The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Lies and the lying liars who tell them

Posted on February 11, 2011 by

Just got back from Bath’s opulent Guildhall, where the Deputy Prime Minister held a “question and answer session” with 200 voters. For most of it, he was stood no more than 18 inches in front of me, in such a manner that I could easily have kicked him hard in the nuts without even getting out of my chair.

I must report, with dishonour, that I failed you.

Remarkably, despite a heavy police presence, the untamed electorate was let in to the building with only cursory checks on bags, and no security checks at all for those of us not carrying one. You had to show photo ID at the door (I used my Bath Discovery card), but nobody was visibly taking note of names or anything. Had I had a gun or six-inch hunting knife about my person, nobody would have made any attempt to separate me from it before I entered the presence of the United Kingdom’s second-in-command.

(I suspect this says more about the status of the office of Deputy PM than it does about the state’s confidence in Bath’s respectable law-abiding citizens, but it was a bit of a surprise all the same.)

Clegg entered the room from a side door, to a mixture of applause and very loud booing, which I don’t think helps. If someone’s come to answer your questions, don’t make out before he’s even opened his mouth that your mind’s made up and he’s wasting his time. If nothing else, it allows him to dismiss any legitimate grievances as kneejerk prejudice.

Annoyingly I didn’t get to ask my question, which would have been something along these lines:

“In 2015, when you’re asking for our vote again and signing your name to pledges promising what you’ll do if you get it, should we believe you?”

I was quite pleased with it (especially the formulation “should we?” as opposed to “why should we?”, and it would have been particularly instructive to hear his response in the light of the many weak excuses he made to defend the Lib Dems’ betrayal over tuition fees. Now as I’ve said before, I don’t actually feel that strongly about tuition fees per se, but Clegg’s attempts at justification made me even angrier than I’d been already.

His line was basically “Labour and the Tories both wanted to raise fees and we didn’t win the election, so as the minority party we had to compromise and we did the best deal we could in terms of the pupil premium and access for lower-income blah blah blah”. Which is fine so far as it goes, but it raises a couple of fairly compelling issues.

1. The Lib Dems can’t, presumably, have thought that in a hundred million years they might have won an outright majority in May. Given how stacked the First Past The Post system is against them, even if their pre-election poll ratings had held up rather than collapsing they’d have been third place by a long distance in terms of seats.

2. So why on Earth, given that situation, would you take the extraordinary step of signing an incredibly specific pledge that you knew you would have to not only break but do the exact opposite of, whichever party you formed a coalition with? Why, as the only party retaining any level of public trust whatsoever, would you so suicidally discredit yourselves when you didn’t have to?

There are of course only two possible honest answers to that question. Either that you deliberately and cynically lied in order to grab the student vote, or that you expected the Tories to win an absolute majority, letting you vote against the fee increases piously (and equally cynically) from the impotent safety of opposition.

The former is a bit too guileless and short-sighted to be plausible, which only leaves the latter, and it would have been interesting to see how he tried to avoid it. Sadly, we’ll never know. Clegg spent most of the hour spouting clearly prepared paragraphs of empty politician waffle so bland I had to keep digging my nails into my arm to stop my attention wandering off or getting my iPhone out for a quick game of Monsterball A.

The mask only slipped a couple of times, when he became quite venomous and animated in response to questions essentially implying that he was colluding in a right-wing Tory government, which of course he is. But the only question that clearly threw him a little and made him have to think on his feet was when this blog’s own beloved associate Comrade John X asked him something close to this:

“Is there anything that has happened since the formation of the coalition government about which you’ve felt shame?”

Clegg stumbled around a bit and waffled some filler about the inevitability of compromise, dodging the question until John asked it again, at which point he managed to get out a “No”, which was at least the straightest answer he’d given anyone all night.

(He’d managed to bluster around an excellent question from a young woman who’d asked, in the light of his professed great pride over the new student funding arrangements, whether he’d believed that that, or the very different proposals in the Lib Dem election manifesto, were the best way forward.)

At the end of the allotted hour, and not a minute over, he bid the audience farewell, said he’d enjoyed himself and disappeared as swiftly as he’d entered, having told several incontrovertible lies (“We’re not selling off the forests!”) and left us no more enlightened than we’d been before we arrived. It was an expected, but still depressing, glimpse of the meaningless, empty future of British politics.

Up close he’s surprisingly paunchy.

0 to “Lies and the lying liars who tell them”

  1. RowanDT says:

    "I could easily have kicked him hard in the nuts without even getting out of my chair"
    Reasonably certain you wouldn't have found anything to kick.

    Reply
  2. Patrick Rose says:

    Interesting fact, which I've learnt from my friend who's a member of Conservative Future (I don't hold it against him. Much): The tuition fees weren't high on the agenda when they were dealing.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,995 Posts, 1,254,115 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “@Geri 9:08 Biolabs. You forgot the biolabs. Also the Nazis. And the baby eating. Take your time, Geri, as otherwise…” Nov 22, 08:57
    • Minceheid on Mind Your Business: “Hatey McHateface says: 21 November, 2026 at 4:47 pm It’s not something you can do all by yourself, MH. You’ll…” Nov 22, 08:22
    • twathater on Mind Your Business: “Andee has stated that 3/4 of uk citizens either want back into the EU or want to work closer with…” Nov 22, 03:09
    • twathater on Mind Your Business: “THAT is a great idea ,as one who has repeatedly proposed and promoted that DONORS get together and instigate a…” Nov 22, 02:43
    • Aidan on Mind Your Business: “Yes – if in doubt blame the “Anglo”” Nov 22, 01:40
    • Anthem on Mind Your Business: “Because their fat controller is a member of the cabinet.” Nov 22, 00:25
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “Confused is correct. The EU was colonised by the yanks & the wankers in Blighty, the kiss ass errand boy,…” Nov 21, 21:08
    • Hamish M on Mind Your Business: “Breaking news: SNP cancels £60,000 loan repayment owed to Peter Murrell https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c9p83kyryp7zo” Nov 21, 18:20
    • Captain Caveman on Mind Your Business: “To be fair, Spartan, I’m surprised you give Confused’s inane arse-drippings the time of day. Funny how the “english” [sic]…” Nov 21, 17:29
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “It’s not something you can do all by yourself, MH. You’ll need somebody to shovel your shite on a daily…” Nov 21, 16:47
    • Hatey McHateface on The Shots You Don’t Take: “You don’t really want to know the answer, Confused. Very probably far more than you.” Nov 21, 16:34
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Seriously? So you’re another antisemite blaming the Jews for everything? Or is what Confused’s angling at going over the top…” Nov 21, 16:31
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Always helps to hear the view from The Kremlin. Cheers, Geri.” Nov 21, 16:27
    • Spartan 117 on Mind Your Business: “For once, a sensible post from Confused that sums up the state of the European Disunion and the “thinking”, if…” Nov 21, 16:02
    • A2 on How To Change People’s Minds: “That Moawri link takes you off this page (which I was trying to read)on to your x link for the…” Nov 21, 14:57
    • Andy Wiltshire on Mind Your Business: “Was it anonymous again?” Nov 21, 14:46
    • James on Mind Your Business: “Excellent. Keep ’em coming. The squealers will appear ony meenit.” Nov 21, 13:32
    • Confused on The Shots You Don’t Take: “questions that need answered (a selection) “So, Nikki – how much fanny have you had?” SNP gov is full of…” Nov 21, 13:25
    • Confused on Mind Your Business: “the EU was a good idea to begin with – a west european trading bloc and a counterbalance to overweening…” Nov 21, 13:17
    • Minceheid on Mind Your Business: “Hatey McHateface says: 21 November, 2026 at 9:42 am I don’t understand it myself, but it seems there is no…” Nov 21, 11:49
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: ““They’re not gonna be wanting to hear any of your puerile shite.” You better STFU then. The EU won’t exist.…” Nov 21, 10:53
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “I don’t understand it myself, but it seems there is no doubt about it – the people are speaking -…” Nov 21, 09:42
    • Chas on Mind Your Business: “It would not surprise me to learn that the Scottish Government are channeling funds to an entity called ‘Scottish Nature…” Nov 21, 09:35
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Good idea. I’m sick of playing SNP Doom.” Nov 21, 08:33
    • 100%Yes on Mind Your Business: “Game in the making, SNP grand theft auto 7.” Nov 21, 08:18
    • Hatey McHateface on The Shots You Don’t Take: ““I’m sure you’ll leave me something exciting to read in the morning” A fictitious post! Hoaching with illusory insights and…” Nov 21, 08:09
    • Aidan on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Thanks for posting all of this Geri – it’s a lovely read, obviously total nonsense as per usual. I’d love…” Nov 21, 00:47
    • Geri on The Shots You Don’t Take: “It is a fictitious Union. Even yoons can’t wait to tell us we’re not an equal partner. We’ve no seat…” Nov 20, 21:24
    • Hatey McHateface on The Shots You Don’t Take: “Another believer in the “fictitious union”! Ever thought of going in for mime, Geri? You’d be excellent at acting out…” Nov 20, 20:28
    • Geri on The Shots You Don’t Take: “It isn’t a requirement. We’ve just heard a team of international lawyers argue this very subject at the ICJ regarding…” Nov 20, 19:58
  • A tall tale



↑ Top