The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Migration and unemployment

Posted on January 13, 2014 by

Chapter 10 of “The Claim Of Scotland”.

claim10

Quote Of The Chapter:

“The relative stagnation of industry which has been described earlier means more than a mere failure to increase material wealth. The resulting unemployment has caused many of the youngest and most vigorous men and women to seek their fortunes elsewhere.

In economic decline Scotland could still survive; but a disproportionate drain on her resources of mind and character, great as they are, must mean in the end that Scotland will cease to be herself.”

On the upside, of course, if everyone leaves it does lower the unemployment figures.

15 to “Migration and unemployment”

  1. SquareHaggis says:

    Rev, you forgot to link the .pdf šŸ˜€

    Reply
  2. Jim T says:

    Sorry rev, unable to open the full chapter. Ā Just get a single image jpeg.
    Need my daily fix of “claim”Ā 

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “Sorry rev, unable to open the full chapter. Just get a single image jpeg.”

      That’s because I’m a giant balloon. Try now.

      Reply
  3. SquareHaggis says:

    Cheers šŸ™‚

    Reply
  4. Jim T says:

    proper hero – not balloon (giant or otherwise) :-))

    Reply
  5. Paul Kelly says:

    The Irish got by relying on the Emigration boat for years. Every time the economy becomes a bit dodgy they pile on the first available flight out of there. I remember some idiot a few years ago who was working as a teacher in Libya. Teaching rich Libya’s with the advantage of huge wages and no tax that the Irish economy was so bad that he had been forced to go to places like Libya to look for work. (yep he sounded a right tit). Anyway it work’s for them because only the well off and really stupid are left. Makes for low house prices and loads of room.

    Reply
  6. Atypical_Scot says:

    In economic decline Scotland could still survive; but a disproportionate drain on her resources of mind and character, great as they are, must mean in the end that Scotland will cease to be herself.
    Ā 
    That Scotland would cease to be the same perhaps. Still inherently Scotland.

    Reply
  7. gordoz says:

    Hey stu : Did you see you get a mention on BellaĀ  re ‘Claim of Scotland’ ?
    link to bellacaledonia.org.uk

    Reply
  8. Lanarkist says:

    Groundhog millennium, cycles of mismanagement and obsruction, apathy and greed controlled through managed decline and resource malappropriation.

    Has anything really fundamentally changed in the mindset of Westminster with regards to Scotland. Always throwing a googly, twisting any chance of improvement to screw another few bob out of the populace whilst smiling reassuringly and patronising the natives. They behave like shareholders stripping out the majority share for themselves and their families and associates.
    Ā 
    This ties in with the earlier chapter of Preventing Scottish representation and directly working against the idea of Scotland having specific, particular needs addressed by experts from the local culture, ignoring Scots Law and dismissing the Equal Partnership clauses inherent in the Act of Union.
    Ā 
    This book is very powerful, a snapshot of a countries governance almost half a century ago With references to similar injustices going back another hundred years, a snapshot of half the time the Union has existed. Really shameful and makes the bank crash of 2008 and subsequent rescue of the City of London fall into place.Ā 
    It is just the way it has always been.
    Ā 
    These political types really know how to operate in the fast lane, especially where their own enrichment is involved.
    Ā 
    rage/rant over.

    Reply
  9. fairiefromtheearth says:

    Lanarkist the worst thing is they made the banking collapse on purpose the would be rulers of Earth, just another way to strip the wealth out of the citizens of the planet, keep them poor and divided, thats the way they have been doing it from day one.

    Reply
  10. Ted says:

    The tone of this chapter seems to be overtly racist/xenophobic towards the Irish Catholic immigrants. Ā Many came to Scotland before 1916 as citizens of the UK, which Scotland also belonged to. Ā At that time they were British citizens moving from one part of Britain to a different part of Britain. Ā The author still appears to regard the Irish Catholics as outsiders, why has no-one commented on this aspect? Ā To be honest it sounds a bit Enoch Powellish to me. Ā He seems to suggest being of Irish Catholic descent is somehow inferior. Ā A bit like the Westminster attitude to Scotland Ā that we are rightly condemning.

    Reply
  11. yerkitbreeks says:

    @ Ted Ā Agreed, but this is his most emotive chapter with a final need to “fight” for Scotland. I do not think he is getting at the Irish as a race, but again at the blindness of the London masters who ignored the demography of ” North Britain “. Currently though, there has been blogging about how New Labour might “use” the Catholic vote around Glasgow this year, so there may be a legacy, we shall see.

    Reply
  12. John Jamieson says:

    Having browsed the contents pages from the first PDF, I was dreading this chapter.Ā  It was of its time and thank goodness times have changed.

    Reply
  13. James D says:

    @Ted That’s probably why this book doesn’t have a greater readership, excellent up to that part then crashes and burns on the type of casual anti-Irish racism and anti-Catholic bigotry which was considered normal back then and is still quite prevalent today – shame really.
    He expresses exactly the same attitude towards the Irish that he bemoans in the English.

    Reply
  14. Hetty says:

    Wow, I think this is an eye opener. It is seemingly leaning toward being anti-Irish and with little favour for Catholic immigrants. There was much more of an open dislike of Catholic folk back then, which would be unacceptable now. (I know our school in Gateshead had run ins with the local Catholic school, always seemed quite daft to me). I do not think the argument here was meant to be racist however.

    When taken in context, he was stating what happened in terms of the issues of emigration and immigration, and laying the problems at the feet of that lot down in Westminster, in which the agenda was certainly not about creating a fair society with equal rights for the people in all parts of the union, indeed the plan looked to be to depopulate and carry on with divide and rule as normal.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,870 Posts, 1,235,151 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • willie on Shield Of The Phantom: “One thing to also consider is that with the rapid development of AI the industry needs two very key things…Jan 30, 00:42
    • Alf Baird on Shield Of The Phantom: ““Over time their cultures merged.” Linguistic evidence rather suggests divergence. In most former Pictish areas from the lowlands to the…Jan 29, 21:31
    • Saffron Robe on Shield Of The Phantom: “If a judgement is selective rather than objective, it ceases to be a judgement of law and becomes merely an…Jan 29, 20:58
    • Lorna Campbell on Shield Of The Phantom: “Aidan: the Treaty could not have been spent on the accession of the two states into the one state, the…Jan 29, 20:54
    • Cynicus on Shield Of The Phantom: “I have just encountered an ā€œAI detector ā€œ online: it is called justdone.com. I am afraid I cannot recommend it…Jan 29, 20:32
    • Aidan on Shield Of The Phantom: “Do please tell us all about this sea power Northcode, is there any large-output tidal energy project anywhere in Scotland…Jan 29, 19:46
    • Cynicus on Shield Of The Phantom: “ā€œ..the new evidence aqq Aā€ ====== Sorry for this gibberish in my long post above. The phrase should read, ā€œthe…Jan 29, 19:37
    • Northcode on Shield Of The Phantom: ““Scotland already possesses key competitive advantages in marine energy, including abundant natural resources and dedicated enterprise agencies. The country’s marine…Jan 29, 18:50
    • sam on Shield Of The Phantom: “Gaels and Picts combined to face the threat of the Vikings. Over time their cultures merged.Jan 29, 18:42
    • Cynicus on Shield Of The Phantom: “Lorna Campbell says: 29 January, 2026 at 2:12 pm ā€œAI spews out according to that which you put in, Cynicus.…Jan 29, 18:39
    • sam on Shield Of The Phantom: “It is not 25% of the Scottish population, It is a turnout of at least 50% of those registered to…Jan 29, 18:36
    • Hatey McHateface on Shield Of The Phantom: “So you don’t even grant them the basic courtesy of calling our ancestors by their own names? Preferring to use…Jan 29, 18:35
    • Northcode on Shield Of The Phantom: ““In summary, Scotland’s marine energy resources have the potential to significantly contribute to its energy output, aligning closely with the…Jan 29, 18:34
    • Northcode on Shield Of The Phantom: ““Indeed so, these are immense energy surpluses that would be earning Scots around Ā£100 billion a year…” Yes, Alf. The…Jan 29, 18:27
    • Hatey McHateface on Shield Of The Phantom: “Some good points made by David Davis and yourself, factchecker. My view is that if people can’t be arsed to…Jan 29, 18:26
    • Northcode on Shield Of The Phantom: “Long before the arrival of The Christ the sixteen tribes held sway across the northern lands. So effective were their…Jan 29, 18:16
    • agentx on Shield Of The Phantom: “@ Saffron Robe – interesting – thanks.Jan 29, 18:15
    • factchecker on Shield Of The Phantom: ““Our view is that a reasonable level for the threshold that determines a settled will is that at least half…Jan 29, 18:00
    • Hatey McHateface on Shield Of The Phantom: “Oh, give it a rest, Alf. If Scotland has a renewable leccy surplus on one of those days when the…Jan 29, 17:15
    • sam on Shield Of The Phantom: “5 Regional Assemblies During the second reading of the Regional Assemblies (Preparations) Bill 2002-03 the Conservative spokesman, David Davis, expressed…Jan 29, 16:06
    • factchecker on Shield Of The Phantom: “The 2015 election was the one when Nicola Sturgeon specifically stated that a vote for the SNP was not a…Jan 29, 15:16
    • Aidan on Shield Of The Phantom: “@Alf – so in a future independent Scotland electricity bills would amount to around 33% of GDP? Sounds like a…Jan 29, 14:19
    • Aidan on Shield Of The Phantom: “Okay so yet more lying, I honestly don’t know what you seek to gain out of saying things that are…Jan 29, 14:16
    • Lorna Campbell on Shield Of The Phantom: “That may be true, but, if you know anything about AI, it will try to find the answers to that…Jan 29, 14:12
    • Hatey McHateface on Shield Of The Phantom: “@Lorna Globalisation has worked on the most stupendously successful scale for the Chinese. Just as it is currently working unbelievably…Jan 29, 14:02
    • Alf Baird on Shield Of The Phantom: ““Are they acting in the interests of Scotland” If the SNP leadership were acting in the interest of Scots we…Jan 29, 14:02
    • Alf Baird on Shield Of The Phantom: ““Wind power is so abundant in Scotland” Indeed so, these are immense energy surpluses that would be earning Scots around…Jan 29, 13:58
    • Hatey McHateface on Shield Of The Phantom: “Gonna level with you, Confused, these days I really miss your antisemitism. What I’d love to know is why you’ve…Jan 29, 13:54
    • Peter McAvoy on Shield Of The Phantom: “If John Swinney said we can have among the cheapest power in Europe why doesn’t he do it and say…Jan 29, 13:48
    • Lorna Campbell on Shield Of The Phantom: “Confused: good comment. No public utility should be outwith state control for precisely the reasons you have listed. Also, the…Jan 29, 13:46
  • A tall tale



↑ Top