The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



Soapbox: In the hawk’s nest 238

Posted on July 26, 2020 by

This week saw publication of the long-awaited Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC) report on alleged Russian interference in British affairs. Despite media hysteria, the report contained no new revelations, just all-too-familiar catastrophising about Moscow’s ill-defined “disinformation” efforts and warnings of the undue influence rich Russians (most of whom are actually Kremlin opponents) have bought themselves.

The most salient point for supporters of Scottish independence to consider was the allegation that Moscow’s interference efforts extended to the 2014 indyref. As Wings pointed out earlier this week, however, the “evidence” to support this sensational claim amounted to nothing more than a heavily-redacted single paragraph, citing “credible open source commentary” as its sole source.

A look at the paragraph’s accompanying footnote reveals the “credible open source” commentator was Ben Nimmo of the Atlantic Council. For those in the fortunate position of being unfamiliar with his work, Nimmo is known for, among other things, falsely identifying a Syrian-Australian blogger and a British pensioner as Russian bots – so clearly someone whose expertise should be relied upon to determine the extent of Russian infiltration into Scottish politics.

I mention this not simply to reveal the transparently amateurish nature of the ISC’s report but rather to offer a commentary on the SNP’s (predictably) disappointing response to its allegations.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,691 Posts, 1,208,783 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • gregor on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Congratulations, Mark, et al re. Hall of Scotland/world shameJan 14, 13:57
    • gregor on Safeguarding Is Not Right-Wing: “Mark Beggan re. failure: “Gregor!!” https://wingsoverscotland.com/nicolas-non-truths/#comment-2947568Jan 14, 13:56
    • Andy Harrison on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “She threw Alex, her long time friend and mentor under a bus to protect her own self interests. It looks…Jan 14, 13:40
    • gregor on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Steph Paton @stephenpaton134: “No plans to leave just yet, but I’m on Bluesky as a backup.”: https://x.com/stephenpaton134/status/1859235175743275221 BlueSky: Columnist for…Jan 14, 13:37
    • Portysoul on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Bravo Robin McAlpine, a brutal, but accurate slaying of Sturgeon. Thank you for the link.Jan 14, 13:37
    • Chas on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “I wonder how many people no longer read the articles or comments on Wings as they are simply put off…Jan 14, 13:35
    • Harry Dunlop on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “A colleague made an interesting comment to me about her ‘legacy’… I ventured that it would be the Child Payment…Jan 14, 13:20
    • gregor on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Scottish Trans: TERMS: “It is important to remember that trans terminology is constantly changing and evolving. Particularly as many terms…Jan 14, 13:11
    • Vivian O’Blivion on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “What a rollercoaster ride in nine years. In the 2015, Westminster, General Election, the SNP went from having six seats…Jan 14, 13:08
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “And that pool of dribble was brought to you by #ScreamingLadySuchJan 14, 13:00
    • gregor on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “They/Them LGBT+ Liberation Front (2025): Steph Paton: Why social media faces existential threat: “The internet has always been an anarchic…Jan 14, 12:55
    • Michael Laing on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Sturgeon quite deliberately and systematically wrecked the SNP, so I doubt if she’ll care when it goes down the pan.Jan 14, 12:52
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Mandy Rhodes: ?“Flynn thought he was the oxygen needed to breathe life into a moribund party, but he could yet…Jan 14, 12:28
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Only problem is they’re British Racing Green.Jan 14, 12:27
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “I’ve gotta lovely pair of Penelope Keith garden wellingtons..Jan 14, 12:26
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “What size of shoe are you?Jan 14, 12:25
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “I was going to say ‘use this mask and get away with murder’ but I thought better of it.Jan 14, 12:24
    • robertkknight on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “If they’re the black pvc ones with the fake pony tail and the zipper across the mouth, then I’ve already…Jan 14, 12:18
    • Alf Baird on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “A good article, however, Robin rather misses a key point in his listing of certain other prosecutions that were more…Jan 14, 12:14
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Largactil can work wondersJan 14, 12:13
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Nothing missing?Jan 14, 12:11
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “How did the operation go.Jan 14, 12:11
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Gregor!!Jan 14, 11:54
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “I’ve just ordered a hundred thousand Sturgeon face masks… … Anyone care for a free mask..Jan 14, 11:53
    • diabloandco on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Most excellent! Thanks for the link.Jan 14, 11:50
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Baby boxes were designed for refugee camps they are also intended as coffins.Jan 14, 11:47
    • Mark Beggan on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Makes Mandy Rhodes article look like a Ladybird guide to Scottish politics.Jan 14, 11:43
    • diabloandco on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Nicky -tams??? For those who don’t know they were bits of string tied round trousers at the knee to stop…Jan 14, 11:34
    • gregor on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “The Independent: There’s a lesson for all politicians in Kezia Dugdale’s resignation…: “All political careers end in failure… Dugdale has…Jan 14, 11:26
    • robertkknight on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Link B useful… When does post-Sturgeon begin? | RobinMcAlpine.org https://robinmcalpine.org/when-does-post-sturgeon-begin/Jan 14, 11:25
  • A tall tale



↑ Top