The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


The home front

Posted on July 17, 2013 by

An alert reader today pointed us towards internet traffic analysis site Alexa.com, and in particular its statistics for the Yes and No campaigns’ official websites. There was an interesting quirk (or at least one that might pass for interesting in the silly season).

alexa

Can you spot it?

(Mind you, Alexa also provides the slightly surprising news that Wings Over Scotland is far more popular than either of them and that 23.7% of our traffic comes from Tunisia, so it might not be 100% reliable. But hey, what do you want? It’s our day off.)

alexa2

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

53 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Cath

Hmm, I see the oddity.
However, I’m much more amused that people find your site using the search terms “John Macintyre OBE” (seriuosly? People search for that obsessive Herald stalwart from down south somewhere?), “Salmond Fidel Castro” and “cybernat”. Nowt so queer as folk.

Stuart Black

John MacIntyre OBE? Really?

Brian Ritchie

Hmmm, odd how only 57.6% of BT’s visitors are fom the UK? I smell  a rodent…

Iain

@Cath
‘However, I’m much more amused that people find your site using the search terms “John Macintyre OBE” (seriuosly? People search for that obsessive Herald stalwart from down south somewhere?)’
 
I suspect most of the searches for John Macintyre OBE are by…John Macintyre OBE.
Yer a Unionist naebody until you’ve been slagged off on Wings.

HoraceSaysYes

Excellent spot! Does that explain why the SoS polls seem to take a huge jump in the middle of the night, too? lol

And I love the Top Keywords for Wings too! Do you have the same for the other sites? 😀

Atypical_Scot

42.4% of Thrown_Together – nigh on half are expat or from a TOR Browser or from Mars.

naebd

Maybe all those BT Facebook ads are being badly targeted.

Cath

“I suspect most of the searches for John Macintyre OBE are by…John Macintyre OBE.”
 
Ah, of course. Why didn’t I think of that? He really must be quite a sad person.
 
<waves to John who is presumably reading> Chin up, mate. Go and enjoy a Pimms in the sunshine instead! None of this really matters you know? If we vote Yes, life will go on just fine.

Cath

“Maybe all those BT Facebook ads are being badly targeted.”
 
Probably hitting loads of folk abroad who click on it because they think it’s a dating site. And leave fast after seeing images of Darling and Johann Lamont.

Luigi

BT pop-ups are now popping up everywhere. Not a wise use of resources. They are becoming deperate!

Tattie-boggle

From BT Facebook page comment. The Beautifully uninformed “It’s impossible to leave Salmond out of it. The SNP is run by a small clique if talentless third rate politicians. Look at his deputy, a talentless over promoted career politician. To attack the SNP means attacking Salmond because he has organised the party around himself and his cronies”

Train fares

Alexa is not the most acurate thing in the world. Hoewver it is a very good indicator. Going from my own rankings and the known visitors figures for this site I would say that better together are getting around 10,000 a month and yesscotland is double at 20,000

muttley79

@Tattie-boggle
 
 
From BT Facebook page comment. The Beautifully uninformed “It’s impossible to leave Salmond out of it. The SNP is run by a small clique if talentless third rate politicians. Look at his deputy, a talentless over promoted career politician. To attack the SNP means attacking Salmond because he has organised the party around himself and his cronies”
 
Oh dear.  What a lot of garbage.  So SLAB for instance would not like somebody of the calibre of Sturgeon in their party?  Mind you how could she compete against the likes of Jackie Bailie, Patricia Ferguson, Lamont, Martin, McMahon etc?  Nicola Sturgeon a career politician?  What does this person think Darling, Alexander, Murphy, Harris, Curran etc are?  Does this individual honestly think they are conviction politicians?  More to the point: where is your famous positive case for the Union?  Don’t make me laugh… 😀 😀

orkers

@Muttley79
It’s heartening that people are reading the BT site.
A pretty poor cupboard of ‘hope’ they must have on display.

Bugger (the Panda)

Ah, Tunisia, that’ll be GCHQ tapping in somewhere in the desert.

Hetty

O/T, sort of…
oh no, Tunisia? when my son lost his mobile last month, the toerag that found it called Tunisia over 24 hours while we searched for the phone and before cancelling it, and they ran up a bill of £490.00. So tunisia has bad connotations for me…
 
and the better together facebook ads have been snuck into my and others’ pages and actually looks like a ‘yes’ ad until you look closer, so many people have clicked ‘like’ by mistake. Very underhand, but what’s new?
I still haven’t heard even one positive case for the union, but most recent reason given by a Labour friend is, the uk is crap, getting worse and so is Scotland.
 

muttley79

@Bugger
 
There must be thousands of those evil Scotch separatists in Tunisia, using it as a base for their repellent cybernat tactics…

HandandShrimp

I have looked at the Better Together Faceache page and I have to say it is a real Private Faser experience. They make Eeyore look cheerful….curiously nasty edge to some of it as well but hey ho, that’s politics. The comments are as one would expect a mixed bag and we all have our intemperate members but the articles on Yes Scotland are a lot lighter and more positive on the eye and heart.

Roddy Macdonald

Remember “Better Together was originally the brand of http://www.bettertogetherscotland.com, an NHS Scotland initiative. Furthermore, there’s a helluva lot of Better Togethers around the world. 
Their hit rate may be high, but I doubt more than a few linger to read.

a supporter

Slightly O/T.
Why have there been no recent opinion polls about Independence in the media?

old mikey

O.T. a tad. Ian Bell has a very good piece in todays Herald, ‘ The lies of the land that demonise people’. It regards bankers bonuses, crown estates, and people on benefits.

Max

 
I say, “Damn those Tunisians” 

MajorBloodnok

I say “I prefer the line caught dolphin friendly Tunisians, in olive oil preferably.”

Luigi

Why have there been no recent opinion polls about Independence in the media?
 
If current poll support for independence was down, or stalled at 30%, they would be plastered all over the front pages.  DC has recently suggested (we have already won, but) support for independence may rise a little due to anti-coalition protest.  Read into that what you will.

Ericmac

I’d love to see a WoS article on OBE, and his unhealthy obsessions…   But more than that I’d love to see Jezerna (The false flag Sage of Serbia) being outed.  

a supporter

Another very recent poll by ICM shows the following results for voting for Westminster in a  Scottish Sub-sample. (The UK poll showed Tories and Labour each at 36%.)
SNP 40%
Labour 30%
Conservatives 18%
Greens 6%
Liberal Democrats 3%
UKIP 1%
Others 2%
No wonder Scottish Labour are spitting vile venom at the SNP and AS. Because it appears that a NO or a YES vote in Indyref is going to kill the career prospects of the pig troughers and wannabees at Westminster. The figures also seem to demonstrate that the negative campaign is really a disaster for Scottish Labour.

Ericmac

The Tunisian Government has a massive Better Together campaign.  The stats are correct. Seriously.

scottish_skier

Erimac. Yup.
link to opengovibt.org
OpenGov: It’s Better Together is the beginning of a new era for governance in Tunisia. On 19 December in Bizerte, government champions, civil society idealists, and private sector innovators will gather to discuss how to create and implement projects that will improve government transparency and accountability through open data, citizen engagement through e-participation, and service provision through online applications.

Brian Ritchie

Another very recent poll by ICM shows the following results for voting for Westminster in a  Scottish Sub-sample. (The UK poll showed Tories and Labour each at 36%.)SNP 40%Labour 30%Conservatives 18%Greens 6%Liberal Democrats 3%UKIP 1%Others 2%
Insert those figures at link to scotlandvotes.com and you get some interesting results. 🙂
 

a supporter

Brian Ritchie
Wheeeeeeoooow! I put the figures in. I didn’t realise things would be so bad for Labour.

Cath

Remember “Better Together was originally the brand of http://www.bettertogetherscotland.com,
 
Yes, hence why I have a Better Together pen and keyring.
 
Poor old Tunisians. They click on thinking they’re getting some friendly, open governance site and find the precise opposite. Hope it doesn’t put them off their government!

Mister Worf

I think this is down to a few things. Bitter Together’s supporters already know their guff inside out, and as has been noted most other visitors think it’s a dating site because it’s such a generic name that doesn’t really specify what it is. If you check hashtags or trending it turns out a decent chunk of the people talking about better together are often not even in the UK and are talking about something else.

Yes Scotland however, is pretty much as to the point as you can get. Better Together doesn’t explain anything with the name. Who is better, together with what?

Oddly, neither does it explain with the rest of the website.

Generic names might help them pretend they’re more relevant than they are by sharing unrelated blogosphere and twitter hits, but given how easy it is to show the problems with their broad and generalised ideas on everything, this is just par for the course.

Better Together: Barely explains anything and is so broad, omitting so many key facts and points, as to be rendered meaningless when examined under any scrutiny. They can’t even keep their own bloody name focused and clear.

MajorBloodnok

@Ericmac & scottish_skier
 
Mystery solved!  You couldn’t make it up, really, you couldn’t.

David McEwan Hill

John McIntyre OBE is I believe a tit from Inverclyde

scottish_skier

Another very recent poll by ICM shows the following results for voting for Westminster in a  Scottish Sub-sample.

It’s better than that if you look at all the subsamples (unweighted) from every poll and the weighted SNP share of the UK total. I use the latter to determine SNP share and the former the remainder splits for the other parties.

SNP UKGE VI peaked late 2011 at 47% (just a smidgen lower than Holyood VI). It then fell back over 2012 to 42% at the end of the year. This was mirrored by 31% for Labour late 2011, recovering to over 35% late 2012.

You see the same trends in Yougov (ignore absolute values as Yougov weights Scotland like it was England which is wrong in so many ways).
However, SNP has been climbing again rapidly and is at least 45%. Labour down to 31% again over the past six months with an acceleration of decline around May (UKIP factor?).

This mirrors independence polls which peaked with the Yes ahead in late 2011 (right, Tories are back and we’re off) followed by a decline through 2012 (wow, this is a bit of a step and I didn’t think about the EU etc) with No peaking at the end of the Year.

Since then (hey, I’m being told a lot of crap about independence by BT and Labour are going full on Tory with UKIP deciding policy, I think I’m going to back yes definitely), we’ve seen the Yes rising (only MORI has it steady) with the no falling (panelbase, Angus Reid, TNS, only MORI have it steady within variance).

That recent MORI that had BT singing and dancing was a rogue which probability says will happen at some point (they caught too many people who felt strongly British so did not match Scotland’s demographic in this respect). Chances are the next one from MORI, whilst still being on the higher side for No (discredited landlines telephone polling and associated problems cause this), will show a fair drop in No and rise in Yes, even if just from probability within variance.

In summary, evidence increasingly suggests NO peaked late last year and has been on the slide. Modest 2012 recovery for Labour in Scotland is dying off too.

I’m happy with the way things are going anyway.

Brian Ritchie

Enlightening analysis Skier as usual 🙂 Things are EVEN WORSE for Labour.  Spitting venom indeed!

a supporter

What about the Greater Tit from the ‘West Midlands’? Now would that be somewhere around Lanark?

annie

Interesting to note Alf Young is chairman of Riverside Inverclyde.

HandandShrimp

Ericmac
 
Didn’t OBE join us here briefly? However, as he seems to mount a full time watch on the Herald I doubt he can spare us the time. I can’t say I have ever felt enticed to respond to his Herald musings. However, I thought he was an ex pat, lost somewhere in middle England and consequently irrelevant to the vote as is Jerenza from Slovenia and MM from wherever. Their frequently quite colourful assertions as to the political affiliations of the FM and all his little demons, whilst entertaining, aren’t actually adding a tin of beans to the debate.

Jimbo

Better Together – Maybe getting so many hits because people think it’s a marriage guidance outfit.
 

Les Wilson

Luigi
Some little questions for you, are you from Inverness? if so do you have a restaurant there? Do you own a motorhome.?

Luigi

Nah – youv’e got the wrong guy, Les. I’m from Aberdeen.

Ericmac

@handandshrimp
“Didn’t OBE join us here briefly? However, as he seems to mount a full time watch on the Herald I doubt he can spare us the time. I can’t say I have ever felt enticed to respond to his Herald musings. However, I thought he was an ex pat, lost somewhere in middle England and consequently irrelevant to the vote as is Jerenza from Slovenia and MM from wherever. Their frequently quite colourful assertions as to the political affiliations of the FM and all his little demons, whilst entertaining, aren’t actually adding a tin of beans to the debate.”

You are quite correct.  I must admit I do feel the need to challenge these three because they are on the one mainstream newspaper that people can find a modicum of balance.  I hate the idea that these extremists can taint people progressing their thoughts and beliefs….  
Its no coincidence that Jezerna appeared on the only Scottish Newspaper that engages some sensible people in sensible debate…  I have no doubt that there are two or three people posting under her name and are paid to do so by one of the party research units.  
They are unrelenting in their attacks… with the sole intention of hurting the electorate.

Ericmac

The other ardent, vitriolic, and rabid GH poster is called Peter Kelly, outed on here a few days ago.  I congratulated him on the infamous publicity.. I don’t think he likes me any longer 🙂
 
 

Bugger (the Panda)

I think it is Terry Kelly you are talking about Ericmac

Dramfineday

@ Tattie-boggle
The SNP is run by a small clique if talentless third rate politicians .

So the BT commentator imagined they were dishing an insult calling AS’s team “Third rate”? Well in the age of sail, where the term appears to have come from, third rates were warships that were considered to have the right speed, agility and firepower to do the job effectively. To be surrounded by third raters would either have been terrifying as an enemy or reassuring as a friend.

First and Second rate ships of the day were considered to be too expensive to operate, too slow, cumbersome and, unless it was a near flat calm, were unable to deliver a full broadside due to the low waterline / gun-port configuration. They were usually used to plough up and down, trying to look effective as blockade / flagships.

Third rates were the ships of the day. A bit like Alex’s team don’t you think?
 

fairliered

John MacIntyre OBE, WOKING”
Is Woking in Tunisia?

john king

“I’d love to see a WoS article on OBE, and his unhealthy obsessions…   But more than that I’d love to see Jezerna (The false flag Sage of Serbia) being outed.”
Are you kidding? a self serving nonentity like McIntyre getting the wings treatment? he’d go into raptures, he’s a nobody. if we ignore clowns like him and the genius Terry Kelly they’ll soon find a new fly to pull the (wings) off,
just saw Terry Kelly’s picture on his website ha ha , and if you visualize an objectionable creature it would look like that picture  >-)
  

john king

can anyone tell me if John Mcintyre O.B.E. Woking, Surrey, England
has a vote in the referendum? 

john king

I’ve got it I’ve got it
I’ts John Mcintyre Old Bucket Emptier
 
ah’ll get ma coat :#)

Les Wilson

Luigi.
cheers, was just wondering as a met a guy……

scotintun

Now what is the problem about Tunisia? After all wings is the first site I visit every morning and again in the evening. How else do I keep up with the times?


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,653 Posts, 1,198,480 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Mac on Coping with change: “The green counter stuck at 90 appears only once you enter a particular article but not on the home page.…Oct 10, 08:47
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “The Guardian is reporting that genetically engineered wild cattle variants are about to be set loose near Loch Ness. Known…Oct 10, 08:21
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “Moving my bowels as I type, Geri. And thinking of you 🙂Oct 10, 08:10
    • The Flying Iron of Doom on Coping with change: “Am I the only person who has the green counter thingy at the lower left stuck at 90? Also, yon…Oct 10, 06:34
    • Geri on Coping with change: “Scotland would be as well to leave it in the ground until we’re independent. Oh deary, Nigeria has officially ditched…Oct 10, 00:09
    • Geri on Coping with change: “School meals in England are means tested. Parents have to apply which is the usual English pastime of humiliating &…Oct 9, 22:58
    • Geri on Coping with change: “The only ones to fck up the exit to Brexit were the English. They wanted their cake & eat it.…Oct 9, 22:39
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “Here you go. A list of the eligibility for free school meals from the UK Gov site: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/65fdad5965ca2f00117da947/Free_school_meals.pdf And for…Oct 9, 22:30
    • Geri on Coping with change: “Proclaimers are dedicating Cap in hand tae the six time loser Sturgeon.Oct 9, 22:17
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “I’m of the opinion the oil & gas is yesterday’s scab. Sure, we can pick at it, but if our…Oct 9, 22:12
    • Geri on Coping with change: “The English don’t even give poor children a free school meal or prescriptions so we’re safe from ever being envious…Oct 9, 21:51
    • Robert Hughes on Coping with change: “Whit ! no Sensational Hatrick Pervy Band , Average WHITE WHITE WHITE Band or Buns n Poses ; nah ,…Oct 9, 21:40
    • Aidan on Coping with change: “If everyone in England got free energy and the people of Scotland were in bondage slavery working to produce it,…Oct 9, 20:44
    • Dan on Coping with change: “In other music news… I hear Twa Ferries Procurement Disaster, Kinlochleven Smelter Fiasco, and The Arsecrack Smeg Muppeteer Instigators of…Oct 9, 20:41
    • Aidan on Coping with change: “You can’t be that stupid, environmental taxes aren’t charged on renewable energy! The taxes falling within the definition of ‘environmental…Oct 9, 20:38
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “Sure, Dan, but check out the size of the bawbag.Oct 9, 20:37
    • Alf Baird on Coping with change: “The EU has a far bigger population than Norway but the latter’s piped gas still has to be paid for.…Oct 9, 20:35
    • Aidan on Coping with change: “You are right, the right to self-determination applies to all people. I was using the term coloquially to refer to…Oct 9, 20:29
    • Andy Ellis on Coping with change: “International law – such as it is – is far from perfect. There again much the same could be said…Oct 9, 20:29
    • Alf Baird on Coping with change: “Its not unreasonable for a sovereign state to seek recompense for exporting £100bn worth of Kw/hr energy produced to its…Oct 9, 20:27
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “Ah James, you’re blowing perfect smoke rings yourself and you don’t even know it. Onlookers are astonished at their diameter…Oct 9, 20:26
    • Aidan on Coping with change: “With wisdom like that, what can mere men doOct 9, 20:19
    • Aidan on Coping with change: “Oh dear, I assume the Buckie’s out early today. If the law is what you say it is and no…Oct 9, 20:18
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “Here’s some links for readers who find Geri’s mince gives them the boak: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_Free_Scotland https://scotsindependent.scot/FWShop/product/pirates-of-the-air-the-story-of-radio-free-scotland/ It would be nice to…Oct 9, 20:12
    • Dan on Coping with change: “And there was you moaning about flippant responses yesterday… Yer jist a totes hypocritical bawbag.Oct 9, 20:10
    • Campbell Clansman on Coping with change: “The thing you reference as “international law” that supposedly overrides national constitutions, is of course a big joke. Nobody should…Oct 9, 20:09
    • Andy Ellis on Coping with change: “The right to self determination is constantly misunderstood here. It deliberately does not provide for the rights of people within…Oct 9, 20:04
    • Hatey McHateface on Coping with change: “On buses and trains you mean? Only fair I guess, the ticket price should include a guaranteed seat.Oct 9, 19:54
    • Dan on Coping with change: “Alert readers and eager hunter gatherers of hidden special feature buttons which make the “upgrade” so uber slick to use,…Oct 9, 19:52
    • Andy Ellis on Coping with change: “Spain’s written constitution is immaterial from the POV of self determination, since SD is a jus cogens or peremptory norm…Oct 9, 19:46
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
90
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x