The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Kettle, meet pot

Posted on February 11, 2012 by

It’s almost like they don’t even know they’re doing it, the poor loves.

“The First Minister was selective in his definition of a ‘gauleiter’ in the Holyrood chamber on Thursday.”

That’s Ruth Davidson, quoted disapproving of the FM’s shady behaviour in a Scottish Conservatives press release today. And it’s a strong point – there’s nothing worse than using definitions selectively to support your own case, right? But wait, what’s this?

“Alex Salmond described it as the kind of decision made by a tin-pot dictatorship populated by ‘gauleiters’ – which, according to the Chambers dictionary is a Nazi official.”

That’s the very same press release, just a few lines earlier. And unless we’re very much mistaken, what it’s doing is… you guessed it, readers. It’s selectively quoting from the dictionary definition of a “gauleiter”. Oops! Our wife’s going to kill us, etc.

But in fact, it’s rather worse than just selective – as the Collins definition quite clearly notes, “Gauleiter” in a Nazi context must have a capital “G”, because all German nouns are capitalised. If you write the word all in lower-case (as the Tory press release attributes to the FM) you’re explicitly citing the non-Nazi definition, which means that according to the Tories themselves, Salmond’s usage is correct and theirs is wrong.

And the Chambers definition they refer to makes things worse still – it explicitly refers to the Nazi definition as “historical”, meaning the current usage of the word is indeed to describe a petty bureaucrat. It also states that the former definition is only applicable to the period “under the Nazi regime”, which as far as we’re aware ended in 1945. (Germany has no Gauleiters nowadays.) In other words, unless you’re directly referring to specific events that took place in Germany under Adolf Hitler, the ONLY legitimate current definition of the word “gauleiter” is the one the First Minister used.

We’re sure the Scottish Conservatives would be embarrassed at this shocking display of both rank hypocrisy and basic grammatical ignorance, except that looking at what they’re doing to the unemployed, the disabled, and the sick at the moment, we’re forced to conclude that the Tories have no shame at all.

1 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. 12 02 12 17:33

    Round Up #01: Jan – Feb 2012 « Skull and Saltire

7 to “Kettle, meet pot”

  1. Scottish republic says:

    It's pathetic that's the best they've got is this against our natonal movement.  But that is all they've got because they are sitting on 300 years of corrupt empire building which has been reduced to zilch.
    We on the other hand wish to accomplish something for our country and countryfolk

    Reply
  2. Bugger (the Panda) says:

    Ruth Davidson appears to be an idiot.
     
    That is a selective quotation from me.

    Reply
  3. Shodan says:

    Ruth also "forgets" about all the comparisons to dictators that have been made to Alex, as she fails to complain or bring this up at any time. When SNP members are outright insulted or threatened they are told it should be shrugged off by her and her kind. She also fails to notice that the very same term has been used in parliament many times, by her own party no less. If it is okay for MPs, Lords and the media to use it and she doesn't complain about it then she's only making herself look pathetic and hypocritical, but then this is Ruth Davidson and she is rather dim and a very bad politician.
     
    Would we expect any better from someone who used valuable FMQ time to call someone fat instead of doing anything worth while or to justify her pay? This is how far the unionists have sunk. Truly pathetic bunch.

    Reply
  4. Diane says:

    Every day is a school day right enough.
    By the way, how does one pronounce it?
     

    Reply
  5. Shodan says:

    Big news for Scotland today. Apparently Whitney Housten has died. A tragic blow for the independence movement, I'm sure you will agree:
     
    link to newsnetscotland.com
     
    The SNP and Scotland will never recover from this. Thank goodness for quality journalism at NNS raising the bar and letting us know about all these Scottish events.

    Reply
  6. Shodan says:

    @ Diane
     
    GOW-LIGHTER, from what I can tell.

    Reply
  7. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    @Shodan, Diane: Yes, that's correct.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,785 Posts, 1,221,407 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Andy Ellis on The Con Merchant: “Chiefly between the ears it would seem.Jul 5, 14:52
    • Confused on The Con Merchant: “Apologies Klingfilm – you are obviously a high class gentlemen. “book knowing” is not for everyone. “everyone is clever, nowadays”…Jul 5, 14:39
    • James on The Con Merchant: “I’m not fat I’m big boned.Jul 5, 14:25
    • Mark Beggan on Too Tight To Mention: “Have you taken your medication?Jul 5, 14:14
    • Captain Caveman on The Con Merchant: “@Confused Nah. Went to a third rate comprehensive (subsequently put into “special measures”) – got expelled at 16 and straight…Jul 5, 14:08
    • Aidan on The Con Merchant: “If my hobby is debating constitutional law, then what would you describe your hobby as?Jul 5, 14:08
    • Confused on Too Tight To Mention: “Northcode – I think I know why main is getting so wound up about myths and legends – it is…Jul 5, 13:55
    • Confused on The Con Merchant: “Lickle Aidan and his historian / constitutional lawyering fantasies, bless. We all need a hobby. You can do a course…Jul 5, 13:53
    • Confused on The Con Merchant: “where did u go to skool caveman klingfilm a decent public (private school) I hope how often did you get…Jul 5, 13:50
    • Aidan on The Con Merchant: “I think a copy of these posts with an appropriately worded covering letter to whichever university supposedly educated “confused” might…Jul 5, 13:41
    • Aidan on The Con Merchant: “@Xaracen – you are right, I had misinterpreted what your comment meant. Please celebrate this small victory in an appropriate…Jul 5, 13:34
    • Captain Caveman on The Con Merchant: “Your latest coherent, ever-eloquent post, with trademark faultless syntax and punctuation [sub please check] causes me to ponder the likely…Jul 5, 13:31
    • Aidan on Too Tight To Mention: “@Hatey – I’m guessing there’s some truth in this part of the story though; “I needed some extra cash for…Jul 5, 13:20
    • Captain Caveman on The Con Merchant: “Yeah, we heard you the first time, Fatso. Your calling me a “tosser” in between flicking TV channels via remote…Jul 5, 13:19
    • Confused on The Con Merchant: “lochinvar – you have to remember with our persistent friends that they project, as they are narcissists, thus – every…Jul 5, 13:10
    • James on The Con Merchant: “* You’ve certainly proved time and again on this site that you’re a ‘tosser’ right enough….Jul 5, 12:49
    • James on The Con Merchant: “You’ve certainly proved time and again on this site that you’re a ‘tosser’ tight enough….Jul 5, 12:47
    • James on The Con Merchant: “Come on now, everyone. The Franchise Fanny has spoken. End of debate. As you were.Jul 5, 12:44
    • Dan on Too Tight To Mention: ““Deprive the people of their National Consciousness, treat them as a tribe and not a Nation, dilute their National pride,…Jul 5, 12:39
    • Mark Beggan on Too Tight To Mention: “What is ten Shillings?Jul 5, 12:31
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Con Merchant: “« There is evidence of a formative Scots language at the time of the Dalriada Scots takeover of Pictavia, and…Jul 5, 12:09
    • Dan on Too Tight To Mention: “@Andy Jeezo, anything to have a go ya fud. The point wasn’t that I couldn’t search and provide the result,…Jul 5, 12:02
    • Hatey McHateface on The Con Merchant: ““a falsehood and discriminates against the Scots language and Scots speaking majority” I’ve already corrected you on this, Alf, yet…Jul 5, 11:57
    • Aidan on Too Tight To Mention: “@Alf – is that a review of your own work?Jul 5, 11:55
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “Is it possible that Grok is “living in fear”? Somebody should ask.Jul 5, 11:45
    • Captain Caveman on The Con Merchant: “@Xaracen For the third time of (polite) asking, please explain what success looks like in your view, in a 12-month…Jul 5, 11:41
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “Sorry, NC, not buying it. Burns wrote of the “honest men” of Ayr. They would never have let you in.…Jul 5, 11:41
    • Northcode on Too Tight To Mention: “Starship Troopers (1997) – unbelievable that 28 years have passed since I first saw that movie on the big screen.…Jul 5, 11:40
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: ““the fact is under London rule we are in perpetual socio-economic crisis” The fact is we are fighting the new…Jul 5, 11:36
    • Alf Baird on Too Tight To Mention: “AI may be the fashionable go-to tool but is hardly an acceptable refereed academic publication, unlike like this one which…Jul 5, 11:35
  • A tall tale



↑ Top