ratio of, er, 7-1 so far (leaving aside the actual content of some of the reporting in the above stories, some of which also left a little to be desired in terms of neutrality).

We’ll be keeping our eye on the newswires today to see if any more coverage of Gray’s findings crops up. Do let us know if you spot any.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

39 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
redcliffe62

If the beeb covered it we would know the sky had fallen in due to little green men attacking with daleks.
An opportunity for some to try to show a little bit of quasi-neutrality. If they do not then this may come back in advertising towards the vote. A good argument to use on bias. With no comeback.

Geoff Huijer

Sums it up really…
 
and on YouGov when I commented on the 4-1 bias on the
recent Question Time I was amazed to see that some people
still thought that the bias was in favour of the SNP! Don’t ask me why.
(Neatly ignoring my point that it’s not about just the SNP).
 
Some people will deny the facts even when they stare them in the face.
Others, however, will see this kind of article as an eye-opener when
reposted… Thanks.

Paul Martin

Michael Gray has put the majority of the Scottish media to shame by the simple expedient of asking questions and getting answers. No wonder Kenny Farquharson has been recently dismissing them as mere creatives who should keep out of his domain (words to that effect).
 
Well done Michael Gray. Well done National Collective.

Doug Daniel

It’s funny how the BBC hasn’t given us any quotes from ministers from the Nordic countries (and I believe the Dutch have also made positive sounds regarding Scottish EU membership, but don’t quote me on that one). It’s almost as if they’ve only picked the ones that can be selectively quoted to make EU membership sound difficult.
 
Perish the thought, obviously.
 
Anyway, it’s good to see Danes saying what most of us here have been saying all along – that EU members have absolutely no reason to not want Scotland in the EU, and that membership would be a mere formality since we already comply with the Copenhagen Criteria and the Acquis Communautaire.

Paul Martin – “No wonder Kenny Farquharson has been recently dismissing them as mere creatives who should keep out of his domain (words to that effect).”

That’s very interesting, considering Kenny was full of praise for them a few months ago.

Bill C

This is a quality piece Rev and illustrates why “Wings” is so important to the movement for Scottish self determination.  Once again, thanks.

HandandShrimp

Geoff
 
People like Lord Foulkes feel any report or interview panel is biased towards the SNP if the the SNP position is articulated by anyone reagrdless of numbers of people putting an opposing view. Any oxygen of publicity towards a Yes vote is contested vigorously on the grounds that people shouldn’t hear stuff like that (or something).

Jiggsbro

a very similarly-ranked politician
 
Not, I expect, in the BBC’s eyes. The Latvian one was a Foreign Minister, the most similar Danish politician was a spokesman on foreign affairs for one of the coalition parties. Not exactly the same, therefore no bias. 😉

Robert Kerr

Rev.
Why is there no longer a link to National Collective on WoS?
Genuine concern
Hail Alba

Jiggsbro

Any oxygen of publicity towards a Yes vote is contested vigorously on the grounds that people shouldn’t hear stuff like that (or something).
 
The BBC has to be impartial and should not be persuading anyone to vote any particular way. Putting forward the Yes message would clearly persuade people to vote Yes, so they shouldn’t do it. No such danger exists with broadcasting the No scare stories, so they’re safe.

John Lyons

I don’t think Foulkes believes his own claims of bias in favour of the SNP, I think it’s just bluff and bluster to keep the pressure on the BBC to limit SNP airtime as much as possible.
 
Or am I crediting him with more intelligence than he has?

Colin Dunn

Hmm. I await the BBC “Scotland warned that only Denmark supports Scottish application to join EU and NATO” story later today.

Paul Martin

Hi Doug – just his recent tone:
 
Kenny Farquharson ?@KennyFarq 27 Jun
To be clear, I’m hugely interested in how politics/art interact but I’m not at all interested in artists’ view of #indyref currency debate.
 
Kenny Farquharson ?@KennyFarq 27 Jun
@WeAreNational More posters, less posturing.
 
Kenny Farquharson ?@KennyFarq 27 Jun
Can someone please explain to me why views of, ugh, ‘creatives’ are more important in #indyref than views of teachers, nurses, draymen, etc?

Michael

Why on earth do people encourage Kenny F in his belief that his views are of any significance by constantly repeating them and discussing them. I am at a loss. Just ignore the tosser FFS.
 

Doug Daniel

John Lyons – no, I suspect you’re quite right. Which, to be honest, makes it even worse – it’s one thing to be a ranting bampot who shouts “BIAS!!!” wrongly, but it’s quite another to deceitfully claim bias towards your opponents when you know fine your side is the recipient of the bias.
 
Paul Martin – interesting. Kenny was definitely one of the original trumpeters of National Collective. Clearly they’ve became a bit too much of a threat for his liking. I suspect they’ll be at the same place on his Christmas Card list as the Rev…

Hairy Beastie.

Humorous to note, of late, the complete lack of the formerly ‘regular European updates’ from cheery wee Raymond Buchanan.

I would imagine the words ‘Hi, I’m from BBC Scotland and I’m looking for an interview with your foreign minister on Scottish membership of the EU’ is now greeted with a rough approximation of ‘go away; we have seen how you’ve misquoted other senior politicians around Europe.’ And I say a rough approximation, because there would be more swearing.

The media is clearly biased in my view. Have you seen that speech by Craig Murray where he reads out a list of headlines used by the BBC? He could have gone on for his whole speech if he’d extended that to the print media.

mealer

The BBC only asks the question to those they know will give the answer which suits London.
The Danes are correct.Our continueing membership will be a mere formality because that’s what suits everyone.Throwing Scotland out and telling us to re-apply from scratch would cause far too many problems and expense for them to even contemplate doing such.And for what gain to them ? None what so ever.
Everythings in place all ready.Sure,there will be a bit of haggling over the fine detail.And its important we take time and get things right.But our membership will continue while discussions take place.
Some people would like us to think Europe will make things hard for Scotland.Thats not my experience from the many Europeans I’ve come across.They’ve always shown me friendship and respect.

Luigi

This high level BBC bias against Scottish independence would make a brilliant PhD study for someone. The material is oiut there, it’s a goldmine that just needs to be quantified and analysed.  It just needs proper funding (SG?) and an objective mind.

Tom Hogg

This is embarrassing for Scotland’s so called mainstream media. In the nicest possible sense, Michael’s pieces from Iceland and Denmark haven’t exactly been Pulitzer Prize material.  The fact that he’s been able to go and chap on folks’ doors, ask them basic questions and get simple answers really shows up the rest of the media as parochial parasites feeding off their mates and the whispers of the Scottish establishment.
PS, I saw Cochrane in Poundland in the St James Centre this morning. No idea what he was buying but he seemed to struggle with paying. Hard times at the Telegraph apparently.

Shinty

Tom Hogg,
No idea what he was buying but he seemed to struggle with paying
 
Saving up for his chopper exit in 2014
 
 

Embradon

Cochers in poundland? Was he puzzled at the pricing structure?
 

Kenny Campbell

Cockers shouts as he leaves the shop “Aye they’ll be nae Poundland if you lot vote YES”…….

john king

“Cockers shouts as he leaves the shop “Aye they’ll be nae Poundland if you lot vote YES”…….”
 
fit aboot three chickens an a goatland?

Atypical_Scot

Good bye Royal Mail.

Andy-B

As Craig Murray says
 
The BBC and its media cohorts, are the new “Hammer of the Scots”
 
The question is whether they will hammer us into oblivion,through their lies or hammer us into shape, through our determination for independence hopefully the latter prevails.

Currywurst

“EU members have absolutely no reason to not want Scotland in the EU, and that membership would be a mere formality”
 
Helloooo!
 
Budget rebate, anyone?

Jamie Arriere

I would have mixed thoughts about this story reaching the MSM – yes, it is a voice showing a more relaxed attitude to Scotland maintaining its EU status, but it will only be mentioned alongside the already distorted statements from the other countries they used before.
 
If only Michael Gray could do a ‘Fake Sheikh’ and get it on camera from the horse’s mouth of a big player (ideally in London!)

Doug

Currywurst
 
What’s that got to do with anything?  As I understand it, the EU would lose out financially if we were not allowed in.  The loss of our fisheries to the CFP, for example, would be worth far more than our pro-rata budget rebate. 

Holebender

Currywurst; most EU members pay their dues and get various payments from the EU. The UK has this rebate thingy, pays less in and gets NOTHING back. It’s not really such a great bargain and I’d happily do without it in exchange for EU funds to upgrade our infrastructure, etc.

Angus

What Jiggsboro says about ‘equality’ in the various foreign (subjectively reported) ministeriel soundbites may be true, or not true, we can only compare it to the fact that ‘anything’ said by ‘anyone’ that makes it appear as if that is the main ‘fact’, that there are ‘difficulties’ ‘time restraints’ ‘have to reapply for EU membership” as opposed to renegotiate as a country with a new Government responsible for all of Scotland looking to ‘continue’ in the EU which will simply not be reported as widely as a haverer spouting off, or a misinterpretation of say the position Ireland holds on the same subject.
 
It is whether or not people are feeling a bit insulted at this pretty early stage about being told we won’t have stamps, mobiles nuclear weapons (that one is true) etc if we dare vote Independence…….I have witnessed a few people getting fed up with negativity spruced up, given a summer hat and then paraded on a gala day as being worthy of reporting and that will matter over the next year……….poker players shouldn’t bluff at all times, and better together and the british establishment have pushed credibility of their barrage of utter pish too far already.
 
The good thing is that in an effort to enjoy their unlevel playing field with the media in cahoots, the unionist side will not learn a single thing…..it is what they do and it is this belligerent attitude that made the media and westminster based politicians in Scottish versions of their parties (and their London bosses) fail to have a finger at all on the Scottish voter pulse in 2011………a spectacular miscalculation.
Long may it continue!

naebd

I would imagine the words ‘Hi, I’m from BBC Scotland […] is now greeted with a rough approximation of ‘go away; we have seen how you’ve misquoted other senior politicians around Europe.’
 
LOL – massively overstating the visibility of this issue, and BBC Scotland, around the corridors of European power methinks.

Jiggsbro

What Jiggsboro says about ‘equality’ in the various foreign (subjectively reported) ministeriel soundbites may be true, or not true,
 
It’s an objective fact. Its truth is hardly open to debate. The two are not equivalent. Whether the BBC would actually use that as their excuse is another matter. What is demonstrably not true is “the fact that ‘anything’ said by ‘anyone’…will simply not be reported as widely as a haverer spouting off“. That’s your subjective view and that sort of exaggeration is exactly what they use to brush off claims of bias. They find someone whose claim about an instance of bias is clearly ill-founded and use that to dismiss all claims about the instance. They rely on people complaining immediately, when they’re angry – and so more prone to hyperbole and less focused – so they can dismiss complaints as the ‘green ink’ brigade. You need to back-up your calm, measured complaint with facts and empirical evidence…the difficulty of which is where we came in.

Bill McLean

Stop calling them BBC Scotland – they are British, they do broadcast and they are a corporation – but they are not in any way Scottish. Call them what they are “THe Pacific Quay Ministry of Propaganda”!

Clydebuilt

Well if the unionist media won’t report this initiative by National Collective, then time for W.O. S. readers to do their bit and forward this article exposing the media bias to all our contacts.
Also forward a link to the Herald article.

Currywurst

“The loss of our fisheries to the CFP, for example, would be worth far more than our pro-rata budget rebate. ”
 
So? The rest of the EU simply applies the letter of the existing treaties and says “You can enter – as a new state.” That way, they continue to access the fish and we lose our share of the UK rebate.
 
Funny how Salmond never mentions that.

Currywurst

“Currywurst; most EU members pay their dues and get various payments from the EU. The UK has this rebate thingy, pays less in and gets NOTHING back.”
 
Er, this is false, as you could have found out by typing “EU funded projects in uk” into any search engine.
 
Furthermore, if “independent” Scotland is going to be so “wealthy” (at least according to the in-this-case-dodgy measure of per cap GDP), then why would the EU provide any funding for anything in Scotland?

Braco

Currywurst,
If you want out of Europe why not campaign for that after Independence? There are others out there who share your view. Otherwise, what exactly is your point?

Currywurst

I don’t want out of Europe.
 
My point is that the SNP, and people here, have claimed that EU membership for an “independent” Scotland would be “automatic” and a “formality”.
 
Quite clearly it would not, since a large number of EU Member States would have political and financial interests in making it a matter of entry as a new state.
 
Why do the SNP pretend that it isn’t so?

CameronB

@ Currywurst
Any evidence to support your point?

Caroline Corfield

is the large number actually the number one, and is it likely to be the ‘successor’ state of rUK? Assuming that is what happens. Because I simply see no financial reasons for countries within the EU to block or make it difficult for an energy rich country with fishing fields within it’s territorial waters, a net surplus of agricultural output and a diverse background of tourism, world class research facilities, high tech industries, etc. etc. etc. (i often refer to it as whisky, wind and weir pumps for shorthand) to join what is a economic collective with some finacial issues. Every little helps said the old woman as she peed in the sea ( one of my mother’s saying). In whose interest, exactly, would it be, to give those in an independent Scotland who want out of the EU, ammunition?


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,653 Posts, 1,198,477 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • The Flying Iron of Doom on Coping with change: “Am I the only person who has the green counter thingy at the lower left stuck at 90? Also, yon…Oct 10, 06:34
    • Geri on Coping with change: “Scotland would be as well to leave it in the ground until we’re independent. Oh deary, Nigeria has officially ditched…Oct 10, 00:09
    • Geri on Coping with change: “School meals in England are means tested. Parents have to apply which is the usual English pastime of humiliating &…Oct 9, 22:58
    • Geri on Coping with change: “The only ones to fck up the exit to Brexit were the English. They wanted their cake & eat it.…Oct 9, 22:39
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “Here you go. A list of the eligibility for free school meals from the UK Gov site: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/65fdad5965ca2f00117da947/Free_school_meals.pdf And for…Oct 9, 22:30
    • Geri on Coping with change: “Proclaimers are dedicating Cap in hand tae the six time loser Sturgeon.Oct 9, 22:17
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “I’m of the opinion the oil & gas is yesterday’s scab. Sure, we can pick at it, but if our…Oct 9, 22:12
    • Geri on Coping with change: “The English don’t even give poor children a free school meal or prescriptions so we’re safe from ever being envious…Oct 9, 21:51
    • Robert Hughes on Coping with change: “Whit ! no Sensational Hatrick Pervy Band , Average WHITE WHITE WHITE Band or Buns n Poses ; nah ,…Oct 9, 21:40
    • Aidan on Coping with change: “If everyone in England got free energy and the people of Scotland were in bondage slavery working to produce it,…Oct 9, 20:44
    • Dan on Coping with change: “In other music news… I hear Twa Ferries Procurement Disaster, Kinlochleven Smelter Fiasco, and The Arsecrack Smeg Muppeteer Instigators of…Oct 9, 20:41
    • Aidan on Coping with change: “You can’t be that stupid, environmental taxes aren’t charged on renewable energy! The taxes falling within the definition of ‘environmental…Oct 9, 20:38
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “Sure, Dan, but check out the size of the bawbag.Oct 9, 20:37
    • Alf Baird on Coping with change: “The EU has a far bigger population than Norway but the latter’s piped gas still has to be paid for.…Oct 9, 20:35
    • Aidan on Coping with change: “You are right, the right to self-determination applies to all people. I was using the term coloquially to refer to…Oct 9, 20:29
    • Andy Ellis on Coping with change: “International law – such as it is – is far from perfect. There again much the same could be said…Oct 9, 20:29
    • Alf Baird on Coping with change: “Its not unreasonable for a sovereign state to seek recompense for exporting £100bn worth of Kw/hr energy produced to its…Oct 9, 20:27
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “Ah James, you’re blowing perfect smoke rings yourself and you don’t even know it. Onlookers are astonished at their diameter…Oct 9, 20:26
    • Aidan on Coping with change: “With wisdom like that, what can mere men doOct 9, 20:19
    • Aidan on Coping with change: “Oh dear, I assume the Buckie’s out early today. If the law is what you say it is and no…Oct 9, 20:18
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “Here’s some links for readers who find Geri’s mince gives them the boak: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_Free_Scotland https://scotsindependent.scot/FWShop/product/pirates-of-the-air-the-story-of-radio-free-scotland/ It would be nice to…Oct 9, 20:12
    • Dan on Coping with change: “And there was you moaning about flippant responses yesterday… Yer jist a totes hypocritical bawbag.Oct 9, 20:10
    • Campbell Clansman on Coping with change: “The thing you reference as “international law” that supposedly overrides national constitutions, is of course a big joke. Nobody should…Oct 9, 20:09
    • Andy Ellis on Coping with change: “The right to self determination is constantly misunderstood here. It deliberately does not provide for the rights of people within…Oct 9, 20:04
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “On buses and trains you mean? Only fair I guess, the ticket price should include a guaranteed seat.Oct 9, 19:54
    • Dan on Coping with change: “Alert readers and eager hunter gatherers of hidden special feature buttons which make the “upgrade” so uber slick to use,…Oct 9, 19:52
    • Andy Ellis on Coping with change: “Spain’s written constitution is immaterial from the POV of self determination, since SD is a jus cogens or peremptory norm…Oct 9, 19:46
    • Alf Baird on Coping with change: “Aye George, a colonial administration is permitted only limited powers and is unable to influence the economic plunder it is…Oct 9, 19:41
    • James on Coping with change: “Sorry, ‘Aidan’ I got it wrong. It was actually 52.5billion. I thought you were Michael Gove but it turns out…Oct 9, 19:31
    • Dan on Coping with change: “Hi George, Trust you are keeping well. Have you spent anytime looking into the BESS grid backup leccy storage facilities…Oct 9, 19:02
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
90
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x