The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Unionists ponder suicide pact

Posted on November 08, 2011 by

David Maddox in the Scotsman livens up a previously-slow news day with a report that Labour are preparing to team up with the Conservatives in the UK Parliament to force a Westminster-led referendum on Scottish independence. The article is short on solid quotes to contradict David Cameron's repeatedly-stated position that the referendum is a matter for the Scottish Parliament, relying instead on unnamed "sources", but if true it would be an astonishing development. None of the UK parties stood on a platform of holding a referendum – indeed, all three explicitly opposed the idea – so where they'd be conjuring a mandate to do such a thing from would be anyone's guess, whereas the SNP have an extremely clear one from the Scottish people to conduct the vote in the second half of the Holyrood parliamentary term.

Most observers on both sides of the debate agree that a Westminster-imposed referendum would be an enormously risky gamble for the Unionists, as Scottish voters are unlikely to take kindly to such a democratic trampling. But it may be that the three London-based parties sense a growing trend of support for a Yes vote – reflected in recent polls – and consider it less of a risk than waiting for three more years of brutal cuts to take effect and persuade Scots that they're better off away from Tory-led UK governments. Labour especially, though, would be dicing with death were they to collude in such a scheme. We shall see.

Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,874 Posts, 1,235,820 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Cheyne on A Dumber Nation: “Hatey, I think I said energy, not specifically just wind, although that could be included, along with water, Whatever we…Feb 10, 10:50
    • James Cheyne on A Dumber Nation: “Alf Baird, As I was suggesting yesterday, the networking between Colonialism and venture capitalism built on historical events and evidence…Feb 10, 10:32
    • Alf Baird on A Dumber Nation: ““Immunity from what?” (English) Crown immunity means that they (i.e. state actors, institutions or its agents) cannot be prosecuted, no…Feb 10, 10:18
    • Hatey McHateface on A Dumber Nation: “You an all, Dave? You another one who has yet to twig that on some days, the wind doesn’t blow?…Feb 10, 10:15
    • Hatey McHateface on A Dumber Nation: “@Cynicus Even the BBC Radio 4 could see this morning that almost certainly, yesterday’s spat was pure, performative theatre, scripted…Feb 10, 10:05
    • Insider on Echoes of history: ““I will be retiring from Wings over Scotland, which I have been promising for awhile,” Please, please, dear God! Let…Feb 10, 09:56
    • David Holden on A Dumber Nation: “I looked it up a while back as I was going to a meeting about the proposed offshore wind farm…Feb 10, 09:47
    • Hatey McHateface on A Dumber Nation: “Ah, c’mon noo, James. Hoo mony hames dae we supply wi energy in a flat calm? Engage brain afore posting!Feb 10, 09:46
    • James Cheyne on A Dumber Nation: “PC Foster, Crown immunity ( prisons) Hansard, Volume 771. Debated on Tuesday 22nd July 2025. 3: 10 pm. Presented by…Feb 10, 09:28
    • James Cheyne on A Dumber Nation: “Karen, As Alba mentioned, the energy firm Octopus comments suggest that Scotland should be one of the cheapest places in…Feb 10, 09:20
    • Ally on A Dumber Nation: “It’s like the SNP Gov have forgotten that they have to govern for all of Scotland not just a minority…Feb 10, 09:12
    • ALANM on A Dumber Nation: ““a guard told me I would need to take my sweater off if I wanted to visit my niece This…Feb 10, 08:52
    • Karen on A Dumber Nation: ““Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit attocities” – Voltaire. What are the atrocities? Freeports, pylons,…Feb 10, 03:54
    • Angus on A Dumber Nation: ““We honest-to-God wish we could believe that our leaders were merely morons.” Yes they are pure evil. Not only in…Feb 10, 02:55
    • Cynicus on A Dumber Nation: “Morag says: 9 February, 2026 at 4:31 pm “The Scottish National Orchestra has been captured?” ======== And will the Parliamentary…Feb 10, 02:53
    • Cynicus on A Dumber Nation: “Rev. Stuart Campbell says: 10 February, 2026 at 12:45 am “Sarwar is a complete irrelevance not worth wasting breath or…Feb 10, 02:43
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on A Dumber Nation: “” Many of us would like to see you further tear shreds out of Anus Sarewar following his blatent “not-my-fault-if-we-tank-in-election”…Feb 10, 00:45
    • A2 on A Dumber Nation: “would the hypothetical Trrans person sue before or after performing suicide?Feb 10, 00:19
    • GM on The Marshalling Plan: “Small change, Northcode man. You need at least a billion to get into the Degenerate club. Millionaires would maybe get…Feb 10, 00:06
    • sarah on Echoes of history: “@ James Cheyne, those rumours sound good. I hope they come true. But must you leave Wings?Feb 9, 22:30
    • Aidan on Echoes of history: “@Hatey – it’s vanishingly unlikely that any Liberate bum will be hitting any Holyrood seat given the general lack of…Feb 9, 22:20
    • Rob on A Dumber Nation: “I very much doubt any trans man would argue to be in the men’s prison estate. Can you imagine what…Feb 9, 22:20
    • sarah on A Dumber Nation: “This report confirms what we knew would be the case if men were allowed into women’s prisons [and elsewhere]. What…Feb 9, 22:09
    • Hatey McHateface on A Dumber Nation: “Be more specific, Fearghas. Up what?Feb 9, 21:27
    • Hatey McHateface on Echoes of history: “We’ll still be favourites for the toe curling.Feb 9, 21:25
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on A Dumber Nation: “Re the article’s top photo: Why has Swinney only got ONE hand up?Feb 9, 20:32
    • Peter McAvoy on A Dumber Nation: “The Health Minister should rule out the trial of puberty blockers in Scotland. Then this awful policy should be scrapped.…Feb 9, 20:28
    • Scot Finlayson on A Dumber Nation: “The American government is looking into opening up insane asylums for the protection and safety of those that are insane,…Feb 9, 20:11
    • 100%Yes on Echoes of history: “Playing for the colonizer is a hard act to swallow, I couldn’t watch or support team GB no matter where…Feb 9, 20:04
    • Hatey McHateface on Echoes of history: “” With luck, the Alliance MSPs might be part of the “government” ” Seriously? So as soon as bums hit…Feb 9, 19:56
  • A tall tale



↑ Top