The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


The cry of liberty 14

Posted on April 08, 2012 by

*Wings over Scotland is very pleased to be able to bring its readers another terrific guest post from Andrew Page of A Scottish Liberal. We spoil you, really we do.

This past Friday, the 6th of April, saw the anniversary of one of the most significant events in Scottish history – the signing of the Declaration of Arbroath.

It was a truly inspirational and courageous statement on many levels, and it is unsurprising that almost eight hundred years later it continues to have an impact on our understanding of nationhood and Scottish identity. That it was an expression of Scottish nationalism cannot be doubted: indeed, it is one of the most articulate, eloquent and heartfelt expressions of Scottish nationhood ever written.

But it is so much more than that, and at its heart was more than mere nationalistic aspiration, but a passionate cry for freedom and liberty. It was also, at its most basic level, a challenge to religious authority centuries ahead of its time in addition to arguably being a stimulus for far-reaching changes in European constitutional thinking.

In appealing to the Pope the signatories to the declaration make clear their commitment not merely to Scotland’s independence but also to its nationhood. In a curiously selective recollection of Scottish history, they point to how the Scots “came, twelve hundred years after the people of Israel crossed the Red Sea, to their home in the west where they still live today”, thereafter “[holding] it free of all bondage ever since” while “in their kingdom there have reigned one hundred and thirteen kings of their own royal stock, the line unbroken [by] a single foreigner.”

While these “facts” are more the product of cultural sensitivities rather than historical understanding, there can be no escaping the sense of belonging to a proud nation – one of “freedom and peace” in which “our people harbour no malice or treachery and [are] unused to wars or invasions.” A fine vision, indeed.

In some respects, it is easy to detect a more than faint romanticism in these claims as is generally true with most nationalist thinking. Perhaps, while many today identify Scotland in terms of Celtic mysticism, the tartan and bagpipes culture of the White Heather Club, haggis and shortbread tin landscapes the signatories of the Arbroath declaration were equally in love with an artificial view of Scotland, based itself on false assumptions about the nation’s history, its potential and its individual nature.

Such assumptions perhaps contain a grain of truth, but are in fact quite dangerous and are themselves usually based on modern hostility to Scottish nationalism. Certainly, the myth of ethnic origin apparently expressed within the Declaration can be easily debunked, but it’s also clear that Scottish nationhood was not defined by such fiction. The explanation of Scotland’s establishment was designed to persuade the Pope of their cause rather than an exercise in writing accurate history.

What is immediately obvious is that the nature of nationhood itself, as expressed in the Declaration of Arbroath, is far different from that often associated with the romanticised view of Scotland that appeals far more to foreign visitors than it rings true to most contemporary Scots. At the root of the nationalists’ cause in 1320 were core values, not determined by lines on maps or even historic achievements but a right to self-determination, for recognition, for an end to oppression and the subservient status apropos England. Put in modern terms, it was a desire on the part of Scots to take control of their own political destiny.

Read the rest of this entry →

Voices off 10

Posted on March 06, 2012 by

WoS: Despite what the media would have you believe, independence isn’t a party political issue. A sizeable minority of SNP voters don’t back the policy, and many members of the other parties do, but the voices of either group are rarely heard. Andrew Page of the popular A Scottish Liberal blog is a proponent of “Home Rule”, and has kindly allowed us to reproduce this superb piece on the subject.

A few weeks ago I put together a draft topical motion with Derek Young on the issue of the party’s position on a second question in the independence referendum. My motivation for doing this was primarily to ensure that this issue is debated rather than being decided for the members by the party leadership. I was also concerned that the Scottish Liberal Democrats can campaign positively during the independence referendum, that we seize the best opportunity in decades to achieve our vision for a constitutional settlement and simultaneously ensure that the Home Rule Commission has some purpose other than cynical opposition to the SNP.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,745 Posts, 1,216,546 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • MaryB on Unhinged Malady: “Off topic, almost … but Leah Gunn Barrett has written today about the advance of Blackrock in Scotland under Nicola,…Apr 25, 16:01
    • Jim Bo on Unhinged Malady: “Just bumped into this very unhinged malady in Dundee 15mins ago- quite conveniently at a crossing so was able to…Apr 25, 15:59
    • Mark Beggan on Unhinged Malady: “I think the supreme court ruling has saved the Transvestites from themselves.Apr 25, 14:11
    • Sven on Unhinged Malady: “PacMan @ 13.17. The case of Nurses raising court actions against NHS Trusts would seem to be operating both ways…Apr 25, 14:09
    • Willie on Unhinged Malady: “That’s a braw comment. Rangers the 1690ers. You couldn’t make up a better quip. But here’s a thing. Anyone know…Apr 25, 14:09
    • PacMan on Unhinged Malady: “Found this article from 2016 which details how the Trans movement was born in America: https://archive.is/UP6Vw Some details of it…Apr 25, 13:21
    • PacMan on Unhinged Malady: “James Cheyne says: 25 April, 2025 at 10:54 am Who are the rich people funding all these ideologies working behind…Apr 25, 13:17
    • James Cheyne on Unhinged Malady: “Most of what is offered in Scotland is politically wrong. And most parties have affiliations through one background idealogical political…Apr 25, 12:21
    • Hatey McHateface on Unhinged Malady: “No real argument from me over that post. I would add that as paying swingeing taxes is defo contributing to…Apr 25, 11:48
    • robertkknight on Unhinged Malady: “O/T I hear that as part of any deal to take over Sevco, the soccer team formerly known as GRFC,…Apr 25, 11:45
    • James Cheyne on Unhinged Malady: “Who are the rich people funding all these ideologies working behind the government, And who is funding the attempt to…Apr 25, 10:54
    • Stevie on Unhinged Malady: “These Green lunatics are a disease in Scotland BUT so is the SNP. Imagine REFORM gets enough seats to form…Apr 25, 10:43
    • Dan on Unhinged Malady: “@ Aidan at 6.55am Linking to the shitfest that is twitter / x means many folk won’t be able to…Apr 25, 09:23
    • Hatey McHateface on Unhinged Malady: ““I haven’t a clue what you are talking about” I was making the points that people are generally sick and…Apr 25, 08:29
    • Willie on Unhinged Malady: “Just been reading that Wes Streeting has announced that the NHS needs to make provision to treat transgender people with…Apr 25, 08:20
    • PacMan on Unhinged Malady: “Hatey McHateface says: 24 April, 2025 at 12:12 pm Whether that “sickness” is justifiable, or compatible with a general reluctance…Apr 25, 07:25
    • PacMan on Unhinged Malady: “You don’t need to walk to far to see this is another Teletubby fantasy. In fact if you dare walk…Apr 25, 07:13
    • Aidan on Unhinged Malady: “I’d also direct you to Roddy Dunlop’s interesting response on the Claim of Right: https://x.com/RoddyQC/status/1555714099018973186/photo/1Apr 25, 06:55
    • Young Lochinvar on Unhinged Malady: “The media, advertising, politics and the infamous “3rd sector” are awash with them. That’s what comes with a joke further/…Apr 25, 03:12
    • Geri on Unhinged Malady: “Ach – it doesn’t matter…Apr 25, 02:31
    • JockMcT on Unhinged Malady: “Simply unfit for office and should be sacked forthwith!Apr 25, 02:24
    • Geri on Unhinged Malady: “Stu If you have a moment can you tell me why my post is in mod? Thanks..Apr 25, 01:12
    • Anthem on Unhinged Malady: “It really is outrageous how the BBC,STV & Sky News are still promoting the “poor vulnerable trans” story. Yet hardly…Apr 25, 00:52
    • Mark Beggan on Unhinged Malady: “” I am ahead. I am advanced. I am the first mammal to wear pants. I am at peace with…Apr 24, 20:08
    • Aidan on Unhinged Malady: “@Lorn – I’m afraid the Salvo case has no chance, there have been innumerable cases on the U.K. constitution in…Apr 24, 19:55
    • Hatey McHateface on Unhinged Malady: “Ah c’moan now, Mark. If they’re mostly called Navid, it’s all going to be grand. Never forget that for some…Apr 24, 19:51
    • Hatey McHateface on Unhinged Malady: ““the very establishment of a supreme court should have had our legal profession outraged and riotous as they have been…Apr 24, 19:35
    • Hatey McHateface on Some People Try To Fuck With You: ““tick numerous red flags – Histrionics, Narcissism, Authoritarian, Grandiose, Anti Social, obsessive & Compulsive. They think they’re the smartest person…Apr 24, 19:27
    • Aidan on Some People Try To Fuck With You: “Absolutely shocking that a single individual can waste so much valuable judicial time on vindictive attacks and not suffer any…Apr 24, 18:51
    • twathater on Unhinged Malady: “Lorn I don’t believe anyone posting here would call you stupid or otherwise in relation to the Scottish judges or…Apr 24, 18:09
  • A tall tale



↑ Top