The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


One more time for the folks at home

Posted on January 11, 2013 by

For goodness’ sake. Despite believing we’d laid the issue to rest once and for all, we’re STILL getting comments and tweets from readers who haven’t grasped Alistair Darling’s simple, straightforward explanation of whether Scotland’s decision in the independence referendum would be irreversible and forever, or whether we would instead quickly and inevitably find ourselves back in the Union.

Since you clearly found our previous quotes from the “Better Together” chairman inexplicably ambiguous, we’ve gone back and found a couple more from the same interview that should DEFINITELY clear things up.

5 minutes 3 seconds

“I think people in Scotland can distinguish between the election of a government for five years – Holyrood or Westminster – and this thing, the referendum, which is about what we have for the next three HUNDRED years!”

14 minutes 24 seconds (in response to the question “Do you think a currency union with Scotland would be in the interests of the United Kingdom?”)

“Of course! If you have independence, or separation, of course a currency union is logical, and d’you know why? Because a currency union ultimately leads to an economic and then a political union, which is what we’ve got now! I believe in a political union!”

Pay attention this time, readers. Honestly.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

6 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
naebd

“independence, or separation”

‘Independence’ passed his lips! Progress!

EDIT: remove italics that I never wanted in the first place. Damn wacky comment system.

Luigi

“Oh what a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive”.
 

Morag

You really think he’s a novice?  I think he’s just incompetent despite years of high-level experience.

cadgers

I think he’s secretly in the pay of the YES campaign. He’s angling to ‘flip’ to the winning side!

Jeannie

I think people in Scotland can distinguish between the election of a government for five years – Holyrood or Westminster – and this thing, the referendum, which is about what we have for the next three HUNDRED years!”
WHIT?  They told me if I voted No it would settle the question once and for all.  Now he’s telling me that in 2314 those nasty Nats are going to start this all over again???? Whit are they like? Don’t think I can go through it a second time!

Could somebody ask him – is it once and for all or do I need to worry about this for the next 300 years? Oh and while you’re at it, ask him why, if his powers of clairvoyance are that good, he didn’t see the financial crash of 2007 coming.

Cuphook

 
I don’t think that Darling cares if he contradicts himself. The soul purpose of the No campaign is to instil fear into the voters and therefore all questions must be answered with a negative spin. Any inconstancy in their argument is irrelevant as it’s not if the media will pull them up on it.
 
Look at Darling’s ‘tour of Scotland’ which is portrayed by the media as a god walking among us rather than a discredited politician unable to attract enough people to fill small rooms.
 
And Iain Grey as an ‘advisor’? I thought that the country had already passed its verdict on him.
 
I’m convinced, more than ever, that with a bit of work we’ll get an unequivocal YES in 2014.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,698 Posts, 1,210,923 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Young Lochinvar on Freedom of choice: “Yup it’s 4 in the morning and isn’t it just great getting the false actors apoplectic about it! Hey Transatlantic…Feb 2, 04:21
    • twathater on Freedom of choice: “Who votes for the likes of Alex cole scuttle the fud , the whole D’Hont system imposed by WM has…Feb 2, 02:41
    • G m on Freedom of choice: “Swinney and Cole Hamilton. Why are people still voting for these thieves?Feb 2, 01:56
    • Geri on Freedom of choice: “It’s a mental illness & low IQ. It’s the only logical explanation for fckwits going out of their way to…Feb 2, 01:23
    • G m on Freedom of choice: “Human trashFeb 2, 01:02
    • Geri on Freedom of choice: “Lib Dems – Alex Cole Hamilton who famously declared Scotland should never be allowed to exist again & wasn’t a…Feb 2, 00:43
    • Geri on Freedom of choice: “She’s like Thatcher. She never knew when to collect her coat & fck off either. Hanging about like a bad…Feb 2, 00:26
    • Geri on Freedom of choice: “The right wing have so far killed two empires LOL! Well done!Feb 1, 23:57
    • G m on Freedom of choice: “The commentariat haven’t got round to the locals yet.Feb 1, 22:57
    • Young Lochinvar on Freedom of choice: “Ignored as spamFeb 1, 21:40
    • aLurker on Freedom of choice: “Hi VoB I have a side-quest question for you today. In another place a reliable commenter reminded me of the…Feb 1, 21:25
    • gregor on Freedom of choice: “re. “we are nationalists who will put our country first.” Wingsists strongly disagree (WTF) #ScotlandLastFeb 1, 20:55
    • gregor on Freedom of choice: “Wings crew doesn’t just prefer the status quo – it strongly advocates for imperial monarchism? Jeez: #WingsCrewOverruledFeb 1, 20:45
    • gregor on Freedom of choice: ““‘HyperNormalisation’, is concerned with the deceitfulness of power, and in extension, the all encompassing deception that runs the modern world.…Feb 1, 20:10
    • gregor on Freedom of choice: “re. “circulation and hitting power” The Globalist (2024): The National puts extra newspapers in shops for next four weeks: “The…Feb 1, 19:34
    • Geri on Freedom of choice: “I think the covid spreaders maybe a little closer to home. It’d certainly explain the hyper moderation & censorship from…Feb 1, 19:32
    • Xaracen on Saying sooths: “No, Aidan, your assertion is wrong, because the current reality is not an outcome of the authentic use of the…Feb 1, 19:17
    • gregor on Freedom of choice: “Wanging: “To be ruthlessly trolled, roasted or all around humiliated online: Damn, you just got a Wanging!”: https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Wanging #WangingOanFeb 1, 19:06
    • gregor on Freedom of choice: “I’ll continue slapping reality in Scotland’s face, Hatey My key doesn’t require locked doors… “The part of a building or…Feb 1, 18:51
    • Xaracen on Saying sooths: “But, Andy, the reason it won’t work is precisely the reason we need it to work!Feb 1, 18:46
    • Xaracen on Saying sooths: “Yes, EVEL was indeed dodgy. England’s MPs have never suffered any particular difficulty in passing legislation because of Scottish MPs…Feb 1, 18:38
    • TURABDIN on Freedom of choice: “Latest colonialist iteration, who owns Greenland? An old Danish guy who has visited the country «45 times», WOW!, claims the…Feb 1, 18:38
    • Hatey McHateface on Freedom of choice: “I guess Indy has tried everything else, gregor, so why not use #WangingOan and see if that gets any traction.…Feb 1, 18:19
    • Hatey McHateface on Freedom of choice: “#WangingOan I’ve still got my metals, Geri, and if any Covid Spreader comes to buy them off me, I only…Feb 1, 17:44
    • Young Lochinvar on Freedom of choice: “Ignored as spamFeb 1, 17:41
    • gregor on Freedom of choice: “Globalist: “Someone who believes that economic and foreign policy should be planned in an international way, rather than according to…Feb 1, 17:34
    • Hatey McHateface on Freedom of choice: “Haha, good one. Worth pointing out that Scotland was always a staunch and loyally monarchist country. That’s a little wrinkle…Feb 1, 17:34
    • gregor on Freedom of choice: “The Globalist (2025): Why The National newspaper went to The Hague: “While the team is used to heading to press…Feb 1, 17:31
    • TURABDIN on Freedom of choice: “These agents of the British state are doing nothing wrong, they are simply protecting their paymaster’s interests. Colonialism has many…Feb 1, 17:24
    • Hatey McHateface on Saying sooths: “I’m thinking you’re splitting hairs there, Xaracen, but no harm done. Authentic or inauthentic, my earlier point stands. There’s 300+…Feb 1, 17:22
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
292
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x