The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Keeping the fire burning

Posted on December 12, 2024 by

Since it was founded back in November 2011, Wings Over Scotland has been solely financed by its readers. The site has never carried any advertising, we have no secret corporate backers, everything we do is funded by transparent voluntary donations and subscriptions, mostly of a few pounds a month.

We have the freedom to write what we believe, thanks to you, our readers. And since those earliest days, opponents have tried to end that freedom by blocking our funding.

Our crowdfunders were accused by Scottish MSM hacks of being a fraudulent lie.

Unionists and others have repeatedly (unsuccessfully) reported us to HMRC with false allegations of tax evasion. And since we started campaigning against gender ideology almost seven years ago, in January 2018, transactivists in particular have relentlessly tried to shut our fundraising platforms down, sometimes successfully.

The last time we did a crowdfunder to support Wings’ work, a little over two years ago, Ko-Fi shut the page down after a concerted barrage of complaints from transactivists, openly stating that “anti-trans material” was the reason.

That is of course unequivocally unlawful discrimination, as per Forstater vs CGD Europe, but Ko-Fi blackmailed us against taking legal action by saying they’d keep paying subs if we didn’t sue them, they just wouldn’t let any more be taken out.

Fighting in court would have cost hundreds of thousands of pounds we didn’t have, and taken years (Maya’s case took four years to fully play out), during which Wings wouldn’t have been able to continue, so we had little choice.

But it means that our income falls steadily as subscribers drop away for one reason or another over time, with no way to replace them. (It’s currently still at a sustainable level, don’t panic. We live a very modest lifestyle, other than vast cartooning fees, and there are no bailiffs kicking the doors in.)

Anyway, long story short, Twitter has finally – after six months of waiting – enabled subscriptions on our account. We’ve set them at the lowest level allowed by the system – $2 a month, which is about £1.55 in UK money.

If you can spare it, and you want to support our work on Scottish independence, women’s rights, LGB rights and child protection – or you just enjoy Bear Patrol pics and our incisive commentary on pizza toppings, football and Bullseye – please consider helping out with the price of a share bag of nice salt’n’vinegar crisps a month by clicking the cute little pink “Subscribe” button on our bio page.

(NB Your money will almost certainly actually be spent on a share bag of salt’n’vinegar crisps. Especially the Co-op’s hand-cooked Sea-salt-and-Chardonnay ones, because we’re pretty lah-de-dah now.)

If you can’t spare it or you don’t want to support any of that stuff (or if you already do), then don’t bother, obviously. Thanks for reading.

0 to “Keeping the fire burning”

  1. sarah says:

    Well I don’t think you can eat that many crisps but I’ll make the attempt to send you a contribution. Can’t promise I will manage it – Peter A Bell’s system defeated me the other day and I had to WRITE a cheque and POST IT!!!

    Reply
  2. Captain Caveman says:

    Subscribed. Been reading the blog for years, it’s only fair.

    You probably don’t want to hear this, Stu (lol) but we are quite aligned politically as well these days, too! Good stuff, more power to your elbow.

    Reply
  3. Skip_NC says:

    Sea salt and Chardonnay? I cannot possibly agree to help fund such gastronomic murder. Well, not unless the Chardonnay identifies as the finest claret.

    My meagre monthly contribution leaves my bank account every month. Is there any need to finally cave in and set up a Twitter account if that continues?

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      No, all current subs will continue, no need to change anything. And thanks 🙂

      Reply
      • Vestas says:

        I’ve asked a couple of times via the contact form* and had no reply – is the only way to cancel the “ko-fi” subs by getting the card company to do it?

        *which I know wasn’t working but then you said it was. Meh – WordPress…

      • Carol Neill says:

        Thanks for that , would hate to have to join twatter to continue my paltry sum

  4. Graf Midgehunter says:

    Sarah said:

    “Well I don’t think you can eat that many crisps….”
    —————

    You don’t know the Rev, Sarah…!

    That guy has heavy duty reinforced teeth, cupboards/fridges full of tasty goodies and is the picture boy of all dentists in Bath.

    Crisps are just an Appetizer for him…. 🙂 🙂

    Reply
    • sarah says:

      I know and I worry about him!

      Reply
      • Geri says:

        Have you seen his walk in larder? I’m well jel. It’s like his very own tuck shop so it is! I reckon it’s more than posh Chardonnay crisps he’s been squirreling for later! There was shelves of pop too! I fleetingly thought of converting my spare room. It was inspiring..LOL..

        Looks over at the sad crinkled & damp digestive I have …meh. Maybe next year..

  5. TurnbullDrier says:

    @Rev, Do you have a preference?

    Currently donate via kofi, but presumably they take a cut..

    Quite happy to migrate to this method if you’d prefer?

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      No, if you’re already donating there’s no merit in going to the hassle of switching. And thanks 🙂

      Reply
      • Jay says:

        I am nearly antedeluvian.What other methods exist for donations, either single payment or recurring?

      • Sven says:

        If you press the “Donate” in the list of headings at the top of the page you can give one offs through PayPal without an account with a Visa card or similar.
        Being an analogue guy in a digital world myself that’s what I do.

      • Jay says:

        Thank you, Sven, and to Rev Stu. Have used paypal, sorry only v small contribution per month.

        I learn a lot from Wings, various topics. Always hoping for good news concerning downfall of Murrells and conspirators against Mr. Salmond.

      • Robert Matthews says:

        So you can’t put your money where your big mouth is. Cheapskate.

      • Jay says:

        Oh dear, what a disappointment, me and my big mouth, wonder what irritated you. Please do tell.

        I had been thinking to ask more about the fascist movement. Are you old enough to remember Jeffrey Hamm? Most amiable and helpful chap. Maybe you should follow his example. He must have died by now.

        Do you read and comment here as an English suppoerter of Scots independence or as an English (or some other nationality) fascist saboteur?

      • twathater says:

        Who the fuck do you think you are trying to demean someone because of their financial situation, the Rev has stated that people can donate if they can afford it, but if they cannot no problem , so Mr Rich guy tell us the exorbitant amount you are donating, you’ve been on here for the past couple of months flapping yir gums so out with it BIG MOUTH

      • Robert Hughes says:

        My income fluctuates wildly , Stu – I work outdoors and the weather , eg currently , often affects my ability to work ; so , I’ll just continue to donate when my finances permit

      • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

        Much appreciated. Never leave yourself short on my account, we’re doing okay.

      • Robert Hughes says:

        Cheers , Stu

  6. Milady Lynne says:

    I’ve just done a PayPal. Hope that’s OK. Lx

    Reply
  7. Ruby says:

    FYI Vinegar is French vin + aigre (sour). Sour wine.

    Just Chardonnay Vinegar would be fine.

    I also have a problem with Hand cooked sea salt. WTF?

    You can make wine vinegar at home by leaving an open bottle of wine in a warm place.

    These crisps need a better name.

    I don’t like salt & vinegar crisps whether it’s balsamic, white, malt or left over Buckfast.

    Reply
  8. Phil says:

    Subscribed. I’ve been reading Wings for free (apart from a single, one-off contribution) regularly for years and feeling very guilty about it. Enjoy your crisps!

    Reply
  9. Geoff Anderson says:

    I will do a deal with you.
    I already support you through the old system but you have me blocked from your Twitter account. Unblock me and I will set up a second donation.

    I don’t know why you blocked me?

    Reply
    • lee says:

      Just donated some money. Many thanks for all the brilliant, much needed articles and for all the work you do in the struggle to regain our country’s independence. Appreciated.

      Lee

      Reply
  10. JOHN TALBOT says:

    already donating Rev, keep up the good work

    Reply
  11. Mark Beggan says:

    This post was brought to you by the guys who really care and share.

    Reply
  12. Mark Beggan says:

    Become a lesbian and the Scottish government will through cash at you.

    Reply
  13. Hugh Wallace says:

    On the basis that some of your subscribers have dropped off I am increasing my donation via PayPal. Whatever I am paying you is a bare token of what you are worth, Stuart.

    Reply
  14. sarah says:

    Thanks for the reminder about the Donate button, everyone. Have just used it, and must remember to do so more often!

    Reply
  15. Astonished says:

    The small amount I give you every month is money well spent.

    Reply
  16. McDuff says:

    Contribution made Rev money well spent. You put up with a lot of hassle.

    Reply
  17. Mark Beggan says:

    Empty Crisp packets and psychological profiling.

    Reply
  18. Mac says:

    Removed, meant to post on previous BTL.

    Reply
  19. Robert Pollock says:

    I’d buy you a pint any day. Keep up the greatest work.

    Reply
  20. Gerry Parker says:

    Subscription renewed Stu.

    Reply
  21. Oscar Taime says:

    Hi, happy to sub on Twitter. See my PayPal is going through Ko-Fi which I’ll happily cancel due to their stance BUT looks like there is no option other than £1.55. Is there somewhat to let us send more? Also while not important I like badges so am still hoping for the ones with the monster logo …

    Reply
    • sarah says:

      Hi, Oscar, look at the Donate button at the top of this site – lots of options there for sending more!

      Reply
  22. Shauny Boy says:

    I too am quite la-de-dah now amd appreciate the shoutout for co-op sea salt and chardonnay crisps, they’re the business

    Reply
    • Southernbystander says:

      I like the Co-op tortilla chips. If slumming it I go for the cheese puffs or onion rings.

      Reply
    • Ruby says:

      Hello Shauny Boy! Nice to see you here.

      Thank you for being an artist and enriching my life.
      I love your work.

      PS Salt & vinegar crisps stink worse than
      halitosis. Might want to give them a miss at the Christmas Party where there’s a risk of being caught under the mistletoe.

      Reply
  23. Muscleguy says:

    I can’t subscribe on twitter since you have blocked me.

    Reply
    • sarah says:

      There’s always the Donate button – you can donate by debit card. I did it that way being antediluvian. : )

      Reply
  24. Southernbystander says:

    For the fact this site has provided me with many interesting insights, a few quid donated.

    Reply
  25. K C says:

    If I am still banned and this post is rejected then you can sod off. I didn’t do anything wrong you just didn’t like what I’d written. Time to move on especially if you need money. I’d have got less time for murder. If it goes through I’ll consider it and look into doing it. I read the articles on the site but I’m unable to comment.

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “If I am still banned and this post is rejected then you can sod off. I didn’t do anything wrong you just didn’t like what I’d written.”

      Whoever you are, this shows as your first post so I have no idea what you might have done.

      Reply
      • K C says:

        OK no matter now I’m glad it’s sorted. I’ve got a sub set up through your donate page. Thanks.

  26. Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh says:

    A ‘CHILLING ATTACK ON FREE SPEECH BY MEDIA REGULATOR IPSO
      
    « The Spectator has defended the freedom of speech of one of its journalists, following a reprimand from the Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO).

    « In an article, Gareth Roberts used the phrase “a man who claims to be a woman” when referring to transgender author and columnist Juno Dawson, who lodged a formal complaint to the media watchdog. It ruled the phrase to be “pejorative and prejudicial”.

    « The Spectator published the judgment, as required of the magazine by IPSO, but criticised the decision as an attack on free speech.

    Free speech

    « Michael Gove, Editor of The Spectator, responded: “We publish what Ipso requires of us here. But I am in no doubt this is an outrageous decision, offensive to the principle of free speech and chilling in its effect on free expression.”

    « He continued: “When Gareth Roberts wrote that Juno Dawson is a man who claims to be a woman, he was exercising his right to free speech and indeed expressing a view that many would consider a straightforward truth.”

    « “For The Spectator, free speech is not a cause among many others which we may champion – it is the essence of our existence.”

    « Gove added: “Dawson may have a Gender Recognition Certificate but no piece of paper, whatever it may say, can alter biological reality.

    « “Parliament may pass laws, but they cannot abolish Dawson’s Y chromosome.”

    Pursuing truth

    « Toby Young, Director of the Free Speech Union, said IPSO “has censured The Spectator for publishing an article that is in no way inaccurate or intrusive but which it disapproves of for political reasons. If a press regulator penalises a newspaper or magazine just because it doesn’t like its politics, it is no longer fit for purpose.”

    « Helen Joyce, the Director of Advocacy at women’s rights group Sex Matters, commented: “Ipso’s guidance is biased and illogical. Journalists and editors feel under pressure to accept the fringe belief that people can change sex as settled fact.”

    « The Christian Institute’s James Kennedy stated: “Journalists are right to say what everyone knows – that a man cannot become a woman, no matter what a piece of paper from the government says.”

    « He added: “Courtesy should of course be shown to our trans friends and family, but no one should be punished for stating the truth.” »

    (From The Christian Institute website, 13 Dec 2024)

    Reply
    • sarah says:

      Gove, of all people, doing the right thing.

      Isn’t it hate speech to say a GRC holder is still what their chromosomes are?

      Reply
    • Ruby says:

       “Parliament may pass laws, but they cannot abolish Dawson’s Y chromosome.”

      The GRC is a con to make people believe that the Y chromosome has been abolished.

      Parliament has passed a very bad law that has led to a never ending number of problems.

      It would be great to hear Michael Gove or any politician recognising that fact.

      If Juno Dawson has a GRC then he is
      “a man that the UK Government claims is a woman’
      Michael Gove is part of that government.

      Difficult to know who made the claim first. Maybe Juno went to the doctor and said I have a fetish I like wearing women’s knickers and the doctor said that is because you were born in the wrong body and you are in fact a woman here’s your certificate to prove it. BTW Miss Dawson women can have penises.

      Reply
  27. Ian Brotherhood says:

    Here’s another worthy fundraiser…

    Why don’t we Scots raise enough to buy a big house in one of England’s ‘loveliest villages’ (I dunno, maybe £3,000,000 or thereabouts would be a reasonable target?), then timeshare it, make sure it’s packed with real Scots every day all year-round, pack-out their local pub every night (kick up fuck until they get Tennent’s on draught) erect a huge flagpole in the front garden with a Saltire, then call the local constabulary every time we get bad vibes from the locals?

    ‘If we build it, they will..’ well, they will ‘what’, exactly?

    Reply
    • twathater says:

      I’d donate tae that Ian and we could advertise it on air b&b with only mad Jock parties acceptable

      Reply
      • Ruby says:

        I wouldn’t donate but I might buy the book especially if the local chippy in Bibury was forced to sell deep fried mars bars.

        (Bilbury is in the Cotswolds described by Victorian designer William Morris as “the most beautiful village in England”.)

      • Southernbystander says:

        I mean the real issue here would be forcing people to buy them

      • Ruby says:

        You have totally missed the point Southernbystander.

      • Southernbystander says:

        You underestimate me Ruby

    • Ruby says:

      That would make a good story!

      Reply
    • Robert Hughes says:

      Brilliant idea , Ian ; why don’t we buy the local pub too n have a jukebox that only has songs by The Proclaimers , Dick Gaughan , Dougie MacLean , The Blue Nile ( my faves ) and other Scottish musical luminaries 🙂

      Joking aside ……not so long ago in my ” village ” ( it can hardly be called a ” village ” now such has it’s population been swelled by people from ” elsewhere ” ) one of our can’t-wait-to-be-integrated New Scots put a post up on the local Facebook page complaining about lorries passing by their house in the evening which they claimed – quote ” might disturb our paying guests ” – that’s right …..timber-lorries transporting logs in the area , avoiding using the busy ( in the summer very busy ) A82 by doing some of the work in the evening were just a damn nuisance and might annoy this person’s Air BnB customers therefore should not be allowed to pass their house after 5pm .

      Such is the sense of entitlement by these people ; yet , according to some – too many – we’re supposed to defer to these arrogant arrivistes in the ( vain ) hope they might – if we ask nicely – support Scottish Independence

      NEWS JUST IN ……..not a fckn chance people like those referred to above ever will .They consider Scotland the Northern fringe of England and think/behave accordingly

      If the SNP & it’s Anglo-centric fan club spent half the time informing and cultivating the support of Scots as they do * others * we may see some progress towards becoming a ” nation again “

      Reply
      • Geri says:

        The franchise will sort that problem out.
        Decolonisation has strict rules where the colonisers isn’t considered at all.

        Little England is starting to circle the U bend. R just signed a huge deal with India over oil & they dumped London insurance services in the process LOL

        Fck about, find out.

      • Robert Hughes says:

        Yip , G , Angloville is ( has ) sowing ( sewn ) the seeds of it’s own – if not destruction , certainly severe impoverishment . Trouble is this will likely have the effect of increasing the South to North flight as they seek to exploit the current advantage , eg in terms of property-price differentials , of * suddenly * discovering how much further their finances will go North of the Border

  28. Gordon Millar says:

    Odd….I would be keen to support your fundraising however I am somehow blocked from doing so on your Twitter / X account ?

    Reply
  29. Gary says:

    Does Tesco have the same diminishing returns problem, as people die? I guess they’re rich enough to realise that young people become old people, and the whole cycle repeats ad infinitum?

    Reply
  30. Ian Stewart says:

    Obviously I don’t support the Indy goal as can be seen from my rare posts but I still want to see it discussed earthily on your site; and I definitely support the exposure of trans extremism.

    I don’t do Twitter – is there an alternative method of donating? I’ll have a look at your page banners to see if it’s explained there.

    Reply
    • Ian Stewart says:

      Ah just noticed the PayPal link below, I’ll use that.

      Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,761 Posts, 1,218,469 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Lorn on The shifting sands of memory: “Xaracen: yes, the ToU is, indeed, an international treaty and may be challenged only inn international law. I am getting…May 25, 21:02
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The shifting sands of memory: “Wikipedia: « GEORGE BUCHANAN / SEÒRAS BOCHANAN (1506-1582), native Gaelic-speaker, was a Scottish historian and humanist scholar. « According to historian Keith…May 25, 20:26
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The shifting sands of memory: “HERMAN DOOYEWEERD (Professor of Law and Jurisprudence at the Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam 1926-1965) explained: «The Roman republic started with an…May 25, 20:23
    • Mia on The shifting sands of memory: “That is indeed very interesting, Sarah. There are rumours as well about the ex PM of New Zealand. It is…May 25, 19:38
    • Xaracen on The shifting sands of memory: ““The ToU does not create any rights or obligations in international law, it is domestic law, so outwith the remit…May 25, 19:16
    • sam on The shifting sands of memory: “Andy, 3 years to complete negotiations. Sets a deadline. It can be done by seats won rather than votes cast.May 25, 19:08
    • Young Lochinvar on The shifting sands of memory: “Aidan at 2.40pm It’s bad enough that it might be the case without you wishing it so..May 25, 18:55
    • Young Lochinvar on The shifting sands of memory: “SM; Yup. Idle curiosity makes we wonder if SHE who’s name shall not be uttered is still shacked up for…May 25, 18:46
    • sarah on The shifting sands of memory: “@ Mia at 5.16: “Starmer and the three male models/arsonists”. Phil Boswell has something to say about this on today’s…May 25, 18:41
    • Northcode on The shifting sands of memory: ““a major cultural and legal difference lies between what they regarded as nations following the ‘Latin tradition’ compared with the…May 25, 18:35
    • factchecker on The shifting sands of memory: “A voice of reason.May 25, 18:29
    • Andy Ellis on The shifting sands of memory: “@Sam 5.04 pm What’s with the 3 year thing? All that’s necessary is for all pro-independence parties who support the…May 25, 18:18
    • Andy Ellis on The shifting sands of memory: “@Breastplate 3.19pm Other countries don’t care about the Treaties of Union or 300 year old history, any more than we…May 25, 17:39
    • Mia on The shifting sands of memory: “What is this thing about Starmer and the three U male models? Why is it being said that the three…May 25, 17:16
    • Hatey McHateface on The shifting sands of memory: “What do you reckon, Marie, did they have a hand in the Dandy Dons victory yesterday? I mean, why not,…May 25, 17:04
    • sam on The shifting sands of memory: “What’s the wording of a plebiscitary election to be? This is a tentative try. A majority vote by seats won…May 25, 17:04
    • Hatey McHateface on The shifting sands of memory: “Well, Mia, at least you managed to reply to Andy without blaming Da Dews. (I think. It’s next to impossible…May 25, 16:55
    • Mia on The shifting sands of memory: ““The only plausible route likely to achieve results in any reasonable timescale is to gain a majority in plebiscitary elections,…May 25, 16:27
    • Mark Beggan on The shifting sands of memory: “They are going to paragraph themselves into independence. Paragraph by paragraph.May 25, 16:02
    • SilentMajority on The shifting sands of memory: ““N.. S… has argued the law on the definition of a woman may need to be changed to accommodate trans…May 25, 16:01
    • Breastplate on The shifting sands of memory: “Andy, I agree with some of what you say and there’s room for manoeuvre on others. I think many people…May 25, 15:19
    • Young Lochinvar on The shifting sands of memory: “Over in Tranny-land SHE whose name shall not be uttered is in out of control hose mode again, wanting laws…May 25, 14:55
    • Andy Ellis on The shifting sands of memory: “Why is it “quixotic”? It’s quixotic in the usually accepted definition of the term in that it’s “extremely idealistic; unrealistic…May 25, 14:21
    • Aidan on The shifting sands of memory: “If you’re pinning your hopes on the UN enforcing a vote where only Yes voters are allowed to participate then…May 25, 14:14
    • Young Lochinvar on The shifting sands of memory: “Mia Maybe, maybe not. However it would be interesting to speculate if C3 and his progeny would show up in…May 25, 14:09
    • Young Lochinvar on The shifting sands of memory: “Well well well! Everyone is a lawyer now using Latin terms 🙂 I always wondered where the lawyers were hiding…May 25, 13:57
    • Aidan on The shifting sands of memory: “The ToU does not create any rights or obligations in international law, it is domestic law, so outwith the remit…May 25, 13:56
    • Marie on The shifting sands of memory: “No bigger fan of exceptionalism than you Mr McHasbara.May 25, 13:54
    • James Cheyne on The shifting sands of memory: “The point is that the Westminster parliament ask Scotland to set up the all the struggles for themselves, While it…May 25, 13:15
    • Lorn on The shifting sands of memory: “I would like to make it plain that I am not dissing the esteemed professor. Other equally eminent professors of…May 25, 13:09
  • A tall tale



↑ Top