Dan, I fully sympathise with wanting to bring accountability closer to home – which ironically was what Brexit was all about. MPs hated the idea because for ages they’d blamed every failure on the EU not letting them do stuff. They’ve still not given up on it but they’ve fewer excuses. There is and always will be the courts which revel in doing the opposite of what governments want. Civil Servants too seem to spend their time preventing public will. But those are the realities of both of our countries.
The worst part of the Brexit campaign was about having more money to spend. I’d have rather heard that we’d have less money to spend but could use it more wisely.
You keep banging on about *legitimate referendum* but fail to recognise that route has been deliberately denied regardless of various mandates.
So how do you suggest we have one?
Scotland is already beating the pants of England in outstanding services & it’s doing it within budget & at a cost of over £600 million mitigation against cruel Tory policies we don’t vote for. We’re not permitted to go over our spending money. Our overlords don’t allow it. The money Scotland spends is Scotlands to spend as it pleases. It’s not Westminsters money.
Scotland has more to offer it’s citizens than just oil.
SNP didn’t come up against reality. It didn’t even try. It became more interested in it’s self & maintaining their own position.
England have to grow up. They’ve cut off a referendum like a abuser would to a partner who is leaving. They’ve done the same on immigration – block safe passages of travel & then greet like fuck people arrive *illegal* Who swallows this endless woe is me shite?
Elections are legal & legit. Ignore it & see what happens. A country won’t be held against it’s will.
You talk of Brexit & the EU..
A few questions..
Imagine if they’d said no to a referendum?
Imagine they said you couldn’t leave without their permission.
Imagine they put a % & a time frame on it?
Imagine they held all your country’s money & control of all your assets & gave you peanut pocket money in return.
Imagine they had the whole EU vote on that referendum too.
Imagine they demanded a full future breakdown of your future economic plans?
I think you’d agree it was fucking insane..
That’s yoonland I’ve just explained..
Scotland is a sovereign nation. How she conducts her country is of no concern to nosy neighbours. Improve your own land. Start by campaigning for a devolved parliament & an independence referendum. You’d certainly win.
Geri, I’ve told you, if Scotland leaves I want it to be successful. Loads of people in England have Scottish ancestry and don’t want to see it fail.
I doubt that it will achieve success with the mindset I see here. However, since you don’t think that having persuasive plans to present to future voters is important, I am unlikely to find out how Scotland will fare on its own.
There is already persuasive plans.
None more so than being in charge of our own decisions & what we choose to spend our own money on.
Yoons want to see accounts – guaranteed future economic plans & with guaranteed future outcomes. See Westminster – they won’t hand over the true accounts. They stopped recording them in 1921 because it was too embarrassing for them that Scotland was funding England in full.
It’s just a Yoon delay tactic & everyone knows it.
Scotland is already 50% +
We already vote for independence.
We already know we’re a wealthy country.
We already know we need no one’s permission to leave the union.
We already know there is no Better Together remaining in the Union because we’re already in it & or we’re not.
What part are you missing?
I could have ancestry in Timbuktu – I wouldn’t give a fck what their country voted for in a legitimate election if I didn’t even live there. It would be nothing to to with me.
You still haven’t answered any of my questions. Another Yoon tactic. Answer a question by asking another question.. Zzzzz
You need to spend more of your time on the Englands accounts & future economic plans – they don’t look good.
BTW, don’t pay any heed to the “you don’t live here so wheesht” argument. That’s only ever selectively deployed if you present unanswerable arguments.
There’s plenty of regular posters on here deploying the “Sean Connery” defence – they love Scotland so much they’ve fecked off – usually cos they love paying lower taxes even more.
You don’t have any unanswerable questions. You simply don’t like the answers.
& There’s a huge difference between people who don’t live here having an opinion – to people imposing rules, timelines, percentages & all manner of criteria for a country to jump through to appease them. That’s electoral interference.
& Scotland fecks off because the UK is absolutely shit. Their own prospects are extremely limited & their own country is being turned into a fucking retirement home for yoons snapping up property & to scrounge off the system we provide.
Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.
Heaver on The Grand Tour: “Slag off some minorities. That’ll get you noticed. Works for Farage.” Jun 10, 23:55
Willie on The Grand Tour: “Interesting day tomorrow in parliament. Will the vote on the decision released late tonight by the Scottish Government be enough…” Jun 10, 23:49
Eddie Munster on The Grand Tour: “Alba are list only so to not split the indy vote, they’ve been saying that for a long time now.…” Jun 10, 23:41
Bill Cowan on The Grand Tour: “ALBA a complete no-show? And what of the combination of all the other Indy parties, groups, and individuals, Liberate Scotland?” Jun 10, 23:12
Jim Anderson on The Grand Tour: “S Gethins is earmarked to replace the useless Shona in Dundee East.” Jun 10, 22:40
George Ferguson on The Grand Tour: “Excellent analysis Stu as usual. I can’t disagree with any of it. Slightly disconcerting to me trying to stand as…” Jun 10, 22:22
sarah on The Grand Tour: “Rev, I take it that you don’t think that ANY SNP candidate can lose Edinburgh Eastern, given that Ash Denham/Regan…” Jun 10, 21:57
KEITH HYND on The Grand Tour: “Even if the SNP were the only option on the ballot paper I still wouldn’t vote for them. They need…” Jun 10, 21:50
Aidan on Two Of A Kind: “That’s not what you’ve been saying over the past few weeks and months though is it” Jun 10, 21:39
Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Grand Tour: “Edited, ta.” Jun 10, 21:23
Viscount Ennui on The Grand Tour: “Just wondering if anyone has put in an FOI about how the Scottish bond initiative is going. I am so…” Jun 10, 21:21
Hatey McHateface on Two Of A Kind: ““when did the north and south of Scotland become reconciled, and see themselves as one nation?” Yet to happen, IMO.…” Jun 10, 20:54
@nairnkev on The Grand Tour: “You need to get the slacker cartoonist to produce a visual of a stinking festering corpse blocking the door to…” Jun 10, 20:52
Hatey McHateface on Two Of A Kind: ““the management of North Sea resources” Aha! That’s what’s really getting their goat. It’s Scotland’s oil. They missed a trick…” Jun 10, 20:42
Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Grand Tour: “Eh? I did.” Jun 10, 20:32
sarah on The Grand Tour: “Constituencies SNP 56, Labour 9, LibDem 3, Conservatives 5.” Jun 10, 20:31
Gary on The Grand Tour: “Would it be possible to finish the job, and add up the seats?” Jun 10, 20:13
John McTaggart on The Grand Tour: “Annabelle Ewing is standing down in Cowdenbeath. I’m not sure if the selection has been made yet but I’d think…” Jun 10, 19:37
Dan on Two Of A Kind: “Oh aye, here’s another splitter unable to get behind the original ISP formation. Fucked off to the US because he…” Jun 10, 18:02
sarah on Two Of A Kind: “To clarify the UN procedure for being recognised as a Non-Self-Governing State, an existing member state of the UN can…” Jun 10, 17:29
factfinder on Two Of A Kind: “James says: 10 June, 2025 at 4:13 pm “Factfinder” [lol] – read it and weep, sunshine No need for tears,…” Jun 10, 17:00
AndrewR on Two Of A Kind: “factfinder The Schools Bill is really interesting. This is a general question to the forum: when did the north and…” Jun 10, 16:51
Aidan on Two Of A Kind: “Taken from JPTI’s website today: “The C-24 has very strict rules. Only regions already on the UN’s official list of…” Jun 10, 16:23
Willie on Two Of A Kind: “Just read this as I sit on a train on the West coast line travelling to Glasgow Partick. Only going…” Jun 10, 16:17
James on Two Of A Kind: ““Factfinder” [lol] – read it and weep, sunshine. “…Most importantly, Scotland lacks international legal personality, is not permitted to conduct…” Jun 10, 16:13
factfinder on Two Of A Kind: “The deliberate campaign to eradicate Gaelic language and culture was, of course, started long before 1707. The Establishment of Schools…” Jun 10, 15:23
Northcode on Two Of A Kind: “Thanks for the link, Alf. Very helpful. This from the Justice pour Tous Internationale (JPTi) website : Building on two…” Jun 10, 13:54
Alf Baird on Two Of A Kind: “Instead of playing British politics, here is what the SNP leadership should have been doing long ago, taking Scotland’s case…” Jun 10, 13:14
Oneliner on Two Of A Kind: “The Kosher and Halal punters will only screw it up” Jun 10, 13:02
diabloandco on Two Of A Kind: “Like it!” Jun 10, 11:54
Dan, I fully sympathise with wanting to bring accountability closer to home – which ironically was what Brexit was all about. MPs hated the idea because for ages they’d blamed every failure on the EU not letting them do stuff. They’ve still not given up on it but they’ve fewer excuses. There is and always will be the courts which revel in doing the opposite of what governments want. Civil Servants too seem to spend their time preventing public will. But those are the realities of both of our countries.
The worst part of the Brexit campaign was about having more money to spend. I’d have rather heard that we’d have less money to spend but could use it more wisely.
Pat Blake
You keep banging on about *legitimate referendum* but fail to recognise that route has been deliberately denied regardless of various mandates.
So how do you suggest we have one?
Scotland is already beating the pants of England in outstanding services & it’s doing it within budget & at a cost of over £600 million mitigation against cruel Tory policies we don’t vote for. We’re not permitted to go over our spending money. Our overlords don’t allow it. The money Scotland spends is Scotlands to spend as it pleases. It’s not Westminsters money.
Scotland has more to offer it’s citizens than just oil.
SNP didn’t come up against reality. It didn’t even try. It became more interested in it’s self & maintaining their own position.
England have to grow up. They’ve cut off a referendum like a abuser would to a partner who is leaving. They’ve done the same on immigration – block safe passages of travel & then greet like fuck people arrive *illegal* Who swallows this endless woe is me shite?
Elections are legal & legit. Ignore it & see what happens. A country won’t be held against it’s will.
You talk of Brexit & the EU..
A few questions..
Imagine if they’d said no to a referendum?
Imagine they said you couldn’t leave without their permission.
Imagine they put a % & a time frame on it?
Imagine they held all your country’s money & control of all your assets & gave you peanut pocket money in return.
Imagine they had the whole EU vote on that referendum too.
Imagine they demanded a full future breakdown of your future economic plans?
I think you’d agree it was fucking insane..
That’s yoonland I’ve just explained..
Scotland is a sovereign nation. How she conducts her country is of no concern to nosy neighbours. Improve your own land. Start by campaigning for a devolved parliament & an independence referendum. You’d certainly win.
It’s ironic
You don’t even live here yet you are telling a Sovereign Nation they can have a referendum mibbies in 11 years LOL!
What’s Scotlands constitution to do with you anyways? Why be involved?
Geri, I’ve told you, if Scotland leaves I want it to be successful. Loads of people in England have Scottish ancestry and don’t want to see it fail.
I doubt that it will achieve success with the mindset I see here. However, since you don’t think that having persuasive plans to present to future voters is important, I am unlikely to find out how Scotland will fare on its own.
There is already persuasive plans.
None more so than being in charge of our own decisions & what we choose to spend our own money on.
Yoons want to see accounts – guaranteed future economic plans & with guaranteed future outcomes. See Westminster – they won’t hand over the true accounts. They stopped recording them in 1921 because it was too embarrassing for them that Scotland was funding England in full.
It’s just a Yoon delay tactic & everyone knows it.
Scotland is already 50% +
We already vote for independence.
We already know we’re a wealthy country.
We already know we need no one’s permission to leave the union.
We already know there is no Better Together remaining in the Union because we’re already in it & or we’re not.
What part are you missing?
I could have ancestry in Timbuktu – I wouldn’t give a fck what their country voted for in a legitimate election if I didn’t even live there. It would be nothing to to with me.
You still haven’t answered any of my questions. Another Yoon tactic. Answer a question by asking another question.. Zzzzz
You need to spend more of your time on the Englands accounts & future economic plans – they don’t look good.
@Pat Blake 3:47
Just have faith.
If that doesn’t work, just have more faith.
That’s what I’m always told.
BTW, don’t pay any heed to the “you don’t live here so wheesht” argument. That’s only ever selectively deployed if you present unanswerable arguments.
There’s plenty of regular posters on here deploying the “Sean Connery” defence – they love Scotland so much they’ve fecked off – usually cos they love paying lower taxes even more.
Main
You don’t have any unanswerable questions. You simply don’t like the answers.
& There’s a huge difference between people who don’t live here having an opinion – to people imposing rules, timelines, percentages & all manner of criteria for a country to jump through to appease them. That’s electoral interference.
& Scotland fecks off because the UK is absolutely shit. Their own prospects are extremely limited & their own country is being turned into a fucking retirement home for yoons snapping up property & to scrounge off the system we provide.
Learn to know the difference.