The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Positive-case-for-the-Union update #6

Posted on January 13, 2012 by

(See here for the whole story.)

An exciting development this time, readers. Right-wing magazine The Spectator makes no bones about its opposition to Scottish independence, and fair play to it. This week it very sportingly republished an archive of the editorial column it also ran expressing its opposition to the first Scottish devolution referendum, back in 1979.

(Alert viewers will recall that the Scottish people narrowly voted Yes in that poll, but were foiled by a rigged amendment proposed by Labour which effectively counted the dead as No votes, and thereby denied devolution for 20 years.)

There's much to enjoy and admire in the piece, such as the use of the quite splendid word "fissiparous" and the revelation that even in 1979, "Until the last moment the Labour Party in Scotland held out against the devolution proposals, and had to be cajoled and bullied into line". But the thing that really tickled us about the column was a sentence which shows how little some things change across the generations.

"We have left unargued the essential case for the Union, because we do not believe that most British people need to be persuaded of it."

Endowed with this new knowledge, we've adjusted our clock accordingly.
 

TIME ELAPSED: 31 years, 11 months
CONFIRMED SIGHTINGS OF POSITIVE CASE FOR UNION TO DATE: 0

 

2 to “Positive-case-for-the-Union update #6”

  1. AFaulds says:

    I dearly hope this is the argument employed by all Unionists throughout the campaign. It’s not only unconvincing guff but sounds somewhat patronising.

    Reply
  2. Stronger says:

    Michael Moore: 'We are much, much stronger together'
    No one listened the first time, so he's beefed it up. How many muches by next month?
    link to independent.co.uk

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,875 Posts, 1,236,159 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Modern Politician: “Thanks TURABDIN. In a footnote to the article by Poncarová to which you refer (link posted by me above at…Feb 15, 22:50
    • GM on The Modern Politician: “Good shout Turabdin.Feb 15, 22:48
    • Lorna Campbell on The Modern Politician: “H. McH: yes, I have often thought about that, too. Independence for so many former colonies ended up in conflict…Feb 15, 21:23
    • Lorna Campbell on The Modern Politician: “H. McH: what you don’t get is that these men do not just want to be women facsimiles, they claim…Feb 15, 20:54
    • Onlooker on The Modern Politician: “Fourth Scottish church to burn down in six months. As Harry Hilll would put it: “What are the chances of…Feb 15, 20:47
    • willie on The Modern Politician: “All prosecution is in the name of the Crown. Quis custodiet ipsos custodes, or as they say in Glasgow, -…Feb 15, 20:03
    • Saffron Robe on The Modern Politician: “That’s very much the heart of the matter, Colin. As a conscientious Scot, I could not in good faith serve…Feb 15, 19:06
    • Xaracen on The Modern Politician: “The relevant prerequisites for that assessment haven’t been met yet, sam. Scotland needs to be recognised as a territory by…Feb 15, 19:06
    • Peter McAvoy on The Modern Politician: “I shared the views of many who opposed Thatcher at the time. Something seldom mentioned at the same time the…Feb 15, 18:27
    • sam on The Modern Politician: “Betraying the namr. More outsider than insider. Heir, when it comes to royalty, is who is in line to succeed…Feb 15, 18:21
    • Sven on The Modern Politician: “Heir; A person entitled to the property or rank of another on their death. A person who inherits or continues…Feb 15, 18:15
    • TURABDIN on The Modern Politician: “@ANDY ELLIS, Timor Leste is a Portuguese speaking democratic republic recognized by the UN, and Indonesia from which it split,…Feb 15, 17:45
    • Insider on The Modern Politician: “Sven.. Try looking up what the word “heir” means ! FFS !Feb 15, 17:44
    • agentx on The Modern Politician: “Line of Succession: Despite losing his titles, Andrew remains eighth in the line of succession to the British throne. The…Feb 15, 16:34
    • Sven on The Modern Politician: “Insider @ 15.53. Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor does indeed remain 8th in line as heir to the Monarchy of King Charles 111.Feb 15, 16:25
    • Hatey McHateface on The Modern Politician: “@Andy You left Tibet off that list, not to mention around 20 colonies the Orcs have their claws into, plus…Feb 15, 15:57
    • Insider on The Modern Politician: “Colin Alexander says: “That’s King Charles, King of England and head of the UK state. Also, his heirs continue to…Feb 15, 15:53
    • Hatey McHateface on The Modern Politician: “You think, SR? 319 years of “history stuff” can be unwritten by proving that something underhand went down in 1707?…Feb 15, 15:42
    • Lorna Campbell on The Modern Politician: “Dan: I said it was dire because it was. I do not fgotget that it was many people’s living. Of…Feb 15, 15:31
    • Colin Alexander on The Modern Politician: “James Cheyne “All political parties in Scotland are registered in England.” Is it only me that sees a problem with…Feb 15, 15:27
    • Andy Ellis on The Modern Politician: “The right of any people to self determination is guaranteed by the UN. There is however no general agreement of…Feb 15, 15:23
    • Saffron Robe on The Modern Politician: “Excellent comment, James. I really appreciate your insights. All power to your elbow! Don’t let the naysayers discourage you, it…Feb 15, 14:27
    • TURABDIN on The Modern Politician: “@Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh THANKS for the most engaging link to the Poncarová article on Erskine. The lady is a Czech, i…Feb 15, 14:02
    • Young Lochinvar on The Modern Politician: “Yup, Big Theo has gone, in a huff no doubt. Watch out private health providers, troublemaking pervert circling in the…Feb 15, 13:54
    • TURABDIN on The Modern Politician: “AT THE MOMENT it is all down to the algorithm «training». At the moment that is certainly far from being…Feb 15, 13:47
    • Northcode on The Modern Politician: “I say, old chap, Mogger’s unnatural and deeply condescending accent is straight out of the empire’s metropolitan centre, don’t ya…Feb 15, 13:25
    • Xaracen on The Modern Politician: “@Andy Ellis; The way you stated “Scotland becomes de facto an independent state the moment a majority of votes is…Feb 15, 13:20
    • Young Lochinvar on The Modern Politician: “Confused A great many national anthems are shitty and dirges, heck God save the King is defo top ten chart…Feb 15, 12:59
    • Hatey McHateface on The Modern Politician: “BBC reporting that Upton has walked from NHS Fife. Perhaps a case of New Year – New Grifts.Feb 15, 12:56
    • Andy Ellis on The Modern Politician: “@Xaracen & @Aiden There is no cast iron guarantee that the either the British nationalist state OR the international community…Feb 15, 12:45
  • A tall tale



↑ Top