The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



They come bearing half-truths 22

Posted on September 09, 2012 by

The CBI Director-General, John Cridland, came north this week to tell Scotland we shouldn’t be independent. He has every right to do so. But what he has no right to do is use half-truths as the basis for his scaremongering.

I hear that Mr Cridland told the CBI Annual Dinner in Glasgow on Thursday night that the “immediate effects [of independence] would be profound, and in the short term costly. When Slovakia separated from the Czech Republic, it cost the country four per cent of its GDP in the following year.” But what Mr Cridland won’t tell us is what happened next.

Read the rest of this entry →

The arc of recovery 101

Posted on September 08, 2012 by

We’re thrilled to welcome to the blog the YesScotland campaign’s estimable post-graduate European law expert Stephen Noon, with some intriguing stats.

The International Monetary Fund has just published its latest statistics for the relative wealth per head of different countries. And, for Iceland, Ireland, Norway and the UK, they paint a fascinating picture.

The figures are based on “purchasing power parity”, which allows us to make a fair comparison between the different countries, and they show that Norway, Ireland and Iceland are all wealthier per head than the UK. Indeed, at no point in the financial crisis did any of the countries dip below the UK in this IMF wealth league table.

If we take a look at 2010, when the full impact of the crisis was being felt, the wealth per head for each country, in current international dollars, was:

Norway     $52,165
Ireland      $39,492
Iceland     $36,535
UK           $35,344

The UK was $1,192 behind the ‘poorest’ of the three, Iceland, at this point. If we fast-forward to the current year, 2012, the IMF estimates are:

Norway     $54,479
Ireland      $40,443
Iceland     $39,083
UK           $36,605

This year, the average UK citizen is now forecast by the IMF to be $2,478 poorer than his equivalent in ‘insolvent’ Iceland. And putting the IMF’s crystal ball to full use, let’s take a look at referendum year, 2014. What will be the relative strengths of the four nations by then? Won’t being a powerhouse big country have propelled the United Kingdom above lowly Iceland at least?

Norway    $57,217
Ireland     $44,283
Iceland    $41,647
UK          $38,935

It seems not. In 2014, the UK won’t even reach the level of GDP per capita that Iceland enjoyed in 2012. The wealth gap between the two countries will have increased, once again, to $2,712 per person.

Similarly, for Ireland, 2010 saw the Irish $4,148 ahead of the UK in wealth per head, and according to the IMF that Irish advantage will increase to $5,348 in 2014.

And finally, Norway’s $16,821 advantage per person in 2010 is forecast to become $18,727 by 2012 – in other words, just short of 50% wealthier than the UK.

It’s not quite what you’d expect from listening to the rhetoric of the anti-independence parties. Perhaps they should actually go to Iceland, or Ireland or Norway – small, independent nations which, it seems, now form an arc of faster recovery.

.

A version of this post appeared previously on SNmr.

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,712 Posts, 1,213,600 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “You could be onto something, gregor. I bet that search as long as you like, you won’t uncover any online…Mar 4, 19:02
    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Dinna fash, Marie, you’ll be at work. Shame you’re so busy because maybe you could have stepped up to answer…Mar 4, 18:48
    • Marie on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “If that’s the Britain we’ve to fight for them I’m not interested. No sale.Mar 4, 15:41
    • gregor on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “BBC (04/03/25): Who is Elissa Slotkin, the Democrat chosen to rebut Trump’s speech?: “A former Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) analyst…”:…Mar 4, 15:02
    • Cynicus on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Aidan says: 4 March, 2025 at 1:03 pm “What does Mr Murray have to say about all of the death…Mar 4, 14:54
    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Meanwhile back at the ranch: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14453137/Hundreds-civil-servants-dodge-SNPs-harsh-tax-regime-living-England.html It’s the Daily Hate, so bound to be all lies, but still. Fit if…Mar 4, 14:34
    • diabloandco on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “The world I’m looking at appears to be run by the mad ,the bad and the stupid – it’s terrifying.Mar 4, 14:24
    • Robert Hughes on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Yes , Viv , it’s obvious Starmer The Cunt is trying for the Thatcher/Falklands effect …. Poll ratings flatlining ?…Mar 4, 13:54
    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Think of the environment, Confused. Switch off your computer and take oot the dug. Alternatively, if you just have to…Mar 4, 13:49
    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “@Aidan I was tickled to find the following in that “effort” by CM: “R is gradually winning a war of…Mar 4, 13:34
    • Confused on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Harvie, avid butthole-ist and potato model, has said we should fight mad vlad to the last tranny, or something. I…Mar 4, 13:07
    • Aidan on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “What does Mr Murray have to say about all of the death and destruction his side caused by invading an…Mar 4, 13:03
    • Vivian O’Blivion on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “The opening salvo from Mr Murray. “When politicians in power are extremely unpopular, they generally turn to militarism and jingoism…Mar 4, 10:56
    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Anthem, the discussion re European nuclear weapons has moved on significantly and seriously just within the past week. It’s all…Mar 4, 09:44
    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Aye, CYNICUS, the Yanks made poot do it. I’m betting you’re an enthusiastic panto attendee. What’s your favourite? It must…Mar 4, 09:41
    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: ““Close wan , eh ? Think I’ll stick with Mr Murray” Ah well, CM famously put in writing his support…Mar 4, 09:32
    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: ““includes 12 secret locations” You sure have a lot in common, gregor, with another boy who used to post interminably…Mar 4, 09:19
    • Aidan on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “It’s the brass neck to continuously complain about the costs to us of a war that their side startedMar 4, 07:59
    • CYNICUS on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: ““ Gethins’ line is consistent with the rest of the SNP hierarchy. Flynn, Swinney et al.” ========== Why is that…Mar 4, 02:15
    • Young Lochinvar on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Well Southern “Bystander”; Probably correct. Sounds awfully like Englands medieval behaviour then the “British” (sic) Empire experiment though doesn’t it?…Mar 3, 23:58
    • gregor on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “@Marie Your life – the challenges that you’ve faced and have successfully navigated, on a daily basis, have provided you…Mar 3, 23:16
    • Marie on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Thanks Gregor. These pathetic bigots don’t scare me – they’re not remotely capable of leading the difficult life I lead…Mar 3, 22:30
    • gregor on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Hatey McHateface says:3 March, 2025 at 9:02 pm: “Time for the biolabs…” Time to bring the CIA (and partners) into…Mar 3, 22:26
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “REJECTED PLANS TO ALLOW STRIP SEARCHES BY TRANS POLICE OFFICERS BACK ON THE TABLE « Male police officers who identify as…Mar 3, 22:09
    • gregor on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “re. “And what impression of Scotland do you think Mia and Geri give?” Both Mia and Geri impress me -…Mar 3, 21:57
    • Anthem on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “But,but, we can’t use our nuclear weapons without the authority of the USA. So that ain’t going to protect us.…Mar 3, 21:53
    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “I’ve long considered, Aidan, that Mia and Geri actively work towards tarnishing the Scottish Indy cause. I mean, what other…Mar 3, 21:10
    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “Time for the biolabs to get an airing again. And why not? Assuming they are equally distributed across the country,…Mar 3, 21:02
    • Aidan on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “And what impression of Scotland do you think Mia and Geri give?Mar 3, 20:59
    • Hatey McHateface on Why I’m Never Leaving Twitter: “It’s “utmost respect” gregor. “Upmost respect” is something else entirely. In fact, to many people of an old-fashioned POV, it…Mar 3, 20:48
  • A tall tale



↑ Top