The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Minding your own business

Posted on April 05, 2012 by

Pretty much every newspaper and media source ran with a particular statistic as their headline from the published conclusions of the UK government's consultation on the independence referendum. More or less everywhere led with the 75% of respondents who wanted a single Yes/No question, which is mildly curious because it's not really news – the stated preference of every party and MSP in the Scottish Parliament, and the Scottish Government itself, is already for a single question.

The Secretary of State for Scotland loudly proclaimed that the consultation had therefore delivered a mandate to get on with the referendum on the UK government's terms, meaning a single question as quickly as possible and no votes for 16/17-year-olds. But the respondents to the consultation actually presented a much more significant demand: a similarly large majority of them – 72% – expressed the view that what they really wanted the UK government to do was butt the hell out altogether and give the Scottish Government the power to get on with it.

For some reason, Moore and the Scottish media weren't so keen to draw attention to that particular finding. But it would appear to mean that the electorate overwhelmingly want the Scottish Parliament – the only body which has an actual democratic mandate to hold a referendum on independence at all – to handle the entire matter without interference from Moore and his coalition colleagues.

We look forward, therefore, to the Scottish Secretary and his chums – having made their point and stated their views – keeping their noses out from now on, waiting for the Scottish Government to conclude its own (far more popular) consultation, and make its own decisions about the number and wording of the questions, the timing of the vote and the extent of the franchise. As democrats, we're sure they'll happily comply with the wishes of the people.

2 to “Minding your own business”

  1. Doug Daniel says:

    Another figure that seems to have been missed (or maybe it hasn't – I've been ill the past few days so I'm not as on top of the news as usual) is that 71% of those who responded to the question on the voting franchise agree with the Scottish Government (and the UK government, apparently) that it should be based on residency, like the Scottish Elections, rather than the Westminster election franchise. Only 4% back the ridiculous idea of letting everyone in the UK vote on it. So, assuming the Scottish Government's consultation backs this up, then hopefully those two particularly pathetic arguments can be put to bed.
     
    Not only that, but it shows opinion is completely divided over votes at 16 (44% for, 47% against – although they still manage to point out that "more" were against it), so it will be very interesting to see what the figure is in the Scottish Government's consultation (i.e. the REAL consultation).
     
    One final observation – responses from the public are as moronic as you might expect. I hope they're better in the real consultation; and true to form, Westminster are excellent at spinning neutral responses to sound like they back their point.
     
    Oh, and the fact that A Boyd Tunnock of the outspokenly unionist Tunnocks (not sure why Salmond continues to offer people caramel wafers with their tea) thinks the referendum needs to be as quick as humanly possible does not hold much sway with me. And I don't need to know how fat he is either ("As a reasonably large employer in Scotland…") I also don't care about members of the public parroting lines they've heard on the news about "the damaging uncertainty" – this adds nothing.
     
    A final point – look at the list of respondents, and look for the political parties. SNP (various branches), Scottish Labour (wow, Jim Sillars' defunct party has been resurrected?) and Scottish Liberal Democrats. No Greens, no SSP, and most importantly, the only Tory response is from the London Scottish Conservative Club.
     
    So the Scottish Tories didn't even respond to their own consultation. Unbelievable.

    Reply
  2. Tony Boaks says:

    There was a far easier way of discrediting the UK consultation. Less than 3000 responses in a country of 5 million is 0.06%. So any figure of 75% is 75% of 0.06% of the population: 0.045%.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,995 Posts, 1,254,124 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Early discussions with Alex Salmond, after he had been in Westminsters library regarding the Treaty of union caused a change…” Nov 22, 12:56
    • Captain Caveman on Mind Your Business: ““Confused is correct” Ha. Really? Apart from the laughable inconsistencies that I’ve pointed out between the very things even he…” Nov 22, 12:41
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Only when the people of England, Wales and Ireland recognise there is no actual parliament of Scotland in the Westminster…” Nov 22, 12:18
    • sarah on Mind Your Business: “Rev, I hope that your network of supporters is gathering a body of donors to provide statements of authority for…” Nov 22, 12:13
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Police Scotland are actually police England under the Crown of Englands Westminster laws, legislation and Statues ” Scotland Act “…” Nov 22, 12:01
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “AI- Dan “Yes – if in doubt blame the “Anglo” Boo boo! Perfidious Albion wasn’t coined for nuffink. You really…” Nov 22, 11:58
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “The way out for all of the nations of these Isles is some genuine fact finding to the original hoax,…” Nov 22, 11:42
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “What happens when England, Wales and Ireland realise that there is No treaty of Union with Scotland other than a…” Nov 22, 11:23
    • James Barr Gardner on Mind Your Business: “Police Scotland refused to issue an incident number for the report of crime of reset, their answer it was covered…” Nov 22, 11:04
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “@Geri 9:08 Biolabs. You forgot the biolabs. Also the Nazis. And the baby eating. Take your time, Geri, as otherwise…” Nov 22, 08:57
    • Minceheid on Mind Your Business: “Hatey McHateface says: 21 November, 2026 at 4:47 pm It’s not something you can do all by yourself, MH. You’ll…” Nov 22, 08:22
    • twathater on Mind Your Business: “Andee has stated that 3/4 of uk citizens either want back into the EU or want to work closer with…” Nov 22, 03:09
    • twathater on Mind Your Business: “THAT is a great idea ,as one who has repeatedly proposed and promoted that DONORS get together and instigate a…” Nov 22, 02:43
    • Aidan on Mind Your Business: “Yes – if in doubt blame the “Anglo”” Nov 22, 01:40
    • Anthem on Mind Your Business: “Because their fat controller is a member of the cabinet.” Nov 22, 00:25
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “Confused is correct. The EU was colonised by the yanks & the wankers in Blighty, the kiss ass errand boy,…” Nov 21, 21:08
    • Hamish M on Mind Your Business: “Breaking news: SNP cancels £60,000 loan repayment owed to Peter Murrell https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c9p83kyryp7zo” Nov 21, 18:20
    • Captain Caveman on Mind Your Business: “To be fair, Spartan, I’m surprised you give Confused’s inane arse-drippings the time of day. Funny how the “english” [sic]…” Nov 21, 17:29
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “It’s not something you can do all by yourself, MH. You’ll need somebody to shovel your shite on a daily…” Nov 21, 16:47
    • Hatey McHateface on The Shots You Don’t Take: “You don’t really want to know the answer, Confused. Very probably far more than you.” Nov 21, 16:34
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Seriously? So you’re another antisemite blaming the Jews for everything? Or is what Confused’s angling at going over the top…” Nov 21, 16:31
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Always helps to hear the view from The Kremlin. Cheers, Geri.” Nov 21, 16:27
    • Spartan 117 on Mind Your Business: “For once, a sensible post from Confused that sums up the state of the European Disunion and the “thinking”, if…” Nov 21, 16:02
    • A2 on How To Change People’s Minds: “That Moawri link takes you off this page (which I was trying to read)on to your x link for the…” Nov 21, 14:57
    • Andy Wiltshire on Mind Your Business: “Was it anonymous again?” Nov 21, 14:46
    • James on Mind Your Business: “Excellent. Keep ’em coming. The squealers will appear ony meenit.” Nov 21, 13:32
    • Confused on The Shots You Don’t Take: “questions that need answered (a selection) “So, Nikki – how much fanny have you had?” SNP gov is full of…” Nov 21, 13:25
    • Confused on Mind Your Business: “the EU was a good idea to begin with – a west european trading bloc and a counterbalance to overweening…” Nov 21, 13:17
    • Minceheid on Mind Your Business: “Hatey McHateface says: 21 November, 2026 at 9:42 am I don’t understand it myself, but it seems there is no…” Nov 21, 11:49
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: ““They’re not gonna be wanting to hear any of your puerile shite.” You better STFU then. The EU won’t exist.…” Nov 21, 10:53
  • A tall tale



↑ Top